Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Alex

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-11-13, 10:54:12 AMSounds amazing! Does anyone have seeds for S. corneliomulleri? 😉
HRseeds has all the wild tomatoes except Solanum huaylasense, I bought there.

Joseph Lofthouse

#361
Corneliomulleri, peruvianum, and arcanum seem so closely related that I combined the populations in my garden.

Justin Jardinier

#362
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-13, 10:26:36 PMCorneliomulleri, peruvianum, and arcanum seem so closely related that I combined the populations in my garden.

Is that the same population as sold by the Experimental Farm network, or a separate population?
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/solanum-peruvianum

I ask because that is specifically listed as "Solanum peruvianum", rather than a hybrid swarm of 3 different species.

I don't know if this is universally accepted, by my understanding of the modern species classification of tomatoes is based on the book 'TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE)', Iris E. Peralta - 2008. I find this an extremely useful text. It groups the 17 tomato species in the following way:

QuoteWe rely on clear morphological discontinuities to define the easily distinguished species
S. habrochaites, S. juglandifolium, S. lycopersicoides, S. pennellii, S. ochranthum, and S. sitiens. The following closely related species are generally easy to distinguish but sometimes intergrade: 1) S. lycopersicum, S. pimpinellifolium, 2) S. cheesmaniae, S. galapagense (sometimes also with introduced S. pimpinellifolium), 3) S. arcanum, S. chmielewskii, S. neorickii, 4) S. corneliomulleri, S. peruvianum, 5) S. chilense, S. huaylasense.

Their grouping seems to be well backed up by the various recent genetic analyses. I seem to have observed also notable similarities between arcanum and chmielewskii, and found it quite interesting that whilst they smelled different from each other, they both smelled strongly and most pleasantly. And whilst chmielewskii's flowers were significantly smaller, they both had straight anther cones and styles, unlike the characteristic curve of peruvianum accessions. Though these observations of mine are based only on one chmielewskii accession and two of arcanum. I found some peruvianum accessions also smelled very good, though none as strong and some barely at all. Those that smelled the most tended to have a rather sweet smell, though somehow less exciting than chm. and arc.

I made a chart to show the species' relationship in graphical form, including the group names and section names and colouring the more closely related species within the groups though note, black is the one colour having no special meaning in that respect. I include it here in case it is useful for others:
Screenshot 2023-11-16 at 02.13.03.png

William Schlegel

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-15, 07:17:26 PMIs that the same population as sold by the Experimental Farm network, or a separate population?
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/solanum-peruvianum

I ask because that is specifically listed as "Solanum peruvianum", rather than a hybrid swarm of 3 different species.

I don't know if this is universally accepted, by my understanding of the modern species classification of tomatoes is based on the book 'TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE)', Iris E. Peralta - 2008. I find this an extremely useful text. It groups the 17 tomato species in the following way:

Their grouping seems to be well backed up by the various recent genetic analyses. I seem to have observed also notable similarities between arcanum and chmielewskii, and found it quite interesting that whilst they smelled different from each other, they both smelled strongly and most pleasantly. And whilst chmielewskii's flowers were significantly smaller, they both had straight anther cones and styles, unlike the characteristic curve of peruvianum accessions. Though these observations of mine are based only on one chmielewskii accession and two of arcanum. I found some peruvianum accessions also smelled very good, though none as strong and some barely at all. Those that smelled the most tended to have a rather sweet smell, though somehow less exciting than chm. and arc.

I made a chart to show the species' relationship in graphical form, including the group names and section names and colouring the more closely related species within the groups though note, black is the one colour having no special meaning in that respect. I include it here in case it is useful for others:
Screenshot 2023-11-16 at 02.13.03.png

