F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

#75
I would be interested to see the calculation for SI outbreeding plants that shows the equilibrium value for % heterozygosity and the factors on which it depends.

Inbreeding plants lose 50% of heterozygosity in every generation, but outbreeders preserve it.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-07-24, 07:01:32 AMI would be interested to see the calculation for SI outbreeding plants that shows the equilibrium value for % heterozygosity and the factors on which it depends.
Yeah that;s the problem, I didn't really do any maths. I was just basing it on assuming if there's a 20% rate of outcrossing then there might be an overall heterozygosity (if population is big enough) of 20%. But I'm sure to work it out properly one would need some proper maths beyond my simple understanding!

Still, not too important to make the calculation I guess, until we would know what heterozygosity we should be aiming for!

But thinking from another angle, if we had the same flower structure as chmielewskii, and maybe colour too if that's important, then we would likely have the same rate of outcrossing as chmielewskii. So we should be fine. Again this is probably oversimplified but, kind of taking a trusting approach towards nature!

Though another thought could be.... well I will make up an example. Let's suppose chm. has 80% outcrossing rate but 30% is enough for the majority of the 'hybrid vigour' phenomenon (or should we say perhaps 'absence of inbreeding depression' phenomenon! Then going for 30% might actually be preferable if the target growers would benefit from more fruit setting in the case of having just 1 or 2 plants, for example, assuming that 80% outcrossing also means most flowers on an isolated plant wouldn't set.

But then, is that what it means? Does anyone have experience for example, growing single chm. plants, and seeing how much fruit sets? Or with a facultative SC accession of arcanum?

I also had another thought today about preserving diversity. I was considering how humans are outcrossers but also have cultural mechanisms to prevent inbreeding, such as the taboo of incest. Even in Australian Aborigine societies such rules get quite complex. Well, I thought of a very simple system just for going 1 step at least, and that would be, if selling or sharing SI or facultative SC tomato seeds, one could when processing them, keep the seeds stored separately for each plant. Suppose you're giving 10 seeds, then, give 1 seed from each plant. That way it at least avoids... well the analogy would be people having kids with their siblings. For farms it wouldn't matter due to population size, but for people growing small populations, basically anything significantly under the TGRC guidelines 75 plants, then I would guess this would be a wise way to at least attempt to help preserve the genetic diversity. Otherwise there could be some severe bottlenecks as seeds get passed along. Well, growing under 75 already makes a bottleneck, but I mean as a way to minimise it at least.

Tim DH

Hi Justin,
   I like your flipping of the 'Hybrid Vigour Phenomenon' into the 'Inbreeding Depression Phenomenon'. ... Neat: To look at both sides of the proverbial coin.

Tim DH

Tim DH

My F1 project now has two distinct threads:
Early Red F1s which are currently producing tomatoes
Cherry F1s the parents of which are currently producing seed for next year.

Once again not all the parents have turned out to be what I expected. The Sunrise Bumblebee is clearly not! (See pic)  I'm not sure about the Brandywine Cherry either. Googling images for that name suggests that there is more than one cultivar called Brandywine Cherry!

One of the reasons for starting the CherryF1s with seven parents was to allow for such cultivar non-conformity. I started the Early Red F1s with only five parents. When one of the two male parents turned out to be not what I was expecting, that changed the outcome for half of the seed lines.

Steph S

Tim, are you growing the parent lines as a control/comparison for fruitfulness? 
Looking forward to your results with the early lines!

Tim DH

Hi Steph,
   In an ideal world I would be growing multiple plants of each F1 and multiple plants of each parent. However the reality is that I only have space for eighteen plants in the greenhouse! Competition for those spots is FIERCE!!

   I have given away lots of seed of the Early Red F1s, always with a parent for comparison and always with a plea for feedback/data. My guess is that, at best, the information which I get back will be fuzzy!

   All I'm really hoping for this year from the Early Red F1s is:

1) Proof of Concept. That small scale creating of F1s is a practical proposition. Available to all, not requiring much in the way of specialist equipment or skills.
2) Validation of Theory. That growing non-commercial F1 seed is worth the effort. (Either raising plants from someone else's seed or creating the seed using someone else's F1 recipe)
3) Indication of Potential. That creating and assessing new F1 recipes is an interesting and rewarding pursuit.

   It will take ages to collate all the data I have on this years Early Red F1s, but early (subjective) indications are very positive. As a taster here is a pic of a StupiceXLatah F1, before I pulled 956g of ripe fruit off it.

