Cold Temperate Perennial Tomatoes

Started by Thulahn, 2023-10-03, 09:02:32 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Thulahn

I guess all this talk about tomatoes on forum has finally gotten to me.

I've been thinking about how to create a cold temperate perennial tomato for a long time now, and I finally had a break through today whilst recovering from some kind of cold (ironic, really).

The process I outline below might in theory produce a true cold temperate perennial tomato. It involves grafting of a tomato onto a cold hardy Solanaceae rootstock, and repeated grafting of the subject generations.

Let me know what you think: https://urbanfoodforest.substack.com/p/perennial-cold-temperate-tomatoes

Garrett Schantz

Nice idea.

And, no. I haven't read much about mRNA and the like being moved back and forth between grafts.

DNA and mRNA, though.

They're different things. mRNA usually needs some instructions and the like, from DNA to carry out processes. Or they fit into different DNA portions.


It's still pretty cool.




https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,231.msg5322.html#msg5322

Here's a thread on Tomato x Lycium.



https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,516.0.html

That's one, just on Goji.






https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,559.0.html

And, here is a thread that I made. Mentioned Goji a few times here.


Goji x Tomato hybrids, have actually been made without too much of a hassle. It still requires some work. But, it seems to work relatively well.


Solanum sisymbriifolium x Lycopersicum hybrids have been made in labs as well.



Both are hardier than tomatoes - and all of the members of their clade.



You also mentioned that Tomatoes, aren't from a temperate location.


Which, means that they lack a lot of perennial cold traits. And, even if you made a perennial variety or line - it's going to run into some issues. Mostly with diseases and pests.

Certain weather conditions or temperatures, weaken tomatoes. Some pests may notice a later snack further into the year as well.


I believe that our conditions are already screwy for tomatoes. You can do all of the breeding that you can, and still end up with things that hate temperate conditions.


I'm fine with zone pushing on some trees and things, because I want to cross them with more adapted things.



A zone too high or low, can produce a possible disease vector or unhealthy plant.


I have a Gymnocladus dioicus seedling growing. It's ideal top range, is Zone 8. I'm in Zone 8b. I'm probably planting it in partial shade.


Luckily, Mississippi is sort of a swamp, especially my area. A bit of compost, and messing around in a small area, will allow me to remove a clay sort of soil to some extent, and hold more water.


Even though this is 8b, and I could actually get away with perennial tomatoes, using S. habrochaites whole 25F or so hardiness - save for heavy frost years, I likely won't even try it too much.


Perennial crops, usually grown as annuals. For one. Disease vectors.

Good luck growing Eggplants, Peppers, Ground Cherries or any other relative without issues nearby, ever again.


Lycium doesn't share as many pests with Solanum, nor disease. And you don't see a lot of people in the States growing them.



Lycopersicum, has a lot of pests and the like that know it exists, and they view the species group as a snack.


Insects, will overwinter or lay eggs on / around these things. Diseases which may not harm the plants may also overwinter and eventually spread to other species and the like.


Or a disease may adapt and screw over the perennial plants, or they'll get weak when there's any frost or snow, and then pests or disease take them out.



Many Kangaroo apples, are actually hardy to USDA Zone 7a. Others are more of Zone 8a.

I've been wanting to grow Tasmannia lanceolata, a species hardy to USDA Zone 7.


Billardiera scandens, the Australian Appleberry is hardy to USDA Zone 8a.


Finger Limes, are hardy to USDA Zone 8a.

Australia has throughout time, had some odd and random frosts. So, many species have retained some hardiness.

Kangaroo apples are somewhat related to Solanum sisymbriifolium. Clade wise.

There's also a species called Solanum plastisexum, that's also a close relative of those two.

Kangaroo apples, like Tomatoes - can cross more or less freely. There are desert types, rainforest understory types, some are from higher elevations.


Some have complex flavors.


The flowers are very showy, they have large leaves, thick stems and grow upright as a shrub. Plus they're pretty much all perennials.

They can have ploidy changes due to hybridizations.



