F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Roland

I thought the definition for "Hybrid vigor" in plant breeding is a trait where the F1 outperforms both parent plants.

In recent years I have made quite a few crosses to get better tasting tomatoes with resistance to late blight (Phytophthora). I find that there are not many F1 plants that have a better taste than both parents. It is therefore very difficult to find "Hybrid vigor" when you want a better taste.
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-09-05, 07:28:26 AMbetween different species of the same species.
Maybe between different species of the same genus?

Steph S

Quote from: Roland on 2023-09-05, 01:44:21 PMI thought the definition for "Hybrid vigor" in plant breeding is a trait where the F1 outperforms both parent plants.

In recent years I have made quite a few crosses to get better tasting tomatoes with resistance to late blight (Phytophthora). I find that there are not many F1 plants that have a better taste than both parents. It is therefore very difficult to find "Hybrid vigor" when you want a better taste.

This is one reason to breed OP's instead, and keep crossing those early generations until you get a line with taste you like and can select for the resistance traits.
The downside is that you have to keep selecting so many years to get them stable.

Tim DH

This is interesting! What is the difference between traits and vigour? Or perhaps what is the interaction between traits and vigour?

If I take two fairly productive OP varieties I think I have a reasonable expectation that the F1 might be more productive. (I can understand productivity as a linear thing. Although many factors may bear upon the final outcome, that outcome, from different plants, can be plotted on a line. The data from different groups of plants can be averaged and compared.)

Productivity is a nice easy trait to work with. The question is how, or how much, does that theory translate to other traits.

If I take two fairly flavoursome OP varieties, can I have a reasonable expectation that the F1 might be more flavoursome? (I can't understand flavour as a linear thing. It's far too subjective. I can't average results!)

Certainly poorly grown plants (Underfed, poorly illuminated, cold grown etc.) tend to produce less flavoursome fruit. So conversely, maybe to some extent a vigorous F1 might have more photosynthetic products available to pack into its fruit. This may translate into a human perception of more/better flavour.

My understanding of 'Sungold F1' is that it is the interaction of flavour traits from the parents which creates the exceptional flavour. Not any (more general) F1 vigour. The failure of Sungold offspring to recreate 'Sungold' flavour is to do with the segregation of those flavour traits, rather than loss of F1 vigour.

So my suggestion would be that finding exceptional flavours in F1s is possible. (Flavours which can't be stabilised in later generations.) However the chance of stumbling across a winning flavour combination is very much less certain than the chance of creating a vigorous F1.

One of my current interests, with the Early Red F1s, IS (as the name suggests) earliness! Just to be clear I'm interested in Calendar Early, not Stopwatch Early (See #13 in the Shortest Season Tomatoes thread) Will hybrid vigour give me earlier tomatoes? Will the combination of parental traits give me earlier tomatoes. So far, the answer (either way) appears to be. ... No!

Maf

I have heard it described as combining ability. As in some selections have better combining ability than others. Obviously combining ability can be for quantitative effects such as yield or qualitative ones such as flavour.

Crossing two very good tasting stable lines can result in an F1 that tastes much worse than either parent. We've all been there. Other lines can be the opposite and if you stumble upon a parental line that has proven good combining ability for flavour, in a variety of crosses, it is worth remembering.

Steph S

I've certainly had disappointing F1's from tasty parents.  I've also had lines that started tasty and remained tasty through generations with rarely a less tasty individual.  So I think the advice to never select away from taste is probably good.
However the big asterisk for taste is always environmental conditions.
Also I think there are other fruit traits that can make the difference between tasty or bland fruit in the offspring - size for example.  I'm thinking of this because of the environmental effects of putting a great tasting tomato into a cushy environment where it produced a lot... and they were nothing like the superb tasty fruit that were smaller and few in a cold and stressful and small pot season.
It's as if the total amount of flavor compounds per fruit is the same, and that is watered down when the fruit are pumped up?   I guess it's not that simple but just grasping at perceptions here.
In the F1's, take Sungold for another example.  This is a really small fruit packed with flavor.  I have heard that segregates are sometimes larger but lacking the flavor intensity.  Well well.   I would guess that a medium sized or larger parent has been crossed with quite a small one, to produce these long trusses of small but very flavorful tomatoes, where the QTL's for flavor are fully expressed in the small cherry, therefore at their most intense.  The small fruited parent ensures the intensity in a wide range of conditions, because the fruit can't get big regardless.
Black Cherry is a great flavor parent, which tends to have tasty F1s and down the line.  At least in my situation, the skew towards smaller fruit in a small sample of F2's which are selected for flavor, does also tend towards a small fruited but flavorful end game.  You can cross Black Cherry or another good cherry flavor parent to something larger or something with basic beef traits like locule number and fas, and you can get flavorful offspring that are larger than a cherry but they tend to be smaller than the big beefs.
I'm only now getting to the point of crossing the OP's I created with larger fruit to see how well I can combine flavor, earliness, disease resistance, and see whether there's 'combining ability' in a general sense or at least specific to some crosses.
So what about the large tasty tomato OP's as a flavor parent?   Well they will be a bit later, there's no avoiding that compromise with earliness.  One reason for crossing unstable generations with one another is to shake up the recombination process and increase your chances of transgressive segregation.
I have used bigger fruit in my breeding lines, some of which produced tasty lines worth following, however the selection for taste and/or the skew towards small size has led to smaller but tasty fruit.



