Experience with Unilateral Incompatibility breeding?

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-10-09, 09:54:01 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I'd really love to hear anyones direct experience of breeding with UI traits, or any reliable info on that.

I have some F1 pimp x chmielewskii crosses which so far seem SC but seem to be unable to be pollinated by lyc. And some F1 pimp x pennellii (the pen supposedly SC) which seem to have those same traits also, though my testing on the latter has been less extensive. I'm growing out various other lyc x pen and lyc x chm crosses now also.

My hope is that I can:
1) Grow out the F2 and that at least some of them will still be UI and with exserted stigmas, resulting in a largely outcrossing but UI protected population, and
2) Use the F1 pollen to cross to lyc, gal and che, and get more readily edible UI populations from them too. (Already making cross attempts for that).

So I am curious of others' experience on this. Like, percentage of F2 in 1) to be expected to be UI? And, in 2), would some or all of the F1 from [SC x UI} x SC be expected to be UI; or would that only reappear in the F2? If the latter, then what percentage might be expected?

Thanks!

Garrett Schantz

I noted that some things like Chmielewskii and other species, will only accept pollen in one direction.

Even if they're SC.


Usually with Solanum pimpinellifolium or lycopersicum as the mother.


So, once you cross them, there's still issues.


I'm unsure of what direction your Chmielewskii x Pimpinellifolium was in.


If Chmielewskii was the mother, I'm not sure if all Lycopersicum types can fertilize it.


Or, sometimes incompatibilities just pop up when species cross with one another.



If you have SC F1s, how did you test for that?

And confirm that they can't be pollinated by Lycopersicum?


If these are open pollinationed, and bees are going back and forth - I'd imagine there are possible crosses from that.


Indoors, I got Chmielewskii from HRseeds to set fruit without pollination. I did blow on the flowers and things.


Are you transferring pollen onto exserted plants - or whatever and then bagging them? Or are you emasculating the flowers?


The second thing, could indicate that they're just dropping off because outdoor conditions can tend to kill off emasculated flowers.

It seems climate dependent on whether or not that happens.


If you used Lycopersicum and Pimpinellifolium as the mother, whatever incompatibilities which only allow things to go in one direction, could've been passed down to the F1. Dominant genes.


Which, would mean that these need to pollinate Lycopersicum or Pimpinellifolium.


Or, the trait can be weeded out in the F2. Or selected for.


Neorickii, Arcanum and Chmielewskii are all in the same group, in the proposed Lycopersicon clade.

In my opinion, Pennellii is their closest relative in the clade outside of themselves.


I believe that most people here that are heavy into this stuff, have touched on Arcanum breeding briefly.

Most, focus on Pennellii and Habrochaites.


Many traits that these other species in that group have, are shared by other groups



It's not that others here aren't interested in working with them. They're usually more occupied with interesting Habrochaites accessions and the like.

And moving them into other populations. It's not easy to do all of that at once.


I believe that some of these are thought to be old hybrids of other species, which eventually became their own group.

Some of those things may be somewhat related to Peruvianum.



Either way, what I'm getting at.


These may have incompatibilities or different UI properties than other groups.


Chmielewskii smells great, to me.


And bees loved it when I moved the pot outside.



Many researchers are interested in being rid of many traits from these sorts of species.


Neorickii, Arcanum and Chmielewskii can cross fairly readily themselves.

Their "UI trait", may also make them susceptible to being pollinated by a few other species as well.



These are on my radar, mostly because they would be fun to mix into a population that's dedicated to making an intermediate that can be crossed into Peruvianum in some direction.


Payette, Purple Smudge and Burnley Bounty are on that list for the same reason.


With Solanum peruvianum, it's a fun species complex which likely has at least three different mechanisms which prevent crosses with other species.


Payette and other things have been attempted to be crossed back to Peruvianum - I believe that some of them probably retain some things that would do away with or bypass a mechanism or two, inside of Peruvianum.


I've noted that Purple Smudge wasn't working well, as a father.


As in, not at all.


I'll try again, but I feel like it's retained some sort of barrier.


A barrier could be seen as the opposite of one, if integrated into a landrace or grex which is wanted as a bridge to Peruvianum.



I don't have any percentages and things for this stuff, unfortunately.