F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Adrian

#135
Exemple of plant with large leaf.
We can see great heterosis effect.
The first parent has a large thin and wispy leaf and the second has a strong and court leaf.

Roland

Staying on topic, I wonder how many test crosses are needed among the heirloom breeds to find a superior F1. The publication shows that less than 10% of crosses are an improvement for commercial growers in terms of production and earliness. We want improvements in production, taste and colors. Even more difficult to find a good heterozygous combination for this.

Adrian, I don't think it is true that more leaf surface always means more production or better taste.
Netherlands

Tim DH

Hi Roland,
   The paper you quote is interesting. Eleven out of 163 is roughly a 7% hit rate. Hopefully the hit rate might be a bit higher these days, since the paper was printed in 1957, when there seems to have been less genetic variation in cultivated tomatoes than now.
        The same might be true for flavour profiles. ..... Either way, I'm happy to keep on testing novel F1s for a few more seasons, partly because it doesn't take up much space. I only need to grow one or two plants of each F1. Also I get the results the next season, in comparison to stabilizing an OP variety which takes years.

Tim DH

Roland

I also continue to make crosses every year to find a good F1. My crosses mainly consist of hybrids that possess the ph2 and ph3 gene against Phytophthora. And I have to say that I have found some very tasty ones.

In 2023 I crossed very tasty and sweet cherry varieties with resistant lines that I will plant out in 2024. I hope to find a tasty cherry that is suitable for growing outside.

It is partly difficult because the characteristics I am looking for are often recessive and therefore cannot be seen in the phenotype of the F1.
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-11, 12:20:03 PMStaying on topic, I wonder how many test crosses are needed among the heirloom breeds to find a superior F1.

Why stick to heirlooms? Especially since genetic diversity is so low, wouldn't it be more suitable to be searching among the more modern tomatoes, due to their wild introgressions giving them more diversity? Like,
- This may give an increased rate of improvement, since the genepool you are crossing within is wider.
- There is way more disease resistance available, and potentially more visual beauty too, some might even say more flavour potential even.

Quote from: Tim DH on 2024-01-11, 02:50:15 PMHopefully the hit rate might be a bit higher these days, since the paper was printed in 1957, when there seems to have been less genetic variation in cultivated tomatoes than now.
        The same might be true for flavour profiles.

Oh, sorry I wrote the above before reading down to your comment! Yes seems we had the same thought!

Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-11, 03:02:51 PMI also continue to make crosses every year to find a good F1. My crosses mainly consist of hybrids that possess the ph2 and ph3 gene against Phytophthora. And I have to say that I have found some very tasty ones.

Cool. Did you find any tasty ones from stable LB resistant lines? Could be cool if there's a good one with an OSSI tomato. But yes I'm more interested in not F1s, I hope you get your traits as the generations move forward!

Cathy A

Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-11, 03:02:51 PMIt is partly difficult because the characteristics I am looking for are often recessive and therefore cannot be seen in the phenotype of the F1.

Do you use backcrossing?

While backcrossing is best used for introducing dominant alleles, if you were to make your F1 crossing and then backcross a fairly large number of the resulting F1 plants to the F0 parent with the desired recessive trait, you would expect about half of the resulting F2 generation to show the phenotype of the recessive trait.  Then do your later generations of select from there.

Adrian

Why do no make a small blueprint with the carachteristics of the 2 parents and classified who is dominant, mid-dominant and recessive.
For you heterosis effect is the most important on a cross dominant x recessive or mid-dominant x mid-dominant?

Roland

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-11, 05:01:05 PMWhy stick to heirlooms?

I don't mean in general but mainly for this topic. If you look at the start of the topic, this topic is clearly not about interspecific hybrids.

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AMAn  F1s for the People!  Project.

The advantages of F1s, particularly in vigour, are well documented. What I don't like about them is ceding control over my seeds, plants and ultimately food, to anyone else.

SO: How about creating a suite of F1s in which the parental lines are easily sourced Open Pollinated cultivars? Then, instead of keeping the parental lines secret, intentionally publicising the recipe!

