Trying to get dark greens tomatoes

Started by Nicolas, 2023-03-19, 06:24:27 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Roland

Do you notice that the tomatoes with the hp-2dg gene homozygous have a long ripening time?
Netherlands

Nicolas

Found one !

I guess it is dg + gf, but lacking r^y ?

375048215_6193024800802303_7401628821741777997_n.jpg
375212020_6193007894137327_8402767537454889889_n.jpg375066335_6193009314137185_1675043036273696743_n.jpg374859046_6193010634137053_2304886878812203199_n.jpg   

Roland

How was the green fruit, normal or dark green collor?
Netherlands

Nicolas

It was dark green fruited

The red interior is very dark, the dg is showing there too
375140502_6193894637381986_7680655255345059654_n.jpg

Steph S

Very nice Nicolas!   You may still get the ry in the next generation too.

Nicolas

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-09-05, 03:44:40 PMVery nice Nicolas!   You may still get the ry in the next generation too.

Sure, there's even good chances :)

Roland

Quote from: Roland on 2023-08-21, 02:39:40 PMThe results after 9 days in the dark:
green leaf: Absinthe (gf and r, green fruit)
green leaf: Black Cherry (gf and R, brown fruit)
yellowish leaf LA3005 (hp-2dg gene)
yellowish leaf Galahad (pink fruit)
yellowish leaf Piccolo OP (Red fruit)
yellowish leaf Glacial Zebra x galahad F1 (Heterozygous for gf, gs and r. Red fruit)

These were old leaves of the plants and after 9 days they were almost through, or dried up or full of diseases such as late blight.

Now to test again with young suckers...


Hmm, young leaves withoud gf genes do not collor to yellow in the dark.
Netherlands

Nicolas


Nicolas

#83
We're not trying to get dark greens tomatoes, we got some and other very good interesting stuff ! Here is a recap of lines of interest discovered during this first year of the collaborative project (F2 grow out). Thanks to all members who participated :)

First, we've discovered some dark green'ish tomatoes. Those line should combine three recessive genes : dg (dark green, accumulation of chlorophyll), gf (green flesh, retention of chlorophyll during ripening), and r^y (reddish yellow, suppression of some lycopene during ripening).

We've got a line from Gabriel


F3 Dark Green #3 - Gabriel



F3 Dark Green #3 - Gabriel



F3 Dark Green #3 - Gabriel



F3 Dark Green #3 - Gabriel



F3 Dark Green #3 - Gabriel



A line from Marie

F3 Dark Green (top left) - Marie



F3 Dark Green - Marie



Maybe a line from Klaus, but i'm not sure if the photos are misleading because fruits have been harvested too early (Klaus can you confirm if it stays relatively green whhen ripe ?)


F3 Dark Green (or unripe brown?) - Klaus



F3 Dark Green (or unripe brown?) - Klaus


F3 Dark Green (or unripe brown?) - Klaus



Then we've got brown line, combining the dg and gf genes, but lacking the r^y one. The fruits have intese red parts, dark green interior towards peel, and a brownish external color.

A line from Gabriel

F3 Dark Brown #8 - Gabriel



F3 Dark Green #3 & Brown8 - Gabriel



At least a line from Klaus


F3 Dark Brown - Klaus



F3 Dark Brown - Klaus



F3 Dark Brown - Klaus



And one from me

F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



F3 Dark Brown - Nicolas



Then we've got dark red lines, containing dg but neither gf or r^y

Some lines from Gabriel


F3 Dark Red #2 - Gabriel



F3 Dark Red #1 - Gabriel



And a line from Klaus, whose fruits are quite bigs and of beefsteak type. Klaus noted that the flesh is firmer, which is apparently a feature of the dg gene.


F3 Dark Red Beefsteak (unripe) - Klaus



F3 Dark Red Beefsteak - Klaus



We've aso got lines with lovely red color and dark shoulders. This phenotype is kind of a mystery for me because it dos not contains dg gene (flesh is normal red). So maybe it is caused by the dg gene in heterozygous condition, and/ormaybe some combination with the u gene (uniforma ripening / dark shoulder gene locus).

