When planning tomato breeding

Started by Kadence Luneman, 2023-12-10, 03:08:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kadence Luneman

I'm looking at my plans for next year and curious about deciding on a single line and doing it more "by the book".
I plan to make as many hand pollinated crosses as I can manage. I'm including dwarfs and micro dwarfs. Micro dwarfs especially make it easier to manage over winter growing to further the generations.

For the average... Assuming 119 days (17 weeks) from seed to seed for each generation. Based on William's direct seeded thread it seems doable even then.

1- Dec 10 2023
2- April 7 2024
3- Aug 4 2024
4- Dec 1 2024
5- March 30 2025
6- July 27 2025
7- Nov 23 2025
8- March 22 2026
9- July 19 2026
10- Nov 15 2026

It sounds really exciting "on paper" to have such quick generational progress. Harvest seed and right to planting some for the next one. Obviously it doesn't go perfectly smoothly in reality.

Population size. The more, the merrier. And more plants = More genetic combinations = Seeing more possibilities and weeding out the undesirable traits.

I'm planning on 140 tomato plants. It's alot. Most of that is 6 of each variety. To evaluate them, make crosses, and hopefully enough of each that I have wiggle room for loss or culling.

Wildling Panamorous, 10 plants.
Panamorous Direct Seeded, 19 plants.
Promiscuous G2 pink, 18 plants.

-Bag flowers to screen for SI/SC.
-Hand cross SI plants and save seed. SI only population.
-Screen for exsertion, showy flowers, open anthers. Save OP seed. Panamorous population.
-Pest/disease pressure notes and selection to send seed back to William.

I think the Panamorous and SI populations are best to keep in the normal growing season and outdoor growing unless I take cuttings at the end of season to make more of certain plant hand crosses.
But going back to my 140 plants in the garden... if I wasn't doing all the trialing and oodles of hand crosses for future use... I could do a fair grow out of one population to work on it. Or even two. 70 plants per generation should show plenty of variety to whittle down to the wanted type of a cross.

- Is 70 plants a fair grow out size? 140? It seems alot of us get into many projects and grow less plants of each, versus many of one or two.

- If you had the space what would be your optimal number of plants to grow for each generation?

With my dwarfs I may be able to adjust the spacing and grow more even. I'm waiting to see how it actually looks with them at the current planned spacing before deciding I can squeeze in more if it would turn into a jungle.

- Do people grow micro dwarfs in ground? They are marketed for small pots and hydroponics and indoors. I'd think they can be pretty close, much more than standard indet huge plants. I'm planning to put mine in large pots with many per pot. To maximize the rest of the tomatoes in the ground.

William Schlegel

#1
I am in the process, for the first time in many years, of rereading Carol Deppes Breed Your Own Vegetable varieties. This time the second edition- though I did read portions of it piecemeal over the years. I highly recommend the book or a similar one to anyone starting out in vegetable breeding.

Generation size can be determined mathematically or it can be determined by the size of your available garden space.

Carol breaks down several steps. She usually starts with a trial. It sounds like you are planning a trial and some new crosses during that trial. You don't need much space for a trial. Six individuals of each type being trialed is probably fine. Some of those you mentioned will be quite variable genetically within accession and it should give you an idea of the range of variation present.

In the next generation after your trial and crossings you'll be growing out F1s. There will be a little bit more variation in your F1s from unstable parents but between stable parents a single F1 of each would be adequate. With some unstability growing a few more of the F1s won't hurt. Still doesn't really take much garden space in the F1 generation.

So third generation the F2. This is the generation where typically you may want to use the most garden space. Depending on what you want from the cross that is! So in 2023 I grew that Aztek x Mission Mountain Morning F2 generation. I wanted a blue dwarf. I got a blue dwarf from just four dwarf seedlings I managed to sort out. No need to grow the non-dwarf seedlings. I really wanted more from the cross. I gained a little experience working with dwarfs so next time I'll likely be more efficient at sorting out dwarf seedlings. If I had sorted out more dwarf progeny I may have wanted a harder to find micro dwarf blue skinned dwarf. Maybe an early one at that.

Basically the more observable genes involved in what you want, the larger the grow out you need to find that magical F2.

However, there are lots of ways around that huge population size problem. One of which is back crossing. Got some of what you want with the space you had? Back cross to the parent with the genes you missed out on.

So I can take my blue MMM x Aztek Dwarf. Maybe even just stabilize it for a few years to get that blue stable, then I can back cross it to Aztek any year I want and have another shot at getting a micro dwarf with blue blush. That was my original goal when I thought I might want to do tomato breeding in a classroom environment with my future students. I still might someday but right now I am working as a botanist, so not so many students.

