Cold Temperate Perennial Tomatoes

Started by Thulahn, 2023-10-03, 09:02:32 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Sledgehammer Potato

Quote from: Sledgehammer Potato on 2023-10-07, 11:54:53 PMFlowers were bagged prior to opening to prevent self-pollination, and the parent was a pure inbred line homozygous for potato leaf, meaning without heritable DNA crossing the graft union every seedling produced should be potato leaf.
I double checked this in my notes (I take too many notes), and I was wrong above.  I bagged the flowers prior to opening, and left them bagged until the fruit was ripe.  I did not emasculate or pollinate these flowers, they were all selfed. 

Quote from: Thulahn on 2023-10-08, 01:32:08 AMThis is interesting. My guess would be that visible traits are just the surface level indication of gene transfer, and that there will be a higher percentage of non visible traits transferred. Did you notice any other differences to growing habits of the seeds collected from the from the fruit of the graft union?
I agree completely, there would have been a lot of gene transfer that I couldn't know about.  I chose to try this with simple dominant recessive traits that are easy to see as I don't have access to a lab.  The Yuhuang plum experiment saw up to 15% success rate, my results were far less promising, I am not sure why.

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-10-08, 04:18:20 AMDid you run a control, such as planting (or grafting to potato leaf rootstock), pollinating them in the same way you did the test group, and planting out the same number of F1s?
Yes I did control groups.  I grafted potato leaf to potato leaf, only potato leaf seedlings arose.  I planted 100 to 150 seeds of each replicate.     

I ran this experiment as a proof of concept after having read several papers on heritable DNA grossing the graft union.  All of these had been using the same species (and so was my experiment).  I have no idea how well it works with different species or genera.  I had planned on grafting tomato to chilli, and attempting to produce a hot tomato with some level of capsaicin.  Sadly life has prevented me from pursuing this any further. 


Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Sledgehammer Potato on 2023-10-14, 05:05:04 PMYes I did control groups.  I grafted potato leaf to potato leaf, only potato leaf seedlings arose.  I planted 100 to 150 seeds of each replicate. 
Excellent! How many true leaves did the seedlings have before you cut them for attaching to the rootstock? And, it would be super interesting if you'd run the experiment again comparing a regular graft type group with a mentor graft group! Or even do 3 groups - one mentor group and the other two both usual graft type but one at 2 true leaf stage and the other at a later stage if you used a later stage in your original trial. I would guess doing it at an earlier stage might increase the percentage somewhat and the mentor graft might increase the percentage more dramatically.

Also could be cool to chose more than one obvious phenotype difference, like leaf type and maybe also fruit colour? Or even more, like flesh colour plus skin colour.. I'm not too familiar with specific genes but maybe there are multiple traits around that that show up in the F1 if you chose the right pair of varieties? Though, it sounds like maybe you won't be running another trial... Cool work though.

Tim DH

Inheritance from Grafts

When Thulahn first mentioned this concept I was, frankly, sceptical.

However Sledgehammers contribution is not so easy to dismiss as wishful thinking!

Thulahn's goal still seems to me to be way over the horizon, but Sledgehammers 'proof of concept' shouldn't be too hard to replicate. And if his results are reproduceable, then it could be a breeding tool with much wider application than Thulahn's vision.

I had a thumb nail removed earlier this week and, when the painkillers are working, that has given me plenty of brooding time! I'm thinking of running a little trial next year.

I like the idea of using a potato leaved scion on a regular leaved rootstock, because visually checking a hundred seedlings at the three leaved stage is simple enough. (RL seedlings will stick out like the proverbial sore thumb!) Such a trial would take up very little space.

Taking the idea further, I'd like to know if some seedlings receive a lot of rootstock DNA, or if lots of seedlings receive a little bit of rootstock DNA. THEREFOR: I'd like to screen for a second trait at the same time. (The three leaf stage.) I have one cultivar, ABC Potato Leaf which has no long stem hairs. I assume this trait is recessive. However ABC PL only does a few seeds per fruit, and given Sledgehammers observation that transfer decreases with fruit distance from the graft, that's obviously not ideal.

SO Does anyone know of a PL cultivar which has smooth stems and seedy fruit?
OR Can anyone suggest another recessive trait which is screenable at the three leaf stage?

Also, Ive been wondering about a mechanism for such DNA transfer. Harking back to my first degree (last Millennium!) perhaps there are transposons in the sap. That leads to two further thoughts. Firstly, presumably some rootstocks are better at producing transposons than others. Secondly, whatever the actual mechanism, this is probably a form of genetic engineering. ... GMOs anyone?

