Newfoundland tomato projects 2023

Started by Steph S, 2023-04-09, 01:05:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

Does the beta allele carry any known benefit to the plant that is unrelated to color?

I'm wondering if beta evolved and was preserved for some unrelated benefit in a solanum that apparently lacks the red gene needed to get the orange fruit. Or is it just a mutation with little selection pressure either for or against?

If beta is dominant, which I think is true, that could explain why it has not been eliminated in the absence of strong selective pressure against it.

AndrewB

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-06-04, 09:00:01 AMNice! 
Overall this bit of information reinforces the idea that all of the Beta tomatoes in circulation got the B allele from breeding with a wild ancestor somewhere back down the line, whether galapagense or habrochaites.  I wonder whether penellii has it too.
So cool that the allele was just waiting there in a species with no way to color its fruit!  Waiting for a cross with a relative, I guess.

I suspect S. pennellii has it too.

Here is photo of S. penellii F1 hybrid fruit. Quite light yellow like the habrochiates fruits. At least I think it looks similar to me.


Steph S

That's a pretty good glow, Andrew.

Colored fruit, according to the pundits, is attractive to animals and helps to disperse the plant's seeds.  Just speculating about an environment where S. pimpinellifolium has color and may enjoy better dispersal for that reason.  Habrochaites or pennellii (obligate outcrossers?) may benefit more from having a good group of their offspring in a patch in close proximity, where they can easily pollinate one another, than they would from longer distance dispersal by animal or bird.  At least until it is too crowded or there is environmental stress in the local microclimate.
In the case of a stress event, if their pollen could pollinate pimpinellifoliums in the area, then they could be dispersed away from the local area.  The Beta allele would allow that first generation to attract and be dispersed by animals again, while the F2 would to some extent revert to the previous fruit type, as William commented.  So by this time you are some distance from the origin and self-sow another patch of your Habrochaites or Pennelli type plants, and let the animals carry away any orange ones.
Not suggesting that this commonly happens (I have no clue and am just speculating) but it would be a hypothetical benefit in case of, for example, major climate shifts, as these are the times that interspecies crosses are favored in order to survive.
I suppose S. galapagense could have originated from a habrochaites in that way, with birds taking the orange fruit all the way to the islands, and leaving the green ones behind.

Vesa Tee

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-06-04, 01:23:05 PMDoes the beta allele carry any known benefit to the plant that is unrelated to color?

I'm wondering if beta evolved and was preserved for some unrelated benefit in a solanum that apparently lacks the red gene needed to get the orange fruit. Or is it just a mutation with little selection pressure either for or against?

If beta is dominant, which I think is true, that could explain why it has not been eliminated in the absence of strong selective pressure against it.

My understanding is that Beta did not actually express in those green or pale yellow wild tomato fruits. The carothenoid pathway stopped before there was any use for the enzymes that transforms lycopene to beta carotene. It only started to express after making the wild to domestic cross. There are no Beta wild tomatoes out there. It is an interesting question if there could be other benefits, maybe in the leaves or something. The same pathways are typically present both in leaves and in fruits, however, they are often because of a different gene position, e.g. there might be B1 and B2 genes (don't know for sure).

The enzymes for creating beta carotene are already present in domestic tomatoes, it is just down regulated soon after the ripening starts. Only a fragment of lycopene is transformed to beta carotene, then the enzyme is gone. The Beta gene is a fault in the down regulation mechanism which means that the enzymes are present longer and more lycopene transforms to beta carotene. It is like leaving a tap open and all water (= lycopene) is running away (to beta carotene).


Steph S

The weather has been so dreary this week, it's taking me days to tell red from gf flowers. Finally got over 70F for a couple of hours yesterday, and was able to confirm another red F2, unmarked for dark cotyledons.  I have two plants that have been stuck in the early opening stage for days.  I can tell that they are not tangerine already, but that's all.

