Question about dwarf tomato crosses

Started by Mike Deyo, 2025-01-26, 03:03:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

KaguyaCloud

Congratulations on a successful cross! I wonder what the flavor will be like.

Mike Deyo

Quote from: KaguyaCloud on 2025-02-15, 01:12:40 PMCongratulations on a successful cross! I wonder what the flavor will be like.

I wonder too!

After the first tomatoes started developing, I moved the plants upstairs where it was 5-10F warmer. Then I noticed that the tops of the plants were starting to grow more like a normal indeterminate, and less like a dwarf. The first flower truss developed after maybe 6 leaves, and it was only 8" tall at that point. The first photo was taken on Feb.15, and you can see how the top of the plants are more elongated now. The yardstick is at ground level in the pot. The second photo was taken on Feb.28. I've left just six fruits to develop, pruning off all later fruits and flowers.

The cross with Hazy's Dream is acting the same. Lights, day length all the same.

It will be interesting to see how the F-2 seedlings act, and if I will get the expected 25% dwarf plants, or something different.

KaguyaCloud

Looks like they're growing quite nicely.

The first 2-3 leaves in the F2s can be non-rugose, from personal experience. So be careful if you can! Very interesting to see them take off after being compact for a short time.

AndrewB

This does not answer the original question, and may not be true for all dwarfs, but I found this on Google scholar and it seemed relevant to the rugose leaves:

QuoteIt was also found that Micro-Tom has a mutation in the DWARF gene (d) that leads to mis-splicing and production of at least two shorter mRNAs. The d mutation is predicted to generate truncated DWARF protein. The d sequence defect co-segregates with dark-green and rugose leaves, characteristics of brassinosteroid biosynthesis mutants. Micro-Tom also carries at least another mutation producing internode length reduction that affects plant height but not active gibberellin (GA) levels, which were similar in dwarf and tall Micro-Tom×Severianin segregants.

Mike Deyo

Here are some photos (taken today) of the lower leaves (developed before first blooms), a leaf from higher up (above the second flower truss), and the growing tip (they've grown higher than the plant light, I tilted it so they showed up in photo). To me, they look less rugose as you go up the plant. But I didn't pay close attention to this when I grew dwarfs in the garden last summer. I also notice that the leaflets are more jammed together down low, and more spaced apart like a normal indeterminate at the top.

AndrewB

Quote from: Mike Deyo on 2025-03-10, 11:14:22 AMTo me, they look less rugose as you go up the plant. But I didn't pay close attention to this when I grew dwarfs in the garden last summer. I also notice that the leaflets are more jammed together down low, and more spaced apart like a normal indeterminate at the top.

If this is indeed true, wouldn't this indicate that this is a form of co-expression? Ie, an indication of either an F1 or heterogeneous alleles?

In my mind, this observation is the evidence you needed to show that these are indeed F1. Not all recessive genes in crops are completely mendelian in nature. And sometimes other genes can change expression of normally mendelian traits.

Good luck with your new cross either way!

KaguyaCloud

#21
Based off my personal experience, F1s can have rugose-like leaves. Here is a photo of a Micro-dwarf x Regular Indeterminate F1 cross at 13 days:


It's likely a case of incomplete dominance and/or co-dominance, where certain genes are partially expressed. Typically from my micro-dwarf project, heterozygous normal types typically have semi-rugose leaves, followed by normal leaves as it matures. Nice to see documentation that there is a consistent pattern.

All the homozygous recessive dwarfs that I have grown out usually don't have rugose leaves until the 3rd true leaf has formed. So try not to cull early on if you can.

KaguyaCloud

#22
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2025-03-10, 06:56:08 AMThis does not answer the original question, and may not be true for all dwarfs, but I found this on Google scholar and it seemed relevant to the rugose leaves

There are actually quite a few un-characterized genes responsible for growth habits like micro-dwarfs that grow similarly to Micro-Tom(Orange Hat, Micro-Tina, Jochalos, Vilma). Currently growing out multiple F2s to see segregation ratios.