Tim DH

Roland

If u want to test this, use a rootstock with recessive genes like Dwarf Jade Beauty and use scion with dominant genes (red fruit and RL leaves).
U pollinate the Scion on the rootstock with pollen from the variety with recessive genes.

Why Dwarf Jade Beauty is a good rootstock and pollen donor:
Dwarf Jade Beauty is a potato leaf dwarf variety that produces round medium to medium small fruit that ripen with green flesh and clear skin.

So the dwarf gene u can fount at seedling stage in the F1 generation if there was gene transfer from the rootstock in the dominant variety.

The potato leave gene u can fount at seedling stage in the F1 generation if there was gene transfer from the rootstock in the dominant variety.

The other recessive genes (yellow, green and clear skin) u can fount in the ripe fruit in the F1 generation if there was gene transfer from the rootstock in the dominant variety.

Using a dominant Scion there is no problem with contaminated pollen.
Netherlands

William Schlegel

#19
I agree use a potato leaf dwarf but I say RL rootstock and PL scion. I don't think you would recover the traits till the F2 otherwise potentially. At least possibly.

Transposons are a possible mechanism. Another is cellular repair including DNA repair after damage but with mixing. Another is transfer of mitochondria and chloroplasts.

If this sort of thing works, I wonder if it could work with a purple interior tomatillo and a tomato. Multi gene traits might be too much to ask for but anything that just needs one could work. I wonder if it is close relatives mainly.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#20
Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-10-15, 05:39:49 AMOR Can anyone suggest another recessive trait which is screenable at the three leaf stage?
How about dwarfs? Would Wherokowhai be easy to recognise if dwarf at that stage, from the fattness of the stem? It's potato leaved.

And if you will do this trial, will you also run some using mentor grafts? I think that would be really valuable to add to the trial! I've been considering doing mentor grafts to hab LA1777, might be a way to gain late blight resistance - but without UV lights (so far), that's not something I can really do easily. But anyway trialing mentor grafting in this way would be a really good and direct test of the method's potential value.

By the way has anyone done or heard of grafting direct to habrochaites, not merely hab crossed rootstock? Is it similar in ease to regular grafts? If it's not easy, I might have to get Nicotiana benthamiana involved as a graft bridge, though, I worry if that might make the genetic transfer a bit harder having to pass through 2 grafts.

Quote from: Roland on 2023-10-15, 07:03:43 AMWhy Dwarf Jade Beauty is a good rootstock and pollen donor
Oh, you beat me to it with the dwarf idea, just read that! Neat idea to do it that way around. I guess it would work either way, selfing a dwarf scion and checking for loosing homozygosity, or using the rootstock to root stock and pollen gaining the trait. Ah I see everyone's mentioning dwarfs, I should probably read all comments before starting a reply!






Adrian

Graft of solanum lycopersicum to habrochaite is easy.
Unfortunately solanum habrochaite grow in zig zag: for exemple one internode go toward right and the second go toward the left.

Roland

Don't expect too much from this, there's a reason:
Why don't professional growers use this?
Why do F2 seeds of the commercial Picolo variety not show any properties of the rootstock?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new apple varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new pear varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new cherry varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new grape varieties?

So if you want to test this out, it is important that you rule out other causes and it is better to have the recessive properties in the root stock.
Netherlands

Thulahn

Quote from: Roland on 2023-10-15, 12:05:40 PMDon't expect too much from this, there's a reason:
Why don't professional growers use this?
Why do F2 seeds of the commercial Picolo variety not show any properties of the rootstock?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new apple varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new pear varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new cherry varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new grape varieties?

So if you want to test this out, it is important that you rule out other causes and it is better to have the recessive properties in the root stock.

I think that might be attributed to not grafting very young saplings that are more genetically elastic. There's a thread going on here https://landracegardening.discourse.group/t/cold-temperate-perennial-tomatoes/1511/1 which goes into more detail.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Roland on 2023-10-15, 12:05:40 PMDon't expect too much from this, there's a reason:
Why don't professional growers use this?
Why do F2 seeds of the commercial Picolo variety not show any properties of the rootstock?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new apple varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new pear varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new cherry varieties?
Why is grafting not a problem when growing new grape varieties?

So if you want to test this out, it is important that you rule out other causes and it is better to have the recessive properties in the root stock.

There are some obstacles here that might make cross breeding the more reliable tool for amateurs.

Especially within the multi species tomato complex there are close to a dozen species where conventional breeding is a very productive approach. Tremendous genetic diversity there.

