Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Last year I grew Payette tomatoes for a seed grow out for Snake River Seeds Cooperative. The field behaved really nicely because of spacing and the dwarfism trait.

This leads me to think that breeding a strain of dwarf obligate outcrossing tomatoes would make selection easier in two ways.

1. Seedlings segregate into two height classes. So the dwarfs can be separated out before out planting.

2. The dwarfs play nice in the field and individual plants stay separate at a nice spacing.

Which has me intrigued about breeding with dwarfs and with potato leaf. Hmm. Exserted dwarf potato leaf yellow fruit, obligate outcrossing. Long term goal.

When the dwarves hit OSSI Carol Deppe said something about how she thought the dwarf trait might replace the determinate trait. Because of the good performance of determinate varieties in his breeding conditions Joseph breeds with determinate a lot. So determinate is incorporated into his obligate outcrossing project. Its also very common in my garden now. I'm not sure how determinate and dwarf interact. However I am sure that small early tomato plants must have some diversity in trait and trait interactions and I wonder if it goes beyond dwarf project dwarf, determinate, and micro? I did a search and interspecies habrochaites hybrids do sometimes produce dwarfing effects.

My 2020 grow out of Lizzano descended tomatoes made a nice uniform row of basketball shape and sized tomato plants for instance.

Sweet Cherriette plants can be small to very small.

In my garden 42 Days and Forest Fire have also been very small in the past. Though in 2017 I had a lot of plants freeze to the ground and come back. I suspect that tomato torture leads to smaller plants especially on determinate varieties.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

The large Peruvianum that I mentioned before is looking quite nice.

So far it has pretty big leaves compared to the others in Joseph's mix, growing pretty fast compared to the others. Also larger / sturdier stems. Green colored stem as well - other peruvianums are sort of purpleish. Stem image is rather blurry, phone camera refused to focus, the green color shows up though...

Having leaves this big - this early probably means that it will be a rather large plant. Or the leaves will be huge and the plant will be small. Variable population.

Suppose I will post a supposed SC Peruvianum - I am not growing many of them. I will be isolating them from other Peruvianum types.


Third image is the SC Peruvianum. The other two images are the weird Peruvianum.

Garrett Schantz

Got bored and looked around for more interesting accessions.

Solanum arcanum:
PI 127829 - Highly exserted
PI 365952 - Slender foliage, seems quite fruitful

Solanum peruvianum:
PI 128651 - Slight anthocyanin appearance
PI 251309 / LA0448 - High anthocyanin on some fruit
PI 365948 / LA1337 - Small purple fruits - small foliage
PI 390681 - Nice flowers - small foliage - slight anthocyanin appearance
PI 390685 - Slight anthocyanin appearance
PI 306811 - An inbred selection From PI 128650 made for mosaic resistance.
PI 298934 - L. esculentum x L. peruvianum
PI 306814 - L. esculentum x L. peruvianum Lines that segregate for the mosaic resistance carried by the male parent.
PI 306812 - L. esculentum x L. peruvianum Lines that segregate for the mosaic resistance carried by the male parent.
PI 298935 - L. esculentum x L. peruvianum

Solanum lycopersicum:
PI 272219 - Reportedly a cross between L. esculentum, L. pimpinellifolium and L. peruvianum.

Solanum pennellii:
PI 414773 / LA1724: One plant intermingling with Lycopersicon peruvianum. Flowering profusely. Some fruit set, ranging from ripe to unripe. Not sticky. Some plants with basal stem 3to 4cm diameter. Flower with basal articulation.


I mostly looked at accessions with images. Helps to judge exsertion and other traits that aren't documented very much.

I might request some of these next year. Having an exserted arcanum would be quite nice.

I am doing some further Peruvianum intermixing this year / next year. Some of the types that I am growing have different leaf types than Joseph's mix - different.

One type that I have should have small purple hairy fruits - similar trichomes to habrochaites. I don't see any fruit drop in the images provided - possibly SC.
Another type has cherry - larger than currant sized purple fruit. Supposed to be SC.
Another type is a large plant, white fruit. Also supposed to be SC. Some of the bracts on this one can have up to 8 - 16 flowers / tomatoes.
Another type is fast growing, larger trichomes on leaves than other types I have. Has a lemony smell. Supposed to have small green fruit.

