Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-21, 02:32:23 PMI still haven't located my Plum Regal seeds. :-[ I was F3 with them or maybe even F4 if I recall correctly and hate the notion of starting over but I am getting the other new F1s so probably will if I have too.

I guess at least there could be a benefit of using the F1 if it comes to that. Those traits that are heterozygous are presumably more easily lost so might not be in your F3/F4, and those that were homozygous could now still be heterozygous? And even ones that are now homozygous, when crossing to your main tomatoes, could still be lost within a couple of generations. So I would guess that you have more chance keeping those traits by crossing directly with the F1. So whilst it might take you back some steps for some phenotype selection, the advantage of crossing directly with the F1 and then selecting from there, could end up being a benefit. So far as I understand anyway.

Here's what Roland said about which traits are hetero/homozygous:

Quote from: Roland on 2023-08-21, 01:23:10 PMHomozygous resistance to:
Verticillium wilt (Ve gene)
Fusarium wilt (I and I-2 genes)

Heterozygous resistance to
tomato bronze spot virus (TSWV) (Sw5 gene)
Phytophthora (ph-3 gene)

Roland

Both Parents of Plum Regal have some resistance for early blight, so probably its homozygous for some early blight genes.
Netherlands

reed

#62
My favorite thing about Plum Regal was that tendency to easily dry, wouldn't mind keeping that trait around. I picked up a fresh pack from Johnnys while shopping for Galahad F1 and came across a yellow tomato listed on Johnnys with the same disease resistance as Galahad, so I got some of it too. It's called Hot Streak

I have a some more questions. How long does it take to stabilize a new variety from an F1 between two inbreds?
An inbred and an F1?
Two F1s?







Roland

Hot streak F1 has the ph2 and ph3 genes heterozygous and is therefore less resistant than Galahad F1.
It is a late variety, I think Galahad F1 ripens earlier.
The fruits are crack resistant, while Galahad is more sensitive to cracking.
The brix of Galahad is higher 5 vs 4 of Hot Streak.

Disease resistances Hot Streak F1:
-Fusarium crown and root rot,
-Fusarium wilt races 1–2,
-gray leaf spot,
-leaf mold,
-tomato mosaic virus,
-tomato spotted wilt virus,
-Verticillium wilt,
-late blight (ph2 and ph3 heterozygous)

My fruits and results from 2023:
https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=pfbid02ccsky2kYN3nXT8vXFehrwrXswMaSajKM1j7CqoxxGoJcj9fSVZM2m3pXwviCk3ekl&id=100024953531011
Netherlands

William Schlegel

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-24, 10:04:44 AMMy favorite thing about Plum Regal was that tendency to easily dry, wouldn't mind keeping that trait around. I picked up a fresh pack from Johnnys while shopping for Galahad F1 and came across a yellow tomato listed on Johnnys with the same disease resistance as Galahad, so I got some of it too. It's called Hot Streak

I have a some more questions. How long does it take to stabilize a new variety from an F1 between two inbreds?
An inbred and an F1?
Two F1s?


No matter how mixed up your initial cross is it will still take only 7 generations or so to stabilize the new variety unless it crosses again.

Inbred1 x Inbred2 = 7 generations

Inbred x F1Hybrid = 7 generations

F1Hybrid1 x F1Hybrid2 = 7 generations.

What will change though is how large of a F2 you night need to recover the most optimum combination of characters. Though you can bypass that a bit by making subsequent crosses if they are sibling crosses you can still cut down how many generations you need to stability. Also if the characters of import to you are stable sooner you can declare your project done sooner. My Mission Mountain Sunrise was essentially stable for everything but blue as soon as potato leaf and bicolor segregated back out. I have a precious packet of F7 seed but it is not really for me its for others who might want a more stable version.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Roland

A few other varieties that are heterozygous for the ph2 and ph3 genes against late blight:
- Abigail F1 (heterozygous ph2 + ph3)
- Strawberry Fields F1 (heterozygous ph2 + ph3)
- Harvest Moon F1 (heterozygous ph2 + ph3)
- Marmalade Skies F1 (heterozygous ph2 + ph3)

No idea why Jhonny`s does not mention these genes on the website??
Netherlands

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-24, 12:41:35 PMNo matter how mixed up your initial cross is it will still take only 7 generations or so to stabilize the new variety unless it crosses again.

