Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

Discussion on another topic has me thinking more about the open flower issue.

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2022-07-29, 11:32:19 PMThe beefsteak type flower structure is an example of an open flower (that may have small petals).
Which explains why, although from reading open flowers might be rare, I see it all the time. I guess because I grow mostly beefsteaks.
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2022-07-29, 11:32:19 PMAs a general principle, populations that are more promiscuous tend to have larger and more open flowers.
That makes sense and sounds like something that can be easily selected for, especially within beefsteak types. I've been wondering, since most of my tomatoes have such flowers and I commonly see pollinators, why don't I find crosses. It finally dawned on me it's because I start ten seeds of each type, plant four and give the rest away. Out of the thousands of seeds a plant may have made and trimmed down to the hundreds that I may have saved, only four are planted the next year. That's pretty poor odds for finding a cross. I wonder, if I dip in the seed archive and plant a few hundred of my one potato leaf variety if I might find a cross or two.

William Schlegel

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-18, 03:43:05 AMDiscussion on another topic has me thinking more about the open flower issue.
Which explains why, although from reading open flowers might be rare, I see it all the time. I guess because I grow mostly beefsteaks. That makes sense and sounds like something that can be easily selected for, especially within beefsteak types. I've been wondering, since most of my tomatoes have such flowers and I commonly see pollinators, why don't I find crosses. It finally dawned on me it's because I start ten seeds of each type, plant four and give the rest away. Out of the thousands of seeds a plant may have made and trimmed down to the hundreds that I may have saved, only four are planted the next year. That's pretty poor odds for finding a cross. I wonder, if I dip in the seed archive and plant a few hundred of my one potato leaf variety if I might find a cross or two.

In 2017 I found two potato leafs that had styles and stigmas that stuck out a bit (exserted style / exposed stigma). I daubed pollen on both varieties without emasculating. Then germinated lots of seed. Matina had no regular leaf seedlings. Unknown Lofthouse Potato leaf (likely Brad) had a few. This led to my Mission Mountain Sunrise variety (MMS) as the father was the variety Blue Gold. i
In certain years MMS is exserted but other years it is not. I think it is dependent on weather.

In 2021 I crossed MMS with Big Hill HX-9 which is always exserted. Grew out the F1 over the winter and got F2 seed. I picked out the segregating 1/4 potato leaf. Named them Mission Mountain Morning (MMM)

In 2022 I set up crossing blocks to cross with MMM and MMS. Many failed utterly! Huge trays of potato leaf seedlings with no crosses. One worked great.

The one that worked great had lots of varieties very densely planted together. It was also very close to my wife's extremely bee attractive flower garden. A single plant of MMM F2 potato leaf had an extreme form of exsertion. It was the mother to my 2023 F3 MMM and multiple unknown father crosses.

I've concluded it helps to have potential fathers with good pollen production very close to the mother plant. Also very high populations of pollinators.

One of the failures was a MMM plant in a crossing block with The One. It seemed just as good of exsertion as the one that worked. Farther apart plants, seemed hard to extract pollen from The One. Flowers were farther away. Zero regular leaf seedlings found from the potato leaf mothers. Except in 2023 a lot of The One plants picked up a blue blush. The cross may have only worked with MMM and MMS as fathers!

It costs very little to save say a 1000 seeds of a potato leaf and germinate them with a little potting soil in a flat or an old food container with a clear plastic lid. I highly encourage it, even one regular leaf seedling is a great find. Sometimes there are lots! Sometimes there isn't even one though!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#47
All of that is very encouraging that what I am trying to do will work. I have several hundred seeds of all of my tomatoes saved by year. Only the Hooser Rose is potato leaf, but I have plenty of seeds, I wonder if planting the others would yield anything I could tell as an off type early on. It just might I think, even if it was subtle, it might stick out among a hundred others, especially if the father happened to be a pimp.

I think open flowers is definitely temperature related. Here they are open in cool weather and not so much in the heat. In the spring a lot of them are also fasciated. In fall they nearly all open, even types that don't do it so much in spring. Fall is when bumblebees take notice of them, apparently, they don't really like tomatoes all that much, but tomatoes keep blooming all the way till frost, so the bees eventually have to settle. Unfortunately, it's too late to get any seeds then. But I have plenty of other pollinators, like in this photo.

