peruvianum x pennellii, only SC penellii or also SI?

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-07-19, 05:36:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I know SC pennellii can pollinate peruvianum. Does anyone know if SI pennellii can also? And, if per SI x pen SI has been done, can anyone share about how that goes in the F1 and onwards, in terms of fertility and compatibility with itself or members of other species? I'm curious whether it might only be wise to use SC pennellii to avoid potential hazards of two SI systems interfering.

I'm also curious if the SI system from per can still be viable in populations of per x pen-SC populations, or if the SC in the pennellii breaks the per SI system somehow, and, if so, whether it can be reclaimed in later generations.

My reason for this interest in partly just to get per genetics into domestic populations, but also because I'm wondering if we can build a domestic SI system based on per., which could be cool, meaning we could grow hab. based SI domestics along side per. based SI domestics and save seed easily while keeping the lines distinct without any need for isolation.

AndrewB

#1
Interesting questions.

My memory is a little spotty, but I remember reading a paper on Google scholar that I think said even SI pennellii was still self compatible at something like 4%. That's not much, but more than zero.

I'm not sure if there is much literature on crosses between these two species.

Could they each have distinct SI systems? Maybe, I wouldn't know for sure. If they do, I would think they would exist in different parts of the plant. For example, Joseph knows a lot about the different alleles present in habrochiates, something like 4 combinations, I think. They don't like to pair up, but occasionally do (4%??). But they help to prevent selfing.

Pennellii has anthers that open in different ways than the other species, including domestics in that the pollen comes out sideways rather than at the end.  There could be another system that would reject pollen that was the wrong shape or size I suppose. But if it did, would this system interfere or complicate the other system? I don't think so other than adding another "padlock", so to speak.

I still think the best way to make intentional crosses between these two species is by using the info from the Patricia Bedinger papers from Colorado State University. Her research shows that most if not all of these barriers are not active if you catch a flower at something like -5 days to pollen maturity. The catch is that the stigma is not very receptive and lacks the sticky residue. Early experiments by me indicate that Walnut Oil may be an easy way around this. There is also a more complicated recipe we never fully replicated that used boric acid to activate the pollen.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-07-19, 01:10:04 PMInteresting questions.

My memory is a little spotty, but I remember reading a paper on Google scholar that I think said even SI pennellii was still self compatible at something like 4%. That's not much, but more than zero.

I'm not sure if there is much literature on crosses between these two species.

Could they each have distinct SI systems? Maybe, I wouldn't know for sure. If they do, I would think they would exist in different parts of the plant. For example, Joseph knows a lot about the different alleles present in habrochiates, something like 4 combinations, I think. They don't like to pair up, but occasionally do (4%??). But they help to prevent selfing.

Pennellii has anthers that open in different ways than the other species, including domestics in that the pollen comes out sideways rather than at the end.  There could be another system that would reject pollen that was the wrong shape or size I suppose. But if it did, would this system interfere or complicate the other system? I don't think so other than adding another "padlock", so to speak.