I've had ideas of crossing a bunch of Kangaroo apples and planting some Solanum sisymbriifolium types all around them. And eliminating the thorns and things. They both contain steroidal compounds in their fruit. Litchi Tomato, you can eat a ton of. Kangaroo apples usually need cooked or dried and prepared. They aren't something to be eaten fresh.

Litchi Tomato has large seeds, and they remind me of blackberry or raspberry seeds. They're woody.



Lycium ruthenicum, has blue berries. There's also Sonoran and Andean Lycium species. There's Lycium barbarum and Chinese.

Plus, species found all over the place. Some North American species were used as food. Some types have larger fruits than usual.


I've been wanting to cross a bunch of Lycium species, side by side and attempt some crosses. Asian and North American species have been separate for quite some time.

Pollinators may prefer some native species flowers. And, you get some different leaf types if you make hybrids.

Not to mention, resistances to diseases from Asia and North America or wherever else. Diseases and pests adapt on different continents.


I've been wanting to grow out a lot of Lycium species. Zone 6a, wasn't very suitable for that purpose.


Hybrids, can really screw with barriers and things. And it's possible that Asian and American species lack barriers.


Obviously, one species which has a type with larger anthocyanin filled berries, is what I'd want to select for fruit wise.


Any berries which are actually palatable when ripe, and not just used when dry, would also be nice.


Goji berries were being marketed as a superfood for some time. Lycium ruthenicum, fits that bill to some extent. Just because it also has anthocyanin on top of rarer nutrients and things.


As with tomatoes, the anthocyanin is probably being shown over top of another pigment.


I don't believe that sun exposure is needed for the coloration, unlike the Lycopersicon clade and Pepinos. I'm unsure if the fruit interiors are blue or not.


It also has one pretty big flaw. If you look at its leaves, that's nearly a full on desert plant.

If I'm doing an interspecific grex, then I'd probably send plants which have those leaves, off to someone who likes those.

Some Lycium species can fruit the same year that you plant them.

Others, it can take 3 - 4 years before you see any production. Unlike other species, this doesn't always correlate to plants that flower earlier in their life, also having shorter life spans.


If I'm doing any sort of breeding with Lycium - I'd prefer to have plants which give out some fruit their first or second year.


Growing these near Lycopersicon interspecific hybrids, is something I've been interested in doing.


Just to see if barriers being all messed up, have any possibility of giving me interspecific hybrids.


If not, I'd still want a wide cross, if I'm actually planning on a lab cross.

Different disease resistances, leaf types, flower types (some flowers may be more compatible when crossed over to tomatoes), various disease resistant traits from all over.


Also, nutritious berries.


These may be a cross, where you can't backcross to certain parents or whatever.


Hybrids that take, are usually surprisingly healthy and fertile for an interspecific cross.


Just figured that I'd mention this stuff here.










Tim DH

Grafts transferring RNA to the offspring of the scion is an interesting concept. Not one I've heard of before. I can't help thinking that if it had a significant impact on a major commercial crop (tomatoes!) then it would be much discussed in the scientific literature.

The RNA here is MicroRNA, a class of it that is new to me. A quick bit of reading suggests MiRNA is non-coding RNA therefore, I'm guessing, its presence in the scion offspring doesn't suggest that the offspring can reproduce it. So it wouldn't be inherited in the normal sense of the term. I don't know what the lifespan of an MiRNA molecule is, but I doubt if its very long, certainly not compared to generations. It will likely just get used up and recycled.

 

Thulahn

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-10-04, 02:57:52 PMGrafts transferring RNA to the offspring of the scion is an interesting concept. Not one I've heard of before. I can't help thinking that if it had a significant impact on a major commercial crop (tomatoes!) then it would be much discussed in the scientific literature.

The RNA here is MicroRNA, a class of it that is new to me. A quick bit of reading suggests MiRNA is non-coding RNA therefore, I'm guessing, its presence in the scion offspring doesn't suggest that the offspring can reproduce it. So it wouldn't be inherited in the normal sense of the term. I don't know what the lifespan of an MiRNA molecule is, but I doubt if its very long, certainly not compared to generations. It will likely just get used up and recycled.

