F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

Quote from: reed on 2024-01-17, 02:57:39 AMI've never grown Sungold. I did notice in some of the photos and videos I found of it, there was quite a bit of obvious disease issues.  I wonder if it is really as good as its reputation suggests.

There is only one source of Sungold F1, because only one company has the required parents. That company is Tokita Seed Company in Japan. Any Sungold F1 seeds come from that source, no matter where they are sold.

It's definitely a small cherry tomato, orange in color, very sweet, prone to cracking, and sets fruit prolifically. If it doesn't have those traits, it's not Sungold.

My experience is that Sungold F1 really is as good as its reputation suggests, but that reputation is based on taste and productivity of fruit, not disease resistance. Johnny's only claims it has resistance to Fusarium Wilt and Tomato Mosaic Virus.

reed

Thanks, I looked that company up and they have a US presence where you can get it straight from them. I decided not to because if the people here can't de-hybridize or cross it into something great, I sure don't have much of chance.

Cathy A

I wouldn't assume that the people here and elsewhere can't "cross it into something great." I see a lot of potential to do just that. I'm certainly going to use it to cross with some of the OP tomatoes that have done well for me.

Dehybridizing, on the other hand, doesn't seem to be a viable path for Sungold. It's been done several times, notably in Sun Select II, but the results never quite seem to be at parity with the original F1. I am guessing that this means heterozygosity at one or more sites is required to show the key traits in the phenotype.

Justin Jardinier

SO far as I could tell by using the search function, this has not been mentioned here. So, here's a quote:
QuoteAnother breeder friend Keith Mueller has commercialized the F1 hybrid "Purple Haze" derived from a cross between Black Cherry and a (Brandywine x Cherokee Purple) line he developed.  He says that this specific combination demonstrates heterosis for flavor that stands out from other similar crosses he tested.

Source:
Hybrid vs O.P. tomato varieties
https://frogsleapfarm.blogspot.com/2014/01/hybrids-vs-op-tomato-varieties.html

Same page:
QuoteSeveral years ago my friend Bill Jeffers sent me seed of a F1 cross he made (Indian Stripe x Sungold).  Flavor in the F1 generation was out of this world, and to our mutual disappointment we were never able to capture anything close to this in F5/F6 lines.

They might be good to ask for others too:
QuoteIn 2016 we tested ~60 hybrids and the corresponding parent lines in both open field and greenhouse trials in Wisconsin.  There was clear heterosis for both fruit yield and flavor - and a handful of parent lines with great general and specific combining ability for flavor, as judged by our 3-4 person tasting team. 

Roland

The gene single flower truss (sft) seems very usefull for a F1.
Netherlands

Maf

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-02-11, 05:35:47 AMSO far as I could tell by using the search function, this has not been mentioned here. So, here's a quote:
Source:
Hybrid vs O.P. tomato varieties
https://frogsleapfarm.blogspot.com/2014/01/hybrids-vs-op-tomato-varieties.html

Same page:
They might be good to ask for others too:
I always wanted to try Purple Haze F1 but it has never been available on this side of the pond, to my knowledge. I believe it was generally sold via selected nursery partners in the US as plants to raise money for autism charities.

I decided to try something similar (didn't want an exact copy) and quite some years ago crossed Gary'O Sena (one of Keith Mueller's Brandywine x Cherokee Purple crosses) with Rosella (the dusky UK bred cherry from Gourmet Genetics) to hopefully create an F1 that grows well in UK greenhouses. Unfortunately there seemed to be a problem with the seed processing as none of the seeds ever germinated. (Probably a single batch that was over-fermented)

So last year I re-made the cross and will be trialling it this year from fresh seed. Expectations are for around ping-pong ball sized large cherry/saladette purple fruit on a strong vine that does well in the greenhouse. If the flavour is there I have it in mind to name this cross 'Gary Loves Rosella' F1

Maf

Quote from: Roland on 2024-02-11, 02:41:22 PMThe gene single flower truss (sft) seems very usefull for a F1.
Yes indeed it would. I seem to remember some years ago they tried to patent (or otherwise commercially protect) SFT? Is my memory faulty? Did this come to pass? Or were they found out to be patent trolls?

