When planning tomato breeding

Started by Kadence Luneman, 2023-12-10, 03:08:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kadence Luneman

Very nice.

I'm definitely thinking of building a grow "tent" cupboard. It would be nice to reflect the light back to the plants, instead of just out and blinding me into a red-blue-purple haze lol. And I could expedite crossing. Grow as usual then plant some F1s as soon as the seeds are fermented and cleaned. Have half grown plants to bring in before frosts. Then be on the way to seed saving or crossing to be ready for next growing season with F2 seed.

I think it makes sense. The F2 shows some traits but F3 is where the real segregation happens.

William Schlegel

In my view, F2 is the magic generation with maximum segregation potential, and F3 and beyond are just for stabilizing and testing to make sure you are saving the right segregants. Unless all the traits important to you are recessive and then you could be F2 and done!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

Ah! I misspoke (mis-typed)... I should have said F1 should be mostly the same to each other, more so the more stable the parents were. So growing them indoors partly to get the seed for F2 is not as important. Because the F2 is where the segregation starts. It's less important to see how the F1 does in the field and better to speed up getting to F2.

ThomatoGarden

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-12-13, 08:59:32 PM... as soon as the seeds are fermented and cleaned ...
You can put the seeds on kitchen paper, let them dry a little bit and then rub them of one by one with a little pressure. The hull of the seeds will stick to the paper. Saves some days and the mess with fermenting.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-13, 08:46:38 PMI think I've avoided crossing LA2329 more widely because I was trying to avoid inserted stigmas and I kind of like having some of my tomatoes be easily palatable.

LA2329 being an SI hab, with exserted stigma right? Do even F1 crosses with it and lyc give usually inserted stigmas? Or like if crossed with exserted orange, do the F1 and much or most of F2 end up inserted?

Quote from: ThomatoGarden on 2023-12-14, 12:44:03 AM
Quote... as soon as the seeds are fermented and cleaned ...
You can put the seeds on kitchen paper, let them dry a little bit and then rub them of one by one with a little pressure. The hull of the seeds will stick to the paper. Saves some days and the mess with fermenting.

That's what I do for almost all my crosses. But it really takes time! I rinse them after cleaning also. I figure it's safer than having loads of containers everywhere and dangers of spilling or mixing or forgetting and overfermenting. But if wanting to clean all the seeds, not just take a few for planting, wow it really takes me time if I have several to process. I started to wonder about maybe using trisodium phosphate (TSP), but I rather not use toxic chemicals if possible. I'd be interested to hear people's suggestions - I have a backlog of literally dozens of crossed fruits to individually process.

William Schlegel

#35
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-14, 05:56:13 AMLA2329 being an SI hab, with exserted stigma right? Do even F1 crosses with it and lyc give usually inserted stigmas? Or like if crossed with exserted orange, do the F1 and much or most of F2 end up inserted?
You can put the seeds on kitchen paper, let them dry a little bit and then rub them of one by one with a little pressure. The hull of the seeds will stick to the paper. Saves some days and the mess with fermenting.

That's what I do for almost all my crosses. But it really takes time! I rinse them after cleaning also. I figure it's safer than having loads of containers everywhere and dangers of spilling or mixing or forgetting and overfermenting. But if wanting to clean all the seeds, not just take a few for planting, wow it really takes me time if I have several to process. I started to wonder about maybe using trisodium phosphate (TSP), but I rather not use toxic chemicals if possible. I'd be interested to hear people's suggestions - I have a backlog of literally dozens of crossed fruits to individually process.

LA2329 is a hab accession with modestly exserted stigmas it is listed as SI but may contain some SC individuals though I have not yet isolated one in my subpopulation. I have primarily crossed LA2329 to date with exserted stigma domestic lines derived from Big Hill HX-9: Promiscuous Bicolors, Big Hill, and Mission Mountain Morning crosses with LA2329 have all been grown out. I don't recall observing inserted stigmas off hand. Some of the mothers have been a little fickle in exsertion some of the 2021 promiscuous bicolors weren't but my crosses came from those that were. However, the isolated patch of Big Hill x LA2329 and MMM x LA2329 patch produced pollen and no fruits in 2023. I assumed that was indicative of a lack of adequate S alleles but stigma insertion could also be a factor if it was present, though I don't think it was. I have made new crosses in 2023 that I will grow out in 2024 of Exserted Orange x LA2329 and Exserted Tiger x LA2329. Interestingly the LA2329 father or fathers of those new crosses produced no fruit in the greenhouse. I tried transferring pollen but apparently not enough S alleles present on the two plants. So I definitely want to plant those new crosses next to promiscuous x LA2329 and LA2329!

Note: it is possible that my LA2329 sub-population has lost some diversity. My first two growouts were only partially successful as many plants produced no fruit. Perhaps there could be S alleles in the crosses that could now be absent from the LA2329 cytoplasm material. It's also possible S alleles could have been picked up from the promiscuous project including BC1 though no morphological evidence has been observed.

I process all tomato seeds by fermentation. If I make a cross and I get one seed, I ferment that seed. Sometimes I add liquid from another tomato.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Ah I see. One thought that comes to my mind would be to find a hab accession with similar properties that you want, but with high exsertion, and mix it into your hab population? Could also be a way of introducing more S-alleles.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-14, 06:24:00 AMInterestingly the LA2329 father or fathers of those new crosses produced no fruit in the greenhouse. I tried transferring pollen but apparently not enough S alleles present on the two plants.

Hmm yeah, sounds like they both share the same two S-alleles, which would be statistically unlikely if your population had a good diversity of S-alleles.

Or if there really are SC in them, maybe .... hmm, I was going to say maybe one or both could have 1 or 2 SC alleles. But then... if the SC is dominant and the SC and SI compatible, the SC pollen should be able to pollinate both. In which case I guess if there were any SC allele there then the SC is recessive? But then, ... hmm I'm thinking that would require for a functioning SC plant, that the stigma also evolved to be able to receive SC recessive - it's a three step evolution process from SI to SC recessive so far as I understand. But I am thinking a bit beyond my clear knowledge now so should probably stop. My first guess would perhaps be just 2 SI S-alleles between those two plants though.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-14, 06:24:00 AMI process all tomato seeds by fermentation. If I make a cross and I get one seed, I ferment that seed. Sometimes I add liquid from another tomato.

Oh wow that's interesting. Is that because of wanting to protect against disease transmission? I did process some seeds from outdoor crosses from fruits that had late blight. Just in case, after hand processing without fermentation, I bleached them a little bit. Just in case that helped. I don't know if that benefits or not but I thought to try to emulate the benefit of fermentation in some way.

William Schlegel

The fermentation is one part force of habit since that is how I started seed saving tomatoes and one part reinforcement in terms of feeling confident that when I share tomato seed it has been cleaned by a widely accepted process. Bleaching and other seed treatments can reduce seed bourne virus transmission.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days