SC x SI question regarding inheritance of SI trait in tomatoes

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-08-30, 03:46:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I would really love evidence-based answers, though I am also open to theoretical answers  :)
I'm interested in what happens in the F1 for SC x SI crosses. I was speculating that SI is dominant (except in the case of SC pen x SI per). Such that the F1 would be SI. So that one would have to use a sibling with a different SI allele to pollinate it, or another SI such as the parent accession for example. And that if sibling, that then 25% of the F2 would be SC and 75% SI, something like this representing the chromosome pairs:
25% SI SI
25% SI SC
25% SC SI
25% SC SC

However, Wojciech has made an arc x lyc cross with SI arc mother but the F1 are SC. So that suggests my thinking may be wrong.

I would really love input on this. I know many people have made lyc x pen and lyc x hab crosses. Presumably at least some of these have been with SI pen and hab. So I would love to hear about those cases, for example.

Garrett Schantz

I had some Solanum pimpinellifolium x Solanum habrochaites F1s and then F2s.

One was SC, the other was SI.

The F1, I grew some plants indoors.

Some went outside. They were all self pollinating in the F1 - SC.


The F2, had plants with pollination issues and some were more exserted.

I didn't harvest much fruit, lost the F3 seed.


Regardless. The appeared to be either just odd pollination issues / flowers dropping. Habrochaites was still nearby.


I also noticed that many plants that were having issues with fruit set, the flowers that did give fruit, were slightly exserted.



But that's an issue with a SI plant being unable to have pollen reach its female organs.




I didn't use Neandermato in my cross. It wasn't the typically used S. habrochaites either.



I may have had some F1 plants that didn't have great self compatibility. But they were overall pretty fine.



With different groups of wild relatives, even in the same species it could be that there are different or slightly different SI / SC genes.

Most of the research on them, is trying to get past SI genes or weed them out or mapping what issues they cause in hybrids.



Exserted genes, have been studied a bit and there are a ton of different traits that make those genes up. Different forms of exsertion

It would be surprising if there wasn't anything like that purely with just SC / SI. Which, this would indicate that there may be different dominant or whatever traits.



There are different alleles in different species and groups as well.

You can plant a S. habrochaites and penneli side by side, and they won't cross even being self incompatible.


Some accessions may mix. Others will reject the others pollen.



This is where different flower structures, and alleles come in. Populations won't cross with inbred lines too well, just like some other species.

They'll reject the pollen.


These SI populations have alleles which just pretty much make sure that they're spread throughout the population and that they'll only pair up with different mixes of alleles and things. Prevents heavy inbreeding in colonies.



Solanum pimpinellifolium and domestic tomatoes, can't pollinate standard wild SI species. That's understood.



Solanum habrochaites and S. peruvianum have almost completely different alleles which make up this system. The same goes for other species and populations.



Taking into consideration, that many of these wild species won't cross despite being SI, I'm assuming that these alleles play a factor in assuring species or individuals which are too distant from themselves won't cross with them.



Solanum pimpinellifolium is usually a mother, but it rarely accepts pollen from things other than itself, mostly being self compatible and preferring it that way.


That would be it's mechanism to prevent related species from crossing with it. When that fails, you can usually get it to be a mother in most cases.


I say most, because Neorickii, Chilense and Habrochaites plus many other species are pretty well able to pollinate domestics to some extent.

Some accessions, are different and outright refuse to do so. Solanum peruvianum pretty much always rejects to be pollinated or pollinate other species, regardless of SI or anything else.




Some people have noticed that Solanum chilense and Solanum pennellii can cross over more easily with S. peruvianum.

I'm assuming that they may share some of the same, or many of the same alleles.



I honestly haven't checked the wild species topic in awhile.



Seeing your question, Joseph did mention making a mistake at one point when mentioning whether some gene is dominant or not.

He corrected himself I believe. Can't quite recall what he figured it was, at the top of my head.



That thread is getting clustered.