Roland

Keith Mueller made from the cross Cherokee Purple x Brandywine:
Dora,
Liz Bert,
Gary O'Sena
Bear Creek,

If u cross them with Black cherry we maybe find a special F1 similar to Purple Haze?
Netherlands

Tim DH

Hi Maf,
   Wishing you good luck with 'Gary Loves Rosella' F1 ... Are you also re-making Raspberry Beret F1 This year ?

Hi Justin,
   The Frogsleapfarm stuff is interesting. However using Sungold as a parent in a cross means that the next generation is not technically an F1, in the normally accepted sense, because Sungold IS an F1! The first generation of a Sungold X OP cross will not be uniform.
        Thinking about Blight resistance, I have considered crossing two commercial F1s (Maybe Mountain Magic x Crimson Crush) to give me a sort of hybrid swarm of blight resistant plants (from cheap seed), with no intention of growing any one line out.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Tim DH on 2024-02-14, 04:38:35 AMThe Frogsleapfarm stuff is interesting. However using Sungold as a parent in a cross means that the next generation is not technically an F1, in the normally accepted sense, because Sungold IS an F1! The first generation of a Sungold X OP cross will not be uniform.

Yes, very true! Is there a name for that? Or, just '3 way cross'? I guess with people's difficulty in trying to dehybridize Sungold, their result there should not be too sprising also.

I guess what I found interesting about that article though, was the fact of F1s not merely being for capitalist purposes like I had assumed, but actually some taste-based benefits that require heterosis. I found that interesting. Even though I still would prefer avoiding F1s. Although, it's also an interesting thing to think about for outcrossing populations.

Quote from: Tim DH on 2024-02-14, 04:38:35 AMThinking about Blight resistance, I have considered crossing two commercial F1s (Maybe Mountain Magic x Crimson Crush) to give me a sort of hybrid swarm of blight resistant plants (from cheap seed), with no intention of growing any one line out.

Sounds nice. Do we have any definitive info on whether Crimson Crush is homozygous for one of both Ph-2 and 3? I just searched the internet without finding anything to say for sure.

 


Maf

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-02-14, 05:09:19 AMDo we have any definitive info on whether Crimson Crush is homozygous for one of both Ph-2 and 3? I just searched the internet without finding anything to say for sure.
Good question. Lots of resources quote that it has both PH-2 and 3 but don't confirm homozygous or not. Ph-3 is only partially dominant so for maximum levels of resistance one would expect it to be homozygous. Either way it had pretty good resistance when I grew it outdoors last year.

I don't have the space for this, but it would be quite easy to check by growing out a number of F2 plants and assessing the uniformity or otherwise of the blight resistance.

(It is well known that Mountain Magic is only heterozygous for PH-2 and Ph-3)

Quote from: Tim DH on 2024-02-14, 04:38:35 AMHi Maf,
  Wishing you good luck with 'Gary Loves Rosella' F1 ... Are you also re-making Raspberry Beret F1 This year ?
Thanks, plenty of seeds for 'Gary Loves Rosella' so if it passes the taste and health test this year I can send some for you to try next year. And yes, I will be remaking Raspberry Beret F1 this year, or should I say attempting to! I hope the pollination gods oblige! It must have taken ten attempts last summer to make one viable fruit of Gary loves Rosella, I must be losing my touch...

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Maf on 2024-02-14, 02:04:09 PMI don't have the space for this, but it would be quite easy to check by growing out a number of F2 plants and assessing the uniformity or otherwise of the blight resistance.

Yeah you could grow Or you could grow out the original Crimson Crush with some other plants known to be heterozygous for both, and other known to be homozygous for both. That might help tell!

Justin Jardinier

#162
I just found this from 2015, seems they were giving away some plants initially. It's ambiguous, but since it's marketed as an F1, this might imply it is heterozygous for both - except they talk about 'selection', which I don't really understand in the context of an F1 hybrid:
QuoteI received some literature with my plants which reads as follows:

The story of Crimson Crush

Resistance genes were discovered in wild species of tomatoes.

These were transferred into our cultivated tomato species through conventional breeding methods.