I still think the best way to make intentional crosses between these two species is by using the info from the Patricia Bedinger papers from Colorado State University. Her research shows that most if not all of these barriers are not active if you catch a flower at something like -5 days to pollen maturity. The catch is that the stigma is not very receptive and lacks the sticky residue. Early experiments by me indicate that Walnut Oil may be an easy way around this. There is also a more complicated recipe we never fully replicated that used boric acid to activate the pollen.
Hi Andrew,
My SC pennellii has the same flower structure, so I don't think that would be making them SI. Though for the traditional landrace system such styles would be very helpful if coming in the cross, increasing outcrossing.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-07-19, 01:10:04 PMThere could be another system that would reject pollen that was the wrong shape or size I suppose. But if it did, would this system interfere or complicate the other system? I don't think so other than adding another "padlock", so to speak.
Yeah that makes sense. However Joseph seemed to think that the 2 SI systems of hab and pen caused sterility issues in his project. Who knows, maybe it was not the SI systems but something else. But his counsel made me think it may be best to work with one SI system at a time. Hence me thinking that the per. SI system could be a nice one to go for. I think it could be cool to even make a series of SI edible tomato families, each using SI systems from different species, and each having numerous varieties, like cherry, salad, beefsteak, and variations for different climates, such that people could choose to grow a number of different types of tomato in their gardens suited to their conditions, but select each one from a different SI family, then not have to worry at all about isolation for seed saving, still being able to grow the same distinct varieties year after year, each population staying separate. If each SI variety were phenotypically stable (like traditional landraces), I think this could please a lot of people and really simplify things. And it would still have the advantage over SC landrace tomato varieties in that there would be genetic heterogeneity, so, easier to adapt quickly to local environments and also to our rapidly changing environmental conditions.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-07-19, 01:10:04 PMI still think the best way to make intentional crosses between these two species is by using the info from the Patricia Bedinger papers from Colorado State University. Her research shows that most if not all of these barriers are not active if you catch a flower at something like -5 days to pollen maturity.

Ah yeah, actually I did try that crossing per. to chm., though I am actually not convinced whether that chm. is truly chm. It smells nice but not strong lemony like another chm. I have. I should have tried crossing it normally too, to see if that would work! Anyway I tried it on about 6 flowers in series, so I guess -1 to -6, and 2 or 3 worked. Unfortunately I think I then lost those fruits somehow! Though I was only really doing it to test the principle rather than actually needing that cross. 

Right now I'm making as many cross attempts as time permits with SC pen. to a whole bunch of per. accessions.

I did try the walnut oil trick on some domestic-wild hybrids for per. pollen. None worked so far. But I think I have a successful pimp x per cross, without any special technique. Let's see once I grow it out... All the other per. crosses just gave embryos with no endosperm (unless I have more seeds drying that I didn't write into my notes yet). Same with using arc., almost all like that but in some, 1 or 2 proper seeds, and the seedlings look promising so far.

Justin Jardinier

#3
Thanks.

Ok so I've had a dig into my library. Here's a paper on the subject - I made some highlighting some time ago, sorry it's not a clean copy... ah, I can't find how to insert a document, so, the paper is 'Interspecific reproductive barriers in the tomato clade/ Opportunities to decipher mechanisms of reproductive isolation'.


And here are some extracts. Interesting to see SC hab. populations from different regions can't cross:
QuoteThe marginal S. habrochaites populations offer an opportunity to investigate the formation of reproductive barriers within a species. The loss of SI in the northern SC population is accompanied by unilateral intraspecific incompatibility. In these unilateral barriers, studied extensively by Martin (1961, 1964), pollen of the northern subspecies (known as f. glabratum under the Lycopersicon nomenclature) are rejected on styles of the central subspecies (formerly F. hirsutum). To add to the complexity, a SC population from southern Peru (Surco, Rio Rimac drainage) also rejects pollen of the northern SC accessions, and pollen from the southern SC habrochaites is also rejected on styles of SI accessions. The loss of SI in the northern (N) and southern (S) accessions occurred via independent mutations at more than one locus, as demonstrated from analyzing the progeny of N 9 S crosses (Rick and Chetelat 1991).

This part I had overlooked before:
QuoteHowever, pollen rejection in the SC species S. chmielewskii shows an exception to the SI 9 SC rule, because pistils of this species reject pollen from both SC and SI species, accepting only self-pollen and of that of S. neorickii.

Whereas we can't get any SI system from chm., if we could make a domestic-chm hybrid population that brings along the incompatibility with other SC species, this could also be a great way of making a traditional style landrace with a good rate of outcrossing due to flower structure, but isolated from other tomato populations. I guess unilateral incompatibility could be just as valuable as self incompatibility for protecting a landrace from dilution. In fact I might suggest that whereas SI is key to maintaining maximum crossing within a population (which is not necessary for a landrace though may be desirable); it's the inability to be pollinated by domestics that is, so far as I understand, the key to avoiding dilution and drifting back to the genetic makeup of regular domestic tomatoes. And having big showy exserted flowers but still being compatible with lyc., will I would assume make that drift all the more speedy, in non-isolated gardens. So, I seem to have overlooked this potential importance of merely UI species for landrace projects.