One from Klaus

F3 Lovely Red - Klaus



And one from me.

F3 Lovely Red - Nicolas



Whats next for the project ?

The project has already been successfull because the goal was to combine the dg and gf gene at least, and dg, gf and r^y at best. Some other interesting lines may be of interest like the dark read beefsteak, and lovely red lines.
Next step this winter is to get seeds from and for members of this year. Next year i will grow seeds from some lines so seeds could be shared widely outside of the project. Some crosses will be made. I hope that other members will join, and that we will be able to try to get new combination with GWR, striped and/or blue tomatoes.

Roland

I wonder how the hp-2 dg gene reacts in a black tomato like Black beauty?
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

I was thinking about wha's been said about the uniform ripening tomatoes, and how that might relate to this dark green project. From what I understand, the uniform ripening trait is associated with lighter green unripe fruits? And with non-uniform ripening, the chlorophyl increases from the top, is that so? Then, it seems there are conflicting reports about flavour, with many saying the uniform ones taste bad, but Roland finding that not to be the case in his experience with Galahad dehybridising. But in general, if there might be a difference in taste, I am wondering if it might be due to the reduction in chlorophyl in the fruit, such that the fruit is thereby less able to produce energy?

So that made me think about these dark green tomatoes, and whether, if there is a negative effect of uniform ripening, there might be the inverse, positive effect from the dark green tomatoes? So I'm curious, have people in this project been noticing any taste difference with the different chlorophyl levels that might show something like this?

Also sorry that I am so ignorant on this dark green topic - are some of them dark green, i.e. darker than usual, and then go red on ripening? I suppose tasting them would be more relevant to this question so we could know the effect of the colours in making energy as opposed to how the colours (chlorophyl etc.) actually taste in the ripe fruit.

Adrian

#86
Justin gardener,
When the fruit has a green shoulder it has above all a difference of chlorophyle rate between the top and the down.Roland has probably selected fruits without green shoulder but with a average superior chlorophyle rate in all the fruit surface.

Nicolas,
The fruit dg that i have picked seem have viables seeds.Unfortunately he has take frost before to be colored.
The fruit amber was very tasty probably above a black krim i will sow again the seeds.

Unfortunately thoses plants are a low vigor and productivity and must be growed at location protected of the diseases.For the most part of thoses fruits the wind is not sufficient for the fecondation.I gave shaked some flowers two times per day for fecondated her.

They will be growed in my planters with the dwarfs plants.

Klaus Brugger

#87
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-30, 07:35:59 AMare some of them dark green, i.e. darker than usual, and then go red on ripening?

That's what they usually do – if they retain the green, it's because of an additional green-flesh mutation being present.
Interestingly, the ripe red fruit is not necessarily as dark red as the unripe fruit was dark green, if that makes sense. hp-2dg fruits have an increased plastid size and number per cell, but the decrease in plastid number during chloroplast-chromoplast transition is relatively higher in them than in normal fruits (Kolotilin, 2007). The ripe fruits still end up being a more intense red than fruits of normal plants, just not as intense as you might have expected ...

Kolotilin, I., Koltai, H., Tadmor, Y., Bar-Or, C., Reuveni, M., Meir, A., ... Levin, I. (2007). Transcriptional Profiling of high pigment-2dg Tomato Mutant Links Early Fruit Plastid Biogenesis with Its Overproduction of Phytonutrients. Plant Physiology, 145(2), 389–401.
https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.107.102962

Roland

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-30, 07:35:59 AMSo I'm curious, have people in this project been noticing any taste difference with the different chlorophyl levels that might show something like this?

Manapal LA3005 is the variety used to cross in the hp-2dg gene.
The taste of Manapal LA3005 is nothing special and has a brix of 4, very low for this size fruit.
Netherlands

Nicolas

In the first message of this thread i wrote

QuoteWhat about crossing these dark green tomato with blue (anthocyanin) tomatoes ? The accumulation of chlorophyll could lead to very dark blue tomatoes.

I still think this would be the case as it seems the "blue" accumulates in the greener parts (top of the tomato and stripes)

My guess is that the dg+gf tomatoes would be tastier as they have more chlorophyll