Sungold F1 and Sunsugar F1 breeding with and dehybridization

Started by William Schlegel, 2022-05-08, 11:15:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

Maf, when you log in, there is a drop-down menu right there in the login box that defaults to 1 hour, but you can set it to as long as 1 month.

Maf

I made a long post talking about Beta in Sungold/Sunsugar derived lines yesterday but I was timed out by the forum software and it vanished when I hit post! To say I was frustrated was an understatement...

I am not going to write it out again. However I will write some of the main points below, an abbreviated version, sorry for the brevity, but you know:

The following is based on observations of crosses derived from Sungold or Sunsugar and reading of papers discussing B (Beta carotene).

Yes, Beta carotene (B) is the gene in Sungold/Sunsugar modern cherry types.

Yes, Sunsugar is from a competitor to Tokita but has the same Beta gene.

@Steph S yellow only defeats Beta carotene (B) if homozygous r/r, if the lycopene pathway is functional, such as in a r/+ tomato, then Beta can still work.

The linked recessive gene (same chromosome/arm) moB (modifier of Beta Carotene) is very important here. If both parents have moB, then an F1, or segregates, with one copy of Beta will be proper orange. If the other parent does not have moB then the heterozygous expression of B will be a weird orange/red colour and the carotene content will be split somewhat 50/50 between lycopene and beta carotene. I do not know how common or rare moB is in non Beta tomatoes, but I know some have it and some do not, based on the fact some F1's are genuine orange and some are red/orange. I suspect it is present in between 10% and 90% of cultivars, but do not have a large enough data set to estimate which end of the spectrum is most likely.

I also have a few papers discussing Beta carotene (and some of the other orange genes). I would like some advice as to whether it is appropriate to upload them directly to the forum or if only links to the original source are allowed. (It would be time consuming to find all the original links.) They were all freely available at time of original download (not behind a paywall).


Cathy A

Maf, do we know whether Sungold F1 ha the moB gene? I have been assuming that Sungold F1 must be BB. If that's true, moB may not express directly in the F1 but would have a lot of impact on any later Sungold crosses.

Maf

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-08-22, 09:09:25 AMMaf, do we know whether Sungold F1 ha the moB gene? I have been assuming that Sungold F1 must be BB. If that's true, moB may not express directly in the F1 but would have a lot of impact on any later Sungold crosses.
B and moB are pretty tightly linked on the same chromosome so the fact that moB is clearly present in crosses to Sungold suggests they are coming over as a duo.

I am not sure if Sungold has two copies of B? Many anecdotal reports of red in the F2 of Sungold. I know earlier in the thread someone posted that they grew out 72(?) F2 Sungold plants and the ratio of reds looked more like 1 in 16 rather than the 1 in 4 we would expect from a simple dominance situation. So, yeah, it could be that Sungold has two copies of B and the reds people are seeing are just outcrosses, or there could be something more complex going on. It would be interesting to see if the reds showed up in seeds from bagged flowers.

Also, I am not sure what an expression of two copies of B and one copy of moB would look like?

Joseph Lofthouse

Quote from: Maf on 2023-08-21, 05:29:40 PMI also have a few papers discussing Beta carotene (and some of the other orange genes). I would like some advice as to whether it is appropriate to upload them directly to the forum or if only links to the original source are allowed.

Links only, and limited fair-use quotes.

Cathy A

Sungold F1 has a truly unique growth pattern. The fruits form a sort of rectilinear ladder growing along a stem. This may be one of the reasons that the yield is so high.

Sungold F1 ladder.jpg
Sungold F1 ladder 2.jpg 

I have never seen this trait in any other tomato. Nor have I seen it in any of the Sungold F2 that I grew this year, which makes me wonder if it is complex (i.e. requires multiple alleles at different locations and will "break" if any one of them is missing).

Where does this trait come from? Has it been bred into any other varieties? Has anyone isolated a Sungold descendant where this trait is stable, even if the stabilized variety is undesirable in other ways?

I'd really like to have this trait in my tomatoes if it could be bred into them.

Mica Winnower

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-08-23, 08:30:59 AMWhere does this trait come from? Has it been bred into any other varieties? Has anyone isolated a Sungold descendant where this trait is stable, even if the stabilized variety is undesirable in other ways?

I'd really like to have this trait in my tomatoes if it could be bred into them.

I've seen that kind of ladder-pattern growing habit in Sweet Million as well, which is also an F1 hybrid. They're smaller in size than Sungold, but I recognize that trait from when I grew them in 2021.

Roland

Ivas Red Berry is also making these long flowerclusters.
is a OP variety from Sungold x Supersweet.

The taste is very good and sweet! i like this one a lot.
Netherlands

Cathy A

Roland, I look at pictures of Iva's Red Berry on the web, and that appears to be exactly the same ladder.

I'm going to order some Iva's Red for next year to see what I think of it, and possibly use it as breeding material.

Mica Winnower

This seems like a nifty trait to try and cross into somebody's panamorous project. I might do Sungolds next year specifically to cross with my wildling or q-series panamorous.

Joseph Lofthouse


Steph S

I believe the ladder-like truss architecture is really common for cherries.  What is unusual with Sungold (and perhaps some others) is the long length of the ladder giving so many fruit per truss.  Maybe from the pimpinellifolium?

Nicolas

Check cherry tomato rapunzel F1 :)


Steph S

Wow Nicolas!  40 fruit per truss.  Do you know who is the breeder, is it under patent or available to breed with?

William Schlegel

Frogsleap farm commented some time back on their Facebook page that they've been working with these sort of long truss tomatoes. I just looked up their post and it does lead to increased yield. I think you can also, particularly in a commercial greenhouse, pick the whole truss at once, thus lowering labor costs.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days