Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

#390
Just a side note: my guess would be that population would probably key nicely to peruvianum with genetic drift probably having taken out most evidence of the other two species. If you went from a morphological perspective on ID but also likely at the genetic level. It might actually be a disservice to customers to relabel the population as a hybrid swarm without checking its ID. In my opinion the peruvianum was so healthy a population based on seed I recieved in 2017 that it likely would have out competed the later additions of Cornelio Muelleri hybrids, Arcanum, and the TGRC hybrids Andrew acquired and distributed to both Joseph and myself. Peruvianum is the most R selected and weedy of the species a corn field weed like pimpinillifolium. Hard to change something that well adapted without considerable effort- (coddling and excessive record keeping) could easily have just resisted the attempt.

I just looked at the listing and I think it's a decent representation of the product. It clearly comes from Joseph. Joseph has made his gardening methods and philosophy very clear. It clearly states some of the hybridization that might have occurred- yes even more than that might have if we go backwards in our collaborative efforts 7 years.

I didn't have the space to isolate but I attempted to grow out Andrew's peruvianum complex and hybrid seed horde again for seed increase in 2022. It would be interesting to see what those mother identified but potentially different father exposed accessions do morphologically over a few generations. Though I don't plan to grow them out often. I really want at the present to focus on LA2329 habrochaites and it's hybrid offspring until I've got something useful to share from that.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Hmm, good point!

For me personally, if "Corneliomulleri, peruvianum, and arcanum seem so closely related that I combined the populations in my garden." is accurate to the situation, that would be useful information for me as a buyer if it is at least included in the description, rather than describing it very specifically as the single species Solanum peruvianum while making it clear by the context that that is being used in the contemporary sense (made unambiguously clear by mentioning corneliomullerii, as well as Solanum being the genus name rather than Lycopersicon, and specifically referring to it as a species rather than 'species complex') and merely giving the caveat "these are part of my promiscuous pollination project so there is a possibility that some seeds might have been pollinated by S. habrochaites, S. pennellii, or S. corneliomullerii." So far as I can see, those two described situations are entirely different from each other. Perhaps I am narrow minded but I feel like if one is a true description of the product, it would be kind and non-misleading to use that one.

Also while as I stated above, TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE), Iris E. Peralta - 2008 indicates that per and arc are incompatible with each other (if there is evidence to the contrary I would be most interested to hear about that), I now see under the corn section that it states:

QuoteSolanum corneliomulleri is a very distinctive species, with its strongly curved anther tube and copious glandular pubescence interspersed with very long uniseriate trichomes that are usually gland-tipped. Rick (1986a) included it in his broadly defined S. peruvianum (as Lycopersicon peruvianum), based on its ability to interbreed with S. peruvianum s.str. and S. arcanum as defined here.

That is interesting! So it would seem corn might act as a potential bridge between per and arc. This would also suggest the possibility that Joseph's mixed population may include some arc genetics, via corn, even if all the pure arc and even all the pure corn, died off.

For me for example, the practical application of this could be that, if all of my cross attempts between per and my domestic x arc crosses fail, it could still be an option to try with Joseph's mixed/hybrid population, or to try myself to cross per with corn, then that with arc, then that in turn with my arc crosses.

As it is, I have just germinated a seed from one of my arc crosses pollinated with mass per+chil pollen. I reserve doubts about it because I myself grew some arc at the edge of my per plot, and I am not 100% sure that I entirely avoided that when collecting pollen, since I had not even planned to use it in this way when I was collecting the pollen back when those were flowering - it was intended for pollinating my indoor per and chil accessions to maximise the hybrid swarm. And now my additional doubt comes since the nature of some of that per is now in question. However, the seeds resulting from those crosses looked quite poor, being rather thin, with dark centres, and not very well shaped, which tells me they are almost certainly not from arc pollen since the arc pollen has been giving good looking seeds when crossing to these crosses, so far anyway. So, I have rather high hopes for this new little germinated seed, the only one of four that finally germinated. And, due to my first doubt above, I also took it upon myself to make multiple pollination attempts with pollen from specific individual per and chil accessions, the fruit of which is now ripening, for these reasons:

1) Because I want to gain enough SI alleles and so want to take care to differentiate which resulting plants have which parents, in order to cross them carefully in the next generation to preserve as many SI alleles as possible.