WRT Vesa's tell with the dark green cotyledons, so far 2 of 3 marked F2 plants have indeed proven to have gf type flowers.   The third marked plant is one of the partly opened, so I hope to see it flower at least by Thursday when the forecast is brightening up. 
I didn't notice any cot color differences in the Bicolor Rumpus F3, but two gf type flowers have turned up. Since I wasn't expecting them I didn't pay close attention and may have missed the tell.  Will try again next season, for sure.
Meanwhile I haven't had any gf flowers turn up on any unmarked F2 plants either, at least not yet.
So it does seem that the dark green cotyledon is a good early tell for gf - thank you Vesa!

I also marked 5 plants for yellow cotyledons to see if that was a tell for tangerine.  Three have opened flowers, and there are two reds and one tangerine.  I also had an unmarked plant in the BND cherry which turned out to be tangerine. (This was also the one plant in that group with dark green leaves.  So in this case, there is no association between lighter leaf color and tangerine either.)  I have two more F2 plants which are on the late side marked for yellow cotyledon, but there's already enough evidence that the yellow cot is not a reliable tell for tt.

Regarding earliness:  It is interesting (and a bit frustrating) that F2 of the earlier F1 (Nev1) have all now opened flowers, while the later (Nev 2) has only one of six already open and as early as the first Nev1.  It reminds me that selecting away from earliness for any other reason, may take you down a path where earliness can't be easily recovered.   Also noting that the Yellow Project plants from last year, selected for taste and fruit size, haven't opened flowers yet although they're close.  So although not a large sample (only two were unbroken in the light crash and on track for 'normal') the earliness is clearly not an easy find. Well, they're just food this year, but food for thought too.

Mica Winnower

I was just reading earlier today, while talking about corn in a different thread, about epistatic vs hypostatic genetics.

My college textbook used Labrador retrievers as an example. Whether a dog is a black lab or a brown lab is a simple dominant/recessive trait. Yellow labs are ALSO, genetically, either black or brown, but yellow labs have a gene that blocks production of melanin in the fur, preventing expression of either black or brown, resulting in the ever-popular blond breed. In this case, yellow labs are epistatic over black or brown, which are hypostatic to yellow. (Because of this, you could potentially breed a yellow lab to a brown lab and get all black lab puppies).


The green fruit color of the wild S. habrochaites seem to be similar pigment-blocking epistatic genes.

I wonder whether this trait emerged before the divergence of the red/yellow fruit; or if colored fruit were the default and these pigment blocking genes appeared in a population of red-fruited ancestors, and then diversified.

Vesa Tee

Steph, that cotyledon colour trick has sure been useful already to myself too, a good example of something in the front of the eyes but so difficult to realize that there might be a more general pattern or a rule of thumb. Note that Roland already reported that heterozygote Gfgf seems to remain green in the dark too, so not all green cotyledons may express GWR fruits in the present generation. I think you have reported earlier that Gfgf fruits have more intense flavor which would be inline with this observation of Roland (of somewhat partial dominance of gf).

https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,794.msg12611.html#msg12611

Mica, the emergency of fruit colours before and after tomato domestication sounds like a good topic to investigate during long winter months. 😀 What comes to my mind now are the reports claiming that the first tomatoes arriving to Europe were not actually red but "golden apples".

On the wild tomatoes, I would have guessed that the red was the best colour to attract the birds, so which animals were then eating and spreading the seeds of these green when ripe fruits?

Steph S

Ah, I had forgotten the heterozygotes - but I did consider that perhaps the red fruited F2s with yellow cots might carry the t allele.   Still, in F2, you expect a lot of heterozygous plants, more than I marked I think. 
It could be quite useful to me, to also identify heterozygous gf plants by the cotyledons!
Since I will have to repeat the growout of Bicolor Rumpus looking for red/yellow instead of gwr/bi, I will be wanting to stabilize the dominant color without gf alleles.  So it would be a very big plus to use this test for the bicolor line which I want to stabilize.