 

Well, the only way to prove this is to try. It wouldn't take long to see a difference, just two growing seasons.

Tim DH

Hi Thulahn,

I've been grafting since 2020. For the last three years the rootstock has apparently been predominantly S. habrochaites. (The first rootstock I used looked like it was predominantly S. lycopersicum.)

One of my favourite cultivars, which came to me as 'Goat's Tit', has been grown on top of all four rootstocks, sequentially. So this years seed has four generations worth of 'benefit' from being grafted.

I have two seeds left from 2019, two from 2018 and ten from 2020(before S.hab got involved)

My guess is that a minimum trial to produce any meaningful results would be three 2023 plants and three pre-graft plants. I don't have space for that next year.

Let me know if you are interested in progressing this. At the very least you should get some excellent tomatoes! Goats Tit is indeterminate, mid/late and NOT Blight resistant!

Thulahn

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-10-05, 02:46:58 AMHi Thulahn,

I've been grafting since 2020. For the last three years the rootstock has apparently been predominantly S. habrochaites. (The first rootstock I used looked like it was predominantly S. lycopersicum.)

One of my favourite cultivars, which came to me as 'Goat's Tit', has been grown on top of all four rootstocks, sequentially. So this years seed has four generations worth of 'benefit' from being grafted.

I have two seeds left from 2019, two from 2018 and ten from 2020(before S.hab got involved)

My guess is that a minimum trial to produce any meaningful results would be three 2023 plants and three pre-graft plants. I don't have space for that next year.

Let me know if you are interested in progressing this. At the very least you should get some excellent tomatoes! Goats Tit is indeterminate, mid/late and NOT Blight resistant!
Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-10-05, 02:46:58 AMHi Thulahn,

I've been grafting since 2020. For the last three years the rootstock has apparently been predominantly S. habrochaites. (The first rootstock I used looked like it was predominantly S. lycopersicum.)

One of my favourite cultivars, which came to me as 'Goat's Tit', has been grown on top of all four rootstocks, sequentially. So this years seed has four generations worth of 'benefit' from being grafted.

I have two seeds left from 2019, two from 2018 and ten from 2020(before S.hab got involved)

My guess is that a minimum trial to produce any meaningful results would be three 2023 plants and three pre-graft plants. I don't have space for that next year.

Let me know if you are interested in progressing this. At the very least you should get some excellent tomatoes! Goats Tit is indeterminate, mid/late and NOT Blight resistant!

I was hoping to inspire someone here to try this, there's plenty of dedicated people in this place and a melting pot of ideas. I don't know if I'll be able to try it next year, but at least I've got the idea out now.

Sledgehammer Potato

I have a little experience tinkering around with this idea, so through I would join and chime in.

This phenomenon, where genetic material from the rootstock crosses the graft union and becomes heritable after entering the germ line, can occur under some circumstances.  It has been experimentally proven/demonstrated in various different studies eg Zhou, XM (2013) "Confirmation of a purple-leaved plum graft hybrid", Taller J, Yagishita N and Hirata Y (1999) "Graft-induced variants as a source of novel characteristics in the breeding of pepper" (Capsicum annuum L.) Euphytica 108: 73-78.

I completed an experiment grafting potato leaf tomato scions onto homozygous regular leaf tomato rootstock, and planting out the F1 seeds. Flowers were bagged prior to opening to prevent self-pollination, and the parent was a pure inbred line homozygous for potato leaf, meaning without heritable DNA crossing the graft union every seedling produced should be potato leaf.

I planted hundreds of seeds and found roughly 2% of the seedlings displaying regular leaf. This indicates that genetic material had crossed the graft union and was heritable, but it appears to only be successful in a small percentage of cases. 

Importantly, I also noticed that the distance from the graft union appeared to influence the rate of genetic transfer.  I repeated the experiment and planted seeds collected from fruit that was various distances from the graft union to see if there are any significant differences.  Fruit produced further from the graft union produced 0% regular leaf, while fruit produced close to the graft union produced up to 4% regular leaf.

