F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Vesa Tee

 Here is a 2021 pic of that Kotlas x pimp line  :)

ED2EE7F7-022A-46FA-9D32-00A5640F0AC7.jpeg





Tim DH

Hi Vesa,
   That's an interesting suggestion. Some seed sources suggest that ABC Potato Leaf is a wild tomato from N. Peru, so it could easily have S. pimp in it. (Or even be mostly/entirely pimp!)
   In the domestic tomato, classic Potato Leaf is a recessive mutation of the regular leaf form. However in S.pimp, Potato Leaf appears to be the regular leaf form, which would suggest it isn't a mutation AND it may not be recessive!

   I note that Kotlas is also a PL, but maybe its a classic PL, in which case you could get some regular leaved plants at F1 or F2 if the PL genes are different!

   Have you tried any S.pimp crosses with a regular leaf??

Tim DH

William Schlegel

#62
Oh, very interesting. I crossed the potato leaf dwarf Gloria's Treat with a mix of solanum pimpinellifolium and sweet cherriette pollen in 2022 and they are just getting true leaves. I do have substantial height segregation also. Though I also noticed that something about the leaves of my new pimpinellifolium accessions last year was very different with what I thought pimpinellifolium is supposed to look like. Broadening my understanding of the morphological diversity within Solanum pimpinillifolium. Unfortunately, I didn't characterize that difference. I've never thought of current tomatoes as potato leaved particularly but perhaps I just missed it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-04-15, 05:54:51 AMBroadening my understanding of the morphological diversity within Solanum pimpinillifolium. Unfortunately, I didn't characterize that difference. I've never thought of current tomatoes as potato leaved particularly but perhaps I just missed it.

I think it really depends. I think some have more a potato leaf like shape, it's just small, and others have more wispy broken leaves closer to traditional domestic tomato leaves. There really is a lot of variation between and perhaps within each species for sure. Sounds interesting though.

Would be interesting to grow all the domestic-like current tomatoes that people like to eat, including ones like coyote with the known wild accessions and see what differences there are.

Diane Whitehead

New Mexico State University took on peppers.  Maybe a university could do tomato research.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Vesa Tee

I didn't make any notes on my Kotlas x pimp cross but I think the F1 was very close to regular leaf domestic tomato and the pimp leaf type expressed again in F2. The leaves are smooth and hairless. The PL trait in my selection is coming from Kotlas, it is a whispy leaf thpe too (i.e. it has the SUN gene and has elongated leafs and fruits). The leaves grow really narrow and long later in the season, like the length of my forearm + hand together (50-60 cm). But it also has this smoothness and hairlessness from the pimp parent. I think the F2 generation had at least 4 or more leaf types, and I on purpose wanted to have the PL.

Tim DH

Hi Vesa,
   Your right about the ABC being almost naked. It is the least hairy of the eighteen cultivars in this grafting round. When I get my hand lens on the stem I can see it has loads of VERY short/fine hairs, many of which have a small drop of liquid on. I'm short sighted, so can see quite a bit of detail, but these hairs (and drops) are below my ability to resolve without a hand lens.
   Curiously ABC does have a few longer hairs on the 1cm of stem above the graft union! Below the graft union is a forest, as you can see from the earlier photo.

   ANYWAY: I'm comforted by your report that the Kotlas F1 was regular leaved. ... Thanks

Tim DH

By the way, I don't think grafting induces earlier flowering. My guess is that, if anything, it delays flowering whist the plant recovers from the surgery!

Tim DH

The variety 'ABC Potato Leaf' continues to surprise. The first truss is in full flower, where as seven other cultivars, (which have received identical treatment,) that all have recognized 'early' parents, have not opened a single flower between them! Tatiana lists ABC as a mid-season variety, so I wasn't expecting such super earliness. I can't imagine that ABC takes a  L  O  N  G  time to fill out its fruit, since it is a cherry variety. 

Incidentally, most of the stigmas are exerted. So I'll have to be careful, except that there is no other pollen around right now!

Tim DH

Tim DH

I'm trying to get smarter about the creation of hybrids.

These little black plastic spoons are great for collecting pollen. (AND they are really cheap.) I've decided to colour code the spoons so that I always use the same one on each pollen parent. This should reduce the chance of accidentally cross pollinating. I've labelled the spoon AND the top of the pollen parent's support string. When I attempt a cross, I'll also label the (female) flower with the same coloured tag.

Tim DH

Tim DH

Oops! ... Here is the photo!!

Tim DH

Of the four potato leaved cultivars I'm growing this year ABC is morphologically distinct. It looks much more like fasciation than the other three (Caitlin's Lucky Stripe, Galina and Cherry Brandywine) I wonder if it is mediated by a different gene?

I'm thinking sometime I might cross all my potato leaves with each other. Presumably if I cross two potato leaves caused by different genes then the F1 will be regular leaved. That way I'd get to find out how many different potato leaf genes I have. (Some of the F1s which are potato leaved might be interesting too! I've never come across a potato leaved F1.)

