Delicious pimpinellifolium x pennellii

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-09-30, 05:41:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Joseph Lofthouse

In the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty tomatoes project, the best flavors, and the worst, descend from S pennellii.

Justin Jardinier

Thanks Joseph - yesterday I used various pen pollen to try crossing to that arc cross that has failed with everything else so far. Let's hope something comes of it! I may also have some successful per x pen crosses, which is what I was focusing more on with the pen, so it will be interesting to see what comes of them too.


Raymondo

When crossing lyc with pennellii does the cross work both ways?
Ray
Mildly acidic clay loam over clay to varying depths; temperate climate modified by altitude (1000m); avg rainfall 780mm; usually wet summers and dry winters.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Raymondo on 2023-10-13, 02:36:04 AMWhen crossing lyc with pennellii does the cross work both ways?

If I remember correctly it is supposed to most normally work as a pollen source.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-10-01, 08:39:08 AMIn the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty tomatoes project, the best flavors, and the worst, descend from S pennellii.

I can't remember which article it was that I had read, but I know it was available on Google scholar. But the article or articles describe how S. pennellii is the tomato species that has the most unique and widest range of volatile compounds. That basically means that it would have the most unique and widest range of scent and flavors, so it makes sense that this is the reason breeding with it would produce both the best and worst tasting tomatoes. If one could identify the next widest species, perhaps crossing the two could produce other unique combinations not found in the other species. I suspect this isn't pimpinellifolium, but I don't know for sure.

Justin Jardinier

#20
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-10-13, 06:10:09 AMIf one could identify the next widest species, perhaps crossing the two could produce other unique combinations not found in the other species.
Might also be worth identifying specific accessions of pennellii for their flavours. Have you (or anyone else) worked with crossing accessions other than LA0716? Or has anyone been crossing with any SI pen?

I would also think that as for crossing pen with another wild species, per should be a most interesting candidate. Not sure how the flavour compares to other wild green species but the disease resistance should be of great value. And to me it sounds like the easiest way of bringing per into a domestic population. I've been working on that a bit, I have some fruits which are hopefully crosses, some already harvested but yet to grow any out. I was originally very interested specifically in that not only for the above reason but also for bringing the SI per system into an edible population, but today I had these thoughts:

1) If I use SC pen for that, would maybe only the pollen with pen's SC allele cross to lyc? If so, then the SI plan wouldn't work. Although maybe that is a silly thought, maybe the incompatibility of per to lyc has nothing to do with that allele so... hmm yes thinking about it, that is probably not an issue.

2) If using SI pen for that, maybe the SI pen and per would interfere too much and cause issues - Joseph did mention before about infertility issues and regretting using 2 SI species for his project and said, unless I am mis-remembering, that were he to do it again, he would use only 1 SI species. But also I wonder if this is evidence based or if the infertility issues might have had a non-2-SI-species cause... (maybe related to UI mechanisms?) Also, isn't the pen content in Joseph's project anyway from LA0716? I unfortunately did not note down which accession it was, quite foolishly, did I misremember that? Because, LA0716 is SC. I welcome any corrections to any of my misunderstandings on the above.

Having thought that aloud now, I wonder that... maybe using SC pen is fine for that. Though I have actually been trying to pollinate several per and chil accessions with LA0716 and separately with a mix of 4 or 5 SI pen accessions, to maximise the chances of gaining successful crosses since maybe some per/chil accessions can be pollinated only by certain pen accessions.

Andrew also have you been crossing with pen at all? If so I would really love to hear about any observations of UI in the F1 and F2. Specifically in terms of the inability to accept lyc pollen. This is a trait I want to chase. I would be equally interested in hearing the same regarding lyc x hab crosses or, any crosses of lyc with a species that can't receive lyc pollen. I made a post asking about that but so far no-one has shared any experience - it's here:
https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,873.0.html

Joseph Lofthouse

#21
Pennellii is most closely related to habrochaites. Both are fairly distant relatives of other tomatoes.