These aren't great numbers, and was using simple recessive/dominant visible trait, so you may need to plant many hundreds of seeds to notice any cold tolerance in tomatoes.

Thulahn

Quote from: Sledgehammer Potato on 2023-10-07, 11:54:53 PMI have a little experience tinkering around with this idea, so through I would join and chime in.

This phenomenon, where genetic material from the rootstock crosses the graft union and becomes heritable after entering the germ line, can occur under some circumstances.  It has been experimentally proven/demonstrated in various different studies eg Zhou, XM (2013) "Confirmation of a purple-leaved plum graft hybrid", Taller J, Yagishita N and Hirata Y (1999) "Graft-induced variants as a source of novel characteristics in the breeding of pepper" (Capsicum annuum L.) Euphytica 108: 73-78.

I completed an experiment grafting potato leaf tomato scions onto homozygous regular leaf tomato rootstock, and planting out the F1 seeds. Flowers were bagged prior to opening to prevent self-pollination, and the parent was a pure inbred line homozygous for potato leaf, meaning without heritable DNA crossing the graft union every seedling produced should be potato leaf.

I planted hundreds of seeds and found roughly 2% of the seedlings displaying regular leaf. This indicates that genetic material had crossed the graft union and was heritable, but it appears to only be successful in a small percentage of cases. 

Importantly, I also noticed that the distance from the graft union appeared to influence the rate of genetic transfer.  I repeated the experiment and planted seeds collected from fruit that was various distances from the graft union to see if there are any significant differences.  Fruit produced further from the graft union produced 0% regular leaf, while fruit produced close to the graft union produced up to 4% regular leaf.

These aren't great numbers, and was using simple recessive/dominant visible trait, so you may need to plant many hundreds of seeds to notice any cold tolerance in tomatoes.


This is interesting. My guess would be that visible traits are just the surface level indication of gene transfer, and that there will be a higher percentage of non visible traits transferred. Did you notice any other differences to growing habits of the seeds collected from the from the fruit of the graft union?

Justin Jardinier

#8
Quote from: Sledgehammer Potato on 2023-10-07, 11:54:53 PMI completed an experiment grafting potato leaf tomato scions onto homozygous regular leaf tomato rootstock, and planting out the F1 seeds. Flowers were bagged prior to opening to prevent self-pollination, and the parent was a pure inbred line homozygous for potato leaf, meaning without heritable DNA crossing the graft union every seedling produced should be potato leaf.

Sounds very interesting! I am not dismissing your findings but just speculating on possible variables, even if somewhat unlikely. Did you bag the flowers also of the pollen parent? If not, the pollinators might have transferred alien pollen onto those flowers from which you collected the pollen.

Quote from: Thulahn on 2023-10-08, 01:32:08 AMI planted hundreds of seeds and found roughly 2% of the seedlings displaying regular leaf

Did you run a control, such as planting (or grafting to potato leaf rootstock), pollinating them in the same way you did the test group, and planting out the same number of F1s?

Quote from: Thulahn on 2023-10-08, 01:32:08 AMImportantly, I also noticed that the distance from the graft union appeared to influence the rate of genetic transfer.  I repeated the experiment and planted seeds collected from fruit that was various distances from the graft union to see if there are any significant differences.  Fruit produced further from the graft union produced 0% regular leaf, while fruit produced close to the graft union produced up to 4% regular leaf.

This sounds like the most promising part of it. But again just to investigate the possibilities for a moment... did you allow the rootstock to flower at all?

Also, if one wanted to maximise the genetic transfer, I would think a mentor graft would be the way to go. Graft the scion when it has only 2 (or maybe 4) true leaves, onto a well established plant (not just rootstock), and only allow the end 2 leaves on the graft, removing all the others as it grows. It seems this maximises the mentor's influence. Plus if wanting to make a wide hybrid with this method for a graft that would not usually work, then trying a small piece of Nicotiana benthamiana as a bridge in between - many intergeneric grafts are possible with this, though I am not sure if having to travel through 2 species would maybe decrease the amount of genetic sharing through the double-graft. But should be worth trying.