8.jpg

So, I think making crosses on purpose might not be as hard as I always thought, and I bet there are already a few in my old seeds.

Joseph Lofthouse

The first true leaves of a potato-leaved variety will show whether it crossed with a regular-leaved variety. Makes it super easy to screen hundreds of seedlings to find the few that crossed.

Roland

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-17, 04:34:34 PMI think the only one I'll get specifically for late blight resistance is Galahad F1 and I think I'll not cross it with anything, just observe it and collect a lot of F2 seed. I think I'll do that with the old Iron Lady and Plum Regal descendants too, just try to get a of lot of seed farther from the original F1.

I am now at the F5 generation of Galahad. There are very tasty plants that are better than the F1. In the F4 I even had a selection with Brix 8. You normally see that with cherry varieties, but these beef tomatoes were 250 grams. You will find red and pink fruits in the F2. For me, 2 or 3 out of 50 F2 plants were disappointing.


I am curious about your experiences with Plum regal, I see a lot of potential in that variety to grow good sauce tomatoes with a lot of disease resistance. The ogc gene is also ideal for beautiful, healthy dark red sauces. Keep me informed?
Netherlands

reed

#50
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-12-18, 11:31:54 AMThe first true leaves of a potato-leaved variety will show whether it crossed with a regular-leaved variety. Makes it super easy to screen hundreds of seedlings to find the few that crossed.
That's what I'm counting on. Problem is that only one of my varieties is potato leaf and I expect there might be crosses in the regular leaf types as well but don't have any easy way to see them.  I have the space and the seeds so will probably start a couple hundred of each regular leaf type as well, on the off chance something noticeable will show up. Actually, it did happen last year when a plant looked quite different as a tiny seedling but as it grew lost its uniqueness, and I lost track of which one it was.

Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-18, 01:48:30 PMI am curious about your experiences with Plum regal, I see a lot of potential in that variety to grow good sauce tomatoes with a lot of disease resistance. The ogc gene is also ideal for beautiful, healthy dark red sauces. Keep me informed?

What stood out to me with Plum Regal is their tendency to hang on the vine and dry up rather than rot and the drier they got the better they tasted. Roasting in the oven or on the grill also brings out the excellent flavor so I suspect you are right about their usefulness for sauce. If I remember right, they tended to make lots of small to medium sized fruits, pretty much all at once which continued to ripen and start to dry, after the leaves had all died. I'm going to try to cross them to Utah Heart.  I can't find my Plum Regal seeds right now; I hope I didn't accidentally drop them a box I sent to a seed swap although if so, I can probably get them back. It's just a little worrisome because I thought they were with the old Iron Lady seeds.

Did you ever notice any open or semi-open flowers on the Galahad plants?

Roland

Yes the Galahad Offspring hase a lot of open flowers with very long sigmas.
Netherlands

William Schlegel

Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-19, 11:39:00 AMYes the Galahad Offspring hase a lot of open flowers with very long sigmas.

This bodes well for my 2023 Galahad cross.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

It bodes well for my plans as well. I've ordered Purple Calabash too, both Baker Creek and Monticello seem to indicate it is from pre-Columbian Mexico. Maybe not the pure wild from farther south but good enough to for my purposes. It also looks very much like one in the 16th century paintings. What sealed the deal on it was a photo on Tatiana's showing it also with nicely open flowers. I'm going to build a population of sweet flavorful beefsteak tomatoes, that freely cross pollinate with each other.

Yellow Brandywine PL, OTV Brandywine PL and Hillbilly Pl are already here, Purple Calabash is on the way. Now I just need to track down Galahad. Haven't ordered Early Girl and a couple others yet but I think I'm about getting there on what I need and what I can actually handle.

Then are the ones from you William. I won't be able to grow them all but definitely what those crossed to my old standbys. And I found some I didn't grow last year including Purple Zebra F2 and some other interesting stuff.

 

William Schlegel

#54
My tomato with the longest style in 2017 was a cherry tomato called Blue Ambrosia. It had regular leaves but was yellow with a blue blush. I daubed all the flowers with pollen then saved all the seeds. Got some red ones back, grew those out the next year and found one some with stripes.