2) To know which per accessions my arc crosses are compatible with, so that if need be, I can grow out more of that accession in order to make more crosses, increasing the number of SI alleles in the population.

William Schlegel

I hear you! Catalogs tend not to be quite that precise and accurate though.

I have gotten a little lazy in my approach to self incompatibility. It is a neat goal to have SI domestic tomatoes and a awesome Idea Joseph brought up. Joseph has been working on it continuously. You are expanding it to use additional SI species. I just sort of have accepted that it is possible I am working with a mixed SC and SI population as long as I am continuously going back to SI material. Though my current focus LA2329 is likely itself a mixed system.

It helps me to remind myself frequently that it is already common in Tomatillos to be SI. Though it wouldn't surprise me at all if some tomatillos are SC. Plants tend to not follow rules humans make.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-17, 07:09:38 AMWhich makes me suspect that that non-hairy one may be a galapagense-cheesmaniae hybrid.
Wild Galapagos Tomato – Lycopersicon cheesmanii v. minor – (synonim names: L. cheesmaniae var. minor, L. galapagense) - the form with rather "loose" (not dense), tripinnate leaves and glabrous (non hairy), small (0,6-1,1 cm), orange fruits, open pollinated

Wild Galapagos Tomato – Lycopersicon cheesmanii v. minor – (synonim names: L. cheesmaniae var. minor, L. galapagense) - the form has very dense, tripinnate leaves and glabrous (hairy when immature), small (0,6-0,8 cm = 0,25-0,33 inch), orange fruits with firm skin

http://unusualediblesandtheirwildrelatives.blogspot.com/2019/03/scirpidiellas-exchange-seed-list-2019.html

Joseph Lofthouse

#394
I used to spend days in my garden, carefully observing traits of tomatoes, and matching them against taxonomy keys. Eventually, I decided that the variability of out-crossing tomatoes exceeds a key's predictive ability. Changes in the environment can modify a plant's phenotype during a growing season. Plants would express both limbs of the key's decision point simultaneously on the same plant.

Anyone is welcome to submit my Solanum peruvianum population to genetic testing, and publish a paper on the results. I will include a link to the paper in the catalog description.

I've grown out enough gene-bank varieties to feel confident that they don't send out pure seed, and not even necessarily the species listed in the catalog.

I recently sent a packet of tomato seeds to someone. I jumbled together about 8 pure species, and inter-specific crosses between them. No identifying information was included to label what was what. It provides the ultimate tomato breeding resource in a compact package. And most importantly, it gets rid of any preconceived notions a plant breeder might have. They get to have their own experience with each plant, rather than getting influenced by words.




Joseph Lofthouse

#395
In pop culture, people tend to think of species as distinct, uniform, and stable. Black/White. Either/Or. Yes/No.

species-in-pop-culture.jpg

In real life, species blend together. Intergrading. Fuzzy. Indistinct. Unstable.

species-actually.jpg

Imagine one seed that shows up on the shore of a huge inland sea. It starts expanding along the shores of the sea. Ten thousand years later the two populations meet on the opposite side of the sea. When they meet, they have different traits, and the taxonomist-splitters call them a separate species. They cross with each other, though some barriers exist.

However, as we trace the path backwards from the direction of migration, each plant exhibits full fertility with its nearest neighbors.

species-lake.jpg

Justin Jardinier

#396
Quote from: Alex on 2023-11-18, 06:00:55 PMWild Galapagos Tomato – Lycopersicon cheesmanii v. minor – (synonim names: L. cheesmaniae var. minor, L. galapagense) - the form with rather "loose" (not dense), tripinnate leaves and glabrous (non hairy), small (0,6-1,1 cm), orange fruits, open pollinated

Wild Galapagos Tomato – Lycopersicon cheesmanii v. minor – (synonim names: L. cheesmaniae var. minor, L. galapagense) - the form has very dense, tripinnate leaves and glabrous (hairy when immature), small (0,6-0,8 cm = 0,25-0,33 inch), orange fruits with firm skin

http://unusualediblesandtheirwildrelatives.blogspot.com/2019/03/scirpidiellas-exchange-seed-list-2019.html

Yes, those are Wojciech's descriptions of the two he grows. And he is very knowledgable about plants. But my doubts explained above remain.