In F3 and subsequent generations your population size can usually go back down to something much more manageable. Though the F3 can also be a chance to potentially capture something you missed in the F2.

Some other thoughts: crowd them- clumps of 10 in the garden or a gallon pot, save any extra F1 and F2 seed, you might want to try again, split a large generation into two grow outs spread over two years, rent or borrow more garden space for a large generation, and make use of powerful techniques like back crossing to get the combinations you want. Also, consider doing the math.

Also, RE: sending seed back to me. We can discuss when you get to that point, but we should discuss and decide if that is something that would be useful. It might be that the information you gathered and shared is enough to inform my breeding with seeds I've retained, it might be that the seed would best be retained in your breeding program, or it might indeed be that if you sent me something I could make a new valuable cross with it and send some of that cross back to you. Or that something that segregated out in your garden might be immensely valuable and could best be stabilized in both our gardens if sent back to me.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

William, I have a question I bet you can answer to help me plan my projects next year. You sent me (Mr. Stripy x Dwarf MMR) so I'm guessing it is just a plain run of the mill F1 and all I have to raise is a plant or two. But also (Mr. Stripy x (MMM x Purple Zebra)). Are they going to be more variable from the F1 seed?


William Schlegel

#3
Quote from: reed on 2023-12-10, 10:35:00 AMWilliam, I have a question I bet you can answer to help me plan my projects next year. You sent me (Mr. Stripy x Dwarf MMR) so I'm guessing it is just a plain run of the mill F1 and all I have to raise is a plant or two. But also (Mr. Stripy x (MMM x Purple Zebra)). Are they going to be more variable from the F1 seed?



Yes all of the crosses I sent you will be more variable than simple F1s. All have unstable parents which will lead to more variability in the F1. I sent you a small amount of seed for each and retained seed for each of the crosses. So we will both be growing the same F1s in 2024.

However the details matter!

The Utah Heart x Dwarf MMR cross was with an actual dwarf, one of four plants. However not the one of the four Dwarf MMR plants that had the blue skin. It was also yellow fruited not bicolored and regular leaf. So likely all you are getting from this cross is dwarf or not dwarf. Yellow or bicolor. So for this cross, a single plant might be fine. The dwarf trait won't segregate back out until you grow out the F2.

For the (Mr. Stripy x (MMM x Purple Zebra) cross (I need to check my records on the four crosses). You'll have more variability in the F1. You might see red, bicolor, blue, stripes, and maybe some resistances. A larger F1 grow out of this cross might be advisable.

Though keep in mind that we have the backup of us both growing them in 2024. Also Julia Dakin and some others are growing your tomatoes now too. We can swap and pool seed to get the effect of a larger F1 growout if we want to. Effectively for this project our growing space is both our gardens! If more people are interested in joining in 2025 saving lots of F2 seed to share might be advisable.

To my view what we are trying to do is leverage the power of your old standbys to produce better or at least more diverse tomatoes under your and Julia Dakins more difficult growing conditions. Also I think to cross in some of Joseph's interesting genetics and maybe some of these modern heirloom quality resistant tomatoes like Galahad F1 and Purple Zebra F1. Towards that all the crosses I made with Reeds tomatoes have Joseph's Big Hill HX-9 as an ancestor as do most of my crosses.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

QuoteAlso, RE: sending seed back to me. We can discuss when you get to that point, but we should discuss and decide if that is something that would be useful. It might be that the information you gathered and shared is enough to inform my breeding with seeds I've retained, it might be that the seed would best be retained in your breeding program, or it might indeed be that if you sent me something I could make a new valuable cross with it and send some of that cross back to you. Or that something that segregated out in your garden might be immensely valuable and could best be stabilized in both our gardens if sent back to me.

That works for me.

I've got that book in my wishlist. May have to stop by and see if I can get it from the library until then.

Kadence Luneman

23 varieties/populations to grow in 2024.
I've started a spreadsheet to better keep track of my thoughts. Way too many hand crosses to manage but they are everything I'm interested in trying out. I should get lots of practice either way haha. This is in flux as I'll be adding crosses I want to try and removing crosses I decide not to try as it goes. If certain varieties aren't doing well I'll remove them or use them only as a pollen donor, etc. Hopefully it will also help me keep track of what crosses I'm making and what ones to try.

I have plant markers and am thinking to tag each plant with a number. Like.. A1, A2, A3, etc for dwarf sandy stripes. Then B1, B2, B3, etc for dwarf Gloria's treat. Make another page in the spreadsheet for it. And crosses would be like F1xV3. Easier field marking.

