Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Kevin Collignon on 2021-03-25, 10:28:45 AM
I am planning on growing out wild tomatoes this year for the first time and I am hoping to create a mix of a bunch of all the wild tomatoes I can get and trying for a hybrid swarm and then begin selecting from that in later generations. If there a specific number of plants that should be grown together for the most genetic diversity? Also I have a few heirloom variates such as black beauty, and brads atomic grape tomatoes that I would like to contribute the color of to the gene pool. Would you suggest just placing these variaties in with the wild mixes so they have a small chance to cross with something else or would their be another method to introduce those types of colors?

Experimental farm network has a bunch of Joseph's wild mixes. Basically these most of these tomatoes need other plants for pollination which allows for a diverse amount of traits / mutations.

As for the 100% wilds, they mostly all need 10 - 20 plants if you really want to sustain the population.

Black beauty / brads atomic grape do not cross freely. If you just want the color I would take some pollen from those tomatoes and rub them on a wild x domestic flower. Mark the flower / fruit, isolate it until you reintroduce the exerted trait. After this, you could plant a large number of atomic grape - somewhat smaller portion of the main population. Afterwards plants those all out and select for the color you want, while still keeping resistant, cold hardy plants with nice flowers.

These populations have the exerted trait pretty much stabilized or are getting close to it. Wouldn't want to mix it back in.

I'm mixing in a few tomatoes with different disease resistances, still doing it in a similar way.

Kevin Collignon

I appreciate the guidance on this.

I have some domestic tomatoes already planted for the year so I may make a new dedicated bed for wild/ promiscuously pollinating tomatoes to start trying to select for ones that handle my climate well and leave the hand mixing for next season. I have tendency to bite off more than I can chew when I get excited about a new technics or ideas for something.

I look forward to reading more about what everyone that are more advanced in this are working on.
Full time small scale farmer and aspiring landrace plant breeder. Current breeding focus for the season are Tomatoes, Melons, watermelons, and potatoes.

William Schlegel

#152
Quote from: Kevin Collignon on 2021-03-25, 10:28:45 AM
I am planning on growing out wild tomatoes this year for the first time and I am hoping to create a mix of a bunch of all the wild tomatoes I can get and trying for a hybrid swarm and then begin selecting from that in later generations. If there a specific number of plants that should be grown together for the most genetic diversity? Also I have a few heirloom variates such as black beauty, and brads atomic grape tomatoes that I would like to contribute the color of to the gene pool. Would you suggest just placing these variaties in with the wild mixes so they have a small chance to cross with something else or would their be another method to introduce those types of colors?

Kevin species tomatoes cross naturally in predictable ways. The group of tomatoes domestic tomatoes are in includes Solanum pimpinillifolium, Solanum galapagense, and Solanum cheesemanii. These along with the domestic tomato can all be crossed and are all self incompatible. However unless you can find a tomato variety with a open flower or  exserted stigma you will have to make the crosses manually. Fortunately Big Hill and its descendant Exserted Orange are just such tomatoes and available on the experimental farm network. Some of the pimpinillifolium strains are also exserted and will pick up pollen from others. You can also manually make the crosses and directions are readily available on YouTube.

Then there are the hard green unpalatable tomato species. These include species like Solanum penellii and Solanum habrochaites that are relatively easy to cross with the first four species but as pollen parents only. Some of the individual populations of these two species are self incompatible and some self compatible. However with these you'll typically end up with some infertility issues for a few generations starting with the F2. Like plants with self incompatibility and inserted stigmas. Or a few plants which simply cannot accept pollen for some reason.

Then there is the group including Solanum peruvianum, Solanum arcanum, and Solanum chilense. These typically require embryo rescue to cross with. However there are a few accessions for which greater crossing success has been reported. I would suggest starting with the first five wild tomatoes I mentioned.

That's nine species there are about fourteen total. You can read more about them online. Such as at the link I mention below.

Ok, population numbers, The Tomato Genetic Resource Center or TGRC is a good resource for this. https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/ It is going to vary by species. I looked it up for Solanum habrochaites and it said to grow fifty to seventy five plants per accession. It also said that I could grow three in each one gallon pot. So basically a grow out in pots of a single Solanum habrochaites accession takes them a minimum of  37 pots. However with Solanum peruvianum I could grow five per pot. Which means a ten one gallon pot minimum for maintaining a accession of peruvianum.

I reckon I would consider a freely crossing population one accession and grow out about 50 to 75 plants of a hybrid swarm. Maybe more until it seems stable.

Brad's Atomic Grape is a relatively recent variety bred by Brad Gates. It is a really neat variety and one I don't have myself.

If I wanted to cross Brad's Atomic Grape (BAG) with habrochaites, penellii or the promiscuous project's self incompatible populations I could either use BAG as the mother in a manual pollination and then allow the F1 to carry the desired BAG trait or traits back into the SI population. Or alternatively I could first cross BAG to a tomato like Big Hill stabilize or at least semi-stabilize an exserted population with the traits I wanted in it and allow natural pollination within the hybrid swarm to eventally carry the trait(s) back into the population.