That works just fine for one portion of my tomato project. That is to just mix up my own with each other and with any of their cousins that do well enough here to qualify. They all already have the most important traits, they grow well here, they make a nice harvest of nice beefsteak tomatoes. Assuming I am successful in my crosses and excluding anything not meeting the initial requirements, I can largely declare it done in one season. After that all I have to do is select any improved plants. Improvement being better fruit set, larger harvest, more open flowers and so on and I can do that for years without ever them really becoming new stable varieties.

If I understand it right, homozygous Potato Leaf (when self-pollinated) will always yield Potato Leaf. Homozygous Normal Leaf will always be normal leaf too, of course but heterozygous will yield 25% Potato Leaf. As long as I always grow some of the PL, and keep crossing, I can keep the whole population heterozygous and keep using the PL mothers as visual proof of crossing. Eventually, if it hasn't happened already with Hoosier Rose, maybe I will eventually see significant natural crossing.

The next section of the project involves trying to slightly decrease the fruit size, improve fruit set, speed up days to maturity and import more known disease resistances, is where the newly acquired hybrids come in. I'll be crossing them with my old favorites as well but keep those seeds separate from the first group. And then to see what comes out of William's seeds also to be crossed with mine and kept is a third group.

Then as individuals descended from the second two groups develop the same requisite qualities as the original, I'll begin mixing them into the first group.

I'm not going to worry about individual diseases or resistances. If a plant makes an acceptable harvest, even if it has a disease, or even if it is killed by one after it produces the harvest, that's all I need. 
 

 

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-25, 08:04:31 AMI'm not going to worry about individual diseases or resistances. If a plant makes an acceptable harvest, even if it has a disease, or even if it is killed by one after it produces the harvest, that's all I need. 

That makes sense, though, if you did cross with the pimp that is resistant for brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV), that could help in the fruit size reduction aim, and leave some resistance floating around in your population that might come in very handy in the future, even if you forget about it!

William Schlegel

#68
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-25, 09:01:50 AMThat makes sense, though, if you did cross with the pimp that is resistant for brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV), that could help in the fruit size reduction aim, and leave some resistance floating around in your population that might come in very handy in the future, even if you forget about it!

Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375)

I made the above cross for that as part of my collaboration with Reed. It should be about half potato leaf too so could be used as cross mothers. I think Hoosier Rose is the potato leaf one from Reed and MMM is potato leaf so about half the seedlings of the F1 should be potato leaf.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I have Brown Rugose Pimp PI 365967 that William sent me last year and I will be growing it and trying to cross it as mother to any of mine but also as father on my Hoosier Rose. As far as size reduction in the beefsteak types I hope for something less extreme than with pimp. The Galahad, Hot Streak, Better Boy and others are more in line with what I want. I still want big tomatoes, just not giant ones. Just knowing that the disease resistant genes are in some of those I'm introducing is good enough even if I can't identify it for sure in the offspring.

Another big part of what I want to do this year is just to produce a lot of seeds from all of the resistant and hybrid varieties and archive it, just in case I need it sometime. This the first time for a long time I bought tomato seeds, and for better or worse, I don't intend to ever do it again.

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-25, 09:13:56 AMHoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375)
Yep, I have that one picked out too. And Utah Heart x (MMM x Sweet Cherette) and Utah Heart x Dwarf MMR, and probably some more too.

reed

Just made my last seed order for my tomatoes. To bring in the possibility of earlier tomatoes and maybe smaller vines I ordered Early Girl F1 at 59 days and Bush Early Girl F1 at 65 days. I've grown Early Girl before, it does pretty well here, and I've had some great volunteers from it in years past. Don't know about the bush variant but it sounds interesting. I think I'll try to cross all of these on to the OTV Brandywine, assuming it does well. Actually, if it does well, I'm going to try to cross all of my regular leaf beefsteaks to it as well.

OTV Brandywine really has my attention, described by Southern Exposure as 72 dtm, it's ten days or more earlier than most of mine and its potato leaf. Tatianas has photos of it with very open flowers. I can see, first if it does well here and second, if the flavor is good, I might not grow much of any beefsteak types in 2025 except for the F1s I make with it in 2024.


