Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-15, 06:07:20 AMOnly cytoplasm that might be worth preserving is that of the current tomatoes. My crosses all ended up with the common cytoplasm.
O' that's a bummer because I don't trust my skills to use those little flowers as the mother. Worth a try anyway, I guess.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-15, 06:07:20 AMThat ratio does go both ways but shows up in the F2. The F1 the crosses will be 100% RL.
Ah, so it only shows up in the F1 when Pl is pollinated by Rl. But if I don't have to worry about preserving cytoplasm, that makes it easier. I can just use ones like Galahad or Hot Streak as fathers on the PL types.



William Schlegel

It can show up in the F1 if the cross is between a heterozygous parent and a potato leaf. So some of my F1 seed I sent you with your potato leaf could segregate half potato leaf.

Otherwise regardless of cross direction between two stable varieties one RL one PL it should be 100% RL in the F1.

Then in the F2 25% PL.


Now with a potato leaf mother you might also get some selfing. So potato leaf seedlings in the F1 of a cross between two stable varieties with the father RL with a few PL offspring those PL ones would just be the selfing.

You may also get just a few regular leaf offspring from a potato leaf that hasn't been manually crossed- those would be the natural crosses. The crosses that made themselves! That's why you can grow out your older excess potato leaf seed to the first true leaf stage and hope to maybe find a few natural crosses already in it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-15, 06:46:34 AMYou may also get just a few regular leaf offspring from a potato leaf that hasn't been manually crossed- those would be the natural crosses. The crosses that made themselves! That's why you can grow out your older excess potato leaf seed to the first true leaf stage and hope to maybe find a few natural crosses already in it

Yes! and I'm nearly positive that has happened before, but I didn't really know what was going on at the time and didn't pay any attention to them. I suspect that if I plant a couple hundred of my Hoosier Rose, I will find a few. Easy cross pollination between plants but not the obligation of it is what I really want in my tomatoes. Assuming the possibility of that is heritable then starting with the natural ones should be a head start on that. The OTV Brandywine came from a natural cross too. Maybe there is really nothing too it except open flowers, but in case something else is a factor then those that started from natural crosses are more likely to pass it on, I don't really need to know exactly what it is.

I don't know yet that OTV Brandywine will be happy in my garden. I hope so as being potato leaf, and if it also tastes good it might become a primary ancestor of a lot of my tomatoes.

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-15, 06:46:34 AMIt can show up in the F1 if the cross is between a heterozygous parent and a potato leaf. So some of my F1 seed I sent you with your potato leaf could segregate half potato leaf.

That did occur to me. If a PL plant is pollinated by a heterozygous RL plant, then the 75/25 ratio will not apply. Sounds like it would be 50/50 instead. I bet I can figure out a way to use that, just not sure exactly how yet.

William Schlegel

Quote from: reed on 2024-01-15, 07:33:46 AMThat did occur to me. If a PL plant is pollinated by a heterozygous RL plant, then the 75/25 ratio will not apply. Sounds like it would be 50/50 instead. I bet I can figure out a way to use that, just not sure exactly how yet.


Because of my past extensive use of potato leaf mothers, I now have a lot of regular leaf plants that may be heterozygous!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Reed I seem to remember you were wanting more potato leaf varieties. In case this is useful for your regional project:
https://jandlgardens.com/xencart/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=&products_id=193

QuoteLEE'S SWEET (NEW SELECTION)
Our flagship beefsteak tomato, Lee's is a deep pink boat-shaped or heart-shaped slicer occasionally with faint green shoulders. The flavor of the 12 oz fruit is unusually sweet and intense. This may be the finest pink tomato on the planet, though I may be biased by the name:) The 6 foot PL plants bear heavily in about 68 days.

reed

Thanks! I've never heard of that company and that one certainly does sound interesting because of the 68 DTM, quite a bit earlier than mine. I had decided though that I had spent enough money and have enough kinds already. But that seller has not just that one but several other very interesting tomatoes, like those giant bull's heart type and a big yellow one they say came from a cross, so now I'm not sure.

reed

#82
I think I mentioned somewhere that I had my 25 gallon tubs ready for tomatoes, mostly clumps of F1s will go in them. Now also most of my cattle panel cages are in place too. So now I'm sitting here inspecting the seeds, and figuring out what to plant. I have too many and need to whittle it down a bit.
 
I'll grow my own of course including Mr. Stripey, Cherokee Purple, Wyllard Wynn, potato leaf Hoosier Rose. These represent the foundation of my attempt to create a Mid-Ohio Valley beefsteak type tomato that is tolerant of environmental conditions and productive. I want them to be more fruitful than they are now, with clusters of fruit instead of one here and there as many of the existing heirlooms do. I'm fine with it and actually would like it if the fruits were slightly smaller, but I still want sizable tomatoes, say somewhere between a baseball and a softball. Wouldn't mind a little insurance on disease tolerance too, as long as it doesn't screw something else up. A bit earlier would be nice, I'd like to think something around 65 days instead of 80 or 85 is probably doable. As I talked before, I'll be relying a lot on the recessive potato leaf trait to help identify my crosses next year.  Anyway, I'm listing some that have made the cut as I'm pretty sure it will be planted.