Another good tell when young is the dwarf tomatoes. A lot of them are potato leaf and bred from heirlooms. Dwarf Gloria's Treat has even better flavor than most bicolor fleshed yellow and red marbled flesh tomatoes and it has the potato leaves. Will have some F2s from it in 2024 and get the potato leaves back on one quarter of them, and 1/4 of those should be dwarf as well. You can tell dwarf seedlings young in the cotyledon stage because they are shorter. I did a bad job of sorting my dwarfs from MMM x Aztek in 2023- I saved out four than stopped and waited too long and they kind of blended back in. I might have more seed but not sure if I want to try again or just go on with the best of the four which was a regular leaf late yellow blue tomato in the F2.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#55
I'm starting to organize in my little brain what the tomato patch(es) will look like next year.

All of mine will be grown more or less as usual except maybe fewer of each.

Utah Heart
Hoosier Rose PL
Sr. Stripy
Wyllard Wynn
Cherokee Purple
Pimp cross mix

The new colorful beefsteaks will be grown among mine, (well-marked) and probably also in pots. I'll probably plant all of the seeds just in case a regular leaf shows up.

Hillbilly PL
Brandywine OYV PL
Yellow Brandywine PL

The new hybrids will be planted crowded in 25-gallon tubs as probably will be Purple Calabash.

Burpee Supersauce F1
Early Girl F1
Burpee Better Boy F1
Galahad F1
Purple Calabash

The rest here will also be planted thickly in 25-gallon tubs.
 
Purple Zebra F2
Mr. Stripey X (MMM X Purple Zebra)
Pimp PH5 LB PI 27044363A105
Brown Rugose Pimp PI 365967
Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1373)
Utah Heart x (MMM x Sweet Cherette)
Utah Heart x Dwarf MMR) F1

Looks like, unless I miscounted, twelve for the tubs. I have fifteen or so and nine are already filled with soil. I think I got the planting figured out, now on to the cross-pollinating plan.   
 

William Schlegel

I see my bad handwriting at work again!

The Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1373). The LA1373 in that should be LA1375 and LA1375 is the same thing as the Brown Rugose Pimp PI 365967 it is the same accession of current tomato. It tolerates that brown rugose fruit virus you first raised the alarm about a couple years ago. The cross has 25% of it which is probably about where we need to be to get the size back in some offspring.

I probably sent you F2 seed for potato leaf Mission Mountain Morning x Brad's Atomic Grape which is regular leaf. Is that first line. That is really just for fun as Brads Atomic Grape has a lot of fancy traits and may not have any special powers when it comes to surviving though.

There should be a packet of your Mr. Stripey X (Mission Mountain Morning X Purple Zebra) in there somewhere.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-20, 04:34:18 PMThere should be a packet of your Mr. Stripey X (Mission Mountain Morning X Purple Zebra) in there somewhere.

O' there is! Definitely going to plant those seeds. I'm going to edit my list to include this and maybe drop the ones with the rugose trait.

Roland

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-20, 04:04:02 PMI'm starting to organize in my little brain what the tomato patch(es) will look like next year.

All of mine will be grown more or less as usual except maybe fewer of each.

Utah Heart
Hoosier Rose PL
Sr. Stripy
Wyllard Wynn
Cherokee Purple
Pimp cross mix

The new colorful beefsteaks will be grown among mine, (well-marked) and probably also in pots. I'll probably plant all of the seeds just in case a regular leaf shows up.

Hillbilly PL
Brandywine OYV PL
Yellow Brandywine PL

The new hybrids will be planted crowded in 25-gallon tubs as probably will be Purple Calabash.

Burpee Supersauce F1
Early Girl F1
Burpee Better Boy F1
Galahad F1
Purple Calabash

The rest here will also be planted thickly in 25-gallon tubs.
 
Purple Zebra F2
Mr. Stripey X (MMM X Purple Zebra)
Pimp PH5 LB PI 27044363A105
Brown Rugose Pimp PI 365967
Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1373)
Utah Heart x (MMM x Sweet Cherette)
Utah Heart x Dwarf MMR) F1

Looks like, unless I miscounted, twelve for the tubs. I have fifteen or so and nine are already filled with soil. I think I got the planting figured out, now on to the cross-pollinating plan.   
 

No Plum Regal?
Netherlands

reed

I still haven't located my Plum Regal seeds. :-[ I was F3 with them or maybe even F4 if I recall correctly and hate the notion of starting over but I am getting the other new F1s so probably will if I have too.