For the paste/sauce/juice type I got Supersauce F1 from Burpee and I already have a new pack of Plum Regal F1 having failed to locate my old Plum Regal seeds. I also have my old PPR (particularly productive Rutgers), so I'll try to mix these up with Utah Heart. PPR may actually be a descendent of a random cross. It showed up one time in a row of Rutgers and was more determinate, smaller vine and more productive than the rest. It does ok but isn't as tolerant to prevailing conditions as Utah Heart and sometimes gets a bit of what I call moon crater disease, where circular rotten looking spots form on the fruit.



reed

#72
I've been reading all the other topics about breeding for disease resistance, open flowers and all the rest and picking up little tidbits of information that I might employ with my tomatoes. Now I'm going through them all and trying to make some kind of plan for it all.

First, I got my mixed-up pimps. They are doing fine on their own so not going to fuss with them much except maybe trying to use them for pollen donors. Also, I'm going to plant some of that smallest yellow one instead of counting on a volunteer.

Then I have the mixed-up ones from William. I'll mostly be observing these, at least at first, they include the following. Those with * means I might be using it as a parent this year, probably as pollen but maybe the other way too, if I think I can pull it off.

Exposed Orange 22
2020 Exerted Tiger
* 2022 Purple Zebra will be F2
2022 MMM F2 any RL across with Brad's Atomic Grape
2022 Pimp PH 5 Lb PI270443
2022 Brown Rugose Pimp PI 365967
MMM x (???) F2 2023
* Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA 1373)
MMM x PH5 LB Pimp 2023
* Utah Heart x (MMM x Sweet Cherette)
2023 MMM x Brown Rugose tolerance
* Utah Heart x Dwarf MMR
* Mr. Stripy x (Mission Mountain Morning x Purple Zebra F1)

Then I have the new ones I bought. Some of these will be mixed up as much as possible with my own. Others, especially the F1s might just be grown to observe and produce a lot of F2 seed.
Purple Calabash - 85 DTM, supposed to be the same as grown in pre-Columbian Mexico
Hillbilly PL - 85 DTM big Mr. Stripey like tomato
Yellow Brandywine PL - 76 DTM  big Mr. Stripey like tomato
**Brandywine OTV PL  - 72 Days big red beefsteak, result of a random cross selected by knowledgeable tomato breeders
Galahad F1 - 69 DTM disease tolerant
Hot Streak F1 - 70 DTM disease tolerant
Plum Regal F1 - 75 DTM disease tolerant
Bush Early Girl F1 - 65 DTM
Early Girl F1 - 59 DTM
SuperSauce F1 70 days

Then I have my own that I want to mix up with some of these, Mr. Stripey, Hoosier Rose, Cherokee Purple, Wyllard Wynn and Utah Heart. These are all well adapted here but I think they could maybe be improved. I'd love a small growth habit but that's probably pretty far off. I wish they set more fruits, three or four in a cluster, not just one and I'd be OK if the fruits are slightly smaller. I've only grown Wyllard Wynn once but it has the slightly smaller fruit in clusters so I think that trait might be doable. Faster DTM would be great and improved disease resistance would also be great. And while I don't want self-incompatibility, I do want more promiscuous pollination. One to keep up the genetic trading but also because I think it might be the missing key to more fruits per cluster and more fruits overall from beefsteak tomatoes.

reed

So, I have, I think four potato leaf varieties that I want to use as mothers, mostly so the crosses will be easy to confirm because of the regular leaf showing up in the F1, and that will be 75% Rl and 25% Pl. But shouldn't that work the other way too? Anytime you end up with Pl being heterozygous you will get that same proportion in the offspring?  So, if I use Rl as mothers, I just need to look for the 25% Pl to confirm the cross?

I remember Carol talking one time about how she liked to use the wilder parent in a cross as mother, in case there is any important cytoplasmic that she would want to keep. I figure it's the same here. For example, with Galahad, maybe there is something cytoplasmic I wouldn't want to loss. If I pollinate it with a PL variety, it's the same deal. The 25% potato leaf will still confirm the cross was successful.

I guess what I'm getting at is that any Pl x Rl, no matter the direction will still end up an easy way to confirm the cross worked, just in different proportions? 

William Schlegel

Only cytoplasm that might be worth preserving is that of the current tomatoes. My crosses all ended up with the common cytoplasm.

That ratio does go both ways but shows up in the F2. The F1 the crosses will be 100% RL.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days