F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Adrian

#90
Its depend what carachteristics fo you want improve for me in your F1.
With my cross between canestrino di lucca and andine cornue the heterosis effect was extrem.For improve the vigor i think that the most interested is to selected two parents with differents carachteristics but who could be combinated mid dominants.For example one parent with small and strong leaf in great quantity and a second parent with large and thin leaf in low quantity.The F1 will have large and strong leafs in great quantity.
For the yield around 10 fruits by plant for andine cornue, around 20 fruits by plant for canestrino di lucca and up to 60 fruits by plants for canestrino di lucca x andine cornue.
You can give extrem heterosis effect to combinated differents recessives characters.

For the disease tolerancy i don't think that she is very tolerant but i didn't have searched to improve disease tolerancy.A lot of F2 are probably tomerant at verticiliul wilt.
This same F1 crossed with roman candle i have noted that the yield is under the first F1 but the fruits are more big.

Joseph Lofthouse

Thanks Steph. I'll stop mentioning that 50% thing.

Steph S

I'm pretty amazed at the range of heterosis effects that are possible.  Some are huge!

Adrian

#93
I think that you can have heterosis effect for differents carachteristics.

I don't think that the first question to ask is how can i improve the vigor but what party of the plant i want improve? For improve vigor i can improve the leaf.Improve leaf = improve photosynthesis.

Or what disease i will improve the tolerancy.
For example take 2 parents with additionals carachteristics.

 You can have heterosis for photosyntesis, a disease tolerancy, a particular taste,a  particulary rootenary system.The most important in my opinion is that the carachteristic that you want improve is different on the 2 parents and have additionals effects.
For example: small and strong leaf x large and thin leaf = strong and large leaf.

Two differents recessives mutations are more luck to have additionals effects to a recessive mutation x dominant?

Maf

This is an interesting thread and something that must come to pass. I would love it if amateur tomato breeders were trading their fovourite F1's. Sometimes an F1 of a cross has a certain something that neither of the parents could achieve alone and is difficult (or impossible) to pin down in subsequent generations. The heterozygous sft production improvement mentioned above is one example, although unfortunately I believe the company invloved patented heterozygous sft or otherwise protected it from general use? Am I mis-remembering or is it a protected technology?

Here is another example: Conventional wisdom has it that the gf gene is recessive, such that if you cross a pink and purple tomato the F1 will be pink and the F2 will segregate for 3 pink and 1 purple. My view is that the gene is incompletely recessive and the F2 actually segregates 1:2:1 for light pink/slightly darker pink/purple and the F1 falls into the heterozygous "slightly darker pink" category. (Obviously the same applies for red/brown as pink/purple.) I have seen threads on other gardening forums where people say something like "I cannot stabilise this cross, every year I select the beautiful deep pink tomato to carry forward, but the next year I always get some purples showing up in the segregates, why will it not stabilise?" Well, newsflash, it won't stabilise because it is a heterozygous expression of gf! When evaluating the reds or pinks in F? generation a gf cross I am pretty confident in my ability to select the ones that are going to segregate for gf in future generations and I am usually proved right. You need a good eye for colour to do this and a level head, but it is not difficult if you know what you are looking for. This trick has been used by big ag tomato companies also, I have grown out the F2 of commercial F1 supermarket tomatoes, that had a deep red colour, and gf showed up there along with a few other recessive genes that weren't (fully) expressed in the parent.

Anyway, here is a little gift to the forum, the recipe for 'Raspberry Beret' F1, which turned out to be a great tasting, productive, fairly early and beautiful tomato. The mother is Vorlon, a dark variety, (itself a stabilised cross between Cherokee Purple and Prudens Purple iirc) and the pollen parent is the Russian variety Pervaya Lyubov, a good tasting, early for a fairly large tomato, copes well outside in the UK, pink. I have run out of seeds and need to remake the cross to replenish my supply, which I hope to do next year. Anyone with a similar interest is welcome to follow this recipe and make their own, and do with it as they wish, as long as they don't want to patent it! It is also a very aromatic tomato, and for a while went by the codename 'Smelly Hat'!

I sent out seeds of Raspberry Beret F1 to a few people in USA but didn't receive much back in the way of feedback as far as I can remember. Here in the UK it was vigorous and productive and tasty.

Also, I wanted to add that when crossing established tomatoes to create a new F1 you are more likely to encounter heterosis if you cross 2 tomatoes from different cultures, where the breeding lines were kept apart for many years, and were progressing along different routes, such as crossing an American tomato with a Russian tomato from the Soviet era. Obviously the new introgressions of wild tomato genetics in such features as antho, woolly leaves, Beta Carotene, disease resistance genes and a host of others have shaken up the dynamic and create the opportunity to cross a regular tomato to something that is genuinely genetically different, and hopefully these introgressions will make for some interesting F1's in the future.

Here is Raspberry Beret F1:

Steph S

Very nice, Maf!   Pervaya Lyubov has become a standard grow at the farm here, being reliable and productive enough.  I grew Vorlon once but it was a cold spring and the plant was pretty sulky.  Good to know it made a brilliant F1.