Or basically yeah eventually over many generations as long as some of the domestic tomatoes in the population have exserted stigmas and can receive pollen from the other tomatoes, eventually things will mix up some. However the tomato species with more extreme species barriers like peruvianum will just remain separate unless a very low probability cross happens. Which has not yet happened for any of us that we've been able to verify and propagate. I've been growing peruvianum since 2017 and it has only crossed with other peruvianum accessions so far.

Also I haven't yet made deliberate crosses with multiple domestic varieties I like. In 2017 I found about 7 exserted domestic plants amongst 70 kinds of tomatoes. I grew a huge growout of the exserted varieties in my second year 2018 and found lots of F1's in 2019 I grew out lots of F2s and made some selections. In 2021 I isolated one of those stabilizing it a bit. It should become available soon as I sold an ounce of seed. Basically a exserted vehicle to get stripes and blue skin into populations. Though most in the 2019 growour were domestics or so domestic I couldn't tell.

I've had habrochaites tomatoes in my garden since 2017. Penellii I think since 2018. However the elite strains were all found by Joseph. He did bigger growouts. So my growouts are getting bigger. The neat thing is that some of the lines now available on the Experimental Farm Network are advanced crosses and are about 75% domestic and 25% habrochaites and penellii and basically the finally tasty material I got to grow last year. So no need to start from scratch. Next year I imagine we will have even more advanced selections to share.

So I guess my best advice would be pick a single wild tomato accession you are really excited about and start small. Make a cross. Grow a small population of the F1 unless you need to grow a larger population to find the F1. Then grow a huge population of the F2. Then stand on the shoulders of folks like Joseph Lofthouse whose seed is available at Experimental Farm network and Lee Goodwin whose seed is available at J and L gardens (the one in new Mexico not France). For existing good wild cross breeding material.

In regards to doing huge growouts. Keep in mind that a relatively large number of tomato plants can be grown in a single crowded pot or in very crowded beds or rows. My direct seeded rows had very high populations.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kevin Collignon

I appreciate all the time you took to explain this to me. Its makes it very clear to me that I have a lot of research to do on my own. I may have to copy the advise y'all give me and keep it as a reference guide.

I have talked to Joseph recently about me investing my seed money budget to get a large number of the seeds he grows to help jumpstart my plant breeding, so I should be getting seeds soon but I am not entirely sure what all he is sending me until it arrives. I guess I will have to make some decisions based on what I get from Joseph on what I will do this season usually I have enough time in the season to plant out 2nd generations sometime in summer to grow things out until usually November or December when our winter starts to show up. So I may be able to do a sampling this year of what works best for me.

Full time small scale farmer and aspiring landrace plant breeder. Current breeding focus for the season are Tomatoes, Melons, watermelons, and potatoes.

William Schlegel

#154
Joseph tends to send a lot. I like his seed and not just the tomatoes. 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

https://seedalliance.org/publications/how-to-breed-tomatoes-for-organic-agriculture/

Some of us are living a bit on the wild side when it comes to tomato breeding. Here is a guide to the basics.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kevin Collignon

Thank you. I'll save all these sources to reference back to later on. 
Full time small scale farmer and aspiring landrace plant breeder. Current breeding focus for the season are Tomatoes, Melons, watermelons, and potatoes.

Joseph Lofthouse

#157
The seeds I'm putting together for Kevin are an archive backup of my entire garden. Last year there were about 88 varieties in the box. I'm writing a book about landrace gardening, and needed cash to help get it published. Thank you Kevin.  It will contain a lot of seeds that I don't write about online, and just about all of them that I have written about, including lots of wild and semi-wild tomatoes.  I'm putting together a number of boxes like Kevin's, and expect to share them in a week or so.

It is common for me to plant 50 tomato seeds into a 3" pot, then thin to about the most vigorous 20, and plant that into a single hole. Makes it easy to maintain high populations with minimal land and labor. It is easy to notice elites in the clump, and save seeds separately.

I concur with Garrett's 10 to 20 plants recommendation. There are about 35 s-alleles in the wild tomatoes. Each plant carries two of them. Therefore 18 plants could contain the s-allele diversity of the entire species.




William Schlegel

#158
S allele diversity is only part of the genetic diversity in an accession though. During selection we necessarily probably will truncate some diversity. However if the goal were to put on our preservationist hat and try to do a good growout of an accession like I am this year with LA2329 we want to get as close to TGRC recommendations as possible for that.

Neandermato Joseph's grex accession of habrochaites would probably eventually fall below individual TGRC habrochaites accessions in genetic diversity if maintained long enough at a too low population size. Despite initially being a hyper diverse combination of ~five accessions. Though that could always be reversed by introducing a new accession to the population. No idea how long it would take to loose diversity either. Also the hyper diversity of a multi accession habrochaites grex might possibly require an even larger population size to maintain. No idea how large. Just thinking out loud. The increased heterozygosity of a grex should work to maintain a high level of diversity in the short term but in the long term perhaps not at a smaller population size.