The most major gene that causes the dwarfing effect is what I would describe to be an early termination gene. The main stem of micro-dwarf tomatoes like Micro-Tom immediately terminate to 2 flower trusses after growing a set number of leaves. This is very different from typical determinate varieties, as they usually alternate a set of leaves and flower trusses before terminating to 2 flower trusses. See comparison here:


This gene also seems to cause the side shoots(axillary shoots) to skip the vegetative cycle and immediately grow a series of flower trusses and leaves after 3 leaves have grown. I suspect that this might be an extreme version of the determinate sp gene.

Another dwarfing gene seems to be related to cotyledon nyctinasty, or the closing of cotyledons during the night cycle. After growing out about 34 individual F2s, I have observed that the 4 of seedlings that keep their cotyledons open during the night cycle(non-nyctinastic) seem to be 2-3 times shorter than their peers. All seedlings so far that express non-nyctinasty are dwarf, and this trait is consistent of the micro varieties I have listed. But the segregation ratios are quite strange, as there might some epistasis happening where the dwarf gene is required for non-nyctinasty to be expressed.

Here's a photo showing a seedling expressing no nyctinasty(left) and a seedling expressing nyctinasty(right):



Mike Deyo

Quote from: AndrewB on 2025-03-10, 01:15:15 PMAnd sometimes other genes can change expression of normally mendelian traits.

This is what I'm guessing is going on. I don't have the space to grow a lot of F-2s to maturity, but I will try to start a lot of F2 seedlings and see what the percentage of dwarf and/or rugose seedlings is. I will get to see if the dwarf seedlings I choose to grow to maturity stay dwarf the whole time.

Quote from: KaguyaCloud on 2025-03-10, 06:04:06 PMAll the homozygous recessive dwarfs that I have grown out usually don't have rugose leaves until the 3rd true leaf has formed. So try not to cull early on if you can.

Thanks, this is good to know. I finish the seedlings in 3" peat pots, before planting them out, so I will need enough pots to get a good idea of the range of variation, before I pick a 6-8 dwarf plants to put in the garden.

Mike Deyo

I've harvested some F-1 fruit from my two plants. They tasted good, the fruits of both are more lobed around the stem than my PPPXCT (Pink Ping Pong X Crimson Trellis, stabilized cross) female parent, which has more ball shaped fruit. The fruits from the Sleeping Lady cross are slightly flatter in shape, and more lobed than the Hazy's Dream cross. The plants were developing some yellowish leaves, probably from me not fertilizing properly. Some of the Sleeping Lady fruits had what looked like blossom end rot, none of the Hazy's Dream fruits did. The black region didn't cause any fruit rot or damage, maybe because they were growing inside with no rain or humidity. It's nice growing inside not having to worry about early blight!

I'm fermenting the seeds, drying them, and then I plan to plant about 25 seeds from each cross, to grow far enough along to see what the ratio of dwarf plants is. I am planning to grow out 5-6 dwarf plants from each cross.

KaguyaCloud

Those fruits sure look very pretty. Do their flavors taste similarly to either parent, a combination of both, or does it taste unique?

Mike Deyo

The fruits really didn't taste quite like either parent. They were less tart and flavorful, but the plants were not in great condition, I think I didn't have the nutrient fertilizing right, and they were growing higher than the lights. The two crosses tasted pretty similar.

I planted 28 F-2 seeds of each cross, and got 6 dwarf plants from PPPCT X Hazy's Dream, and 8 dwarf plants from PPPCT X Sleeping Lady. I'm wondering if something happened with the PPPCT X Hazy's Dream cross, as there were no potato leaf plants in the F-2, although some plants had leaves that were a bit less lobed. But there wasn't an obvious difference overall between the F-2 plants of each cross.

