Tomato Flavor and Tomato Flavor Breeding

Started by William Schlegel, 2021-12-26, 12:50:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Found and tried the first Mexico midget. A spitter.

Walt posted a comment on Facebook the other day. He worked with a pimpinillifolium that tasted good in the heat and bad in the cold. I think that explains alot.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

I can confirm lots of examples of tomatoes that produce crappy fruit in cold and good fruit in heat.  Indeed it's the key reason not to judge a tomato by its first fruit of the season, assuming a cold start.   You should definitely give the MexMidget a later tasting.

I've only met a few tomato cultivars that produce better quality fruit in a cold season than they do in a hot one.  Moravsky Div is a standout for that.  The unripe fruit keep getting darker and darker green in the "too cold to ripen" situation.  Then when they do ripen, so packed with flavor, I assume from the conversion of all that chlorophyll to yummy ripe things.

William Schlegel

I feel like I am starting to fill in some gaps on my knowledge of tomato flavor.

I am not sure I like purple tomatoes that well. Maybe just for variety?

I think I like bright and fruity flavors.

New flavor favorites so far for 2022: Dwarf Kelly Green, Dwarf Eagle Smiley, Dwarf Gloria's Treat, and Dwarf Saucy Mary.

Old Flavor Favorites: Coyote, Amethyst Cream, Sungold, The One, Yellow red bicolors including Big Hill, pineapple and several others including my Mission Mountain series. Also, the occasional red sweet cherry tomato.

Key take aways: Green when ripes can be even better, bicolors can be even better, there are more fruity cherries out there like Sungold. I probably don't like all the flavors. Some tomatoes that I heard rave reviews about all I get when I try them is hmm- very sweet.

More tasting needed even for many of these varieties. Barely tried Dwarf Kelly Green. Haven't eaten enough of some of the new ones to really get a sense for sure- like I may come to really like those purples eventually.

Definitely the time to try tomatoes in my garden. Next few weeks should be fun for this.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Lee Goodwin's Wild Gem is ripe and I got to taste it with a couple friends last weekend. One of them spit it. It wasn't great. I think it might be S. galapagense that is the unnamed wild parent from the jungles of Ecuador. I suspect that my terroir might be the issue- that is my soil lends something nasty to the flavor.

Another real spitter in my collection is the one I call Blue Golden Tressette. Whatever happened with that combination it is as bad as some of our habrochaites hybrids. Really pretty and interesting shapes though.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Just tried Tom Wagner's Muddy Waters. It's a keeper. That extra good green tomato taste, plus blue skin and stripes. I might prefer it for crossing to the two dwarfs with similar flavor. Would probably cross it to a dwarf from MMM x Aztek's upcoming F2 though.

Have dwarf orange cream here to try. Also taste patio round 2. The first taste patio might have been an off type but if the flavor is the same maybe just a weird shaped one. First one was good but Chile shaped.

Tried wild gem again. Just have the one I know where is at the moment. It's not terrible but it does have some yucky notes for me. Wish I had more plants to taste from.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

The F2 MMM that I crossed with Purple Zebra F1 and that particular fruit took forever to ripen? It also tasted on a par with the awesome Dwarf Gloria's Treat. Cross of ordinary bicolor flavor x Ordinary Bicolor Flavor. The plant has another green tomato on it now. Maybe it will ripen in the greenhouse and I can save its seed and see. Only other thing is I did fertilize with some fireplace ash. Genetics or just slow ripening?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Hard to say. I suspect soil type has a significant effect on tomato fruit flavor. I wish someone would do a taste test with a good but not amazing variety. Plant some in your native soil and some in raised beds or pots or all three. Then do taste test comparisons.

Roland

One of my Galahad F3 plants is very inconsistent in taste. The brix content is also very variable. For example, I have fruits with Brix 5.0 that taste a bit watery.
But I also have some fruits with brix 7.0 Brix 7.5 and even last week a fruit with brix 8.0. Also this week various fruits with brix 5 and watery taste.
All the high brix fruits taste particularly good and are this year's best compared to about 100 other plants and varieties.
So that taste is particularly good.

How come the fruits differ so much in taste?
And what can this mean for the next generations?
Netherlands

Nicolas

Carole Deppe has written about the taste of tomatoes, that is not very good if harvested when weather is cold and humid.