This natural gene transfer phenomenon becomes most interesting if it could help cross species or genus barriers. Solve intractable problems like spicy tomatoes, potato tomato hybrids, perennial tomatoes, or blue interior without snapdragon transgenes tomatoes.

However it might require huge effort for minimal reward. I could see these natural transgenetic individuals being very useful but finding them might be very difficult.

I suffer from a problem with my conventional tomato breeding essentially where I always have more seed than I can grow. I think this problem would be exacerbated here. You would have lots of seed with potential and not a great chance of selecting the right seed amongst thousands.

Nature does this just fine say with grasses because the population sizes involved are enormous. Also nature has deep time on its side.

Still it's a real phenomenon in nature and very interesting. Though I'll likely stick with conventional crossbreeding myself because it's already such a productive way to work with tomatoes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Thulahn on 2023-10-15, 12:23:37 PMI think that might be attributed to not grafting very young saplings that are more genetically elastic

Yeah that's exactly what I was thinking, and why I was asking how many true leaves there were when you made the graft, and, why I was recommending mentor grafts at a very early stage also.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-10-15, 01:27:09 PMThere are some obstacles here that might make cross breeding the more reliable tool for amateurs.

I was wondering if this method might actually have some benefits, for example if it were possible to bring over some hereditable late blight resistance from hab without making the fruit horrible for many generations, that would be great!

Also if there are cytoplasmic elements that help with disease resistance that could be brought over this way, that could be interesting.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-10-15, 01:27:09 PMThis natural gene transfer phenomenon becomes most interesting if it could help cross species or genus barriers. Solve intractable problems like spicy tomatoes, potato tomato hybrids, perennial tomatoes, or blue interior without snapdragon transgenes tomatoes.

I assume you have read the Russian work using mentor grafts? Reports of crossing lyc and per this way. Sounds well worth trying. I only tried a few mentor grafts for that purpose this year but was not disciplined enough in making proper conditions, I should probably make a proper humidity chamber.Space is a bit of an issue currently though. Anyway it seems that the plasticity may make the flower structures more able to receive the per pollen, and this could plausible help many usually impossible crosses.

Has anyone here actually done any mentor grafts, and if so, how did it go?

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-10-15, 01:27:09 PMYou would have lots of seed with potential and not a great chance of selecting the right seed amongst thousands.

I like the idea of those easy to see traits at small seedling stage, as a test of the method. If the method could be optimised through repeated trials, it could prove quite useful. And if then applying it to interspecial crosses, again they might be easy o see at the seedling stage?

I get that it's something only few people would want to do though. But if optimised, it could become more relevant for more people, once success rates are increased through identifying appropriate variables.



Justin Jardinier

#26
Just to give a quote from the paper 'WIDE HYBRIDIZATION IN VEGETABLE BREEDING', by D. D. Brezhnev, First Vice-President of the All-Union Academy of Agricultural Sciences im . V.I. Lenin:

QuoteThe interagent method (used by K. V. Ivanova) is another possibility. The maternal plant o f L . e s c u l e n t u m was grafted, in its cotyledon stage, onto more developed stocks of L . p e r u v i a n u m (stage of five to six real leaves); later, L. p e r u v i a n u m pollen was placed on the stig mas of em asculated L. e s c u l e n t u m flow ers for three to four days.

Using all these m ethods, we obtained sound seed which yielded good seed lings when sown. The seedlings of hybrid fruit w ere already distinguished by a large variability in shape, size and leaf characters. M oreover, the germination of the seeds was uneven. Later, this sam e seed was sown near Leningrad and in the Maikop Experim ental Station (Krasnodar T erritory). In the first and second generations a considerable segregation of characters was observed. Plants of an interm ediate type as w ell as a series of com pletely new form s w ere obtained in addition to the two parent types. On the whole, plants of the seed-parent type* dominated. Thus, in 1953, of 606 hybrid plants sown near Leningrad 453 w ere of the seedparent type, 148 of the pollen-parent type, and only five were interm ediates.

Hybrid plants of the paternal type proved to be sterile in cro sses with L. p e r u v i a n u m . A high resistance to M a c r o s p o r i u m and P h y t o p h t h o r a was observed in hybrid plants of the seed-parent. The m ost interesting and valuable feature of these cro sses is the appearance of plants of an interm ediate type. Among such plants a variable range of morphological characters is observed. It appears that hybrid seed is more easily obtained from L. e s c u l e n t u m X U h i r s u t u m - with L. e s c u l e n t u m as maternal form - than from L, e s c u l e n t u m X L. p e r u v i a n u m . From a breeding point of view, L, p e r u v i a n u m is the m ore interesting partner.