Roland

Hmm, this is totaly new for me. If there is 2% gene transfer with one gene, because of grafting.
Its impossible to make F1 seeds when parent lines are grafted on rootstock.

I would go for contaminated pollen to explain where the 2% gene transfer comes from.

I wonder if you get the same results when you use a green potato leave dwarf as rootstock, graft an ovate red regular leaved variety on it.
Pollinate the ovate red regular leaved plant with pollen from the green potato leaved variety.

By using recessive genes in the root stock, contaminated pollen as explanation can be excluded.
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

#10
Quote from: Roland on 2023-10-08, 04:49:13 AMHmm, this is totaly new for me. If there is 2% gene transfer with one gene, because of grafting.
Its impossible to make F1 seeds when parent lines are grafted on rootstock.
Wouldn't it just mean that it is possible, but the F1 should be variable? Though if F1s are commercially made using grafted plants, and there is not variability, then this may support the pollen contamination hypothesis.

Quote from: Roland on 2023-10-08, 04:49:13 AMI would go for contaminated pollen to explain where the 2% gene transfer comes from.

I was thinking so also, although the increased rate near the rootstock does support the genetic transfer hypothesis. Hence my interest as to whether the rootstock was flowering - if it was, then being closer to those flowers would increase the potential for pollen contamination.

Another variable could be ... I wonder... that nearer the rootstock the flowers might be less susceptible to pollen contamination, perhaps being more sheltered from windborne pollen and/or pollinators. Both could be a factor if the bags are not 100% pollen proof (for example if they are made of material/mesh not fine enough to block out all stray pollen), or from windborne pollen (or pollen that fell onto the leaves and is disturbed by movement) whilst the bag is open during hand pollination.

Using a control as I mentioned in my comment above, might be a good way to identify or rule out such variables.

Edit: How strange, it added one of my photos to this comment even though I made no action to do so, and when editing, it shows no indication that there should be any attachment, so I cannot remove it! I even checked my profile setting to see if it mistakenly added it to my tagline somehow, but no sign of it on that page either. Sorry about that!

William Schlegel

#11
https://phys.org/news/2021-04-animals-genes-species-evolution.html

Just ran into a couple popular press articles about grasses transferring genes.

One of the articles mentions an interesting study with tobacco grafting I've seen before.

If distance from the graft union is a factor. Why not try to create a chaemara? Or a plant with lots of graft unions?

There is another way to go. In the book Plants From Test Tubes the author suggests that it would be within the ability of amateurs to continue some cell fusion experiments abandoned by mainstream researchers. Less technical it might be possible to create, crush, and mix callus tissue into a multiple species cell mix. Then regenerate shoots from that. Some of those shoots might be chaemaras of both species. Chaemaral tissue has potentially a lot more interface between the cells of the two species. Also in culture, damaged cells would be leaking into a media with similar conditions to cell interiors. Some subsequently repaired cells might uptake some of that material- from the other species.

Shoots that regenerate from graft unions might also be of particular interest.

There have only been modest frosts in my garden so far this fall. Cumulative damage seems to have selected for R18, habrochaites, and Habrochaites crosses. Suggests vigor leading to larger plant size and hairiness could be very modestly protective.

There is another way to go. Tim Peters wrote about a habrochaites strain with rhizomes he was trying to cross with on the old Homegrown Goodness forum. Rhizomes act as an organ that can make a plant perennial.

Hmm potato and tomato hybrids have proven elusive but they graft readily.

Disclaimer: I am not up for trying any of this personally at this time. Not enough time for my existing tomato breeding projects.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2023/10/231005204059.htm

I had the same sort of article pop up on my Google page the other day.

Pretty interesting.

I skimmed through it. They're thought to have transfers when they grow side by side.

Its at a low rate and seems somewhat random, but over time things just self select if they're beneficial.