Tim DH

Hi William,
   Thanks for the references posted on the 'Dwarf Tomato Project 2.0' Thread. ...  I'm re-posting this one here:


https://library.ndsu.edu/ir/bitstream/handle/10365/8302/farm_49_06_04.pdf

Because it is a guide on how to make an F1 of a favourite mid season tom, that is earlier and more productive! (It is interesting to note the wide divergence in yield, depending on which Ultra Early was the seed parent.)

(I also appreciated the links to the lineage of Latah, my favourite [so far] Ultra Early, tho' sadly only its sister, Shoshone, was included in this trial)

Tim DH

William Schlegel

Tim,

I didn't realize that link included the links to the articles on Latah and Shoshone. I don't have those in my collection yet. It sounds like Latah is a non-dwarf sister line to Sandpoint.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-05-28, 10:32:53 AMI'm trying to get smarter about the creation of hybrids.

These little black plastic spoons are great for collecting pollen. (AND they are really cheap.) I've decided to colour code the spoons so that I always use the same one on each pollen parent. This should reduce the chance of accidentally cross pollinating. I've labelled the spoon AND the top of the pollen parent's support string. When I attempt a cross, I'll also label the (female) flower with the same coloured tag.

Tim DH
Sorry to quote you so many times in a row! Was going through your posts due to your climate being similar to mine. Anyway, in case it's useful for you, this vodka is 95% alcohol and available in the UK. I use it for making medicines (highly concentrated tinctures, like propolis for example), and just this week started using it to clean a pollen spoon too.

https://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/p/9042/spirytus-delikatesowy-vodka

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AMThe advantages of F1s, particularly in vigour, are well documented. What I don't like about them is ceding control over my seeds, plants and ultimately food, to anyone else.

I was thinking about something along these lines yesterday. Specifically, I was contemplating this chart:
Screenshot 2023-07-24 at 11.42.07.png

I'm interested in SI edible tomatoes, which I would guess is a way of maintaining the advantages of heterozygosity. But I'm also interested in facultative SC populations. In particular, in crossing with chmielewskii, which is facultative SC, or arcanum, which even among the SI populations, could give crosses that are maybe SC but have the flower structure for facultative SC, as might some other SI species.

So, I wonder if anyone has done any testing. I think a suitable test could be to get a healthy population of chm., then take let's say 5 or 10 plants, and self them every year, for 6 generations, thus making them 'stable' in the tomato breeding sense as shown in the image. Or maybe go to F8 even.

Then, grow out seeds from each generation. I say 5 or 10 plants to start just to make more data points for more reliability. So supposing it was 10, then it would be a growout of 80 plants if taken to F8. It would be very interesting to see the difference in growth, health, and disease resistance. Basically, rather than a comparison between 'stable' varieties with F1 'hybrid vigour', this would be a good way to see the whole spectrum. Like, at what point does the change become significant?

And with that information, we could apply that to aims for levels of outcrossing. For example, if most of the advantage is there at 25% heterozygosity, then having an outcrossing rate of around 25% might be great! Not sure if my maths is right there, might be a bit more complicated than that, but anyway, this could for example give the advantage of keeping diversity of genetics with the benefits that go along with that, as well as the variety being able to be grown by people who just want to grow 1 or 2 plants but still get fruits, which with 1 wouldn't work with SI and with a small number still might give few fruits or even none if the SI alleles happen to be the same, plus seed saving could lead to dangers for the SI system. If facultative SC with 1 or a few, diversity would wane but I think it would be less of an issue than the requirement of maintaining a tiny SI population.

Plus, if they had a functional UI system, their facultative nature could be protected from dilution from autogamous domestics.

I can't find info on the rate of outcrossing in chmielewskii, so it might actually be better to get a number of accessions, cross them all, and use the F1s as the starting point. But maybe also run it with single accessions to see how their standard rate of outcrossing compares.

I don't have time for such an experiment so I'm just thinking aloud really. But it would be interesting. Anyway I am hoping to get nice flowers from arc. and chm. and we already have nice flowers from Joseph's populations too. But I thought anyway both SI and facultative SC UI populations fit well with this topic, and contemplating the spectrum between F1 hybrids and autogamous SC may be useful. In particular, if we could get most of the benefits of hybrid vigour of F1 hybrids, in a sustainable population, for me that would be preferable. I guess this is a major aspect of the promiscuous tomato project.

That also makes me think of disease resistant F1s like Purple Zebra that may depend on heterozygosity. SI or facultative SC might be a better solution than simple dehybridization, which might not even be possible in that case.

One more thought on why I would prefer not to depend on F1 - if a region needs to depend on qualities from an F1 (due to climate, disease etc.), then that might rule out simple production of the parents to make the F1. I do think hard times are coming. So, I think the less we are dependent on having to grow parents in special conditions free from disease etc., the better. Though of course I do also appreciate and respect the whole F1 project.