Also just to explain the mentor graft for anyone who's not familiar with it, in a bit more detail the way it was explained to me - the mentor should be at least 2 or 3 months old, having maybe 20 or 30 leaves, but the older the better really. The scion should be as young as possible, like 10~14 days after emergence with 3~5 leaves only. I sad 2~4 above but checked my notes now, though I wonder, maybe with a dwarf scion even 2 true leaves might work, since the stem is fatter? Basically, as young as possible so that it is as genetically plastic as possible.Then like I said, as the plant grows, only allow the end 2 or 3 leaves of the scion to be kept. This way, the scion's dependence on the mentor is maximised. Apparently infecting the stock with an RNA-virus a month before grafting can also increase the effect, mentioned in the paper 'GRAFT INDUCED GENETIC CHANGES AND ITS MECHANISM IN BELL PEPPER (CAPSICUM ANNUUM) – A REVIEW' by K. Abirami et al., 2009:

QuoteThe graft induced genetic changes were first known to the Chinese more than 1400 years ago (Liu, 2000).

Though I'd include that quote first - anyway then they go into Michurin's work and others, and the virus bit:
QuoteKasahara and his co workers have independently and repeatedly shown that in Capsicum annuum Mendelian genes can be transferred from stock into scion by grafting (Kasahara et al., 1973; Ohta and Chuong, 1975a; Ohta ad Chuong, 1975b and Ohta, 1977). In 1967, Ohta a Japanese 'Mendelist' was allowed to examine Kasahara's original data. Ohta and his coworker carried out grafting experiments by using Kasahara's materials and methods and produced variants similar to those of Kasahara's. In their experiment reciprocal grafts were made between 2 cultivars of red pepper namely Tochigisantaka (with erect, fasciculate and red fruits) and Kiiro (with pendent, nonfasciculate and yellow fruits). An overall rate of variance of 0.84% was obtained in the first, second and third generations self crossed progeny of the scion (Ohta and Choung, 1975b). In another set of experiment, Ohta and Chuong (1975b) found that in stock artificially infected with single stranded RNA virus for 'broad bean wilt' the rate of gene transfer increased dramatically from 2% for non infected stocks to 16.5% for infected stocks. Apparently the hereditary changes associated with grafting were enhanced by virus infection. Ohta paid a special attention to eliminate possible contamination at every possible step of the experiment. He used pure materials, which had been maintained for five generations by selfing and sown the seeds in sterile soil and boxes. The genotype of each variant was determined by self crossing and test crossing to both parents to check for the possibility of accidental contamination. Ohta and Choung (1975b) concluded that contamination could not be responsible for the majority of the variants and that the rate of variant occurrence was too high for spontaneous mutation. Thus, as one citation of his paper noted – the work is thoroughly documented and there is no cause to doubt the genuineness of the results because these observations were made by professional geneticists and have been reported with similar results in independent laboratories (Pandey, 1985).

A few points that are interesting in that paper include the changes being in the sexual progeny of the scion, not appearing in the scion itself (consistent with the OP). And that while changes are usually single alleles, they can also be double:
QuoteThe change is usually homozygous to heterozygous (one allele changed), but sometimes it can be dominant homozygous to recessive homozygous (simultaneous allele change) (Pandey, 1979). This is non Mendelian inheritance. These change could not be produced by sexual crossing or by contamination and only rarely if at all by mutation. This type of change was first reported by applying DNA in insects such as Ephestia (Nawa and Yamada, 1967 and 1968) and in silkworm (Nawa et al., 1971). The simultaneous alleles change in capsicum was reported for fruit shape (Yagishita and Hirata, 1987) and fruit colour (Hirata and Yagishita, 1986).

That sounds really useful! Imagine if we had a really good tomato and that is totally susceptible to late blight, we might have to dilute it a lot in order to get homozygous ph-2 and ph-3, but maybe with this method we could be lucky enough to get one or both of them over without too many other changes! Hmm, I'm almost making a case for GMO there! But anyway it does sound pretty cool.

Also this is really weird but sounds also quite convenient:
QuoteIn the case of two complementary genes, both genes always changed together (Ohta, 1991). Ohta and Chuong, (1975a) found that pairs of complementary genes such as those for pericarp colour always changed together. Kasahara et al.,(1973) also found that out of 39 observed variants for pericarp colour 36 were red ( i.e both the genes changed together).

They also note that the change can be a single gene change, or multiple, that the rate of occurence of change varied widely between experiments (making trialing for variables sounding a worthy endeavour in my opinion) - their average was around 0.84% - and that while variants usually appeared singly, in one case, all of the seeds inside a fruit gave rise to variants.