All of mine listed above , plus Utah Heart

Hoosier Rose - about 80 dtm. *Natural cross* from a commercial variety and adapted by me for about 10 years, maybe 12. It's PL and will be crossed to all of my RL types listed above as well as a number of the new ones I bought.

Brandywine OTV - 72 dtm. *Natural cross* an accidental cross discovered and bred by Dr. Carolyn Male and Craig Lehoullier.

***natural cross is very important to me because I think it may indicate a genetic propensity for it and I want to reinforce that in my population if I can. If I can encourage and select for that then maybe by using the PL trait as an indicator I can cross, and backcross based on ease of pollination and fruit set to create a diverse population of more productive beefsteak tomatoes. I think any increase in fruit set along with consistently open flowers will be indications that is happening.

Galahad F1 and Yellow Streak F1 69 dtm and 70 dtm. These are supposed to have super LB resistance and resistance to a bunch of other diseases as well, they are earlier than mine too and the fruits are smaller. They are "described" as having good flavor supposedly rivaling that of old beefsteak heirlooms, we'll see. I'l be crossing them to Hoosier Rose and to other recently acquired PL varieties.

Yellow Brandywine 72 dtm. Supposedly an heirloom from Indiana, where I am. Again shorter dtm and it's PL. If it grows well and we like it it could take a major role going forward. I'll be crossing everything to it as well.

Hillbilly PL 85 dtm, yuck but it is PL, yellow with green shoulders, and I've grown it before and we liked it. I forget why I dropped it in favor of Mr. Stripey. I'll plant a plant or two to cross with some of the other shorter dtm Rl types.

Plum Regal F1 75 dtm. Supposed to have good disease tolerance and I've grown it before. It isn't very good unless it's dried and or cooked hot, like on a fire. I think it has the potential to be easy to sun dry. I'll probably try to drop its pollen on some of the PL plants too but technically it isn't part of the beefsteak group.

Supersauce F1 70 dtm. Supposed to be a giant sauce type with few seeds. It isn't going into the Mid-OVT beefsteak mix but maybe something with Utah Heart. I'll have to think about that some more.

Early Girl F1 and Bush Early Girl F1 65 dtm and 59 dtm. Thought I'd use these to introduce short dtm depending of course on how they do and if we like them. Actually, I'm pretty sure I like Early Girl because I've grown it before and if I remember right, it threw some nice volunteers, but I didn't pay much attention to it at the time.

Purple Calabash 85 dtm. Minus I suppose, any genetics that have been lost over the last couple hundred years, it is supposed to be of pre-Columbian origin from Mexico. It looks a lot like the paintings from mid- 16th century Europe and makes me wonder if it and whatever originally went to Europe were pretty much the same thing. Maybe it made the trips from South America to Mexico and Europe both and was then perhaps lost in South America. Anyway, I want to see for myself what comes from it and get my own supply of its seeds.

Then I have the seeds from William where he crossed some of my tomatoes with some of his. I'll be growing at least seven of them, including two F1s with my Hoosier Rose and two with my Mr. Stripey and two with my Utha Heart, one with Mr. Stripy is crossed to a cross involving Purple Zebra, I'm particularly curious about it because of the possibility of introducing some extra color into my tomatoes.  Lastly is William's MMM x PH5 LB Pimp,

I might not plant any of my own pimp segregates and just keep some that volunteer, although one that showed up last year had the best flavor so far, not that any of them are bad, so I may start a few of it, partly just to see if it is stable, which I doubt it is.

 

reed

#83
As talked about before I'm planning on using potato leaf varieties as mother plants in my Mid-Ohio Valley beefsteak tomatoes because of the obvious tell of successful crossing in the F1. I expected in the next year, 2025 to be planting just the regular leaf offspring.

I got to thinking about it though, and if I understand it right the F1 will yield 75% PL and 25% PL. So, if it happens that I see that 75/25 split in the offspring, it will be a pretty good indication that the 25% PL are ALSO crossed and just happened to be in the statistical 25% that look like their mother. I think I can use that little tidbit in lots of fun ways. For example, if Galahad F1 happens to be a very yummy tomato that likes growing here and I cross it to Hoosier Rose. I can then easily backcross in either direction. I can have PL Hoosier Rose as the mother to (PL Hoosier Rose x Galahad) or the other way around, or both just by watching the potato leaf phenotype. And what if add in several other varieties as well and do the same thing?

I'll select out anything really bad in the first year, but I don't expect a lot of that as I've been pretty selective in what I'm starting with. From then on, just keep mixing them up and selecting for preferred traits, including open flowers. Once they are settled to some degree, maybe three or four years, I'll let the bees take over the pollination for the most part while just select for preferred traits. 

add - That recessive potato leaf trait is GREAT! but most of you probably already knew that. I wonder if such traits as easily exploitable exist in other crops.




Joseph Lofthouse

If using a potato-leaved mother, and a regular-leaved father, then 100% of the crossed plants in the F1 will be regular-leaved.

If you are allowing bee-assisted open pollination, then the regular-leaved offspring are cross-pollinated. (The potato-leaved were pollinated by other potato-leaved varieties.)