Joseph's Mix is probably all SI plants.

Those types might be isolated from SI plants. I could try getting SI seed back from someone else rather than separating these plants.

The SI and SC Peruvianums apparently diverged some time ago - same with SC / SI habrochaites. Possibly meaning that they have different traits and other fun things to share.

All of the Peruvianums I have should be exserted to some extent.

Restoring the SI gene throughout the population sounds like it would be a pain - isolating the SC plants, mixing them together and then crossing the best offspring with a SI Peruvianum, isolating the offspring to make sure it is definitely SI (might bottleneck it a bit, but it would be tossed back into the main group).

Any ideas on the best way to intermix the groups? I don't mind if it takes awhile.


Garrett Schantz

Found a BH seedling with really small / yellow cotyledons. The first true leaf is different from all of the others in the group as well. It is sort of deformed and hard to see the leaf in the image - I will probably post an update on it eventually. Could be nothing - but might as well see what happens with it.

William Schlegel

I've poisoned three of my trays, the three 72 cell trays I bought from Walmart with too much of a good thing: water. I think as soon as the weather warns up a little I'm moving everyone out to the greenhouse.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: William S. on 2021-04-14, 04:15:49 PM
I've poisoned three of my trays, the three 72 cell trays I bought from Walmart with too much of a good thing: water. I think as soon as the weather warns up a little I'm moving everyone out to the greenhouse.

I usually buy from Greenhouse Megastore - I use 1020 tray / inserts.

I overwatered one of my trays, moved it outside when the weather was nice for a few days - allowed soil to dry out.

William Schlegel

I think that's where I used to get my greenhouse film on my old greenhouse (over a decade ago) and some pots and things I still use. About due for a new case or something planting tray wise. On the tail end of some 18 cell trays I bought a case of who knows how long ago. 

Have you seen plantel reusable trays? Used them for native grass plugs years ago for work. Those are nice. Though would have to think in what cell size I want for tomatoes.


LA2329 habrochaites tray is the one I am most worried about because I went all in on those. Weather is looking warmer soon.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Some of the notable Peruvianums.

These were all started at about the same time.

Some fun leaf types so far. Leaf types / plant sizes seem to vary quite a bit.

I probably won't post anymore images of these until they are outside.


William Schlegel

Thought this one has wild type leaf.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Today I planted seeds outside for all the peruvianum hybrids or pre-bred introgression lines. I counted 9 total from both usda grin and tgrc. One had large seeds (presumably the pre-bred line), while the rest had small. One line is LA0214 which is an introgression line but has dark orange anthers from S. Peruvianum.

I also planted the rest of the other ones with wild ancestry including Big Hill. I had one saved from me, one from Gilbert and one from William. Will look for any off-types.

Also planted my old seed for Fantom du laos that had unusually tiny seeds in case they are wild hybrids.

Still need to plant the new centerflor tomatoes from peace seedlings and descended from Alan Kapuler's work. I think these are descended from S. Chilense.

Also planted LA1996 pre-bred from S. Chilense.

And S. Sitiens and S. Lycopersicon. I wanted to do the bleach treatment as it seems to help germination,  but I had so many I decided not to. I get what I get.

Also planted the very last seed i have for S. Cheesmaniae and S. Galapagense.

William Schlegel

#190
I am growing out a tiny growout of a second generation of cheesemanii and galapagense from seed you sent me. One took a long time to germinate but did. This time I will plant them further from any other tomatoes as they were small plants and almost got buried in a habrochaites hybrid jungle. Hopefully it will produce plenty of seed for sharing and your growout as well. I think thats a neat part of our collabotative effort as a group. Success can mean seed enough to replenish the whole groups seed stores. Would be cool to use them as a pollen parent on something like Big Hill.

I did the 30 minute 50% strength bleach TGRC protocol on LA2329 and it was the first tomato to germinate. I
Which I found intriguing and perhaps worth using more.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Yeah, I agree.

It's nice because in a way by sharing seed but also each one of us focusing on different aspects of the main overall project allows for both hedging of bets in case of one garden's crop failures, but also allows diverse focus which may each be either a genetic dead end or a wonderful cross or segregation or wonderful discovery.