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-18, 07:31:17 PMI've grown out enough gene-bank varieties to feel confident that they don't send out pure seed, and not even necessarily the species listed in the catalog.

Yes, I noticed some mistakes from the main genebank I got various accessions from. I gave feedback with references to some published papers on some accessions and they changed their listings accordingly. For one cheesmaniae, I noticed the seed size was to large to be pure cheesmaniae and then checked their own photos and the colour looked to me too reddish to be cheesmaniae also, so I reported both traits to them and they asked me to keep them updated when I grew it. On growing I noticed 3 more traits inconsistent with cheesmaniae while the fruits were still unripe, fruit size too big; subtle speckling observed on all other cheesmaniaes I was growing mostly absent; and uneven ripening, and judged that I felt it was a cheesmaniae lyc hybrid, so I sent all that info with photos also, to them. They responded saying they added my remarks to the accession, and seemed glad for it. So they seem really transparent. A great attitude I think. Must be a lot of work running a seedbank!

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-18, 07:31:17 PMAnyone is welcome to submit my Solanum peruvianum population to genetic testing, and publish a paper on the results. I will include a link to the paper in the catalog description.

I actually think that's a really great idea. For the wild species mixed populations but even more so for the wild-domestic populations, both the stable ones like Lee Goodwin's wild crosses, and the evolutionary populations like the Wilding, Q series, MMM etc., and other people's wild crosses. That would be awesome if someone in some university could be enticed to do so. It could maybe attract more attention to this great work, maybe end up attracting a wider audience, and perhaps stimulate more public discussion of the importance of variation especially in the context of climate change. There's a lot of public interest in wheat evolutionary populations and some other grains, among farmers in Europe, them being grown on many farms now. Perhaps some notice from academia could help in stimulating the wide cross tomato projects (those with significant amounts of wild rather than... maybe the normal commercial way is to just bring in specific traits and backcross everything else out?) to be grown more at the farm scale, as more mainstream crops. I guess marketing may be harder than with grains, when it comes to the product, but there could be either ways of influencing fancy supermarkets to take them on, or work more with networks of independent stores or some of the interesting relatively new schemes of marketing direct to customers. I forget the name now but I think I was reading about one such system in Scandinavia - ah I just found it, 'REKO rings', here's a video on it:
https://youtu.be/RFH2KEREndo?si=0FsSz4iwTUYXNX6f

And here's Richard Perkins talking about it, he's a really successful (highly profitable) no dig organic farmer:
https://youtu.be/qn7MP7NeJwQ?si=hhU0J5ftJV0w8CEE

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-18, 07:31:17 PMI recently sent a packet of tomato seeds to someone. I jumbled together about 8 pure species, and inter-specific crosses between them. No identifying information was included to label what was what. It provides the ultimate tomato breeding resource in a compact package. And most importantly, it gets rid of any preconceived notions a plant breeder might have. They get to have their own experience with each plant, rather than getting influenced by words.

That sounds fun. And I think that being rid of preconceived notions can be very helpful. However, in my opinion there can also be great benefit of having preconceived notions, built upon the many years of experience of many people who have contributed to the field of knowledge through their decades or lifetimes of work, accumulating a vast body of collective knowledge. This can save us a lot of time and help to focus our efforts. Just to give a practical example, living in a small space, I have space for a limited number of plants. Each plant is further limited by how much it can grow in my small space. And I have limited time. So for example, if I did not know that it is almost impossible or perhaps actually impossible, to make a per x lyc cross, then if I took up all my space with lyc and per, and attempted that, I could spend 4 months growing these plants and have not a single seed by the end of it, nothing to show for all that time and work! Or if I did have some knowledge, and had a bag of wild seeds but didn't know what the name of the species was, I could spend the whole cycle trying to cross lyc x wild but it might turn out that it was all per and corn and again I might have zero seeds by the end of it.

