Tomato Flavor and Tomato Flavor Breeding

Started by William Schlegel, 2021-12-26, 12:50:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Roland

2021 when is selecterd the F2 it was a very whet and cold summer (most whet in the last 30 years). 2022 is a very hot and dry summer (most hot in he last 50 years).
So two extreem years and totaly different. Maybe this is why the F3 plant are so different in taste.
Netherlands

Adrian

#31
On some f1 with great diversity the fecondation is sometime not perfect and the fruit can stop her developpement more early or have the carachter of alone a parent.
Do you have harvested your 2 fruits on the same ramifications?
Sometime on a f1 a ramification can give a fruit different than the notmal ftuit given by the f1.
I'm sure that the microclimate can activated others genes (sometimes recessives).
My f1 between canestrino di lucca and andine cornue given sometime a potato leaf and sometimes a wispy leafs and in normal time a regular leaf.
A lot of tomatos had differents forms on the same plant: horned or ribbed

Steph S

It is really tough when you have a cross that has a lower ratio of tasty fruited plants.  I admire your perseverance, Roland.  I know it's a worthy project.   For myself, without the capacity to grow large numbers of plants, quite a few crosses reached a dead end at some point, because the taste wasn't there in the number I grew.
OTOH some crosses have good flavor genetics from the start and you get the opposite ratio - only occasionally there is a plant that isn't tasty, but most of them are, so you can select for other traits pretty freely.

I don't think I would ever get the combination of traits I wanted, including taste, without the practice of crossing my unstable generations to other (stable or unstable) plants, to try and roll up the traits that way.   It was Tom Wagner who turned me on to the notion of crossing unstable plants.  He pointed out that this maximized the amount of diversity represented in the next generation.  This makes it easier to select something unusual, without going through large numbers of plants.

You might consider doing a side cross between your line and another plant that has the taste qualities you are looking for.  Then grow it out side by side with the original project, so you have a benchmark for the disease resistance and other traits you were pursuing in the original, with the addition of some robust taste genetics.  Just a thought.   That is, if you are not at the limit of your space.

Roland

For me the strange thing was that the F2 all where good tasting and about 10% was superior. So because I took seeds from the best F2 plant I expected a high amount of F3 plants with good taste. Only again 10% was superior and some where tasting watery.
The watery taste is there if there is not enough acid in the fruit. The good taste is there when there are a lot of sugars with some acid.

So it seems im losing the acid in my selection.

In 2021 and 2022 I planted the bush tomatoes at 47,5cm in the row and the distance between rows 70cm. The plants got very big and wide because I didn't prune them.
For the F2 I grow 50 plants and for the F3 I grow 80 plants.

For 2023 im thinking to plant 34cm in a row and the distance between rows 70cm. I will prune all bush tomatoes to one central leader. Because of this I have more space for more plants.
So for 2023 I think I will use the 3 best F3 plants for F4 seeds and grow about 120 plants.

Netherlands

Cathy A

Quote from: Steph S on 2022-07-03, 05:47:39 AMI've only met a few tomato cultivars that produce better quality fruit in a cold season than they do in a hot one.  Moravsky Div is a standout for that.  The unripe fruit keep getting darker and darker green in the "too cold to ripen" situation.  Then when they do ripen, so packed with flavor...

Steph, will Moravsky Div ripen on the counter after picking? This could be an interesting variety for cold climates.

The challenge for me would be that some years (including this one!), we get a good spell of heat after the initial cold snaps or light freezes, but other years we don't.

Still, Moravsky Div might make interesting breeding material. I don't currently have any of the Stupice strains on the "to try" list, so this could be added.

Steph S

 Yes, M. Div should ripen off the vine if picked at green mature or breaker.
Most years we don't have a long enough warm season for all tomatoes to ripen on the vine.  I usually line a 1020 tray with paper and lay them out in one layer, then cover with another piece of paper to conserve moisture and ethylene for ripening. Check the trays periodically and take out the ripe ones when they're colored but still firm.  The single layer is important in case you get any spoilage, so it doesn't spread. Some tomatoes are more prone to spoil than others, for sure, but most varieties will do alright if they don't already have mold or decay on board.  Some people leave their tomatoes uncovered but I find they ripen better in the closed "box" situation.