Someone also had a website featuring this sort of stuff on it before.



I may create a document or PDF based on some stuff talked about over there and use the authors as everyone in that thread - plus mention some mentioned sources in there as other sources of information.

There's a ton of mention of anthocyanins, SI / SC traits and many other things over there. Some are pages apart.


Some people found that previous thinkings were incorrect or added onto things later on.



It also looks like hours of work to do that, even if I got permission.


I'd probably group different things into groups for cold resistances or other things. So yeah.



Hopefully my answer helped out a bit.



Garrett Schantz

I grew Solanum chmielewskii indoors before, from HRseeds.

That plant was self compatible.

There are SC and SI pennellii as well.


I quite enjoyed the scent that Chmielewskii gave off, lemony and all.


I was going to try and cross it with some F1 Habrochaites / Pimpinellifolium.



I didn't for whatever reason.



I'll be growing a bunch of wilds next year. I moved to Mississippi, so I'm unsure if bees will even pollinate these or understand that these are great pollen sources.




SC Pennellii could work well in crossing itself over to some other wilds, better than compared to SI groups from what I'd read before.



Garrett Schantz

Looked through some of your posts.

Saw that you have the same idea of possibly keeping some lines distinct using these genes and things as I do.

And have grown some of the same things.



When I grew Muddy Waters years back - I couldn't find other blue tomatoes.

I also grew a Peruvianum descendant with anthocyanin showing up, and it was disease resistant.

It wasn't acting well as a pollinator or mother.


That was Orange Fleshed Purple Smudge.

I've been thinking that due to it being a line that was crossed back and forth with siblings and things, that it may have some Peruvianum alleles, not found in habrochaites or whatnot.


Burnley Bounty, also has Peruvianum ancestry and has the whole daylight sensitivity issue.


Payette and some others have also been used by some users here.


Peruvianum F1s don't even tend to cross back to Peruvianum very well.

They're somewhat better at doing so. But, there's still issues - even crossing with other hybrids.



My recent project that I've mentioned, I honestly want to heavily cross over Burnley Bounty and Purple Smudge, so that I have a ton of Peruvianum genetics in a group of fruity / decent sized exserted fruits which also have other wild genes.


They already have large fruits and other traits. Ones from Australia, the other from the states. Meaning they possibly had different Peruvianum parents.

I believe that some people simply tried direct Payette or whatever crosses into other species and figured they were useless.

My project would probably give me things which are genetically mostly exserted / different colored/ flavored Burnley Bounty and Purple Smudge specimens.



But, regardless I think that certain alleles found in populations matter more than SI or SC.

Peruvianum seems a bit more distant / diverged a bit earlier than other species. Or something like that.


Sadly it's not usually a SI x SI species will easily cross.


I thought that I had a pimpinellifolium cross with something like one of Peruvianums sister species before.



I can try growing things in blossom bags next year and pollinating different things with certain pollen of whatever else.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMI had some Solanum pimpinellifolium x Solanum habrochaites F1s and then F2s.

One was SC, the other was SI.

The F1, I grew some plants indoors.

Cool. Regarding some SI some SC, I'm a bit confused. The hab was SI or you also used some SC hab? If the hab was SI and the F1 SC, that's interesting, maybe implies SI is recessive? Or at least that hab SI is recesive?

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMThe F2, had plants with pollination issues and some were more exserted.

I would be interested to know the details of those issues if you'd like to share. Also whether you ran any tests, like actively self pollinating. I have been doing such tests to rule out merely not pollinating due to exsertion. Outside I also run SC/SI tess by bagging some flowers and actively self pollinating, to check for sure if SI or SC. Though I have run few such tests, too many accessions to have time to do on all.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMI also noticed that many plants that were having issues with fruit set, the flowers that did give fruit, were slightly exserted.

That would imply maybe SI I guess.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMThere are different alleles in different species and groups as well.

You can plant a S. habrochaites and penneli side by side, and they won't cross even being self incompatible.