For example, last year my one seed of the alternate pennellii hybrid strain failed, but you were able to grow it to tern and save seed.

This year I hope at the very least to make inroads to the peruvianum hybrids and I am already excited after planting the seed!

But yes, If either or both of us are able to save seed from the pure cheesmaniae and galapagense i think we should share it with the experimental farm network. Especially since there are false cherry tomatoes out there (some which may indeed have cheesmaniae heritage) being sold and labeled as Solanum cheesmaniae when true S. cheesmaniae has much smaller fruits and much much smaller seeds. That is not to say that the hybrids are not tastier and/or better than the original species, but people should at least know what they are growing and not fall victim to snake oil salesmen.

Speaking of a galapagense hybrid.... A few years back I had a plant of an self-incompatible F2 pennellii hybrid I was growing inside. I was able to successfully pollinate some fruits with S. galapagense pollen and fruits started forming. Sadly due to some neglegence on my part I accidentally broke off the stem with a fruit that was fairly far along but not far enough. I would like to repeat that experiment some time.

If nothing else, the bleach treatment should at least clean the seed of pathogens and should help seedling survival that way. But it is possible it helps germination also by eating away at the seed coat. I have wondered if the exact same method could be used on raspberry seeds instead of the common sulfuric acid method. I have some seedlings that have sprouted this week of Rubus bartonianus and Rubus leucodermis that were planted not last summer, but the summer before. I used only mechanical scarification, and while it seems to have worked it needed another year of stratification it seems.

I planted seeds of some of the newer plentiflor tomatoes from the Kapulers. They sound very interesting as they are supposed to be similar to the centerflor cherry tomatoes, but more of a larger salad size tomato.

William Schlegel

When I was doing plant tissue culture alot back in 2009-11 I used a 10% bleach for one minute protocol followed by a H202 minute followed by sterile water rinse. This 30 minute 50% bleach TGRC protocol must soften the seed coat!

For Rubus a H202 rinse may be enough to short circuit the 2 years down to one. I have a wild Rubus ideas patch in the back yard that took two years to germinate. Then some folks in the nursery told me to use the hydrogen peroxide, still haven't propagated more rubus (this would be early 2000's) Check the native plant network's propagation protocol database for duration.

I would feel like I would need to grow an ounce of seed to sell or share on EFN probably take 100 plants or more unless I could get them bigger than in 2019. I don't plan to isolate them either. Would be neat to find a chance hybrid but I suspect they have more potential as pollen parents. Though maybe, it really doesn't take much seed to do some sharing. There aren't that many of us wild tomato enthusiasts. One of the things I learned last year is that one ounce of tomato seed is enough for most tomato varieties. It isn't really that much. One great big plant might almost be enough. Except my 2019 plants of these were tiny. Had a lot more seeds than I planted though in the few fruits!

It was 2019 I grew that big penellii hybrid you sent one seed of. The offspring from it is an interesting seed packet I would like to grow again. Maybe next year. I'll probably scale back my LA2329 next year as if all goes well I'll have plenty of seed to share and years worth of seed. Then maybe I can rotate out some other things.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse


My tomato breeding efforts end up selecting for yellow/orange fruits because of the amazing flavor, and for determinate because of the quick early productivity.

Therefore, I am selecting against the red indeterminate tomatoes that are highly popular. Perhaps other people, in other climates will work on those types.

At my place, Solanum galapagense has tiny fruits, with few seeds per fruit, and few fruits per small plant. I could aspire to grow enough seed for close collaborators, but not enough for a seed company. Although, I have grown it enough generations that the seed doesn't require scarification, and it survives outside in the native soil.


William Schlegel

That domestic galapagense is a nice yellow with good flavor and super early. It would be interesting to have it tested genetically. It would be a neat trick to cross it with the real galapagense and cheesemanii. Also Coyote would be an interesting choice I think it has a lot of pimpinillifolium in it.

Joseph has done a fairly good job of convincing me to not grow red tomatoes. Still a few. My exserted tiger is not yellow yet. The yellow ones so far aren't exserted. Still hoping for a yellow one. Maybe someone will buy a packet and find one that was hiding in recession. Going to cross it to something yellow and exserted.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days