Tim DH

Steph S

Very nice pic of F1 fruit!   I hear you on the space issues, which I know all too well.  I used to always grow a parent or other standard to check for earliness, but in recent years I didn't spare the space.

It's good to hear that your indications are positive and already finding the creation of F1 recipes an interesting and rewarding pursuit.

Roland

I wonder if there really is that much hybrid vigor in the commercial F1 varieties and I think that mainly F1 varieties are produced so that you have to purchase seeds from the breeder again and again.

Because a tomato is a self-pollinator and the gene pool was already small in the domesticated varieties, I expect that all negative recessive genes have already been selected out and a cross will produce relatively fewer heterozygous gene pairs than, for example, maize.

Since it is assumed that the more gene pairs are heterozygous, the greater the hybrid vigor, it would be good to make F1 crosses with tomato varieties that have recently crossed-in genes from the wild ancestors.

Sungold F1 is believed to have been crossed with wild tomatoes, giving it its special taste and smell.
Therefore Sungold's OP lines would qualify as one of the parents to create an F1 that does show some hybrid vigor.

Think about:
Ambrosia Gold
Ambrosia Orange UBX
Ambrosia Red
Sungold Select
Sungold Select II
Big Sungold Select.
Netherlands

Joseph Lofthouse

I consider the term "hybrid vigor" to be a slick marketing campaign. What it really means, is that the cross grows better than the weak highly inbred varieties from which it was derived.

Hybrid tomatoes average 50% higher productivity than the stable open pollinated varieties from which they were derived.

The reason I introduced wild genetics into my tomato breeding efforts, is because domestic tomatoes, as a species, have become so inbred that there simply wasn't enough genetic diversity left to make much progress. You have to have diversity before you can succeed in plant breeding.

One study found more genetic diversity in one population of one wild tomato than in all the domestic tomatoes combined.


Justin Jardinier

#84
Quote from: Roland on 2023-08-17, 01:34:58 PMI wonder if there really is that much hybrid vigor in the commercial F1 varieties and I think that mainly F1 varieties are produced so that you have to purchase seeds from the breeder again and again.

After reading a thread about the financial side of tomato breeding, I think I can sympathise a bit more with that. Not sympathising with big companies, but small breeders, I could see how that would protect them at least from their seeds just being grown out by other people and sold by them, so the breeder's sales go way down due to being outcompeted by others who can easily sell their variety they spent years making. Though, those feelings do conflict with the general principle of seed saving, which is dear to my heart.

Quote from: Roland on 2023-08-17, 01:34:58 PMBecause a tomato is a self-pollinator and the gene pool was already small in the domesticated varieties, I expect that all negative recessive genes have already been selected out and a cross will produce relatively fewer heterozygous gene pairs than, for example, maize.

From what I understand, the situation is not as it was - so many of the modern tomatoes incorporate wild genetics, both the commercial types and also the ones popular with gardeners. Take the craze for purple colouring, with the chilense and Galapagos genetics. The cherry tomatoes with all that pimp genetics. The various disease resistances employing various species, and so on.

I think maybe I heard for some of the disease resistance in F1s, they need the heterozygous chromosomes to get some of that. So that might be rather significant too. Perhaps the good seed saving solution to that is domesticated SI populations like Joseph is working towards.


Quote from: Roland on 2023-08-17, 01:34:58 PMSince it is assumed that the more gene pairs are heterozygous, the greater the hybrid vigor, it would be good to make F1 crosses with tomato varieties that have recently crossed-in genes from the wild ancestors.

I think that's already the case. Not sure about vigour in particular, but in terms of disease resistance, one example I heard of is Purple Zebra. I don't know what was used in its lineage, but here's a quote on it:
QuoteHigh disease resistance to ToMV, Verticillium Wilt Va/Vd, Fusarium Wilt Race 1, Leaf Mold A-E, Late Blight PH2/PH3, and intermediate resistance to TYLCV and TSWV.

That's bound to have a relatively high percentage of wild genetics, no?

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-08-18, 12:01:25 AMHybrid tomatoes average 50% higher productivity than the stable open pollinated varieties from which they were derived.

Wow, I had no idea there was such a big difference! No wonder they're popular.

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-08-18, 12:01:25 AMOne study found more genetic diversity in one population of one wild tomato than in all the domestic tomatoes combined.

I wonder how long ago that was, and I wonder how the diversity compares today, with the widespread use of wild genetics in today's world of domestic tomatoes.