To her, tomatoes harvested few days before total ripeness way day is warm and then let in the room a few days is better than fruit harvested at maturity but on a cold day.

There were some discussions here about solanum pimpi that tasted awful at the beginning of the season and better when days were warmer.

Roland

Strange thing is that i Harvest a Brix 5 fruit at the same moment as the Brix 7,5 fruit?
Netherlands

William Schlegel

That is odd inconsistent on the dame plant at the same time.

I had some plants of Dwarf Gloria's treat that produced small incredible flavored fruits in droughty patches of poor soil.

Over in better soil and more water I had one plant also Dwarf Gloria's treat which had large fruits. They all split though and now I can't remember if they were as good but I doubt it.

I think I need to water less.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adrian

#26
I have tryed this summer to grow a plant of canestrino di lucca x andine cornue in pot  always irrigated and with chicken manure NPK 4-3-2,5 and potting soil with 200-500mg/l of N,130-1300mg /l of P2O5 and 340-2550mg/l of K2O.The chicken manume manure is eaven rich in oligo elements ( trace elements) The leafs was very large and dark greens.The fruits was very bigs and very tasty for fruits picked this week.More tasty than the tomatos in fullground.
I think really that the taste and the sugar rate are correlated with the photosynthesis quality.I try to have balance diet fertilisation and steady humidity of the potting soil for avoid eaven the BER.

For me more the photosyntesys in intens more the tomato plant can product chlorophlasts who contributed at the sugar rate in the fruit.

My tomato plant drank 2l of water each days at the most hot of the summer (sometimes more i think fulled two time per days the bassin the mosts hots days).I have put the pot in a basin of 2l that i fulled each days.
I watered at top alone when i put the fertilizer.I watered mainly in the bassin under the pot.I have rarely see a so vigorous plant.

I think we can reduce the watered not long time before the maturity of the tomato as a melon for get the better taste.

But the watered is extremly important during the grow, the flowered and  the get fat step.
With my method the watered was eaven regular.
The potting soil was always humid.

Adrian

For example you can see a fruit harvested today of my plant canestrino di lucca x andine cornue f1 who has grow  in very goods conditions

Steph S

It's certainly true that soil conditions and weather conditions can affect the taste of tomatoes.  Some plants do seem to be more variable than others though.

Roland, for the question of two tomatoes equally ripe on the same plant which taste differently and have a big difference in brix, we have to think about what are the differences in environment for one fruit vs another on the same bush.   The amount of sun or shade, and the temperature in the microenvironment of the fruit, those are the obvious variables. 
Then think about fruit flavor and how it develops. These are biochemical processes involving enzymes.  Tomato flavor process is notoriously temperature sensitive, flavors don't develop well in the cold. But heat may also impair enzymes.  You can get better flavor and quality by picking at breaker and bringing indoors when the weather is too hot, as well as too cold.
For an F3 that has very variable fruit quality, I would venture that some enzyme involved in developing flavor has an allele with a narrower temperature range for optimal activity, sensitive within the range of temperatures in the canopy, which had a reduced function in the microenvironment of the less tasty fruit.
So if you really feel this plant has the best fruit compared to other sibs and want to grow it forward, in future generations, you would want to select away from that trait of variable fruit quality.
I have always selected away from plants that were inconsistent tasting, so I don't know if one weak allele would produce this effect or if it shows up only when homozygous,  but at least you can hope that it is still segregating, grow a generation and see if you can find a more consistent F4.


Roland

Thank you Steph,

in F2 I selected a plant with very good taste. 3 out of 50 tasted exceptional. This is why I thought that this good taste is mainly determined by recessive genes.
However, now in F3 I only have 5 exceptionally good tasting plants out of 54. However, evolution in the brix can be seen.
F1 Brix 5.0
F2 Brix 6.2 at the selected plant
F3 Bix 6.0. 6.5 and 7.5 for the 3 selected plants.

Because there is still so much variation in the taste of the F3, I assume that the genes that determine the good taste were not homozygous in the selected F2 plant.
This is why I think that many genes work together and that they can therefore be heterozygous in order to still get the good taste.

I think you have a point that in this F3 plant with variable flavor in the fruits, maybe microclimate activates other genes.
Hopefully I can capture the good taste in F4.
Netherlands