Some accessions may mix. Others will reject the others pollen.

Yes from what I understand on the one hand there's the SI system, and on the other hand there's the UI systems, various mechanisms to prevent inter-species crosses from happening, such as mechanisms in the style preventing formation of pollen tubes etc. I think such systems would be very useful in making domesticated populations that are protected from being diluted.
[/quote]

Well, yes, usually. But Wojciech has made an arc x lyc cross, which is quite amazing! He mentioned even the fruit flesh of the crossed flower was a bit red, he put that down to the xenia effect. Cool!

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMSolanum pimpinellifolium and domestic tomatoes, can't pollinate standard wild SI species.
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMTaking into consideration, that many of these wild species won't cross despite being SI, I'm assuming that these alleles play a factor in assuring species or individuals which are too distant from themselves won't cross with them.
Hmm, interesting idea. I would be interested if that is the case, rather than it just being down to separate UI mechanisms.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMSolanum pimpinellifolium is usually a mother, but it rarely accepts pollen from things other than itself, mostly being self compatible and preferring it that way.

I found it quite easy to make pimp accept pollen from lyc and chm, and though I did not try with che and gal, I assume that might be easy too?

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMI say most, because Neorickii, Chilense and Habrochaites plus many other species are pretty well able to pollinate domestics to some extent.

Chilense? Have you ever made viable seeds from lyc x chi? Or know anyone who has? I was under the impression that is effectively not possible without techniques such as embryo rescue.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMSome people have noticed that Solanum chilense and Solanum pennellii can cross over more easily with S. peruvianum.

Oh wow, I didn't know with chilense. Do you have any links to examples of that? I was aware of per x SC-pen crosses. I could not find if that also works with SI-pen, But I have been running some tests, making cross attempts with a supposedly SC pen (LA0716 - I say supposedly because so far I am seeing no self-pollinated fruits on it) to many accessions of per and a few chi, and also same tests using multiple pen accession pollen mix. Some of the per are making fruits, some not. Not sure about chi accessions, I have not written it up yet.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMI'm assuming that they may share some of the same, or many of the same alleles.

In the paper I read it was saying.... I think it was saying, that SI is dominant except in the case of per x SC-pen in which case the pen SC seems to be dominant over the per SI.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 07:49:35 AMI may create a document or PDF based on some stuff talked about over there and use the authors as everyone in that thread - plus mention some mentioned sources in there as other sources of information.
Awesome!

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 08:22:40 AMI grew Solanum chmielewskii indoors before, from HRseeds.

That plant was self compatible.

There are SC and SI pennellii as well.


I quite enjoyed the scent that Chmielewskii gave off, lemony and all.
I'm guessing he may have bought his from Lupinaster on eBay. Did you run any SC tests on it? I hand pollinated a group indoors but outdoors even with much bee activity on a couple, most flowers are dropping. So that made me wonder, even though the species is said to be SC. I also really love the smell. Did you make crosses? I made several.

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-30, 08:41:56 AMI also grew a Peruvianum descendant with anthocyanin showing up, and it was disease resistant.
Yes I am seeing lots of antho in many of my various pers. I just hope I can bring some of them in via pen. It also could be cool if they could cross directly with a lyc x pen cross, to reduce the pen:per ratio. SO far I am seeing variable disease resistance in the pers.

Your per genetics project sounds cool. I hope to keep hearing about it as it progresses!





Garrett Schantz

I used a SC pimpinellifolium and SI habrochaites.

The pimpinellifolium was a type with slight exsertion.

With wild crosses, I'd prefer both parents to have an exserted trait.


Otherwise you'll end up with progeny which are SI, but they can't be pollinated and thus the flowers just drop off.


The SI system and mentioned "UI System" likely work together to prevent crosses or they're linked in some ways.

Thus making hybrids may technically also prevent different crosses from working well.

Or make crosses easier / better in some ways.

Figured they'd be noteworthy here.