A more complex example would be trying to cross domestic C. baccatum with domestic C annuum. This is apparently not possible. Who knows, maybe it really is possible, maybe if I grew an acre of each species, and crossed full time for the season, perhaps I would get a successful cross, perhaps not, I don't know. But supposing there is basically no chance of me getting a cross in my small home, as the academic papers indicate, then in my opinion it is really valuable to me that people have actually investigated this aim in great depth, with extensive testing, and they have determined 2 pathways, and, have determined which is easier to do. Those two pathways use C. chinense as a bridge, one being [C. annuum × C. chinense] × C. baccatum, the other being [C. baccatum × C. chinense] × C. annuum. This seems very useful information for me because then I can spend my space growing specifically for attempting one or both of these pathways, and my time on making those specific crosses, over two cycles, and indeed this is exactly what I am attempting. This means that thanks to their evidence-based learning, and their sharing that knowledge, I don't need to spend the vast amount of time it would take me in my tiny space, with countless unnecessary failures, to create that knowledge myself.

I don't see this as any different from learning some wonderful farming techniques from some indigenous farmers. It's all about benefitting from the hard earned experience of other individuals, and other communities of individuals, whether that be conservative communities of people working with domestic crops over generations in traditional contexts, or communities of academics and plant breeders immersing themselves in the highly creative processes of modern experimental plant breeding.

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-18, 09:49:58 PMImagine one seed that shows up on the shore of a very large lake. It starts expanding along the shores of the lake. Ten thousand years later the two populations meet on the opposite side of the lake. When they meet, they have different traits, and the taxonomist-splitters call them a separate species. They cross with each other, though some barriers exist.

However, as we trace the path backwards from the direction of migration, each plant exhibits full fertility with its nearest neighbors.

Such a scenario is imaginable. In general this seems to me the standard view of evolution. I don't know how much time it might take (and I am sure it would vary) for the two populations to finally be not compatible with each other at all. But with regard to "as we trace the path backwards from the direction of migration", I would say that (not always but) often that would require travelling back in time. That is to say, to use your analogy, as the two populations travel along their opposite sides of the lake, those behind them can disappear, such that the centre of the 'spectrum' no longer exists, as if in a rainbow one is left with green and red, but no orange and yellow between them. And this tendency in evolution seems common, perhaps in self organising systems in general, like even in music, rather than an homogenous continuous spectrum, music tends to exist in genres. There are often a few outliers, bands playing on the fringes of genres or between genres; and in some cases there can be less distinction between certain genres, with a lot of interchange between them or a more blurred boundary. But the general tendency is for styles to gather in groups, and proliferation to occur within the parameters of a genre. Those parameters can gradually shift over time, but generally within recognised parameters (even if those parameters have a gradually evolving nature) hence the 'genre' phenomenon - and this is not mere academic abstraction, this is an observable phenomenon. Naming it merely helps us to communicate about this commonly experienced phenomenon.

Then, whilst most people exhibit the (relatively) conservative characteristic, playing in a genre; a few... wilder... people, don't conform, and make music that isn't recognisable as belonging to any specific genre. Most of these outliers disappear quickly, leaving no impact. They are often just 'bad music' from some kind of more or less consensus view, analogous to a mutant plant that lacks vigour or has some other disabling trait making it unfit for survival. But some quickly attract attention, gain a following, and then act as new centres for the conservative elements to coalesce around, and hence a new genre is born. That can happen quite quickly! This seems analogous to a mutant plant becoming successful in its first generation, its offspring competing well and establishing a new population. It may then mix with other genres, either influencing diverse styles while itself not being influenced; itself continuing its evolution but while still inputting influence from others around it; or a combination of both - like a new plant population that is readily crossing with the surrounding populations in one or both directions. Or it might continue as a new distinct genre while not having an impact on the other genres, like a mutant plant population that developed full incompatibility, or crossed to a new ecological niche, separated by geography (or perhaps by flowering time, or pollinator community) such that it *could* cross but due to conditions, doesn't, like Solanum galapagense that evolved over an estimated one million years of isolation - fully compatible with pimp and lyc but clearly a different species from them, due to such a great length of independent evolution on the Galapagos islands.