Another thought on that though - I get the impression that the way the corporations at least, use wild genetics, is more focused on money than deliciousness. So whilst I am really interested in their work for disease resistance, I am more interested in smaller scale breeders' work for deliciousness. So far the most delicious tomatoes I ate this year were one of Joseph's wildings and one of Lee Goodwin's 'Dwarf Hirsutum', both with habrochaites LA1777 in the mix so far as I understand.

William Schlegel

I thought my 2021 MMS x Unknown crosses produced seedlings more vigorous than their parents and my 2022 MMM x unknown crosses were less vigorous than the parent selfed seedlings. MMS is much closer to stability than MMM but I think it's possible for certain combos to be weak and certain strong.

Purple Zebra F1 wasn't that vigorous in my bad situation for tomatoes but good for my crossing success bed in the backyard last year.

Some stable tomatoes and even species like habrochaites and pimpinillifolium have very large vigorous fast growing plants and others just grow slower or stay small.

Staying small must be important to short seasonality as its fairly common in short season tomatoes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Nicolas

More than hybrid vigor, the interest of F1 hybrids for corporations, from a genetic point of view, is to be able to stack dominant genes for disease resistance from the two parents.

William Schlegel

Yeah I think that is why we have purple zebra F1 and Galahad f1 too even the small companies find it much more straightforward to combine two inbred lines to stack a large number of desirable introgressions into one generation.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

My Sungold F2 growouts have produced some pretty good tomatoes, but they definitely appear to be less vigorous and produce fewer fruit per plant than the F1s did.

Steph S

I'm not sure where the figure of 50% higher yield came from?
 
Some hybrids are outstanding for vigor, but there are OP's as well that stand out as really good producers. So depending on which hybrids are compared to which OP's, your stat will be different.

Just a quick google to satisfy my curiosity about hybrid tomato production, turned up several different results.
This study found no yield differences between locally adapted OP's and hybrids with or without drought stress.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2021.628537/full
Two other studies on the first search page found no significant differences, a third made reference to an old study that gave hybrids a 20-25% advantage.  All of these studies used different varieties in their trials and were carried out in different environments/parts of the world.
OTOH some really high values for heterosis in tomato are reported in a string of studies that are cited here:
https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4395/11/5/822

This article makes some important points about the dominance model of heterosis, ie where in theory, heterosis occurs because the inbred lines have accumulated recessive deleterious mutations, which are relieved by crossing with a dominant non-deleterious allele.

"Breeders have two alternatives—the extinction of deleterious genes by continuous selection, and the concealment of their negative action through heterozygosity [40]. Once deleterious genes are eliminated, pure lines become more important than hybrids. Crow [42] stated that if dominance or partial dominance are the causes of heterosis, it will be possible to produce pure lines similar to or better than hybrids. Powers [43] suggests that tomato lines equal to or superior to F1 can be created by selection. Williams [44] followed self-fertilization in two F1 commercial tomato hybrids and studied the possibility of fixing their vigor by creating inbred lines. In self-fertilized crops, such as tomato, which carry the lowest load of deleterious genes, additive genetic variation predominates, and it is always feasible to fix and transgress heterosis [26,45,46]. "

"Christakis and Fasoulas [48] concluded that continuous evaluation and selection could overcome hybrid vigor by exploiting additive genes. This is demonstrated by inbred lines that surpassed the performance of the original hybrids. Fixing heterosis and increasing inbred lines' productivity has already been achieved in tomato [45,49,50,51,52]."

Other models of heterosis may have different results. 

For example, here is a report of yield heterosis in tomato based on overdominance of a single gene, SFT, where the homozygous mutant is basically a very low production tomato with large fruit.
https://journals.plos.org/plosgenetics/article?id=10.1371/journal.pgen.1004043
The increased yield is due to a modification of truss architecture which only occurs in heterozygous condition.

However, this is not the only case, since the dominance model has been confirmed as well.
So it is all about the genetics of your specific inbred lines, which 'recipes' work to increase vigor, yield etc.  But if you do find a good recipe that is in line with the dominance model, there's nothing to stop you from fixing the high yield character by selection, if you want to do that instead of making F1 seed.

I do get the point that modern hybrids have disease resistance genes that are stacked.  And it makes sense, where there are multiple races of say Late Blight, and being heterozygous at one resistance locus means you can stack resistance to two of them instead of one, well that is an advantage.  Likewise if you want to work with SFT or another overdominance example, the F1 would be best.

I sometimes see a lot of variation in vigor in the F2 generation, so keeping in mind that dominance theory, for breeding beyond F1 it's necessary to always select the vigorous high producing plants to carry forward and grow enough plants/generations to eliminate a deleterious allele that might be lurking.