The potato leaf dwarfs I pretty much want to cross with everything for ease of picking out successful F1 seedlings. Exserted orange, exserted tiger, and big hill also want to cross alot for exsertion.

F1s...
If I don't need to grow out as many as I thought I would then I could grow out smaller amounts of many F1s to decide which ones to continue with. That's exciting!

*Stable domestic parent F1s I can grow just a few to see the results. 1 or 2 clumps of 3 plants.

*With a stable x unstable parent F1s there will be more variety in the first offspring. 3 clumps of 3 plants.

*With unstable x unstable parent F1s there will be plenty of variety in the offspring. 5 clumps of 3 plants.

Most of what I'm starting with is stable varieties. The Promiscuous and SI populations are very wide and unstable and will need larger growouts. This will be fun though to have lots of different possibilities to start with.

I don't really have starting goals for these crosses yet. Kind of waiting to see how they are doing and what I end up liking or preferring then go from there. I'm doing alot of playing with the rest of the garden so in future years I could put more to tomato projects, however it turns out.

Kadence Luneman

14 crosses on RL dwarf mothers.
46 crosses on PL dwarf mothers.
21 crosses on micro dwarf mothers.
31 crosses on Exserted Orange, Exserted Tiger, and Big Hill mothers for exsertion.
7 crosses on Cache valley currant.
23 crosses on domestic mothers.
Plus bag & buzz Panamorous plants to test for SI.

Definitely too many. Reality of when flowers are ready and my time will reign that in  ::)

Actually that gives me a thought... If you hand pollinate a SI plant... If I buzz many flowers and dab many flowers all on the same spoon... Will the flowers fail if they get any pollen that is deemed "self"? Or will the cross pollen be viable and just the pollen deemed "self" not do anything?
I'm not sure what my pollinators will make of Panamorous/Promiscuous tomato flowers. It may be unnecessary.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-12-12, 01:15:24 AMWill the flowers fail if they get any pollen that is deemed "self"?

No

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-12-12, 01:15:24 AMOr will the cross pollen be viable and just the pollen deemed "self" not do anything?
Yes.

Although I dd wonder, one technique supposedly to help hard crosses is to use mixed pollen. This made me wonder if the pollen being mixed might increase the chances of incompatible pollen, making it through. But, so far as I understand, what I said above should be the case. And certainly I have been buzzing SI flowers to extract pollen, then pollinating them with pollen from other plants, no problem. It would be like that in nature anyway.

One thing though - if you are making specific crosses, then if using pollen from one plant on others, dabbing the same pollen on various plants might give rise to cross contamination. I would think just being a bit careful to not disturb the flower you are pollinating too much, to minimise the chances of pollen falling out on to the spoon, may reduce the risk of contaminating the pollen spoon.

I harvest pollen into empty medicine capsules. I store it in the refrigerator. This means increased risk of contamination since I may use it on many plants over the course of days or weeks. So, when possible, I use fresh pollen harvested onto a small flat surface and use it just for what I need right then. This reduces the risk. But it's very handy to have stored pollen so I can still use it when the flowers with that pollen are no longer available. And that's quite common when growing very small indoor plants.

Your project looks great.

Kadence Luneman

I have 144 crosses listed to try. That doesn't include testing for SI, if I end up hand crossing the SI, or hand crossing the Panamorous group. There isn't any reason to list the Panamorous crosses because it will be down to evaluating individual plants.

What's the current interest in the SI tomatoes? I have so many options to follow that I'm not sure I'll focus much on SI once I get going. I'm more interested in the Panamorous than strictly SI.
I'd be happy to just keep a back up of it for myself and send the bulk of it to the more interested parties. Joseph Lofthouse, William Schlegel, etc?

Kadence Luneman

My current list of goals. Vague and squishy.

Priority 1:
Dw Gloria's treat crosses- PL so F1 will all be regular leaf. Dwarf.
Dw stoney brook heart crosses- striped. PL so F1 will all be regular leaf
Dw summer sunrise crosses- PL so F1 will all be regular leaf
Orange hat crosses- micro/dwarf, short DTM
Rosey finch crosses- micro/dwarf, short DTM
XL Red- evaluate.
Promiscuous G2 pink- evaluate. Exsertion, showy flowers, open anthers.
Panamorous Direct Seeded- evaluate. Test for SI. Exsertion, showy flowers, open anthers.
Wildling Panamorous- evaluate. Test for SI. Exsertion, showy flowers, open anthers. Best examples cross to Neandermato.
Neandermato- Test for SI. Test pollinate some flowers with Wildling pollen.