I was reading this thinking: Can Solanum arcanum cross with Solanum peruvianum? Remembering something... Then I came back around to the groupings you made there Justin and I am not sure it can, or at least not all accessions- plants don't exactly follow the rules we make for them. A few years ago I requested seed for two Solanum arcanum accessions hoping they might prove a bridge- but then I read further and found out that they don't cross with Solanum peruvianum though it might be hard to tell the two apart sometimes without consulting a taxonomic key. I should really grow those Solanum arcanum accessions out again and try to cross them with domestic tomatoes- those specific strains were supposed to be easier to cross with domestic! Though just some back ground: Joseph sent me some very interesting seed back in 2017. His then strain of Solanum peruvianum, his then strain of Solanum cornelio-muelleri, and a putative cross- and the cross grew for me. I think we posted an interesting exchange about it on permies.com perhaps in my thread about my direct seeded project of 2017. I wouldn't be surprised if I still have seed of all three- which probably should be grown out again.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-15, 08:11:20 PMI was reading this thinking: Can Solanum arcanum cross with Solanum peruvianum? Remembering something... Then I came back around to the groupings you made there Justin and I am not sure it can, or at least not all accessions- plants don't exactly follow the rules we make for them.

This is one cross I did not actually attempt, but I am intending to do so when I get time, perhaps later this week. Well, actually I do have LA2333, which is listed by the TGRC as arcanum, but in the European genebank as peruvianum. And to me, relative to the population of LA2172 x/+ LA1708 I have, which I have been taking (on a rather random basis with no real justification) as 'standard arcanum', it seems more like peruvianum. I only grew one plant, and pollinated it with mass pollen collected from many per. accessions. I did not process the fruits yet, quite overdue! But I am assuming they have seeds. Hmm, maybe I did already process some fruits in fact... I have not had enough time to update my notes recently.

I did manage to pollinate LA2172 x/+ LA1708 with LA2333 pollen recently, the fruits are now developing. I also have pollinated domestic x [LA2172 x/+ LA1708] F1 with pollen from various per. pollen. The only fruits I harvested of those so far were mass mixed pollen, and there were a few seeds with endosperm and seed coat, so that seemed extremely promising, but no germination. I have numerous fruits ripening how of similar cross attempts but each with specific per accessions so that I can see what is working, and will hopefully get more seeds to attempt to germinate. I have also made multiple attempts using these F1 plants' pollen on various per accessions to see if they'll work that way - too early to tell yet, but one F1 seems to have pollinated one per accession at least. Will be a long time until seeing if there are any seeds on these tests.

I seem to have made successful crosses of SC pen x per, for various per accessions. I have not attempted to germinate any of the seeds yet. I was just processing some such seeds today. If the crosses to the arc crosses work, that would be preferable as I think that would be a shorter journey to edibility, but the pen bridge seems a potentially useful avenue also. If the pen x per proves able to pollinate domestics, then it might be worth making 25% pen 75% per and seeing if that could also pollinate domestics, since having less pen may shorten the journey and allow more focus on per traits.

I found it very difficult to cross arc to domestic. So, even if per and arc could cross, that might not help matters much in normal circumstances, though it might prove useful for me since I could likely use my arc crosses to bridge them. I also have some 75% arc growing, and I have some arc fruits growing pollinated by domestic x arc, so they would also be 75% if they bear viable seeds - I am hoping to get the mother line by doing that. The 75% crosses I am also mainly intending for the purpose of increasing the number of SI alleles, since I only made 4 F1s, one of has failed so far to pollinate anything and has only given 2 fruits so far (with no viable seeds), being almost completely incompatible with pollen I have tried on it, aside maybe from pennellii which has pollinated it fairly easily, though 1) I do not yet know how the seeds will be and 2) it will take it further away from edibility.

I made many attempts at using per. pollen from many accessions to pollinate the red/orange fruited species, with no luck at all. Easier to pollinate than with arc pollen but all endospermless embryos. Not enough data points to be sure, I probably tried only 100 times each with arc and per, I did not count. But my sense is that arc, or the arc I used anyway, is easier than per. So the prospect of using arc hybrids or pen as bridges for per is appealing. Also from the genetic analysis it would make sense that arc might be easier to cross with since it seems closer related to domestic tomatoes than per is.