Quote from: Raymondo on 2023-10-13, 02:36:04 AMWhen crossing lyc with pennellii does the cross work both ways?

Ordinarily, pennellii can pollinate domestic tomatoes, but domestic tomatoes can't pollinate pennellii.


AndrewB

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-10-13, 12:25:13 PMMight also be worth identifying specific accessions of pennellii for their flavours. Have you (or anyone else) worked with crossing accessions other than LA0716? Or has anyone been crossing with any SI pen?

Andrew also have you been crossing with pen at all? If so I would really love to hear about any observations of UI in the F1 and F2. Specifically in terms of the inability to accept lyc pollen. This is a trait I want to chase. I would be equally interested in hearing the same regarding lyc x hab crosses or, any crosses of lyc with a species that can't receive lyc pollen. I made a post asking about that but so far no-one has shared any experience - it's here:
https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,873.0.html

The short is no, not really. At one point I had a pure pennellii line from Joseph, and again from William, and one or two I got from TGRC directly, but I had trouble keeping them alive to maturity. Joseph seems to have discovered a soil mix for it, but i have yet to replicate it. I 'm out of seed at this point. The hybrids are monsters though. I was able to originally request the main F1 hybrid line that was mentioned before from TGRC and share it, that later helped Joseph make so much progress on his end.

I did have some success with the F2 hybrids though that seemed to be self-incompatible. By using the Patricia Beddinger technique of pollinating a -3 day old flower on the F2 hybrid I was able to successfully pollinate it with Solanum galpagense pollen. Unfortunately, I was clumsy that winter and broke off the branch that had the unripe fruit that was still tiny. I really think the Bedinger technique is worth experimenting more with though!

We were using walnut oil to wet the immature styles so the pollen would stick. Some others had a recipe that also used boric acid to get the pollen to do magical things as well, but I didn't get that far. I do still have my bottle of boric acid though.

I do think having a wider variety of accessions within each species has great merit. One year I grew multiple accessions of Zea mexicana and other species. I got one Zea mexicana species that grew a single stalk and looked nearly identical to modern corn. Today I also have some ferral Zea mexicana growing on my patch of dirt off our back porch, but it is tiny and the plants are tiny! Both are supposed to be the same species!!! But they are vastly different. The same or similar could be true of the wild tomato species. It is helpful to look at a map of mexico and south america when looking at the different accessions and to specifically request accessions that are far apart from each other and seem to be in climate areas you are interested in. I know there are maps online as I've used them before for that specific purpose. Same for teosinte.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-10-13, 05:37:23 PMJoseph seems to have discovered a soil mix for it, but i have yet to replicate it.
I didn't find soil mix an issue personally. I used decayed leaves from the woodland floor, mixed with pretty ordinary compost. And in another pot, a mix of coconut coir with compost and perlite. I am also growing some accessions in Kratky hydroponics, and for that, one thing I find very critical is to not refill the nutrients too high, they are way more sensitive than most wild tomato species in that regard, easy to kill if refilling too much. I found habrochaites and corneliomulleri also sensitive to that more than the others (I gave up with corn pretty early, hab still seems maybe less sensitive to nutrient level than pen but maybe similar) but with those 2 I think they probably want UV light added to the spectrum, which I am not using, and hab might be short day? So, no success with those 2 indoors - also cheesmaniae seems to require short day, as well as most of the galapagense I have experience with, so that's also an issue with indoor growing but now I have them on short day they're going well. Pennellii is fine in long day though.

With pen I think maybe the more critical thing is just to not over-water. So if in pots, bottom watering seems ideal, and making sure not to water too often. It can handle some wilting so just waiting until it wilts can maybe be good to get used to how far one can push it, then establishing some kind of routine.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-10-13, 05:37:23 PMI did have some success with the F2 hybrids though that seemed to be self-incompatible.