Or, one of these musicians might make little impact, only having a very small following, or perhaps none at all, but somehow surviving among a tiny handful of musicians or even that one single musician, but then years later, when the public music atmosphere has changed, catching on with the public and taking off! Brahms' Piano Concerto No. 1 and Bizet's opera Carmen, one of the most popular and frequently performed operas in the classical canon, both had terrible reception initially. Bizet even died thinking he'd written a failure. These seem analogous to a mutant plant doing poorly in its environment, but surviving and making a few offspring, continuing for generations but really not being successful, and then as the environmental conditions change over time, it ending up being much more suited to the new conditions and outcompeting the surrounding populations.

In self-organising systems, there seem to be these two factors at play - the chaotic element, like the wild creative process; and the conservative element, the tendency of order. Self-organising systems (including all life) seem to exist on 'the edge of chaos', where these two apparently opposing factors meet in some kind of balance. I see these tendencies of random plant mutation and musical innovation; and the tendency to coalesce into somewhat distinct populations and species, and musical genres, as representing these two factors. I suppose the punctuated equilibrium of evolutionary trajectories are a result of this.

Languages are another interesting example of this same thing. Yes there are blurred lines in many cases, rare dialects on the border of some countries which may represent branches of old evolutionary trajectories in between mainstream modern languages, or the fertile intermixing of separate languages like the Bolze language in Switzerland which is a mixture of French and Swiss German, or the lesser tendency of loanwords such as the Japanese calling bread 'pan' from the Portuguese, the English using words like 'nirvana' and 'karma' from Sanskrit, and so on. But whilst all living languages continue to evolve, like genres of music, and whilst within them there is diversity to be found in the form of dialects (like the sub-populations in plant species), the diversity is not an homogenous spectrum. The concept of 'French language', 'Japanese language' and so on, do serve as useful concepts, in aiding us in communicating about the observed phenomenon of language differentiation, or in making practical decisions.

William Schlegel

#397
I thought about this overnight: trying to put my science teacher hat back on. Joseph, while your explanation of speciation and then reconvergence is clear and simplified, suitable perhaps for your next book?! I think it requires some modifications.

Geographic barriers are extremely important to speciation. A population slowly spreading around a lake should not speciate, though a lot of genetic drift would happen between the founding population and the leading edges of expansion, continuous gene flow should keep it the same. So what we need here is a better geographic barrier. A couple potential examples: volcanic islands and island biogeography, sky islands, where species colonize mountain tops but cannot survive in the intervening deserts- at least not during interglacial periods, river canyons like the grand canyon which down cut and split two populations apart, isthmus connecting strips of land like the Bering land bridge that connect two pieces of land but then rising waters separate them, or another example is mountain ranges pushing up and separating coastal and desert populations. I'm not sure how dramatic these examples need to be, but a dramatic example, such as island biogeography on a volcanic island chain, might be the simplest for the simplified explanation. Another example might be sharply differentiated habitats that allow little gene flow because adaptation to the one is deleterious in the other. 