Green fruits: they don't want animals to eat them or disperse them.  Because they are obligate outcrossers, they need to be near plants of the same kind to cross pollinate.  So the best strategy for outcrossers is for your fruit to fall to the ground uneaten, maybe rolling but not too far, and sprout seeds close to you in a dense patch, instead of being scattered far apart.


Vesa Tee

That was an interesting thing about the green fruits and outcrossing, never thought it from that perspective. That would actually make very much sense to me, not getting very far away from other similar plants.

I was also thinking if there could be some "colours" invisible to human eye that would still be noticed by some animals. Like in those pictures of how flowers look from insect point of view, with infrared filters or something.

Or maybe the odor for animals eating at night, like fruit bats, badger or similar that would not anyhow notice any colours. Badgers likes my green goose berries at least.

Steph S

TBH Vesa, I suspect that the smell of fruit is more interesting to many animals, and color is just a plus for some. 

This Nev1 tangerine plant has got a beautiful growth habit so far.  The two adjacent flower clusters add up to 15 counting small buds that are slowly coming on.  I really hope it's a good setter in spite of the cool and humid conditions, because a plant with 15 fruit in the first cluster is my kind of early.  This one is opening flowers in a third cluster as well.

I also have fruit set on Skipper Pink and the GWR Bicolor Rumpus.
Yellow Project plants are just opening flowers today.


Steph S

We've now had three full days of summer weather counting yesterday. Meaning that it got to 70F in the greenhouse before noon, and at least an 8 hour day of temperatures above 60F, ie a full day of growing instead of maybe an hour or three. 
The two earliest Nev F2s immediately popped up some of those ungrown sets after the first warm day.  That's a relief, although I don't favor plants that refuse to grow fruit in cool conditions, it's better than plants that would rather drop those blossoms than ever grow them up.  The earliest Yellow Project also had a first pea sized set after the warm day, although they flowered quite a bit later.
And maybe I'm judging too harshly, because there are a couple of Rodney's and one Skipper that hadn't grown a fruit yet.  So we are very scarce of degree days this season.  I flagged the plants that were quickest to set in both lines.  Rodney flowered later and is usually a bit later but I was glad to see some sets forming in spite of the cold.
The first hot day was moderated by intense haze and some cloud, so the greenhouse didn't go much over ambient, a comfortable 80F.  But yesterday was clear and sunny as well as hot, and temperature in the gh had shot over 100F by noon.  I set up fans and got it down to 90F but had to keep running them until nearly dark.  So this was a first heat stress day after so much cold.  Today was cloudy and warm, and I assessed the damage.  Most of the Skipper plants immediately dropped a blossom or two at the joint in upper clusters, which had been heat damaged.  None of the Rodneys dropped a blossom, which is consistent with previous years, that Rodney is a bit more heat tolerant. 

Final ratio of recessives in the Nev F2 lines:
1/12 gf
1/12 tt
5/12 sp  4 sp RT, 1 sp tt
In the BND cherry:
1/6 gf
1/6 tt
1/6 sp
Recessives in the Bicolor Rumpus F3
1/8 sp
3/8 gf
2/8 potato leaf

Steph S

While I was offline this past week without a computer I had the opportunity to take a few pics of flower tells at the stage of petal drop, that is as they are drying.  Now that I look at them, I see the light wasn't perfect and the specimens also not the best, but you can still see that the gf petal as it dries is very distinctive, with green markings.  It is quite easy to tell a gf flower from a rr flower at this stage, since the rr flower doesn't have those dark marks.

Steph S

Meanwhile, the environment x genetics effect of the year is DARKNESS.  Weather has been quite warm, and also very humid, yet continually overcast with very little sunshine.  My plants are enormous and fruit set is sporadic with some drops due to heat on all the plants.  While this has affected all genotypes, Rodney has done better than the others wrt both fruit set and growth habit, appearing to be more tolerant of both the heat and humidity and the lack of sunshine.   
I need to move around ten of the 28 plants outdoors and spread them out some.  They will set better outside and the remaining greenhouse plants will have less competition for light.  A bit late doing this, but so it goes...

