Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Hard to say. I decided it wasn't worth ordering.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB


William Schlegel

#347
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-06-14, 08:48:31 PMhttps://growingfruit.org/t/tomato-breeding-and-cracking/50961/13

Have you heard of "wild child" a LA1777 offspring?
https://jandlgardens.com/xencart/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=1_8&products_id=577&zenid=1pimpcfpvhuesndjin14akpte2

I grew it several years ago. It was, as I recall, very short season. I liked it. Saved a lot of seed. Shared some. I should grow it again and make a cross with it some time. Red.

I like Lee Goodwin's work and he has shared quite a bit of it via his website. Impressive list of varieties he has bred both from wild crosses and other projects like his sungold dehybridization Ambrosia and subsequent outcrosses.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

This is an interesting paper and covers many techniques and taxa, useful not only for tomatoes so if anyone wants to move this, feel free, but this was the best place I could think of putting it - 'METHODS FOR OVERCOMING INTERSPECIFIC CROSSING BARRIERS':
https://www.liliumbreeding.nl/pollenbitech.PDF?

AndrewB

#349
Got my first taste of "The One" today. Not sure if there are any viable seeds. Will try my best.

My wife was like "this doesn't taste like any tomato I've ever had before". I agreed mostly. It had a hint of yellow pennelli hybrid fruit juice flavor.

We both weren't sure we liked it but weren't sure we didn't like it. I thought it had almost a peppery (green pepper) / pineapple-ish after flavor to it (minus the sweetness). Fruity I guess. Odd. Unique.

My tomato trial is not going well, but that could be a good thing in the end. Definitely need genetics that can do well in poor nutrient soils and disease resistant. "The One" was heavily hit by some sort of disease this year. Probably the hardest hit of all of them. Though 98% of the rest were pretty hard hit too.

Edit: second taste. Similar to Big Hill in texture but flavor is better I think. Not quite mealy or too mushy but on the mushy side. I think I like the overall flavor. Very fruity. Has pineapple notes. Needs a bit more sugar to be more fruit like. Mine has no viable seeds in all three fruits.

William Schlegel

Interesting observations. You have any more plants- flavor was pretty variable last year?!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

I think this plant is dying. I'll check if it has more fruits forming. There should be another plant in the raised bed. I need to check it too.

Interesting as a breeding line. I think these fruity lines should be crossed with the lines that have been bred for that extra sugar or sweetness.

William Schlegel

Hmm that parthenocarpic? no seed early fruit trait sure snuck in.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I like the idea of crossing fruity lines with sweet tomatoes like Isis Candy, Black Cherry, and Sungold.

I'm disappointed in Sweet Cherriette. The plants do fairly well, but the tomatoes are tiny and not as sweet as I had hoped. I was expecting sweetness level closer to Isis Candy.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-08-02, 08:33:08 AMI like the idea of crossing fruity lines with sweet tomatoes like Isis Candy, Black Cherry, and Sungold.

I'm disappointed in Sweet Cherriette. The plants do fairly well, but the tomatoes are tiny and not as sweet as I had hoped. I was expecting sweetness level closer to Isis Candy.

I think I had read it wasn't sweet before I even got my first ripe one in 2017. I still like Sweet Cherriette as breeding material- though I noticed that now that I finally have a cross with it I didn't grow it this year. Just the cross.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

https://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/solanum-arcanum-red-tomato-hr


I may go back and order more seeds from HRseeds again.


"This is a strange one, one bract on a Solanum Arcanum plant made red tomatoes! It is NOT a hybrid or cross of any kind it just simply put out a red variation of Solanum Arcanum."


Tomatoes can make mutations - and it can affect fruits.


A mutation could only effect certain bracts or parts of a plant.


Some plants / trees, can sometimes put out variegated or other novel things on the same plant.



Regardless, a red S. arcanum.


I'd be interested in seeing if the offspring would put out red fruit as well.


Or if the red gene is a switch on, and it's like common tomatoes and S. pimpinellifolium's red coloration gene.

Or if it's something completely different.



I felt like this was worth mentioning here.

Garrett Schantz

I've mentioned before on here that his pimpinellifolium types are mixed, which he usually confirms.

I haven't grown out the mentioned Arcanum.

A single bract making red tomatoes and the rest being typical, is odd.


Arcanum leaves are very variable, depending on population and things.

https://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/wild-tomato-solanum-arcanum

There's his Arcanum that he sells. He could sell more of them.



The leaves themselves look more or less the same to me, on both types.


The species is very variable in leaf shapes and the like.


Wild Tomato species likely have had hybridizations with different populations and things, adapted for different locations.


I personally love that he doesn't isolate his plants.



I do wish that he'd make it more apparent that bees and things can cause unintentional crosses.


But, save for gene transfer, changing the genetics of one bracts fruit color, is unlikely.



But yeah, he does sell some arcanum crosses.

Being that this has the same leaf type as his other one, I'd think that it's possibly at least semi-pure. And an Arcanum mother would be interesting, but I don't think it's what happened here.



Most of his galapagense fruit and the like, or at least one page, notes that some of them likely crossed with Pimpinellifolium and domestic tomatoes, but they were in fact collected on the Galapagos Islands, thus making them Galapagos Island Tomatoes.


He should probably copy and paste that on all of the pages for various types.


I haven't seen many false claims there, myself.



I've also mentioned on here somewhere as well, that yeah. He probably gets seed from Lupinaster.

I live in the United States, so I would have issues buying directly from him.


