Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

AndrewB

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2021-04-18, 08:15:47 PM
At my place, Solanum galapagense has tiny fruits, with few seeds per fruit, and few fruits per small plant. I could aspire to grow enough seed for close collaborators, but not enough for a seed company. Although, I have grown it enough generations that the seed doesn't require scarification, and it survives outside in the native soil.

Honestly, just that alone may make your efforts worthwhile. Even if getting a lot of seed is problematic, which at this point still is for me as well.

Similar to the domestication / selection for your strain of the pure S. peruvianum.

I have not yet had luck replicating any of these qualities with the wild tomatoes in my garden, but I also have more or less been practicing crop rotation. If I were to dedicate more efforts to the tomatoes I might make more rapid progress. Which, maybe I should and maybe I will. Up till now my crop efforts have mainly been with colorful peas (this year may mark the most advanced trial / selection of colorful pea varieties for me yet!) and watermelon. It is so hard to choose just one crop to focus on when so many different ones interest me.

There is something to be said though for dedicating time / effort to a project that others are also dedicating time / effort to at the same time. In many ways this ethos is the heart of what it means to be open source. It is not so much having access to the source material freely and easily, though that certainly applies and is the first step. But rather that when others collaborate it can (and often does) speed up research and development by several factors and at the same time reduce research costs. Applying this to plant breeding is partly new and partly old, but very interesting.

Joseph Lofthouse

I took a detailed look at tomato nomenclature a few months ago.

The most startling thing that I discovered is that the species most commonly called "Galapagos Tomato" is Solanum cheesmaniae. I have about 8 seeds of that species. If I plant them, I'll go all in, and risk loosing the species from my garden.

I have about 100 seeds of Solanum galapagense, which is the species that common sense would indicate should be called "Galapagos". Oh well! I have a pot of seedlings growing. As a result of this discussion, I'll plant more.

William Schlegel

#197
I looked at my galapagos and there are now five germinates, three of them new. This is the furry fruited one. Has white fly resistance according to Andrew's blog post. I would kind of like to plant more with the bleach treatment so they will germinate fast and evenly.

Cheesemanii is more abundant and germinated faster and more evenly without treatment.

A experiment might be to plant them in an isolation garden with a yellow exserted such as Big Hill. Big Hill would make a obvious F1 and a fun F2. Obvious F1 is useful given my tendency to help transfer pollen but not to emasculate. Especially with the galapagense that F2 will be intriguing.. I think I will combine the three obligate yellow accessions in one block (R18, S35-36, and XA1/A2 G2) and devote one or two of the smaller isolation gardens to this. 

Edit: or I may keep them in the greenhouse. That would save a lot of work for a first cross. Might even be able to emasculate because emasculation works for me inside and in the greenhouse but so far not outside. Tends to dry the flowers out and I loose them in the field.

That also would open the possibility of crossing LA2329 with the galapagose easily because they would all be in the greenhouse together. Which might do nothing, but they are two widely separate accessions both with arthropod resistences so there could be some interesting synergy there and the result of it would be fuzzy.

It would be nice to keep S35-36 seperate for flavor improvement. R18 has too few individuals though for S allele health so I think it should go in with XA1/A2
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

The state here puts quite a bit of salt on the roads, which usually ends up killing a lot of things next to them.

I could try planting either of the galapagos tomato species by the road along with a few different domestics ( maybe some other wilds ) just to see how they do.

Some domestics / pimpinellifolium types could already have salt tolerances due to where they originated.


I can't really do any crosses outdoors either. Emasculated flowers just dry up. Could be a mix of humidity and other conditions.

William Schlegel

#199
I can daub the unemasculated exserteds though! Have a couple varieties started in consequence. Indoors I made a successful peruvianum pollination on domestic but only one seed worth then I didn't have time to try embryo rescue. Ideally would do 100 such pollinations or so then a big tissue culture day. Which would take a lot of plants. Maybe once I start teaching I can take a summer off some day and get it done.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Bunch of Pimpinellifolium x Habrochaites F2 in a pot.

I moved a few other seedlings into their own pot.