So: say we use volcanic islands as a classic (and hypothetical without precise Googling of facts so we will letter the species) example. Periodically a new island has formed, and an old island has sunken below the waves. A single tomato species from the mainland millions of years ago: Species X colonized one island. Over deep time that tomato changed due to adaptation and to genetic drift. Eventually that tomato became say Species Y. Then the tomato did some island hopping- again over deep time. On one of the smaller islands there wasn't much habitat so the tomato got better at living on the coast and became Species Z over deep time. This allowed the tomatoes to occupy the two sharply differentiated habitats available on the island coastal and inland. Could have been the coastal species first and the inland species second either way works for this example. Some more Island hopping occurred over deep time. Now many of the islands have populations of both species, though on each island those two species are likely very genetically and morphologically distinct from those on other islands with lots of time between gene flow events, during ice ages the islands are larger and thus closer together with more gene flow, and during interglacial periods smaller and farther apart. Enter modern times with humans with big silly boats full of gawking tourists. These silly humans have reintroduced Species X AND its domestic relative Species XX and now recent hybridizations have occurred given these newly broken-down geographic barriers.

Important points here. This process takes deep time. Fairly intense geographic isolation, and or differentiated habitats that create separate niches. These barriers and niche differentiations exist in South America in abundance which has driven the evolution of this: 17? species clade. Andes mountain range, Galapagos Islands, Rivers, Tropics, Sky Islands, Atacama desert! So we have desert tomatoes, mountain tomatoes, coastal tomatoes, tropical tomatoes... Just a deep rich clade of still closely related plants.

Then we also see intense within species differentiations because these processes are ongoing! However taxonomists have to draw their arbitrary lines somewhere so they have come up with a system that helps them. With genetic data, they are no longer limited to morphology alone- geneticists can now even detect crypto species with that. Species that are genetically distinct enough to be separate, but which morphologically appear the same as another. So they use multiple evidences to arrive at the divisions they chose to elevate at the species level- and sometimes that changes with new data or new discoveries. So even though say the biological species concept is nicely simplified- it doesn't always jive with the reality on the ground and more lines of evidence are needed to classify species.

Things do get messy around the edges! Whenever two or more of these closely related species are adjacent to each other, there could be gene flow, possibly even hybrid swarms. Though it is messier than that! In an area where two species have been adjacent for a long time, they may have slowly evolved morphological or genetic barriers to cross pollination. However, if they come together again in a distant part of their geographic ranges- those genetic/morphological barriers may not have come with them, and a new hybridization zone may form. So when we bring all 17 species together in a gene bank which has to do periodic grow outs- and humans are imperfect, the occasional mistake will happen- and that on top of the gene flow events which may have created some of the source populations. However, and at the same time, the workers at the gene banks do good work, and often send out high quality seeds that are still fairly representative of the source populations of true wild species which are fairly well agreed upon by taxonomists.

Though there are always exceptions to taxonomic and morphological rules! One of the things I really enjoy about plant biology is that plants don't follow the rules that humans make for them.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

Thanks William.

I have loved watching the Opuntia section of iNaturalist. Seems like many biologists have given up on trying to differentiate by species, and are just calling them "prickly pear" cactus.


William Schlegel

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-19, 08:05:52 AMQuote from: Joseph Lofthouse on Yesterday at 07:31:17 PM
Anyone is welcome to submit my Solanum peruvianum population to genetic testing, and publish a paper on the results. I will include a link to the paper in the catalog description.

I actually think that's a really great idea. For the wild species mixed populations but even more so for the wild-domestic populations, both the stable ones like Lee Goodwin's wild crosses, and the evolutionary populations like the Wilding, Q series, MMM etc., and other people's wild crosses. That would be awesome if someone in some university could be enticed to do so. It could maybe attract more attention to this great work, maybe end up attracting a wider audience, and perhaps stimulate more public discussion of the importance of variation especially in the context of climate change. There's a lot of public interest in wheat evolutionary populations and some other grains, among farmers in Europe, them being grown on many farms now. Perhaps some notice from academia could help in stimulating the wide cross tomato projects (those with significant amounts of wild rather than... maybe the normal commercial way is to just bring in specific traits and backcross everything else out?)