Over here, you can have all of your seed destroyed if it's found that you imported seed without a phyto. And that guy doesn't seem to offer them.



I've done some thorough reviews and things on his blog.


There's some issues with his pages on things. Most species probably have around 10 different leaf types at least, found within a species.


Even Pimpinellifolium can get up there in different leaf types.


Then there's hairs on leaves, root system differences, mountain or plains accessions of species.



I believe that William or someone has grown a supposed subspecies of Habrochaites. But, that subspecies has other types with different types of insecticide chemical makeups. Completely different.



Identifying species based on their leaves, isn't ideal. The same goes with some other factors.


Someone else had a blog about different tomato species. In general, those labels seem to work a lot better with mainly SC species and the like.

Others have more variables.



We also have an issue of where we can only request so many accessions and many users here can't grow out certain wild species due to their climate. Or they manage, but F2s and the like are bottlenecked.



I've noted before that what he grows, is likely bottlednecked. Or will become bottlenecked due to low population sizes.



And, I've sent him an email or something, about this page.

https://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/large-kangaroo-apple

He has it listed as Solanum lanceolatum. That's a completely different species from Solanum laciniatum.

Ones from South America and is toxic, the others from Australia and it's edible.


That was a year or two ago that I sent something out to him.


It's still listed incorrectly.


The whole "types" thing from Lupinaster though. That's outdated or not entirely valid information.


The clade itself seems to have begun speciation fairly recently, as far as some things go.

So it's hard to pinpoint some things to certain standards.


I'm also not too sure about his selling of Buffalo Burr as a good idea.


I haven't found any outright lies or misinformation though.


I believe he has a newer - in the works page, called Invisible tomatoes. But he's probably referring to a variety and mistook it as glow in the dark or something?


I dunno.



I see him as a hobby seller more than anything. He sells hard to find things - rare things.



In the winter, he typically has some live streams. He's mentioned during those that he's busy collecting seed or focusing on plants and things or whatever else during the growing season.


And yeah, outside of gene banks, he's probably one of the better resources for getting wild relative seed.

I believe he's going to be selling a newer Capsicum species, one recently mentioned in science.


His selling of non-pepper relatives, seems more recent.



He's probably better off selling SC types than SI, since different "types" will cross unless he cycles them every year and sells old seed every other year.

And different species could cross.












Garrett Schantz

I'd like to mention that he mentioned "bract" but didn't specify if it's an offshoot bract from the Arcanum or a flower bract, which produced the red Arcanum.

Garrett Schantz

Some of these were in response to another post which now seems to be gone.



Either way.


With the mention of Galapagos Island Tomato hybrids on there.


S. galapagense and S. cheesmanii.


I remember someone on here mentioning them before.


I've wanted to try out salt tolerance tests and make salt tolerant tomatoes for awhile.


I should have time in the upcoming year.



It mostly came to mind, since I'm planning a feeding area for deer. Pawpaws, American Persimmon and Plums. All sorts of other things, even Osage Orange, Hickory and Oak.


There's already a salt lick out there.



I have a bit of an issue with salt licks. They're banned in 5 or so counties here, due to chronic wasting disease.


I'd imagine that deer staying in single areas and licking a cube - and spreading their stuff together. Salt does preserve bacteria and things.


So, it got me thinking.

I can smash it up, and plant Okahiji Saltwort, Crystalline Iceplant, Swiss Chard, Sea Kale, Oyster Leaf and some salt tolerant Mesquite.

Then I could more or less isolate them into a little box.


There isn't much salt in the soils up here.


A small area like that, would also give a decent test area for Galapagos Island hybrids.

Not all Galapagense and Cheesmanii accessions are found on the beaches.

They also likely have different salt tolerant genes.


I could try growing salt tolerant peas and things over there too.


Either way. I wouldn't need to do controlled areas or whatever.


Deer also dislike plants with fuzzy or hairy leaves.


But, they seeminly love tomatoes.



There are some types in the works that I've heard of. Tomatoes with sugars and flavors not found in typical varieties. Some of the white tomatoes "pineapple" or "citrus" flavors are supposedly from Galapagos Island crosses.

Pennellii and things have further interesting flavors to them.


It would be nice if I could breed a Galapagos Island Tomato crossed into a line with wild flavors and the like.

Deer could end up self selecting better fruits for me - and that patch would weed out anything that isn't salt tolerant.


In the future I'd add salt rocks.


Deer also aren't as likely to overgourge on plants versus rocks.


Crambe species, may end up being overeaten by deer. They put out round bundles of flowers and they're related to Brassica.



I'd have to work on making a contained area, which deer will still walk towards.


Deer visiting an area for fruit and things is nice. But they shouldn't be all licking blocks or potentially spreading disease.



I'm unsure if anyone else's Galapagos Island projects have gotten any further than before.


But, I may start trying to make a salt tolerant line or lines.


The state does get hurricanes, rarely as well.


As time goes on, more inland places will likely have flooding.


I'd like to have a selection of plants which can withstand those events.


I've read that besides cold or extreme heat, some plants can't handle salt - crops included.

Cathy A

Sounds amazing! Does anyone have seeds for S. corneliomulleri? 😉

Quote from: Alex on 2023-11-13, 02:02:01 AMSolanum corneliomulleri:
My second favourite out of the Eriopersicon sub-section speceis. Very nice showy flowers, wide leaves. Almost entirely resistant to bugs. leaves become more scentless as the plant ages and the fruits are amazing. The fruits have the texture and feel of a tomato but the taste is like a very sweet cucumber.