William Schlegel

I want to make a cross with Black Cherry now. I thought it had better flavor than the other blacks and purples I grew last year.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I was happy with Black Cherry and definitely want to grow it again. It was easy to grow and likely has good genes for crosses.

I was frankly surprised how little variation there was in taste between all the varieties tested. Almost all were neither bad nor great, not sweet, not fruity, just... tomato.

Now I realize how valuable the exceptions are.

Steph S

@Tim DH I wanted to mention that you can get earlier offspring than parents.  I have seen it and it is doable, but this is what I referred to as "transgressive segregation" - when a pheno trait is more extreme than either parent.   Whether you can get that in F1, well it depends on the parents. You want them to be as far from related as possible ie genetically different.
According to what I've read, the wider the cross, the more likely to get transgressive segs.
Secondly as I mentioned, crossing amongst unstable generations is more likely to produce that outlier beyond the fringe.
Third factor sometimes forgotten is the environment.  The stresses on your plants have to provoke some complex processes in recombination of the genome in order for them to adapt to a stress, such as cold or short season or severe heat etc.  That is the natural way for plants to adapt if the potential is there.  If you cross two F1s or F2s you are maximizing the amount of genetic difference available for the plant to work with.  Then you can end up with an extra week of earliness compared to parents, in an F1 where the individual plants are non-identical, like an F2.
I think it's not impossible for a stable F1, but you need to parse the genetics and try combinations where, for example, one parent has some wild traits introgressed, and one is an heirloom say from a different region and most likely to be as far apart genetically as you can get with a tomato.  JMO.

Tim DH

Last season I made six hybrids by putting the pollen of two early cultivars (Latah and Moskvich) onto the stigmas of three early cultivars (Stupice, Imur Prior Beta and Bloody Butcher) My hope was to create a highly productive early F1 for use in the Greenhouse. (See previous posts for more details)

This season, non of those F1s started fruiting before Latah (my benchmark cultivar) and non of them out-produced Latah either!

So you might consider the project a complete failure! Except that I enjoyed doing it and that all the F1s were indeterminate, which I prefer in my Greenhouse. (Latah is determinate.)

Just because I had spare plants I decided to grow some of the F1s out doors. This produced a remarkable result. F1s with Moskvich as pollen parent went down with Blight. However those with Latah as pollen parent held out longer, with much less Blight damage on the fruit.  This was reflected in the average yield, 2,175g/p for Latah progeny and 940g/p for Moskvich progeny. [Of the Latah progeny, IPB suffered less from greenback. (AKA Yellow Collar)]

SO I have (accidentally) created something of use. An F1 cultivar which is resistant to the strain of Blight which swept my outdoor growing spaces in 2023. Of course that is no guarantee that it will be resistant to next years strain of Blight, however, amongst the plants that crashed in 2023 was a 'Crimson Cherry F1' which is sold as having excellent Blight resistance! So the resistance displayed by my F1s must be worth something. (It is curious, because that Blight resistance must have come from Latah, and yet I've not seen that reported anywhere.)

Consequently, since I think it has some value, I've decided to name the cross IPBxLatah as 'Potemkin F1' because I hope it heralds a peoples revolution of folk making their own F1s. Potemkin is earlier, more productive and better tasting than some of the Blight resistant cultivars I've trialed. (I'll have to put it up against Primabella next season, which I did rate.)

We now have three F1 recipes

Craig's Gift F1 parents Cherokee Purple and Lillian's Yellow recommended for Taste creator Craig Lehoulier

Potemkin F1 parents  Imur Prior Beta(m) and Latah(p) recommended for  blight resistance, early, creator TimDH

Raspberry Beret F1 parents Vorlon(m) x Pervaya Lyubov(p) recommended for Productive early outdoor taste. creator Maf

Tim DH


William Schlegel

#115
Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-11-22, 02:44:15 AMTo my mind, there is a fair bit of overlap between this idea and the F1s for the People! thread.