I believe I've read something else in some research papers as well.



With species - grafts and things.


There's a reason that some closely related species tend to graft well, and others fail.

Some plants just become mush after getting cut.

And there's similar reasonings.



Then there's genetic reasonings. They graft well together, because some of their genome and overall structures are compatible.

Some more distant relatives, or a non woody relative with a woody relative, don't always take too well.



This ties into my point as well.


The genetic changes, are usually splices. Many genes in relatives haven't changed a whole lot.


Just like how viruses can sometimes fuse and make a mixed strain - something very bad, grafts can have something similar happen.



Identical genetic strands, can sometimes rearrange themselves into each other.


Only if they're very similar.



This may not actually change anything in a plant species. And the rate of this occurring seems fairly low.


Plant grafts can be prone to mutations for similar reasons. A mutation in seeds or anything, could give out mutants which lack the things that produce potato leaf seedlings.


Over time some matching genes can end up on different chromosomes.


So there's also that.



I still feel that a hybrid would be ideal.


There are Goji berries which will produce berries in their first year from seed.


This seems like a very fun idea / project.


I made a thread on Permies about possible growing out some Medlar and other things, alongside Crataegus mexicana and some Mayhaws. Plus related species.

I've read of the Pyrus, Sorbus and other crosses.



The rate of any gene transfer in grafts is so low, that hybrids may be more well off.


Diseases themselves actually focus on certain genes and target them.

They can adapt to infect similar things if something happens to their host.


This also means that a disease could infect wild relatives that previously only harmed say, Lycium.



With the Mayhaw - Crataegus mexicana - (Maybe some Asian species used for jams), and desired Medlar hybrids.


Medlar has been shown to be able to cross with Crataegus species readily, to some extent. And some Crataegus species hybridize pretty often as well in certain ranges.


Sorbus, Pyrus and things can also outcross to one another to some extent. As can Raspberries, Blackberries and other relatives.

Fragaria species can do the same. Roses are similar.

Prunus species, can also cross into distant relatives.


These are in the Rosaceae.


Species in this family, don't seem to form complex barriers. I don't have a why.

Some cultivated fruits are thought to have formed from interspecific hybrids from other species, and then humans cultivated them.


Redwoods and some species like Zelkova, certain Oak groups are similar.

Many Citrus species also don't care.


These also still have groups and sections.


Species from different continents, in different groups. I'm surprised they haven't been formed into different genera altogether.

These can be more related to each other, than other relatives on their continent - because their lines branched off into other continents and did their own thing.



Palm trees, won't accept grafts. I'd assume that interspecific hybrids are possible. Many Sabal species can hybridize. I don't know if other close relatives can make interfamilial hybrids with them.

Chinese Windmill Palms, are in the same family. These don't all flower at the same time.


There's also Wisteria and Wisteriopsis reticulata. Both are growing out in the yard in different locations.


One seems to have a form of disease that's spreading to other Wisteria.

The Wisteriopsis doesn't seem affected.


I'm interested in trying for American x Asian Wisteria crosses.


I'm also interested in trying for Wisteriopsis x Wisteria crosses.


I've also wondered why I haven't heard of any attempts.

In the wild or otherwise.


Wisteriopsis is evergreen for the most part. It's leaves won't die back.

That's bad news in a temperate climate.

The species also has black / purple flower spikes. That's a natural coloration for it.


The leaves are pretty glossy.


Now, the biggest obstacle that I've found?


Wisteriopsis reticulata started flowering a month or two ago.


Wisteria seem to bloom in the spring from what I've read.

There's some variations.


Wisteria "may bloom into the summer", Wisteriopsis simply blooms in the summer.


It seems like a late summer bloomer, Wisteria probably just stretches into the beginning of summer.


I'd assume that a graft may help push their flowering times, closer together.


Normally, vines aren't fun to graft.

But, Wisteria usually forms a tall woody base. And Wisteriopsis gets firm shoots and things like Wisteria.

And it's leaves are fairly stiff. Like Pawpaw or Magnolias.