Priority 2:
Exserted Orange- selection for exertion, fruit size
Exserted Orange crosses- exsertion
MMM- William not going to breed out and stabilize. Choose a type and possibly stabilize it.
Big Hill crosses- exsertion, open anther
42 day crosses- short DTM

Priority 3:
Exserted tiger crosses- exsertion
Barry's crazy cherry crosses- Multiflora
Black beauty crosses- antho, shorter DTM
Cache valley currant crosses- vigor, fruit size, exsertion
Dw sandy stripes- stripes, chocolate, variegated leaves

William Schlegel

I think for SI, I may look for it in Promiscuous x LA2329 myself. If Joseph has a hot SI prospect he wants seed increased it can have one of my isolation gardens.

144 crosses! I just had my best year ever in 2023 with some 74 crosses! Though honestly 144 may not be that many! Justin has made a lot more in 2023! I get limited time with my garden, always off doing botany work.

Stabilizing MMM - fancy! I made so many crosses with it in 2022 and it and it's descendants in 2023 I feel like I should maybe move right along on to mother tomato version 3.0. Not quite sure what that will look like. Might have to just keep going to 4.0 and do some sideways crossing to see what all I can accumulate.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

Good to know. I may just do the SI testing and save it for a year or two. Maybe find a spot for an isolated garden for it.

Haha, I know it's a ridiculous amount of crosses! I just like having a list ready made. Then I can easily pull it up when I'm in the garden and see what crosses can be attempted based on available flowers at the time.
It's extremely big dreaming for someone who has not done a single manual pollination of tomatoes before!  ::)

For MMM I'm interested to see what I get, regular leaf F1s and potato leaf MMM, from the MMMxBAG seeds. You obviously saw something in it to use it in so many crosses. I re-found where you said you probably have more to find with the crosses than to further it in it's own. So I thought that would be interesting if I find something in it to work with. It's made of three crosses and only made it to F2 it looked like. So these would be F3 plants and should segregate alot.

William Schlegel

I grew some F3 MMM in 2023. Did not see a exsertion favorite though. Saved some seed for the F4. Will probably grow a small clump. Can't justify a garden of it though when it has so many descendants! I also think it would be more fun with stripes and dwarf!

Will be amazing to see the segregation with the crosses with MMM and the crosses with crosses of MMM in 2024.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

William what would your ideal tomato be then? Dwarf, potato leaf, exserted, stripes, antho all together?

William Schlegel

#14
Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-12-12, 11:50:17 PMWilliam what would your ideal tomato be then? Dwarf, potato leaf, exserted, stripes, antho all together?

Pretty much, there are always more characteristics that could be added. Like if the stripes came from Purple Zebra F1 it might have a better chance at having at least some resistances. Or if Sweeet Cherriette was in the mix for earliness that would be nice. I definitely have it in mind that a stable tomato like that would make a better cross mother.

Possible parents of such a improved mother tomato:

Sandpoint or payette for dwarf.
Purple Zebra F1 for stripes and resistances.
Mission Mountain Morning for potato leaf, antho, and exsertion.

I've made crosses with each of the above and just need to cross again once and segregate or perhaps segregate, cross, and then alow to segregate finally.

Though to be honest a lot of my crosses likely have something that would work. Or that might make an effective back or side cross to get more traits into the same package. I could end up with green, tricolor, bicolor, red and orange versions and keep them all. There are lots of potential crosses there. There are also lots of lines that it might be nice to go ahead and stabilize into varieties. It might not make sense to cross dwarf to dwarf when the dwarfing genes came from different sources. I did make at least one cross like that in 2023, so will see what happens but it could lead to double dwarfing or do something odd like cancel out dwarfing.

I may also have multiple pathways forward towards these goals from different lines.

My MMM x Aztek cross has produced a dwarf yellow antho regular leaf cross. It just needs crossed with a striped potato leaf.

MMM x Sweet Cherriette is now a potato leaf bicolor antho cherry. It just needs crossed with a striped dwarf.

Dwarf Mochas treat x MMS should segregate a dwarf blue bicolor cherry in 2024. Which would then just need crossed again for stripes.

Dwarf Gloria's treat crosses will segregate back to dwarf in 2024. Then would just need crossed to an antho striped tomato.

MMM x BAG will segregate out antho potato leaf tomatoes with stripes as should the more complex cross (MMM x BAG) x (MMM x PZ). Those resulting offspring would just need crossed to a dwarf.

I just need to keep crossing and segregating!

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days