One parent line was developed from a cross in the UK in 2005 with further selection taking place in outdoor trials in Worcestershire & Warwickshire.

This parent contains the PH2 gene.

The second parent was selected in the USA

This parent was shown to have excellent blight resistance even in very warm, humid conditions.

This parent contains the PH3 gene.

The offspring of these parents resulted in vigorous plants with very good temperature tolerance and exceptional blight resistance thanks to having both the PH2 and PH3 genes.

The earliness and excellent eatii qualities were discovered in trials and blind taste tests over a two  year period in various trial locations throughout the UK.

Crimson Crush is the result and is now available to you!


This was an added paragraph to show the results of scientific tests:


Whilst Crimson Crush is fully resistant to Blight, in trials at Bangor University, where a solution of blight spores was applied directly to the plants, some spot infection occurred, this infection affected less than 10% of the plant and the growth and productivity was unaffected,  whereas control varieties were 100% infected and died as a result of the infection.

I can not make head or tail of the  conclusion I think they might mean other varieties that were subjected to the same tests.



This is another claim that Dobies/Sutton make on the same leaflet:

After first selecting Crimson Crush for its super Blight Busting powers, we reselected it again by accident in a blind taste test, where it surpassed established names like Brandywine, Black Russian and a whole host of others.

Also I don't think that 'fully resistance' claims stands up anymore. By the looks of the reports on that forum it didn't stand up in 2015 either. But I'm not saying that to put it down - now even homozygous for both is not fully resistant.

Maf

Thanks @Justin Jardinier, from that description sounds like Crim Crush F1 is hetero for both genes, good find. I think the 'selection' in the text refers to the selection of the parent plants?

I have also read that CC has some minor resistance genes that either offer additional protection or amplify the protective effects of PH-2/PH-3 via synergy.

My experience of Crimson crush last year is that in conditions where all other plants are killed or mortally wounded, CC develops minor lesions on 10-20% of leaves and some infection of ripe fruits but very little infection of unripe fruits. If drier weather follows the blight period, then strong growth resumes. (Obviously your mileage may vary with different strains of late blight).

The interesting takeaway for me is that there is a good potential for selecting for better than parent resistance in the F2 of Crimson Crush. Or indeed in the F1 of CC x Mountain Magic as MM is also hetero for PH-1/2. My math is 1 in 16 homozygous for both genes in either of those situations. Plus you have the potential minor resistance/amplification genes flittering around in the background.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Maf on 2024-02-14, 06:02:33 PMThanks @Justin Jardinier, from that description sounds like Crim Crush F1 is hetero for both genes, good find. I think the 'selection' in the text refers to the selection of the parent plants?

Yeah I agree with your first sentence. Regarding the second...well, that seems to be contradicted by:
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-02-14, 05:08:27 PMAfter first selecting Crimson Crush for its super Blight Busting powers, we reselected it again

Unless by 'reselected' they mean they chose it from various crosses for LB resistance. Then chose the exact same one again, in the taste test. Though that would seem a bit deceptive! Mind you, marketing can be that way I guess. Basically I find it unclear and ambiguous. I guess I'm left assuming it's likely that it's heterozygous for both. And kind of feel that the fact no reliable sources seem to be claiming it is heterozygous for both, increases the chances that it isn't.

Quote from: Maf on 2024-02-14, 06:02:33 PMI have also read that CC has some minor resistance genes that either offer additional protection or amplify the protective effects of PH-2/PH-3 via synergy.

I heard that about Primabella compared to other homozygous Ph-2 + 3. From reliable sources. I'd reckon for top LB resistance that's a great candidate to cross with, if you don't need the larger size of the larger ones homozygous for both.

Still, CC sounds interesting and valuable. And yeah, if it is heterozygous for both, it would be possible to dehybridize it to be homozygous for both :-) If you crossed it with hetero for PH-1/2, you could with a large enough growout get maximum homozygous Ph-2 and heterozygous 1+3 in the next generation if you're lucky. Not sure how much Ph-1 adds now but in some past papers I did read it might add something at least. Though you could get a reasonable homozygous Ph-2+3 and cross it with a really tasty tomato and potentially end up with something lovely!