Did you make sibling crosses? Or, if they were all from a single F1 then I guess you may have only had one allele, so not able to make sibling crosses? If you did have F2s with multiple alleles and were able to do sibling crosses, I'd be interested to hear how the F3 went.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-10-13, 05:37:23 PMBy using the Patricia Beddinger technique of pollinating a -3 day old flower on the F2 hybrid I was able to successfully pollinate it with Solanum galpagense pollen.

That's interesting. Did you also try pollinating with SC pollen to already open flowers? I know you said they were SI which in most cases means not just self incompatible but also unable to be pollinated by SC pollen, but as you may have read, I have been noticing some SI plants (such as BH-NT, a derivative of Joseph's tomatoes, as well as some of Joseph's SI tomatoes) readily accepting SC pollen to open flowers. SO I'd be interested to hear if you tried.

I did try that technique (including the walnut oil) for pollinating chmielewskii from Lee Goodwin (LA1028) with peruvianum, and I got seed from that. But, by the look of the flowers and fruit, I am actually wondering if that is per, not chm. I also ran a self test which failed, which is another indication of that, as was my failure to cross it to lyc and pimp, and its lack of lemony smell. However, I ran that self test with only one cluster of flowers which is not really a vigourous enough test. I should also have tried more tests crossing it with per both ways, and to flowers at a more normal stage (might have worked even without the special method, I didn't bother even trying since I had assumed it would not work), to confirm further, but had other things to do. Also, perhaps there is a non-zero chance that I received the wrong seeds? Anyone else ever grown LA1028?

I also used that early flower technique for some other cross attempts but with no luck - I forget which crosses now. But I have a lot to work with already so that technique is no longer a priority right now for me. Nice technique though. Also instead of walnut oil, one could potentially use the sticky substance on some spare stigmas. I wonder, maybe even could use it from other genera with bigger stigmas, to aid collection of the substance. Might end up being better than walnut oil?

Also, did you try crossing that F2 to galapagense as mother? Would probably be easier that way. Unless you wanted to keep the lyc mother line? Oh also on that note, do you have any info or thoughts on pros and cons of different mother lines in terms of tomato species? I have 4... hmm actually 5 mother species in edible interspecial crosses, and could probably add some more if I thought it was worth it. But I don't know of any studies or experience with relative pros and cons of that for any species compared. If it may be significant, I could put some more energy into that perhaps.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-10-13, 05:37:23 PMI do think having a wider variety of accessions within each species has great merit.
Yes definitely. I can see for example some per x pen fail whereas some succeed, depending on the per accession. Well, I only grew 1 or 2 of each accession so it could potentially be individual specific but I assume its accession specific.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-10-13, 05:37:23 PMToday I also have some ferral Zea mexicana growing on my patch of dirt off our back porch, but it is tiny and the plants are tiny! Both are supposed to be the same species!!! But they are vastly different. The same or similar could be true of the wild tomato species.

Yeah sure. Per especially has a lot of variation, and I mean by modern classification, the single species, not the per 'complex' of multiple species. By the way, have you seen Wojciech M. SzymaƄski's galapagense? He grows 2 types, one of which seems like all the others I have seen, which he calls 'dense leaf form'; one of which he calls 'loose leaf form' is quite different though still the usual tiny fruits (though not hairy) and tiny seeds as we see in the genuine wild accessions. I have not seen any genebank gal looking like this second type anywhere, and I am wondering if perhaps it is not pure galapagense, like maybe a che/gal hybrid? His photo of that one here:

Untitled2.jpg
Source: http://unusualediblesandtheirwildrelatives.blogspot.com/2017/11/wild-tomatoe-species-lycopersicon-spp.html

His more usual type is shown there but maybe more clearly here:
http://unusualediblesandtheirwildrelatives.blogspot.com/2019/06/wild-tomato-species-lycopersicon-spp.html

By the way Andrew, have you grown any pre-Columbian domestic tomatoes? I'd be really interested in any larger fruited (larger than cherry size) landraces that might have late blight resistance, I wonder if you know of any? The only landrace tomato I have grown is Columbianum but it's very small, and also I didn't grow it outside so didn't get to test its LB resistance.