In the next generation, seeds from the regular-leaved plants segregate into 25% potato-leaved and 75% regular-leaved.


reed

Oh shucks, I knew that, just got excited about my little epiphany on how I might use it and got a bit ahead of myself.

Roland

Because you are inexperienced, you use potato leaved mother plants. Other mother plants with reccersive characteristics can of course also be used.

But once you have experience in crossing and removing the pollen you will see that you do not use recessive mother plants at all.
Netherlands

reed

Quote from: Roland on 2024-02-13, 12:42:53 AMBecause you are inexperienced, you use potato leaved mother plants. Other mother plants with reccersive characteristics can of course also be used.

But once you have experience in crossing and removing the pollen you will see that you do not use recessive mother plants at all.

Yep, I am inexperienced and want to make it as easy as possible. My first try will simply be to see if I can successfully make manual crosses and RL plants from PL mothers in the F1 is the tell-tell sign I can use to confirm it. I may try other crosses as well but expect I will have to wait for fruiting or do it enough and long enough to learn to recognize other traits, to know if it worked or not and I don't really have the space or patience for that.

I want to up the diversity, decrease the plant size and DTM of what I already have but not at the cost of doing without tomatoes we actually like for a period of years. Wild tomatoes other than pimpinellifolium do not grow well in my garden, they either die from disease or drought and make little tomatoes with bad flavor if they make any at all. My experience with them is admittedly limited, but bad enough that I don't want to spend the time, effort and space to try again.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Roland on 2024-02-13, 12:42:53 AMBecause you are inexperienced, you use potato leaved mother plants. Other mother plants with recessive characteristics can of course also be used.

But once you have experience in crossing and removing the pollen you will see that you do not use recessive mother plants at all.

I largely abandoned the use of potato leaved mother plants last year in my seventh year of tomato breeding. However, I made a mistake with that! In reviewing some guides to crossing I think I've been using flowers that might be just a little too old. This probably results in at least a few self-pollinated seeds. I observed this with my 2022 crosses, there were a few uncrossed seedlings of Dwarf Gloria's Treat. So I may have abandoned the technique too soon! Though if I refine my flower selection, I can be more confident.

I think dwarfing and potato leaves or dwarf potato leaf mothers like Dwarf Gloria's Treat are ideal mothers for beginners, folks with imperfect technique (and mine has been imperfect to date), and anyone struggling to make crosses or make as many crosses as they might like to. I think that anyone who has problems with emasculation due to drying winds or shaky hands might benefit from using mothers with long styles and a recessive tell and just not emasculating.

If someone with imperfect technique can make tons of crosses and help advance tomato breeding, I would not call them inexperienced at all! 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2024-02-13, 05:33:15 AMMy first try will simply be to see if I can successfully make manual crosses and RL plants from PL mothers in the F1 is the tell-tell sign I can use to confirm it. I may try other crosses as well but expect I will have to wait for fruiting or do it enough and long enough to learn to recognize other traits, to know if it worked or not and I don't really have the space or patience for that.

I would say try crossing everything that you want to try, this year, if you have the time and space to do it. Then when you grow out the crosses with potato leaf mothers, you can see if those worked or not. If they did, then likely so did the others, and that way you don't have to wait a whole more year! And if they didn't, so, maybe some of your others didn't either. But you might have had fun doing it and your technique probably improved by the experience.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-02-13, 06:13:15 AMI largely abandoned the use of potato leaved mother plants last year in my seventh year of tomato breeding. However, I made a mistake with that! In reviewing some guides to crossing I think I've been using flowers that might be just a little too old. This probably results in at least a few self-pollinated seeds.

Interesting. I read one paper, maybe from Sweden from something like the 1950's, from a plant breeding station, and the author reckoned when the petals were white but before yellow, was the best. I was surprised, seemed earlier than what most people say. I am curious, what was your timing, and what has become your corrected timing?

I find lycopersicum harder than wild tomato species now. Probably because I have far more experience with wild or interspecial flowers. Some of the lycopersicum flowers really confuse me, they look immature, such short anther cone and barely petals sometimes just a few mm long, and then I look again and they seem open! And I don't know, are they mature enough now? Or, still developing, still not ready for crossing? Quite confusing. I think this is especially with the ones with very short anther cones. The longer narrower ones, more like wild species, I don't have this issue with. So maybe that would be 'beefsteak' I am having problems with...

Ideally I would emasculate them and cross them later. But, I actually need the yellow just to see them, with so much to do and no capacity to keep track of more things except visually like that. (Luckily most of my work now is with self incompatible plants, or self compatible that will not pollinate themselves even when open due to their exsertion, indoors anyway, and I don't have many lycopersicum to keep track of at the moment.)

Wild ones are harder for removing the anther cone though - some at least. Because such thin delicate styles that can come off so easily. Now mostly I do not remove the anthers. Some species or accessions within species come off way easier than others. My main method now is to remove only the front part of the anther cone, basically making them artificially highly exserted. This means the style is still supported, and probably also helps it to not dry out. However outdoors this would increase the chances of self-pollen contamination.