In 99% of the other recent topics there is a lot of discussion about interspecific crosses.
Netherlands

Roland

@Cathy A, yes i use backcrossing to make an OP variety.

But to make an F1 variety with heterogiss effect, backcrossing is not useful. Or you have to breed two new parent lines and breed the F1 from them. But these lines are not freely accessible to everyone. It is therefore quite a search through all the heirloom breeds to find a good crossing combination that results in a better F1.
Netherlands

Cathy A

Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-12, 11:28:01 AM@Cathy A, yes i use backcrossing to make an OP variety.

But to make an F1 variety with heterogiss effect, backcrossing is not useful. Or you have to breed two new parent lines and breed the F1 from them. But these lines are not freely accessible to everyone. It is therefore quite a search through all the heirloom breeds to find a good crossing combination that results in a better F1.

That's what I was thinking; breed two parent lines, both of which are homozygous for the recessive alleles that don't show up in a phenotype.

Then release both parent lines to all, along with the description of the resulting F1 from crossing them.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-12, 11:22:22 AM
QuoteWhy stick to heirlooms?

I don't mean in general but mainly for this topic. If you look at the start of the topic, this topic is clearly not about interspecific hybrids.

I looked back to the first post and it doesn't make any mention of heirlooms, just "Open Pollinated cultivar" like you quoted, which is what I was referring to. And there's certainly been a lot of conversation of non-heirloom varieties on this topic, for example regarding modern dwarf tomato varieties.

When I think of 'interspecific hybrids' I think of tomatoes that have a relatively high percentage of wild species. They can still be OP cultivars. But even tomatoes not usually thought of as interspecific hybrids often have wild genetics, like Stupice for example, which I read is a mix of Mikado, Sláva Porýni, and Solanum pimpinellifolium.

In the context of this topic, I was actually thinking of the latter, tomatoes that people would think of as 'Solanum lycopersicum', but have some degree of wild introgression. Like for example any of the popular OP tomatoes that have some anthocyanin in the skin, or having late blight resistance (which is one of the things that made Stupice popular, and any of the tomatoes using PH genes also), or various other forms of disease resistance that give so many non-heirloom OP tomatoes advantages. It would seem to me to be in line with the first post to be using such tomatoes. And it would seem potentially highly advantageous. So I don't see the point of deliberately excluding the last 50 or more years of tomato breeding by restricting it to only heirlooms, that's all I'm saying.

Looking back at the first page, Andrew seems to be making a similar point:
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2022-05-21, 03:07:14 PMSome of us are not fond of growing heirloom tomatoes anymore because of poor growth and productivity. Cherokee purple is actually my most hated heirloom as I've tried growing it multiple years and never got anything worthwhile.

I'm not saying don't use heirlooms. I was just questioning why. Especially in reference to low statistical chance of F1 improvement over F0 in the paper shared, and how that might differ if one is open to the wider genepool of the post-heirloom domestic tomatoes.

Tim DH

   As the initial poster on this thread, I'm not particularly precious about where people go with the idea.
   Although the first F1 mentioned IS an HeirloomXHeirloom cross, I'm happy to use whatever publicly available stepping stones there are to get to the destination. To me its the result that matters, and the quicker the better.
   So I guess my position is closest to Justins, and Cathy is being more ambitious than I am!

Tim DH

Cathy A

If anyone could find two readily-available varieties that made a cross anywhere near as great as Sungold F1, that would be incredibly valuable to all!

William Schlegel

In theory, we could potentially improve on Sungold. At least in terms of disease resistance.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#149
I've never grown Sungold. I did notice in some of the photos and videos I found of it, there was quite a bit of obvious disease issues.  I wonder if it is really as good as its reputation suggests. I also noticed some of the pictures are obviously not the same. Is it a small cherry tomato, or a gulf ball sized tomato like in some of the pictures? A lot of different sellers have it too. Does that mean one company produces the F1 and sells it to all the others?