Steph S

Well it's the rare year that I don't have a single ripe fruit by July 15!  None at the farm either.  Plants have been moved out, and it's plenty warm out there, a bit too hot in the greenhouse but keeping it down with fans.  The plants are dropping a few blossoms in the heat but still they are setting better than those early days and are actually growing fruit.  Skipper Pink for sure has full sized fruit on the plant, they just aren't ripening.   And Rodney is as usual losing fewer blossoms as a consequence of heat and setting really well those upper clusters.   Overall Rodney is less affected by the pressure of darkness to grow tall, compared to others.  Skipper Pink has gotten really tall, while the YP are a mixed bag.  Yellow Project plants are doing surprisingly well in foliage health this year, also in the heat tolerance, doing as well as the others.  The seed came from an outdoor plant, and maybe they picked up some microbiome friend?  Anyway it's good to see them in pretty green leaf and there's some decent set coming on as well.

We have a couple of hot but overcast days coming up.  If the RH isn't too high it might be an opportunity for a cross or two, so I'm mulling that over.

The Neville F2 are a motley crew.  The tt tangerine determinate is a bit lanky and viney, with a droopy open growth habit.  Fruit shape is nice, a small pointy heart but the size is pretty small so far.
The lone indeterminate Nev that I kept has gf flowers and perfect, medium sized heart shape fruit, with some set in every cluster, although clusters are only small - 5 flowers.  This plant is no larger than the determinates this season!  Yikes.  Anyway this one has the best fruit shape and 'gumption' for early set, but I'm not looking for gf so a cross would be necessary to select away from that (plus determinate and tt again).
The rest have red type flowers; the earliest is a salad sized looking round.  I think the most interesting is a later plant with large 'double anther width' flowers, open cup shape similar to some flowers that Kathy posted from her Wildings, and promising larger beef type fruit.   
All of the determinate growth habits for Nev F2s are fairly open, spreading or sprawling, compared to Rodney which is so ideally sturdy and structured for self support. So there may be room to improve the growth habit department.  This makes me less inclined to do a sib cross for other traits.
The Rumpus F3 determinate plant (dubbed Kelly's Island rumpus for the expected gf bicolor fruit) is probably the most outstanding plant of the season.  It didn't grow all of its first cluster set right away, but unlike some other plants that will leave the empties, this one is now growing them up.  The growth habit meanwhile has been continually putting out a new sucker below the terminal cluster and forking upwards. A giant of a plant loaded with flowers, with fruit setting in all the clusters pretty well.  A few heat drops but no more than Rodney, which is about my best for heat.   Anyway super vigorous, a bit resistant to the mites which are now infesting upper and outer leaves on most or all plants to some degree, and looks to bear a really good crop of good sized fruit.  Again I wasn't looking for gf, but there it is.
I do also have access to pollen from the farm, where there are 5 indeterminate Rumpus including two ultra early ones.
Oh and I have tt pollen donor in the BND cherry, but it's a ridiculous plant.  The whole group have that super long internode genetics out of Black Cherry, and the tt vine is enormous with 4 admittedly cute cherries on it.  Out by the door. 

With the best parent candidates all being gf, and nev having a gf allele floating around as well, IDK my chances of making any good shortcut crosses. 
Maybe the tt Nev and the beefy doublecone red sib is the only cross with a good chance of easily recovering tt without losing sp or increasing the chance of gf.


Steph S

It's been stinkin hot by local standards, running close to record highs day after day with no end in sight.  Luckily there's been some cloud and a few breezes.  So there's lots of fruit on the plants, and finally I have a few ripening.  Couple of the BND cherries which were early setters (non tangerine), the Skipper Pink are starting to come in, and the first of this GWR Bicolor Rumpus, which is so loaded that I did a count of pea sized or larger sets, around 50.  It ripened at the same time as the first Skipper.
To be tasted soon... it certainly is pretty!