Some of the seedlings seem to be quite small, others seem to be growing large-medium. I figured that this would happen considering what the parents are.

The smaller plants are sort of buried under the larger types...

Second sets of true leaves seem to be varying quite a bit well.

I guess that some dwarf types could show up as well.



AndrewB

#201
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2021-04-18, 11:39:33 PM

The most startling thing that I discovered is that the species most commonly called "Galapagos Tomato" is Solanum cheesmaniae. I have about 8 seeds of that species. If I plant them, I'll go all in, and risk loosing the species from my garden.

I have about 100 seeds of Solanum galapagense, which is the species that common sense would indicate should be called "Galapagos". Oh well! I have a pot of seedlings growing. As a result of this discussion, I'll plant more.

I can't remember which one,  but one of these species is found mostly only on the edges of the island where they get mists of ocean water. Maybe misting similar to S. pennellii would be a good practice. I thought it was S. galapagense with S. cheesmaniae being more inland and sometimes being in volcano soil. Maybe they both prefer volcano soil.

William Schlegel

S. Galapagense is the one near the spray according to wikipedia.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

There are still arguments involving the two species classifications.

Both species can be found on volcanic areas to some extent - same with the salt spray.

Some accessions have notes on them as to where they were collected. That might help.

https://bmcecolevol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1471-2148-13-175
This link talks about trichomes, aclyl sugars being the reason for resistance. Might work with habrochaites, worth a try.

Garrett Schantz

#204
I ordered a few more tomato seeds - mostly Galapagos types. I can probably grow them in pots and get even more seed to experiment with next year.

Cheesmaniae 1: Small orange fruit
Cheesmaniae 2: Small Egg shaped fruit
Cheesmaniae 3: Small green-yellow looking fruit - interesting color
Sara's Galapagos Tomato: Probably Pimpinellifolium x Cheesmaniae, Small red fruit
Some of these are probably hybrids between domestics or pimpinellifolium.


Ordered a Solanum galapagense type from the same site as well.

They also had: Pennellii(LA1272 - PI 365970), Neorickii(LA0247) and Chmielewsky - only one accession for each of these. Figured I might as well get those as well - a bit pricey for these ones, I saved up for these sorts of things though.


Chewy has a product called Fluker's Hermit Beach Sand Substrate.

Contents: Silica sand, coconut fiber for water retention, calcium, sea salt - also has probiotics, unsure of what kind or what they would do to a plant. "No harmful colors or dyes added"

I'm unsure if there is anything in the mix that would cause a toxic fruit, its meant for a pet hermit crab - it does seem like a decent enough mix to mimic certain galapagense / cheesmaniae accessions - could also be used to test salt / sand / flood tolerances in their segregating offspring - would be nice to give to someone living near a beach or salt marsh. The coconut fiber probably wouldn't be too much of an issue considering the tomatoes already deal with a good bit of waterlogging in their natural habitats.

This might work with other coastal tomato accessions as well.

Usually the "true" galapagos tomatoes put out a few small tomatoes, turn yellow - and then they die(unless I grow them out for a few years). Growing them in pots that mimic their natural soils might work better.

I will try some of the mentioned types in the chewy hermit crab sand substrate, others in my normal potting soil.


If any of these grow well for me, flower before the end of the growing season then I will pollinate some exserted pimpinellifoliums with the types that I mentioned.  If not I am growing some of the more interesting wild crosses in pots already, I could do crosses over the winter.


The penneli will be grown in a fast draining mix, misted.

Probably the same with the other two wilds.

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Natural-variation-in-tomato-From-left-to-right-representative-leaf-and-inflorescence_fig1_300919860

This shows Neorickii(LA0247) flowers / leaves in comparison to some other species. Not something that I really want to toss into the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project. Probably getting tossed into my exserted pimpinellifolium - other wilds group. Same with the others if they aren't exserted or large flowered.
 