Some thoughts though: collaborative seed sharing increases effective population size. So does combining seed from multiple years. For instance I could probably find and grow a little bit of Neandermato habrochaites and or BC1 seed from 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2020.  Plus some original packet seed from Joseph packed for multiple years.

Highly recommend the archive copy of Joseph's work. The one I got last year is still very exciting. As are the still viable seeds I got in 2017.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

I lose diversity among the wild species, by selecting them to grow outside in the short growing season. The first couple of years bottleneck the populations. I still have seed from some of the original accessions of S habrochaites. I'm thinking about planting them again, to hybridize with the locally-adapted population.

The bottleneck was particularly intense with S corneliomulleri. I ended up combining it with S peruvianum. I still have seed of the original S peruvianum accessions too, but I hesitate to plant it, cause the domestication efforts with S peruvianum have been going so well.


Kevin Collignon

All of this is very informative and I appreciate the time y'all take to explain it. I feel like there is a lot more than I anticipated to this tomato breeding. But with y'alls guidance I will figure out what the best approach for my garden is.

I am just going to ask for just a strait suggestion of what I should start with this year if I want to have the broadest selection of genetics to start selecting from to finding super stars for my gardening situation? I am probably going to aim for indeterminate types with medium size fruit since larger fruited ones tend to split of the plant before ripening. I live in a very hot very humid climate for most of the year with usually drought conditions during the summer if that makes any difference.

Full time small scale farmer and aspiring landrace plant breeder. Current breeding focus for the season are Tomatoes, Melons, watermelons, and potatoes.

William Schlegel

Kevin the existing mixes of last year's promiscuous project available on EFN and in your archive copy had some very tasty tomatoes finally and a lot of diversity. Probably a good place to start and builds on seven or so prior tomato generations of work. If you don't have to go all the way back to the drawing board that is a good thing.

The three species of wild tomato closely related to domestic S. pimpinillifolium, S. galapagense, and S. cheesemanii might be appropriate as they grow in Equador and the galapagos islands. Though pimpinillifolium has a wider range. These species are also closest to the domestic. Probably a good place to start.

If there exist local favorite tomatoes adapted to the area that is another good place to start.

Incidentally working direct with wild tomatoes is considered a hard way to go. Conventional breeders go back to wild material as kind of a last resort to solve otherwise unsolvable problems. I like it because I just straight up like plants and plant diversity. So it took seven generations to get back to really tasty material from the first wild cross with the hard green tomatoes.

Also Kevin: I think we've drifted away from your original question and back to just chatting about working with wild species.


Joseph: I think some bottlenecking during local adaptation is going to happen on many of these accessions for us rocky Mountain gardeners. Some of them I haven't got seed back yet like Solanum chilense. Last year my LA2329 Solanum habrochaites did a 2 out of 11 maternal bottleneck. I'm all in on the seed this year and plan to grow in pots. However last year's bottleneck will promote the genes of those two maternal lines in the population. Which will probably enhance success the next time I grow in ground. This is both good and bad. It shows that many of these species and accessions have the adaptability necessary to adapt to Rocky Mountain gardening in their populations but it also necessarily truncates some diversity from them. So for LA2329 that could mean losing the genetics I'm looking for in the process of just getting enough of it to grow and adapting it to grow here. A grower further south or lower in elevation might be better able to maintain the accession in original form or at least as maintained in California.

One exception for me is the two accessions of Solanum arcanum. I would say that it didn't bottleneck for me. I still have lots of original seed as well and I combined the two accessions in some saved packets.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Yeah I'm just doing some grow-outs of a few Habrochaites / Peruvianum just to see how well they perform, flowering times, ripening. Whatever does the best gets mixed in with the larger grow out next year - growing a few different types means that they should be OK for now. Having small mixture of the different types for next year should be pretty nice. I don't have LA2329 but I might try requesting it next year to see if I can grow it out successfully in my area.

I bought a bunch of the random habrochaites because I read about the large amounts of die-off in the first grow outs. I should be able to get most habrochaites to flower.

Habrochaites are mostly all in pots right now, I will pluck a bunch out as they mature and put them into cells or smaller pots depending on how they perform.

William Schlegel

Garrett if all goes well I will have LA2329 to share for next year.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

This is a little off topic, but does anyone know (or in their crosses, has bred) a green when ripe pimpernellifolium?  I'm looking for something that combines the flavor of a green when ripe tomato and the fact that pimpernellifolium, unlike most tomatoes, actually grows and produces OK for me (due to various factor, any tomato above cherry size really is a no go for me growing wise, and even cherries don't make much usually.) But I don't have the space for the kind of grow out I'd need to find such a cross myself.