I think with tomatoes specifically, that we are creating a little bit of a false narrative when we say that the normal mainstream way is to just bring in small introgressions with the specific traits commercial conventional tomato farmers want. This is because the introgressions are actually quite large and are accumulating over time from multiple species. These introgressions, especially when they vary from variety to variety, do make modern tomatoes a very good source of wild germplasm especially when compared to true heirlooms. Also, the lines between the two blur together because of occasional cross pollination. The major difference is that when we do this wild species work, we aren't necessarily targeting one specific trait. We necessarily use the cast-off technology that was developed by earlier generations of plant breeders because of constraints on our time and finances as independent breeders most of us cannot access such wonders as marker assisted selection. So we can make these wonderful initial crosses, use the flavor and aroma reception analysis devices each of us is biologically enabled with, and follow segregation to some kind of acceptable end point. So it would be interesting to have someone with those deeper resources analyze this work coming out of our somewhat counterculture tomato breeding efforts. It goes back pretty far too. Alan Kapuler and Tim Peters made some very interesting interspecies tomato crosses: what is the genetic makeup of Tim's fruity, fuzzy, and sweet cherriette? Does Alan's Golden Tressette, which he discovered as a volunteer, really contain the three species his morphological observations led him to believe it did? Even early modern university work like that leading to Payette would be interesting to subject to genetic analysis- are those wild ancestors still in there after all that back crossing? How much pimpinillifolium is in Farthest North and its descendant varieties? What is the genetic background and relatedness of all the amazing short season Soviet era tomatoes? I see what I am doing as citizen science- and citizen science projects work best with some interaction and leadership from university scientists. However: the pool of potential university collaborators is shrinking as folks retire from both botany and public university plant breeding programs those programs are being increasingly shuttered. I wonder if an organization like OSA or the culinary breeding network could become sort of a scientific backbone for our citizen science wild species tomato efforts?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-19, 08:49:47 AMThanks William.

I have loved watching the Opuntia section of iNaturalist. Seems like many biologists have given up on trying to differentiate by species, and are just calling them "prickly pear" cactus.



I wouldn't necessarily go by that example. I deeply love Inaturalist. It provides a very interesting platform for photographic observations of wild species. For plants it functions a lot like a photographic herbarium- which is great! However, it has a few limitations. This would be a lot of work, but collecting numbered herbarium specimens of the same individual plants that go into an inaturalist study would be a real gold standard that could help ground truth inaturalist observations. My guess is that, without actual specimens in identifiable condition, that folks are having trouble differentiating the various opuntias from photos alone. That does not necessarily follow that the actual physical specimens in herbaria are suffering the same fate (unless collected without key characteristics). In sum: Inaturalist has some limitations caused by its photographic nature.

Case in point grasses: hard to photograph. You have to take several photos of each so that there are photos of the whole plant includng the base, leaves, and flower/seed head. In the one of them for the flower/seed head you have to find a specimen with such a flower or seed head, and then get some kind of flat background behind that seed head, to get the camera to focus on it, to have a decent chance at identification.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

Market assisted selection costs about $500 for 128 samples. Definitely within reach for citizen-scientists.

William Schlegel

#402
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-19, 09:29:30 AMMarket assisted selection costs about $500 for 128 samples. Definitely within reach for citizen-scientists.

I am contemplating taking a 4-quarter credit $540 a credit so $2160 dollar plant breeding course from Jim Myers this winter through Oregon State Online. I already paid the initial $35 application fee to reapply to take classes there as I took the prerequisite plant genetics course there a decade ago. I can sort of justify it as professional development for my current botany job and credits towards keeping my teaching license active but a lot of why I want to take it, is for fun, and potentially to further inform my tomato breeding.

If I can afford that (I think it is getting ridiculously expensive to take classes), I can certainly afford the occasional set of 128 samples as you posit. One of my deeper thoughts on this subject is to answer the question of how we can essentially keep public plant breeding going. Or my thought becomes how can I make my tomato breeding profitable enough to justify using tools like this?

A typical bulk seed tomato seed sale brings in $50 an ounce in my recent experience though prices may be rising as they've been on everything. Except for very popular varieties one ounce is a sufficient supply for most seed companies- perhaps for a few years. That $50 doesn't really justify an isolation block- one of the reasons why some seed sellers don't isolate their tomatoes effectively or grow out large enough populations to effectively understand and rogue their grow outs. So I would need to sell 10 ounces of tomato seed at full price (larger quantities are sometimes sold at even lower prices) to pay for one set of samples. Sales of packets direct to the consumer and or of tomato fruit in addition might help.