The fruits did have a slight but consistant difference in shape between the two crosses, so I don't think they are both PPPCT X Sleeping Lady. I guess I'll have to see what the fruits of the dwarf F-2 plants look like.

Mike Deyo

Since I have limited space, I only planted out the 8 PPPCT X Sleeping Lady seedlings that looked like they were dwarf. They were shorter, and had thicker stems. A few weeks ago, one looked like it was getting early blight, and i pulled it out. At that time, they were are about half the height of my regular tomatoes, the same as other dwarf varieties I was growing.

Now I'm seeing a difference in height among the 7 remaining. Two are still dwarf height, but the other 5 are significantly taller. Almost 50% taller than the two dwarf ones. And those five are almost identical in height, no variation between them.

The first photo is of the female parent of the cross, itself a stabilized cross (20+ yrs) of Pink Ping Pong and Crimson Trellis. I didn't plant Sleeping Lady this year, but I have a photo of Dwarf Tanager, that's in the garden with them. The third photo shows two of the F-2 PPPCT X SL, the one on the left is about the same height as Dwarf Tanager, but the one on the right is almost a foot taller. They were planted out on May 5, and the pictures taken June 24. Of the two F-2's that are still dwarf height, one has quite curled leaves, but the other one doesn't.

This also happened to the F-1 plant of PPPCT X SL that I grew indoors under lights. It initially grew like a dwarf, even though the female parent was a normal height indeterminate. Then later, after fruit were set, the tops of the plants took off and really started growing vertically. That this is also happening outside says it wasn't something funny about the indoor growing environment.

It's suggestive that the proportion of 2 dwarf out of 7 is close to 25%. A dominant gene that reverses the dwarf growth at a certain point in development, and when is present in double recessive form allows dwarf growth throughout the lifespan? That still doesn't quite account for the behavior in the F-1.

KaguyaCloud

You've reached a quite interesting conclusion in your grow-outs. Genetics isn't entirely as clear cut as it may seem like in the punnet squares or in Mendel's pea experiments.

The dwarf gene specifically is involved with a mutation of a protein that is responsible to create these hormones called brassinosteroids(BR), which aid in shoot and leaf development. This mutation leads to a defect the prevents the production of those hormones. Typically plants with both dwarf genes grow about 50% as tall as their non-dwarf counterparts due to reduced internode(leaf to leaf) length.

Plants, like all other complex living beings, don't always produce the same amount of hormones/proteins/etc as soon as they sprout. There are a cocktail of hormones in conflict and in harmony with one another. Knowing this, we could make a hypothesis since you've observed these patterns in your grow outs.

It is possible that during the initial vegetative stage for the heterozygous plants, the genes involved with the production of the BR hormone might not be fully compensating for the mutated/defected gene. The vegetative phase of a tomato plant is still immature, and may have been a "late bloomer" due to that.

In terms of your tomatoes taking off after initially stunted growth, a lot of hormonal changes generally occur in plants as they mature. I would likely hypothesize that they were fully able to produce enough BR hormone to develop normally once they begun to set fruit.

You could test this hypothesis out. All you need to do is graft a cutting with dwarfism onto one of your mature regular leaf indeterminates to see what happens. Based off of some research articles, this does somewhat reverse the dwarf traits due to the main plant providing enough sufficient hormones to induce normal development.



Mike Deyo

Thank you for the explanation of the biochemistry behind the dwarf gene. It does seem to fit the growth pattern I'm seeing. And if it is a dominant gene, it would explain why the F-1 grew that way. The odd thing was why did the F-1 start out dwarf?

I'm guessing that seed saved from the two dwarf plants will have all dwarf progeny, while seed saved from the other five taller plants, will have 1/4 dwarf progeny. Time will tell.

I've noticed that the leaves on all 7 F-2 plants still resemble the leaves on other non-potato leaf dwarf plants, with leaflets very close together so the whole leaf is compact, while the leaves on the PPPCT parent have leaflets that are very spread apart, to make a larger but less dense leaf.