I couldn't find much on Pennellii(LA1272 - PI 365970). Suppose I will grow it out and see if its exserted.

https://www.redalyc.org/jatsRepo/609/60958461001/html/index.html
Should be fun to cross with either way - might be self-incompatible if I am reading this correctly, would also make it exserted. I will reread it tomorrow. The accession apparently has a high amount of TSS(Total soluble solids - Brix) - 9.3 a. Could have all sorts of fun sugars to add into the Tasty portion of the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project.


These are all being planted late, not expecting much with them in terms of breeding. This is mostly to get more seed for next year.

AndrewB

#205
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-04-27, 08:58:21 PM

I couldn't find much on Pennellii(LA1272 - PI 365970). Suppose I will grow it out and see if its exserted.

LA numbers can always be found on tgrc. Here you go:

https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/Data/Acc/AccDetail.aspx?AccessionNum=LA1272

Quote
Mating System: Allogamous-SI


Im not sure where you bought the Galapagos tomatoes, but if they are selling them as cheesmaniae almost always on the internet they are hybrids.

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2021-04-27, 10:52:01 PM
LA numbers can always be found on tgrc. Here you go:

https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/Data/Acc/AccDetail.aspx?AccessionNum=LA1272


Im not sure where you bought the Galapagos tomatoes, but if they are selling them as cheesmaniae almost always on the internet they are hybrids.

Yeah, I use the ucdavis site sometimes. Pretty nice resource to have, unsure of why I didn't check there... Having a PI number and LA number is nice as a lot of papers / studies only use one of them as reference.

I got the cheesmaniae types from HRseeds. The others all came from there as well. The person who grows these plants lives in the same state as me, shipping and everything works out nicely.

I don't mind the wilds being expensive as they are sort of tedious to grow - most websites probably wouldn't sell them for that reason. I usually just save my own seed afterwards. I get a lot of things there just for breeding purposes.

https://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/galapagos-island-tomato-type-3
This is the weird colored cheesmaniae - they are listed as cheesmanii on there.

Searching Galapagos in the search shows the others. Rather not post a bunch of items for sale on here.

There are some other wilds out of stock right now, those all seem interesting as well. I believe they are all new introductions, so the seed price may eventually fall - I am unsure.

William Schlegel

Put the tiny clump of Solanum galapagense in a giant five gallon pot today.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

HRseeds order arrived today.

Can't find out where I put my cactus potting mix, going to find it tomorrow and plant some seeds or buy a new bag tomorrow.

Figured I might as well show an image of the smaller seeds. They are still bagged, small seeds are easy to lose and to mix up.

Order of seeds from top to bottom.
Penneli LA1272
Neorickii LA0247
Galapagos Island Tomato Type 3 - Solanum cheesmanii
Galapagos Wild Tomato Minor Type 2 - Solanum galapagense

Chmielewsky is on the right.

Penny is just to help with scaling a bit.

The other Galapagos tomatoes had larger seeds - smaller than most domestics though. Possibly hybrids to some extent. Growing them out regardless.

My habrochaites x pimpinellifolium F2 seedlings are doing great. I should be able to find some exserted types to cross with some of the types mentioned here(If everything goes well). I am probably going to stick with truly wild tomato species for this group at first - maybe a subgroup with cherry tomatoes or something.

William Schlegel

#209
Hrseeds sounds interesting. I've watched a few of their videos before Garrett mentioned them and I realized they had a website with seed sales.

That penellii accession you just got from HR Garrett is SI according to TGRC and that is interesting. My failed 2020 experiment with penellii and peruvianum has a chance of working with a different accession. I should order a pack but suspect I don't have time or space for an repeat experiment this year.

I don't like the seed quantities I'm seeing there in Garrett's HR photos, fairly standard for inbred tomato seeds but these accessions contain massive diversity and minimum population sizes are important to maintain that. So definitely a bottleneck effect. Still good to get these things from commercial sources when available because it takes pressure off seed banks. Definitely not a money maker though. I sell an ounce of regular tomato seed for $50 to $75, growing an ounce of seed for these wild species would be more expensive than domestic because of smaller seed size and lower productivity. I imagine the few of us amateur wild species growers/breeders are the market, so I understand the high prices.  I'd prefer to trade for them though given the time, space, and gardening supplies I already expend to grow out and seed save these wild species.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days