The very scarce operations like those of Fred Hempel, who we so recently lost, provide one possible business model. Target market farmers, create tasty heirloom quality modern hybrids using marker assisted selection, keep the parent lines and recipes proprietary, and we at least have an alternative group of modern tomatoes not owned by truly giant corporations. Though those tomato seeds are sold at a high premium price, must be suitable for market farmers, and must be of the most popular types such as big red slicers or Fred's big striped slicers like Benevento F1 https://store.growartisan.com/product/benevento-f1----200-seeds

My current business model is essentially to give everything away and continuously invest quite a bit of money into this hobby without a return. Though I am hesitant to spend $500 on it too often self-funded! I have ceased operating a business personally and gone back to work full time year-round now that I've finished my second bachelor's in science teaching (oddly working as a botanist from my prior degree). My wife is operating a small micro seed company on Etsy, so it makes sense for me to keep contributing my seeds, as much as possible, to her sales offerings potentially both bulk and direct to the consumer. However, compared to a few years ago when I had more time, my capacity to do the work is now really limited just to weekends.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Diane Whitehead

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-19, 09:29:30 AMMarker assisted selection costs about $500 for 128 samples.
Does this mean one desired quality will be added to 128 kinds of plants?  or that 128 of your hybrids will be checked to see if you did everything right?
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

Quote from: Diane Whitehead on 2023-11-19, 12:48:43 PMDoes this mean one desired quality will be added to 128 kinds of plants?  or that 128 of your hybrids will be checked to see if you did everything right?

Nope not adding traits, just testing for traits you've already attempted to add but which aren't visible.

Say you make a cross with anything you consider to be a good source of traits that may have known genetic markers associated with them. Then you grow out the segregating offspring- maybe an F2. Then you can pay the $500 to see which of 128 of those offspring actually have the markers you are looking for. You kind of rinse and repeat that till you get to the F7 and you have a tomato that has all the invisible resistance markers you want. Once stable you have a very valuable multi-resistant tomato. You can take that tomato like Fred Hempel did and use it as one of your parent lines for your own F1 crosses.

So say I wanted a disease resistant dwarf F1 for MT and surrounding regions. I could do something like cross one of the Idaho state dwarfs like Payette, Sandpoint, or Kootenai with say Purple Zebra F1 or Galahad F1. then sort out a dwarf in the F2, then back cross it again then sort out 128 dwarfs and test them. If I got one that had most of the resistances I wanted I could stabilize that for 5 more generations testing the offspring as I went for the traits I wanted. Once I had a stable version I could do something like: make a new F1 with Payette, Sandpoint or Kootenai (or any nice descendants I made along the way) all of which have their dwarfing trait from the same source- and if it was a nice vigorous and disease resistant F1 I could market it regionally as a good commercial F1 hybrid dwarf tomato for the intermountain west and maybe pay for all that testing and fiddly work (if it is a big enough market to support enough seed sales to make it all worthwhile)!

Or alternatively you could just sell seed for the multi-resistant tomato you developed- but then you might not make enough back to pay for its development because anyone could just save the seeds and probably also just sell them if they wanted to.

One other way to save costs might be to develop 128 stable lines and then test them for $500. For instance, I crossed Purple Zebra to MMM in 2022 and that to Galahad in 2023. That one cross could segregate in pretty interesting ways with a decent chance at having resistances. If I took that to the F7 with 128 separate lines it might be interesting to pay that $500 for the test find out which line has what, and then use those lines as parents or finished varieties.  Or do some skipping of generations between testings to save costs.

Though personally I would want something just a little more interesting to start with which will probably involve a few more crosses before I started paying to check traits.

There are also limitations to this process- the right traits in the wrong package still make for a weak tomato plant. For example: Julia Dakin found that Reed's tomatoes do well for her last year- vigor is important.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days