That's wonderful in graft terms.


With these, I'd graft them at a lower point, maybe overtop of new growth on the Wisteria.


Grafting may change up the flowering time. Maybe any overlapping flowers in terms of pollination, would pollinate one another.

These are in the Fabaceae.



Some Brassica family members, can outcross to some extent.



And here you have Solanaceae.


These species have been known to outcross to some extent. Kangaroo apples with each other, Lycopersicon clade with close relatives.

Kangaroo apples don't even care about different chromosome counts when forming hybrids.



Either way, these are all examples of things in different families. Some mechanisms and things are vastly different and may not apply to distant relatives or things in the same order.



On the topic of mammals.


There are distant hybrids with one another.

Snakes are one large group which cross more often than others.



There have been recent interesting hybrids.

A female Pampas Fox, Lycalopex gymnocercus and a male Canis lupus familiaris, produced children with one another.

One of them, was found after being hit by a vehicle.

It was taken in, for rehabilitation.


Unfortunately, it later died.

I'm unsure if it was euthanized. Or if it died from injuries or genetic issues.


The Pampas Fox, is in the Canidae. But, it's not a true fox. It's from South America. It's in the Lycalopex genus, rather than the true foxes in Vulpes.

Lycalopex contains a bunch of species, some actually mainly eat crabs. Unlike Canis, there are a ton of relatives in the same genus still running around.

Female Vulpes lagopus, Arctic foxes - can mate with Male Vulpes vulpes, the Red Fox. The offspring seems to be generally sterile. There are reports of the offspring being somewhat fertile.


Ligers and Tigons are pretty well known, as are some Cat hybrids with other species.

Ligers and Tigons can be fertile. They usually are.


And of course, the Narluga. A Beluga (Delphinapterus leucas) x Narwhal (Monodon monoceros). That exists.


A male African Elephant (Loxodonta africana), bred with a female Asian Elephant (Elephas maximus). The offspring didn't last too long. Ten days. An umbilical cord infection / E. coli infection. That may not have been related to him being a hybrid with the infection.

He was born six weeks early.


Many fish and insect hybrids also exist. I believe that some aphid or something, formed a hybrid group and ended up targeting strawberries as their main host. Neither parent targeted strawberries as their main host before that.



I'd prefer not to get into Macaques. There are Japanese Snow Monkeys. They could probably survive in Pennsylvania.

There's a sanctuary in Texas for them.

Along with reports of wild ones. Well, feral ones.

They escaped at some point, most were killed by hunters or coyotes and the climate.

So that's great. Some hunters "reportedly" have these on trail cams and other things or there's reports of seeing them run around to get water or that they're fed by locals.


In the sanctuary, they've learned how to safely harvest Opuntia fruits and whatnot.


If anything ever happened, a disaster or something. These would likely all break free.

Imagine if these spread to less arid states or managed to get to a place that has other macaque species.


There aren't any in the states, save for ones in Florida that won't leave the state because they can't handle the conditions.



Either way. Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and Bonobos (Pan paniscus), have formed hybrids.

At some point they were seen as the same species and kept in the same enclosures. Usually a river separates them, and their muscles prevent them from swimming. They sink and flail.


Bonobos are friendlier and form large social groups. Chimpanzees tend to form wars and kill all other groups.

Hybrids could produce a mix of them, which can settle areas and still hunt or do whatever.

There's actual Chimpanzee wars if you look around online.


I've also read that there's an islander population with a different blood grouping or system than what other humans have. They haven't spread too much out of their islands and are one of the last tribal groups to stay somewhat isolated.

Those studies caused some more studies at around the same time, but they vanished.

Something mentioned that they could possibly work as a weird intermediate with related species.


Every study about that entire topic is gone. I can't find them, the links are gone, I can't find any mention of then anywhere.


Thar falls into the topic of "I hope nobody tries anything horrifying!"

I can't remember how different the systems are, but I read that some islanders became more or less prostitutes, and ended up having trouble when giving birth or there seemed to be odd medical conditions.


