F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

Yeah in my mind it would make sense to first make the cross homozygous for PH-2 and 3 before making a public F1 from it, otherwise many of the seeds wouldn't even have any PH-2 nor 3. Though for more experimental people, they might like it for finding their own more resistant ones among a patch of them, for them to do the rest of the breeding work on their own. That would seem more exciting than just trying to grow F2 from commercial F1 heterozygous LB resistant varieties, like Purple Zebra.

Tim DH

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-27, 03:47:40 AMHave you thought of making an F1 cherry by using something like PI 270443, the pimpinellifolium with the strong 'PH-5' late blight resistance, as a parent? (As male parent would be best if you want domestic seed size).

Hi Justin. ... Interesting idea, but it falls a little outside my concept of F1s for the People! since the parents of any published F1 should be freely available. Is PI 270443 truly in the public domain?

Tim DH

Nicolas

Not sure an F1 with a pimp cultivar is worthwhile because it is strongly dominant in all the traits i can think of, so even if disease resistance is cool, there would be no to little variation in fruit size or color or in plant overall architecture.

Nicolas

Well it seems that you get somewhat bigger fruits

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/337409801_Production_and_characterisation_of_tomato_derived_from_interspecific_hybridisation_between_cultivated_tomato_and_its_wild_relatives

not sure about this chart some bars seems to be wrong/mixed (ly2 vs pi4 for example)





QuoteComparison of hybrid fruit with their parents fruit. LY1, LY2, LY6, LY7, LYD1; Solanum lycopersicum, PI1, PI4, PI8, PI9, PI11; Solanum pimpinellifolium, AR; Solanum arcanum, PE4; Solanum pennellii.

William Schlegel

#124
PI numbers come from USDA ARS-GRIN they usually release material without a MTA of any kind in my experience including when they sent me PI 270443 after someone on the forum shared a link to a thesis suggesting it is the source population for PH5 and I requested it two years ago. I believe that makes it public domain as it is unimproved wild material. It is also how many heirlooms now offered by seed companies returned to the public in the United States. Heirloom enthusiasts or catalogues requested them from USDA and sometimes state the PI number in their descriptions. I grew out some seed and shared it with a seed company which may choose to release it at some point. I could grow more seed if it is needed but I expect the seed company may do so. I also sent some hybrid F2 generation seed with OSSI ancestry as part of a larger grex to that same seed company. I would have seed saved and sent the component crosses individually but I ran out of energy during field season. I have about five new crosses now with the F1 at the 1/4 level so I expect to have some size recovery in 2024 between that and the F2 of the original cross.

The cherry tomato F1 idea would be an interesting way to use the material, The F1 with my MMM cross between Mission Mountain Sunrise and Big Hill HX-9 was remarkably uniform in size. I made similar crosses with the other USDA pimpinillifolium accession I requested and all three crosses were remarkably uniform red cherry tomatoes. I did in a prior post in this thread and do still wonder though if a orange parent might be at least co-dominant in the F1 and give a bit of a fruity flavor.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Nicolas

The cultivated cultivars have relatively small fruits, the loss of fruit weight in the hybrid would be more visible with bigger cultivated cultivars i guess

William Schlegel

Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-11-28, 04:44:44 AMThe cultivated cultivars have relatively small fruits, the loss of fruit weight in the hybrid would be more visible with bigger cultivated cultivars i guess

The three pimpinillifolium hybrids I made in 2022 with Dwarf Gloria's Treat a larger beefsteak and Mission Mountain Morning a smaller beefsteak as mothers produced indistinguishable red cherry tomatoes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-11-28, 01:31:21 AMHi Justin. ... Interesting idea, but it falls a little outside my concept of F1s for the People! since the parents of any published F1 should be freely available. Is PI 270443 truly in the public domain?

Tim DH
On the lyc side, you could always breed that ph-2+3 homozygous parent and release it. On the pimp side, good point - that would depend on the seed transfer agreements for whichever institutions hold the seed. I haven't looked into it. Going around that a way would be just to breed a homozygous PH-2+3+5 OP, which you could then make public, but then that wouldn't be an 'F1 for the people' anymore! Would be super useful though. Edit: Ah that's good news William, that that pimp is free to use. Leaving my comment however, since it applies at least to much other genebank material and is worth bearing in mind, we can breed with non-public accession and make the results public, which is a nice way to make unavailable genetics, available.

 
Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-11-28, 02:28:52 AMNot sure an F1 with a pimp cultivar is worthwhile because it is strongly dominant in all the traits i can think of, so even if disease resistance is cool, there would be no to little variation in fruit size or color or in plant overall architecture.

Not sure I get the point about variation - F1s are homogenous, all alike, no? If the lyc parent were large enough, couldn't the resultant cherry be a good cherry size? And if the lyc parent were late (which I imagine would be likely with a large one), maybe not too much problem since only the people making the F1 seeds would have to deal with it, so they could use a greenhouse if in a shorter climate area. I don't know how early that pimp is but I would assume the F1 could be significantly earlier than a fat lyc mother.

Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-11-28, 04:39:16 AMhttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/337409801_Production_and_characterisation_of_tomato_derived_from_interspecific_hybridisation_between_cultivated_tomato_and_its_wild_relatives

Interesting paper. Very strange that the 'arcanum' fruit is orange with red interior, with red F1 cross. Something seem very wrong there, arcanum has green fruits, and the F1 should be yellow or yellow-orange! I also find it curious that whilst they said their seed was from the TGRC, so far as I could see they gave no accession numbers. Perhaps their 'arc' was actually an arc hybrid used for breeding?




Nicolas

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-28, 08:15:58 AMGoing around that a way would be just to breed a homozygous PH-2+3+5 OP

There is no way to select for Ph2/Ph3/Ph5 with any certitude before there is any genetic marker for Ph5 selection, because Ph2+Ph3 is already at nearly 100% resistance.

QuoteNot sure I get the point about variation - F1s are homogenous,

Yes, i meant variation between the wild parent and the F1.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-11-28, 08:29:04 AMThere is no way to select for Ph2/Ph3/Ph5 with any certitude before there is any genetic marker for Ph5 selection, because Ph2+Ph3 is already at nearly 100% resistance.

Ah, I didn't realise they don't yet have the ability to identify the markers for PH-5. In that case I would propose 2 possible strategies:
- Maintain a PH-2+3 population, and a separate PH-5 population which could be stabilised with basic late blight infection tests or field trials. Both should do great for now. At some stage one or the other may fail as LB adapts.
- Have a largely outcrossing population with both PH-2+3, and PH-5 parentage. Allow environmental selection. Might not be as blight proof as the above 2 populations, having varied resistance, but, as a population it might be able to outlast both of the above, if some members acquire all 3 resistances.

Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-11-28, 08:29:04 AMYes, i meant variation between the wild parent and the F1.

Ah I see. Do you not find lyc x pimp with a large lyc mother, to have reasonable cherry sized fruit and the possibility of having good general characteristics?

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-11-28, 02:28:52 AMNot sure an F1 with a pimp cultivar is worthwhile because it is strongly dominant in all the traits i can think of, so even if disease resistance is cool, there would be no to little variation in fruit size or color or in plant overall architecture.

I just posted some pics of a pimp x lyc relating to this, but related a bit more directly to another topic so I put it here:
https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,901.30.html

Tried to tag you but seems maybe tags don't work on this site?

Roland

This research shows that it is rare to find superior F1 Hibrids from crosses of open-pollinated varieties. 11 crosses out of 163 turned out to be slightly better than both parents. And they haven't even selected on taste yet.

https://edepot.wur.nl/392148
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

#132
Interesting. Their criteria:
QuoteIn judging the hybrids we had the following ideal tomato in mind: it should be suitable for growing under glass in the Netherlands; set fruit easily, even under less favourable conditions;givefruits preferably weighing 65-85gramseach,which should be entirely round, not ribbed, without irregular scars, a good uniform colour both internally and externally, not liable to fruit defects such as green back and blotchy ripening, and sufficiently firm for transport. It should ripe early and preferably be resistant to the most important diseases.

The yield increase charts are interesting. Also I was reading a paper today which might be of interest for this thread - 'Bad seeds: How the parental lineage may determine viability in tomato hybrids':
https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/656072

It's about interspecial crosses but it may still have general relevance for potentially some other epigenetic effects. Here's a quote:
QuoteThe new study by Ana Florez-Rueda et al., published in the advance online edition of the journal Molecular Biology and Evolution, has evaluated whether the fascinating and complex phenomenon of epigenetic genomic imprinting (a parental maternal or paternal bias as to whether or not a gene is turned on or off in the offspring) could be contributing to the seed deaths. Genomic imprinting is known to be important for normal seed development in flowering plants and primarily occurs inside the nourishing endospermcompartment of the seed, which contains a triploid genome with a 2:1 ratio of maternal to paternal genomes.

Here's the study they refer to, Genomic Imprinting in the Endosperm Is Systematically Perturbed in Abortive Hybrid Tomato Seeds:
https://academic.oup.com/mbe/article/33/11/2935/2272474

Adrian

#133
In the most part of cross, the medium yield and number of fruit are in increassed but the fruit weight is more low and the final yield is finaly sometimes inferior.This study is unfortunately based on the weight and the yield of the fruits but she don't take the others parameters as the leaf morphology probably more important for me for improve the yield.
For exemple
strong and small leaf x thin and large leaf = strong and large leaf: umprovement of the vigor and indirectely the yield because photosynthesis is more efficient. 

When i make a cross i search to improve the photosynthesis before yo think at my yield.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Adrian on 2024-01-10, 03:34:26 PMstrong and small leaf x thin and large leaf = strong and large leaf: umprovement of the vigor and indirectely the yield because photosynthesis is more efficient.

Would that make more fruit weight per square metre? By this I mean, if the leaves are bigger, maybe the plant takes up more space and/or shades neighbouring plants more, and maybe there is a photosynthesis limit per square metre of plot? I'd be interested in any feedback on this variable.