Justin Jardinier

Hmm, another thing I never tried (and I no longer have chm growing) is that perhaps chm could act as a bridge? I really should have tried making chm x arc. Chm seems very easy to cross with! Oh and, I do have one more chm that is not the one I wrote of above, and that is supposedly LA1028. To me this seems like peruvianum. Again I am basing this really on the other chm I have, taking it as my reference, but that one does seem to conform to general descriptions of the species, for example the characteristic lemony smell, and the ease of crossing with red/orange species. The LA1028 on the other hand had to me the appearance of peruvianum, including not only the flower but also the fruit. And no lemony smell. And I did indeed seem to pollinate it with per, whereas all of my attempts at crossing it to red/orange fruited tomatoes failed. My working conclusion is that I believe it to be per, not chm. And I wonder if that is a misidentification made by the TGRC, or perhaps a mix up by the person who sent me the seeds, perhaps putting the wrong seeds in the packet, whether recently or in the past at some stage.

Anyway, if one could make chm x per, then crossing that to domestic should have a fairly good chance, and the journey to good taste might be shorter than with pen. I have found for example pimp x chm to taste nice already in F1.

William Schlegel

Our accessions may just naturally become a bit mixed up over time. Unless you strictly isolate, self, or hand pollinate and bag. We should start a lovely little seed bank and follow strict protocols!

Another thought: Key the plants out using a taxonomic key- we found a key a few years ago.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#367
The wonderful text I mentioned above says arcanum has corollas 1.8–2 cm in diameter. I've also just noticed that it says:
Quoteaccessions we now recognize as S. arcanum did not cross successfully with either S. chmielewskii or S. neorickii (Rick et al. 1976)

... though it still might be worth attempting perhaps.

Hmm, I'm also now noticing that it says:
QuoteSolanum arcanum is an extremely variable species, comprising four weakly defined morphotypes ("assemblages") with discrete geographic ranges. The complex overlapping variability, especially in leaf morphology, dissuades us from recognizing these as formal taxa.

And goes on to say:
QuoteThis variability and apparent morphological intermediacy led Rick to include populations now recognized as S. arcanum as part of a broadly constituted S. peruvianum (as Lycopersicon peruvianum). The northern populations of Rick's L. peruvianum, now recognized as S. arcanum, have complex crossing relationships with more southerly populations of S. peruvianum s.l. and with S. chilense (Rick 1963, 1986a). Because these northern populations could be crossed successfully with S. chilense but not with S. peruvianum s.str., Rick (1986a) suggested that they were ancestral to the rest of the "peruvianum complex," and that northern Peru was a major site of evolutionary development in the wild tomatoes.

I now also see that it does recognise LA2333 and indeed LA2172 and LA1708 all as being members of "S. arcanum ('Marañón' assemblage)". Also, the fruits I mentioned of LA2333 which I pollinated with mass per pollen, I forgot to mention a critical point - it was actually mainly per but did also include chilense pollen. I have to say I was rather disappointed with this accession though, it having tiny fruits (far smaller than the other and the TGRC also notes "pea sized fruits") and no remarkable smell. But it would seem it really is arcanum.

Of the peruvianums, LA0448 had among the largest fruits, and seemed easy to cross with pen (not all per accessions were), so I find this an appealing accession.

As for chm LA1028, the fruits went black outside and there is no note of anthocyanin in the fruits on the TGRC - this is one of the indications that made me think it may be per and perhaps not actually this accession, perhaps other seeds. I can't find photos of the leaves or flowers right now so can't confirm further. I could of course be quite wrong about my judgement of this plant.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-15, 09:48:00 PMOur accessions may just naturally become a bit mixed up over time. Unless you strictly isolate, self, or hand pollinate and bag. We should start a lovely little seed bank and follow strict protocols!

Another thought: Key the plants out using a taxonomic key- we found a key a few years ago.

On pg.55 of the text I have been discussing, there is a detailed species key. I found it so dense in specialised botanical language that I could not use it, but for those who can understand it, it must be quite useful.

Justin Jardinier

#368
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-15, 09:48:00 PMWe should start a lovely little seed bank and follow strict protocols!
Oh and on this point, that's a nice idea, and I think population sizes should be taken quite seriously for that also. Unfortunately even some gene banks seem to give out quite low seed numbers, which would automatically cause bottlenecks, so perhaps if such a seed bank were initiated, it could be good to make sure to start with sufficient seed numbers when it comes to SI species.