The paper goes on to explain:
QuoteWhether hybridization actually occurs depends on a number of factors including pollinator behavior, floral structure, the presence of prezygotic postpollination barriers and postzygotic effects.


It seems that UI is a mechanism in the style:
QuotePollen–style interactions comprise a major determinant of the prezygotic success or failure of interspecific crosses in the tomato clade (McGuire and Rick 1954; Hardon 1967; Liedl et al. 1996; Covey et al. 2010). A key question has been whether rejection of interspecific pollen in UI occurs through the same mechanisms as pollen rejection during SI. Hogenboom reported that rejection of self-pollen differed from rejection of interspecific pollen in S. peruvianum (Hogenboom 1972) but gave no details about this difference. Liedl et al. (1996) demonstrated that the extent of pollen tube growth in UI differs from that seen in SI in

S. pennellii pistils. In this case, pollen from cultivated tomato S. lycopersicum (UI) was rejected in the upper part of the style rather than in mid-style as was seen in SI. Further, they showed that pistils of SC accessions of

S. pennellii rejected tomato pollen tubes in the upper style, proving that an intact SI system is not required for UI. The pistils of SC S. pennellii accessions used in these studies (LA0716) lack S-RNase activity, strongly suggesting that this pistil SI factor is not required for UI in this species (Covey et al. 2010). ''Early'' and ''late'' forms of UI pollen rejection have been observed, both of which differ from SI pollen tube rejection, as shown in Fig. 4. Similar results were reported for S. lycopersicoides, another SI species (Li et al. 2010).

It mentions some other mechanisms for UI and then says:
QuoteThus, selecting for all the factors necessary for functional compatibility of pollen is not sufficient to confer a stylar UI response to the progeny. The implication is that UI responses of pollen and pistil are controlled by different sets of genes, as is the case for SI.

It goes into way too much detail for me to handle but in practical terms I guess we just test the F2 for the UI trait. And, I guess we should also check them for pollen sterility, which I guess would be more tricky to test for. So I guess keeping records for each plant by doing manual crosses and checking the results for them both as mothers and fathers, should be wise, so we don't end up saving seed from ones that have sterile pollen. Sounds a bit tiresome but I am guessing this would take more time on the F2 year to do but prevent problems for the coming years.

Here's a section that I don't really understand:
QuoteFunctional studies of UI

Plant transformation has been commonly employed in intraspecific SI systems to test the function of specificity determining genes (Murfett et al. 1992; Lee et al. 1994; Murfett et al. 1994, 1996; Murfett and McClure 1998; Schopfer et al. 1999; Nasrallah 2002; Nasrallah et al. 2007). For example, cloned S-RNase genes from Nicotiana, Petunia, and Solanum species cause rejection of pollen with specific S-haplotypes and demonstrate that S-RNase is sufficient to determine S-specificity in the pistil (Lee et al. 1994; Murfett et al. 1994; Matton et al. 1997). Similar experiments show that S-RNase is sufficient for certain interspecific pollen rejection systems. For example, pollen from the SC species N. tabacum and N. glutinosa is rejected on the SI N. alata pistil. These are instances of UI because N. alata pollen tubes grow vigorously in pistils of the SC species. However, these two UI systems do not strictly follow the SI x SC rule because pollen from

N. tabacum and N. glutinosa are also rejected by an SC

N. alata accession that does not express S-RNase. One potential explanation for this is that the UI mechanisms are entirely independent of the SI system; another possibility is that redundant mechanisms contribute to rejection of pollen from these species. To distinguish between these alternatives, the role of S-RNase in UI was tested by transforming SA2 - and SC10 -RNase from N. alata into N. tabacum and N. plumbaginifolia (Murfett et al. 1996). Transformed plants of both species gained the ability to reject N. tabacum and

N. glutinosa pollen showing that S-RNase is sufficient for this type of UI. Both SA2 - and SC10 -RNase functioned in interspecific pollen rejection, but in the intraspecific SI system each S-RNase causes rejection of only a single S-haplotype (Murfett et al. 1996), suggesting a lower level of specificity in UI compared to SI.