I'll be trialling a first run at F1 cherries (created this year) next season, but I'm already collecting contenders for a 2025 hybridisation to trial in 2026!

Tim DH

The dehybridizing then rehybridising Sungold idea is interesting Tim but I am curious about how the orange gene works in a hybrid. When I grew out my three F1 crosses with the two pimpinillifolium accessions I made in 2022 in 2023 they were uniform even with different parents, good red cherry tomatoes. However if some of the orange genes produce an orange or orangish hue to a cross with a red. It might be possible to make a wild parent hybrid in a color other than red. One of the pimp strains is the possible source of PH5 with accession number PI 270443. Julia Dakin sent back a nice grow report for it. So if a really tasty F1 hybrid could be made from it. That could be an interesting cherry tomato. Robust vigor on one side and perhaps a different color and fruity flavors from the other.

Possible orange parents in my collection include: Sungold dehybridizations, exserted orange, galapagense derived orange, and potentially Habrochaites derived orange lines like the one orange which is orange and fruity.

On that last note I ended up with two different orange and fruity blue blushed long tress cherries in 2023. They segregated or hybridized from somewhere and showed up in both my promiscuous tomato patches. Flavor very reminiscent of sungold.


A flipped idea, though I've struggled in attempting crosses with it, would be Solanum galapagense LA1410 as the current tomato- that would allow a orange domestic like Exserted Orange to be the other parent.

My three very uniform red F1 cherries from the 2022 pimp crosses had dwarf Gloria's treat and F2 potato leaf MMM as their mothers. Given that MMM is half Big Hill HX9 it would probably also work as a bicolor mother. Though Dwarf Gloria's Treat has the best flavor. If galapagense LA1410 was the father and Dwarf Gloria's Treat the mother, it might just produce an exceptionally flavored, orange, sparsely hairy, uniform cherry with interesting resistances.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-22, 06:02:59 AMIf galapagense LA1410 was the father and Dwarf Gloria's Treat the mother, it might just produce an exceptionally flavored, orange, sparsely hairy, uniform cherry with interesting resistances.

If there might be issues with the skin being too thick with pure gal father, would it make sense maybe to breed a gal x lyc hybrid that has better skin, then use that as the father for the F1? Could get bigger size that way too?

I'm also curious about fruit sizes in crossing, I'll make a separate thread on that now....

William Schlegel

I have a gal x lyc hybrid or hybrids available at the 1/2 and 1/4 dilution levels. Fairly new though so would be F2 on both hybrids actually because I didn't grow out the F2 of the 1/2 cross because it had an unknown parent and I preferred my deliberate cross with it.

Though that is a general problem I have right now. Very little stable material from my own breeding. Just Mission Mountain Sunrise which should be stable next year at the F7 but is very susceptible to disease from grow reports out of other climates.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#118
Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-11-22, 02:44:15 AMTo my mind, there is a fair bit of overlap between this idea and the F1s for the People! thread.

I'll be trialling a first run at F1 cherries (created this year) next season, but I'm already collecting contenders for a 2025 hybridisation to trial in 2026!

Tim DH

Have you thought of making an F1 cherry by using something like PI 270443, the pimpinellifolium with the strong 'PH-5' late blight resistance, as a parent? (As male parent would be best if you want domestic seed size). One could potentially breed a tasty PH-2 + PH-3 homozygous large fruited tomato as the other parent. That could be very handy, being heterozygous for all 3 types of resistance.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-27, 03:47:40 AMHave you thought of making an F1 cherry by using something like PI 270443, the pimpinellifolium with the strong 'PH-5' late blight resistance, as a parent? (As male parent would be best if you want domestic seed size). One could potentially breed a tasty PH-2 + PH-3 homozygous large fruited tomato as the other parent. That could be very handy, being heterozygous for all 3 types of resistance.

It wouldn't be quite stable but I could do something like cross PI 270433 the pimp I often refer to as just PH-5 pimp with a cross I made in 2023 between Galahad F1 and (Mission Mountain Morning x Purple Zebra F1). It would have the seeming advantage to me of having 1/16 OSSI ancestry via Big Hill HX-9. Though that Galahad F1 x (MMM x PZ) cross could probably, with a little work and some of that $500 testing, be segregated into a tasty PH-2 and PH-3 homozygous tomato.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days