That's how the research popped up.

You'd think that different systems and things would be a widespread or known thing.


Either way, that falls into the area of me not wanting to think about or discuss that too much.



On the topics of grafts.

There are animal grafts. My grandma had cancer and was offered a cancer treatment, and a removed area on her face would have a pig skin graft which would eventually match her skin, applied over the area.


I think they said it would be a light piece of pig skin.


In mice and rats, organs are being artificially grown.


Pig organs may eventually be modified a bit, to work in humans or they already work to some extent.



I'm simply mentioning these things because I saw a mention that these things don't seem to work in mammals to any real extent or they produce sterile offspring.


These processes are actually probably how a lot of new species arise - and it's more common in plants because humans lose their minds over hybrids and kill them.


There are Polar bear / Grizzly Hybrids. Grolar bears. There may be some Sus hybrids as well. There's some Equus hybrids out there.


Most of these hybrids are semi fertile and the fertility can be restored in backcrosses.


I wouldn't recommend it, because I view interspecific hybrids - intentional ones, to be cruel.


Some of the other stuff is just so that others have a better understanding with genetics and things.


I've researched hybrids and grafts somewhat extensively in mammals, plants and things. Mammals and plants are very similar.











Garrett Schantz

I'd personally recommend a rather difficult or rare graft.


I don't know if its been tried with Solanum.


When most people hear "grafts", they think of cutting plants at lower growths, and whatnot.

Then they cut off a piece of another plant, and make a cut and insert it there.


That's the most common graft.


It prevents the original plant from putting out its own shoots and fruit.


It's possible to make other types of grafts, upper ones. This creates plants with multiple fruits, flowers and things.


That's what I'd do with Wisteria and Wisteriopsis.


In this same grouping, you can take two halves from different plants stems, push them together and then grow them on another relative or one of the two stem parents own stems and make a cutting mark, even a lower one.

And then see if they fuse and make a stem that puts out different sorts of leaves, and both regenerated / cloned halves keep on growing over each other.


As these grow larger, one usually outpaces the other due to having more vigor or compatibility.


Or they may completely seperate and make their own branches and things from the initial one.

Or they may continue to make branches and grow over top of each other.


It's not a common graft, because it has a lower chance of taking.

And, it has no real commercial usages.



It's hard to even find anything on those sorts of grafts.


I've been thinking of grafting Mentha and Ocimum species, just for the heck of it.


One reason being genetic drift.

Mint, grows as clonal specimens.

Basil, does heal over wounds. I'd also prefer to do this with a mature basil plant and simply keep the mint cutting alive long enough for the Basil to heal its wound over top of the mint.


I wanted to do that, just for fun.

Basil develops thick - mostly hollow stems. These could make for fun graft materials, make a slit and then insert some mint.



I'm unsure if you've considered these types of grafts or not.

Tim DH

Hi Sledgehammer,
Welcome to the forum, and thank you for your fascinating post.

May be I'm missing something, but in this paragraph:

I completed an experiment grafting potato leaf tomato scions onto homozygous regular leaf tomato rootstock, and planting out the F1 seeds. Flowers were bagged prior to opening to prevent self-pollination, and the parent was a pure inbred line homozygous for potato leaf, meaning without heritable DNA crossing the graft union every seedling produced should be potato leaf.

I don't understand why you wanted to prevent self pollination? To my mind, with self pollination you would have doubled the chance of showing that heritable DNA had crossed the graft, because it could have come from the male or female side. ( A bonus would be that pollen contamination would be eliminated.)

Congratulations on taking the idea further by checking whether the distance of the fruit from the graft made a difference. That really does sound pretty convincing.

My additional question would be if anyone knows at what rate the potato leaf mutation reverts to type? Tho' I can't think why that potential explanation would vary by fruit distance from the graft.

        I think Roland is right. 2% transfer of one gene implies a random 2% transfer of all genes which would mess up the creation of uniform F1s. ALSO it would mess up the preservation of Open Pollinated lines. .... Like my Goats Tit!

Tim DH