It is clear from other studies that pollen from these species is also susceptible to an S-RNase-independent rejection mechanism. Thus, N. alata possesses redundant

interspecific pollen rejection mechanisms for these two SC species—one mechanism requires S-RNase and one does not.

Structure–function studies using plant transformation suggest that S-RNases are uniquely adapted for pollen rejection. For example, Beecher et al. (1998) found that expressing a secreted non-S-RNase could not cause rejection of N. plumbaginifolia pollen. Further studies in the

N. alata 9 N. tabacum system showed that even an S-RNase thatwasmodifiedinvitrosothatit wasnotfunctional in SI remained active in interspecific pollen rejection(Beecher and McClure 2001), but, as in the N. alata 9 N. plumbaginifolia system, a non-S-RNase was not functional. Although these studies do not disclose the exact structural features that make S-RNase proteins suited for pollen rejection, the results strongly suggest that such adaptations exist.

I added bold highlight. Like I said, I don't really understand it, but to me (anyone welcome to correct me if I'm wrong!), it implies that whether there's 1 or more than 1 SI system, we can still have multiple incompatibility systems, due to the UI systems. So perhaps it could be useful to think rather than specifically of self incompatibility systems, just to think of incompatibility systems. Hence we could still, I hope, have mutually incompatible tomato landraces, some of which could be SC, some SI. Some not compatible with any of the others, some only UI towards some others. So that just as one can grow several different wild species of tomato in the same crowded garden without them homogenising, one could do the same with multiple edible landraces.

Doesn't really go to further my questions about bringing in the peruvianum SI system, but I suppose having contemplated all that, I guess it makes me consider this:
1) If there really is only 1 SI system among the tomato species, then if we were to eliminate the UI mechanisms, we could I would guess be able to make a population that brings together numerous SI species and could use the SI ... alleles?... from them but still make a functioning diverse hybrid mix. (Could be interesting to know if the SI mechanisms in those SI wildings etc. come from both pen. and hab. or only from one of them, though not sure how we could know that).

2) And on the other hand, if we want to make mutually incompatible SI populations, we need to take care not only of the SI mechanisms but also make sure to preserve the UI mechanisms, which I am guessing then would be different depending on which species.

3) If we want an SC landrace that won't get pollinated by other species such as lyc., we could take the UI mechanisms from an SC population such as neo., chm., hab., pen., or per. I wonder perhaps the SC pen., and chm., might be the better choices if we want higher rates of outcrossing, due to flower structure.

Justin Jardinier

Regarding the -days flower trick:

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-07-19, 03:32:32 PMAh yeah, actually I did try that crossing per. to chm., though I am actually not convinced whether that chm. is truly chm. It smells nice but not strong lemony like another chm. I have. I should have tried crossing it normally too, to see if that would work! Anyway I tried it on about 6 flowers in series, so I guess -1 to -6, and 2 or 3 worked. Unfortunately I think I then lost those fruits somehow! Though I was only really doing it to test the principle rather than actually needing that cross. 
Correction, I did not loose them! I processed them and put them to dry, I just forgot that! So, 2 of them worked.

Does anyone have Lee Goodwin's chmielewskii? Is it surely chmielewskii not peruvianum? Because if it is, then this was an unusual interspecial cross and could be a good support for this method. I'm just not so sure. If it were still inside, I'd try crossing various peruvianums to it in a normal way, to test, maybe it will cross easily? As it is, I put it outside after harvesting most of the fruits, so doing such a test reliably would be hard with the wind and pollinators. Actually another good test would be trying to cross it with my distinctly lemony chmielewskii and vice versa.