Adrian

#96
Very nice Maf!
She seem tasty!
I think that gf is more present than we can think.I even think you can found differents variants of gf.
Some question
How recognize gf on the green fruit?
Do you think that the fruit on this picture has gf?
Dark green shoulder and dark green leafs are signs of gf?

Maf

 @Adrian  You can spot (homozygous) gf in plants before the fruit is ripe by looking at the old leaves that fall off. Because the chlorophyll is retained in gf plants (both leaves and fruit) the leaves do not turn yellow before falling off like normal plants, they just stay green as they shrivel and fall off. Not sure if you can tell anything from immature fruit colour as gf causes plants to retain the chlorophyll longer but I don't think it necessarily has more chlorophyll to begin with...

Tim DH

Thanks for all the fascinating input. ... I've been away for a week....

SO We now have two declared F1 recipes.

Craig's Gift F1 parents Cherokee Purple and Lillian's Yellow recommended for Taste creator Craig Lehoulier

Raspberry Beret F1 parents Vorlon(m) x Pervaya Lyubov(p) recommended for Productive early outdoor taste. creator Maf


My own experiments have thrown up an unexpected result. I was principally trialling the Early Reds for Greenhouse production. However a few went out in the garden/allotment. On the allotment, all three crosses with Moskvich as pollen parent have got blight mottled fruit. Non of the three crosses with Latah as pollen parent have any blight marks on the fruit! (I've not seen Latah credited with blight resistance and I've never grown it outdoors.)

In the attached photo Left to Right is

StupicexMoskvich (with a little bit of IPBxLatah visible behind)

StupicexLatah (with a little bit of BloodyButcherxLatah visible behind)

IPBxMoskvich (with a little bit of Bloody ButcherxMoskvich visible behind)

Sasha's Altai with Bison behind. Both completely ruined by Blight.

Tim DH

Roland

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2022-05-15, 09:37:27 PMI make a public domain F1 hybrid sweet corn. The mother is Astronomy Domine, the father is either Who Gets Kissed, Ambrosia, or a similar homozygous sugary enhanced corn.

Do the F1 plants all flower at the same time?
Netherlands

Joseph Lofthouse

#100
The flowers of hybrid corn mature mid-way between the flowering times of the parents. Therefore, if crossing a landrace with variable flowering time, to an inbred variety with a fixed flowering time, the flowering time of the offspring will tend to be less variable than the landrace, and more variable than the inbred.

We can select landraces for consistent flowering time, if we value that trait.

Roland

If you cross a land race with a hybrid, you also have different flowering periods in the F1 generation, don't you?
This is because the hybrid comes from parents with different flowering periods?
Netherlands

Joseph Lofthouse

If I were developing hybrids for commercial sale, I would choose parents with similar flowering times, so that I could plant them on the same day, with the same pass of the seeder.

Tim DH

We are hurtling towards the end of the season here, when I'm going to have a  L O T  of number crunching to do! (Last year I stopped weighing in tomatoes on Oct 21st.)

Subjectively it looks like all six of my F1s are displaying Hybrid Vigour. But what does the term even mean? (I've spent a lot of time thinking about Justin's comments on this.)

For a start: What does Hybrid mean? I've googled various definitions and here are three examples:

The offspring of a reproductive cross between genetically dissimilar individuals.

An animal or plant that has parents of different species or varieties.

The offspring of two animals or plants of different breeds, varieties, species, or genera.


Given that the word Hybrid has quite a wide range of meanings, Hybrid Vigour must also cover quite a wide field.

I've been thinking this through by considering Dogs. A hybrid between two domestic breeds and a hybrid wolfdog are obviously very different things!

In setting up my hybrids I was looking for genetically dissimilar individuals. That is why I selected parents with different geographical origins. But if, as suggested elsewhere on this forum, the domestic tomato has a seriously restricted gene pool, then I wouldn't expect it to be easy to select significantly different parents. Perhaps I just got lucky?

Returning to dogs. The most inbred lines are noted for having genetic weaknesses. Surely a stabilized open pollinated tomato is the pinnacle of inbredness?

I set out trying to find F1s which 'worked' (By which I mean were worth the effort). I was expecting that finding itself to take some effort. But maybe all F1s 'work', because they counter act inbreeding depression. (Justin's term) So if you consider breeds, varieties, species, or genera to be a continuum (line) I was expecting success in this project to lie with hybrids towards the species/genera end of that line. Maybe success starts right up at the breeds/varieties end?

Cathy A

#104
"A hybrid between two domestic breeds and a hybrid wolfdog are obviously very different things!"

Well, scientifically, the distinction is very narrow.

The wolf is Canis lupus. It has 38 subspecies, some extinct.

One of those subspecies is the domestic dog, Canis lupus familiaris.

So we have three types of crosses based on our somewhat arbitrary nomenclature: (1) different varieties within a species; (2) between different subspecies of the same species; and (3) between different species of the same genus.