In my own growing I have started with only 1~5 plants of each of the per and chil accessions, basically to trial them and also for working with mixed pollen in wide cross attempts. So, no good for bulking seed of individual accessions. Though I also let all the outdoor ones cross, and mass pollinated the indoor ones with indoor and outdoor pollen, and used indoor pollen on some of the outdoor ones, so my seed should be quite diverse from the bulk seed I collected. The wide cross attempts with those species I have been doing mostly indoors, now completely indoors since the season is over, and that is far easier indoors, especially since I need not worry about contamination. For some crosses outdoors I did also bag flowers which was useful for the following reasons:
1) The bees were extremely active so it was very hard to get any pollen from any of the outcrossing species unless I bagged them to reserve pollen for myself!
2) To prevent... well, I suppose lessen but might not be 100% prevention of unwanted pollen.
3) Bags were pretty useful for falling fruit also.

For per x pen attempts I did make many outside for which I simply removed the petals of per and hand pollinated, thinking that the bees would avoid them. This I regret and would not repeat. I have kept seeds from those that gave fruit, but remain skeptical about those results until I see how they grow. Taking the extra time to bag those would have been much wiser, a process I started rather late in the season. Luckily I made also numerous indoor attempts, although falling fruit has been an issue - I should have bagged the indoor ones! The per x pen project was a relatively low priority so I was not quite on the ball with it.

William Schlegel

#369
This idea of a germplasm tomato seed bank, or maybe even an independent seed bank catering to independent breeders such as ourselves for a wider variety of taxa. It isn't a bad idea, but it is a difficult idea. For tomatoes an optimal climate would be ideal. UC Davis has that, thus TGRC's location works well for maintaining accessions. It is definitely a hard row to hoe! A year round heated greenhouse space would be ideal, but also the ability to tend to the plants. I do think that those accessions I've obtained are declining in quality as they go through generations under my care- that is the ones I can get to set seed! Even at the professional seed banks there is some concern that these wild accessions are slowly declining in quality- that is one reason why they are increasingly reluctant to share seed with independent plant breeders. At the same time, there is a very disturbing decrease in the availability of university plant breeding programs and university plant breeders.

If we can get our tomato genetics into palatable grexes and a lot of people kept growing them out it might be simplified somewhat- as that could conserve a lot of tomato genetics. One of the basic problems we face is that morphological variation without substantial genetic variation is making it look like we have a lot of tomato diversity in domestic tomatoes when, especially with true heirlooms, we don't at the genetic level. I struggle with this even in my own garden and end up making a lot of domestic x domestic crosses! Even with some tomatoes that have modern traits- like blue skin, that is often introgressed into a background without much of any resistance- and that seems to be the case with my Mission Mountain Sunrise tomato for an example- grow reports are coming back from wetter climates showing it to have disease issues.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-15, 07:17:26 PMIs that the same population as sold by the Experimental Farm network, or a separate population?
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/solanum-peruvianum
Is it whitefly resistant? I'm looking for whitefly resistant tomatoes.

William Schlegel

#371
Alex I think Solanum galapagense and Solanum habrochaites would be good germplasm for whitefly resistance. As would Solanum penellii. Peruvianum is hard but not impossible to work with, requiring embryo rescue for successful crosses. It is also one I haven't heard mentioned for whitefly or arthropod resistance. 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-16, 10:12:29 PMSolanum galapagense ... would be good germplasm for whitefly resistance.
Hairy, non-hairy variety or both?

William Schlegel

I assume hairy is where the arthropod resistance comes from but really arthropod resistance is also chemical and could be found in both.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex

Theoretically hairy Solanum galapagense has stronger whitefly resistance, than non-hairy one. Likewise hairy plant and fruit Solanum habrachaites has stronger whitefly resistance, than non-hairy plant, hairy fruit one. Solanum pennellii is not tasty for them.
I hope this list is not finished and some wild tomatoes have whitefly resistance also, at least when they young.