Tomato Brown Rugose Fruit Virus (ToBRFV) Resistance or Tolerance Breeding Thread

Started by reed, 2020-02-10, 06:15:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

This seems to be a good example of a case where we would want to breed in horizontal resistance, rather than vertical resistance.

Including a bunch of genes, each of which gives ~40% resistance through different biochemical pathways, would be a better long-term approach than finding a single super-resistant gene that could suddenly become susceptible after a single mutation of the TBRF virus.

So I am actually more excited about a bunch of ~40 resistant accessions than a single highly-resistant one.

William Schlegel

I think even with the 20% category it is still more of the quantitative sort and tolerance not resistance. I think that is fine because tolerant plants can coexist with the virus. This is a case where it would be nice to have more resistant accessions as they could be additive.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

It sounds like no one has identified a truly resistant (not just tolerant) gene or strain?

William Schlegel

The paper about wild accessions identifies I think two strains of Solanum ocranthum with the ability to clear the virus after infection. So true resistance or a immune system response. However, transferring that might be a slog for a PhD tomato breeder with funding.

Some of the commercial large corporation efforts, some of which may have utility patents, also claim high levels of resistance but they don't reveal any details! The utility patents might reveal some details if we could find them.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Did some reading about this virus today, and regulations affected seed trade between Canada and US.  In fact you cannot send tomato or pepper seeds to the US from Canada any more without a phytosanitary certificate. I was surprised to hear that. 
But actually, the virus was identified in Ontario, Canada in 2019, and although it isn't widespread or anything like it, regulatory decisions are different between countries.  Both Canada and Mexico treat the virus as 'non quarantine' organism, that is to say, they do not test or restrict incoming market fruit.  But the US is in virus 'lockdown' so the intention is to contain or prevent any infection, and that means your incoming fruit crops should be well screened as well - ours are not (and apparently, there are currently no other imported crops being screened for disease which are meant for the table).
Looks like countries worldwide have put some restrictions on seed import/export to reduce seed transmission risks - This also explains the uptick in postal restriction on seed exchanges to the US.  You can't send any type of seeds by letter mail any more, it has to be parcel post with a declaration of contents.  Same chilling effect (cost of mailing parcel post) the other way too, from US to Canada.

Also found this recent work, which confirmed the pollen study cited above, that the virus is not in the embryo, only in the seed coat/endosperm layers.  As such the seedborne transmission rate depends on injuries that occur naturally during germination and infect the seedling in a small percentage of cases.  2.8% infection rate was found in this study n=500.  So that is pretty low.  Also, sterilant procedures do work to remove virus from the seedcoat.
https://mdpi-res.com/d_attachment/plants/plants-09-01615/article_deploy/plants-09-01615-v2.pdf?version=1606046733
So I think this is quite good news for the question, how big a risk are you facing of infection from random sprouted seeds from supermarket tomatoes that develop into virus carrying plants. And the opportunity is there, if really worried about contaminated seed, to use a seed treatment prior to planting.

I also suspect that, with such a low transmission rate in germinated seeds from infected fruit, the infection rate in resistant/asymptomatic plant seeds would probably be even lower???  It just stands to reason (but I may be wrong?) that virus load would be lower in a resistant and asymptomatic plant.

The other interesting thing is that this virus doesn't occur at all in the field crops in Canada.  It only occurs in greenhouses.   Documents from the EU and US also mention greenhouses specifically.  The problem is that in these environments where plants are continually pruned and tied in order to manage high densities, the virus spreads quickly and affects the whole crop.  And it's very persistent on surfaces, which puts your infrastructure investment at risk.  So here you have a virus problem that affects commercial greenhouse growers specifically because of the process involved in the cultivation design.  Even a small percentage of seed transmission could take down the intensive greenhouse crop.
But unless a home grower is using the same high pruning high contact designs, there's little chance of being affected in the same way.   If the virus did turn up on a plant that isn't being heavily pruned and daily handled along with others, you could (probably) effectively rogue it out early on, and contain the spread.

There is a possibility that some weed species could become a reservoir of virus carriers.  So there have been tests on experimental hosts.  Petunias, quinoa, tobacco and a few others.  If the virus became endemic in wild/weedy hosts, then it might start to turn up more often in a field situation.
The other scary issue I saw, is that the virus can be transmitted by bumblebees during pollination.  That would not be good!

Steph S

Here is a useful reference for the symptoms you might look for to rogue out infected plants.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/epp.12891?af=R

This one cites another 2022 study for the rate of seedborne transmission - only 0.08% !!

William Schlegel

That sounds good. If ToBRFV doesn't spread easily in my outdoor growing non-pruning ways and I have some genes out there that could slow it down a bit and can disinfest seeds. It should be manageable if and when it gets here.

For the most part tomatoes die from frost here not disease.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

I admit I am not one of those people who loves to prune, for starters.  But also in my early trials of heirlooms and OP's, I found that pruning cuts in cold wet seasons were associated with disease.  It's just too easy for a wound to become a site for the various molds.   True you can mitigate by dipping pruners in bleach every few cuts, but that is also an extra cost and hassle.  And the investment of time in pruning vigorous indeterminates is high.
So it didn't take much experience to settle on the idea of getting heirloom-worthy flavor into plants that don't require any pruning at all, and to focus on rugged cold tolerance and disease resistance for a grow that takes the least amount of labor.
No regrets on that decision!

Kadence Luneman

Just saw this on a group. So it is definitely around. Thought it was pertinent to share here.

Steph S

Oh, that is bad news!  I wonder how this happened, and where the F1 'Brandywise' seed is produced.

Just noted there's no mention of the virus issues on their page, although they say it's out of stock:
https://www.fruitionseeds.com/shop/vegetables/tomatoes/slicing-tomatoes/organic-brandywise-tomato/

One thing that specifically bothers me a lot about the commercial seed industry, is the production of seed in third world countries, where workers are paid very little and endure some bad work conditions as well.  Meanwhile there is a higher risk of the ToBRFV in the hot climate countries as well.  Of course if the alternative is greenhouse seed production, the same high risk applies.

Cathy A

"For the most part tomatoes die from frost here not disease."

I've seen it go both ways.  Some years the plants turn brown and stop producing leaves and fruit without quite dying, well before frost. Other years they keep producing right up until frost.

Amish Paste did that to me last year. Poor production of stems, leaves, and fruit, few tomatoes per plant, and tasteless. I won't grow them again.

This can actually be an advantage for those of us in the northern climates. The season is shorter, so less time for the plants to become fully infected, and the cold winter kill a lot of overwintering infectious agents. I don't compost tomato plants because of the risk of carrying infection, but just dump them in my woods well away from the garden. Viruses, bacteria, etc. will find it harder to survive on bare ground at 0 F (-18 C).

Keeping tomato plants disease-free during a long growing season sounds very challenging.

Kadence Luneman

Ya I tried searching for more info and the only things I found was more posts by people talking about it that had bought them from there. Like reddit posts and forum posts.

Steph S

I found it on their blog.  It was greenhouse produced, being an F1, not in their fields, and not affecting their other seeds.  Sad news all the same!
https://www.fruitionseeds.com/learn/blog/tomato-brown-rugose-virus-humbling-news-how-we-move-forward/

Roland

Netherlands

atilgan

I tried so many disease resistant tomatoes to overcome the disease we have in our community garden. Ankara/ Turkey 7b. Nothing worked. I posted pictures in tomatoville and eventually realized that it was tobrfv. After reading somewhere that some wild cultivars was resistant I tried  wild tomato crosses I purchased from EFN. These were wilding panamorous (WP) and Q-series panamorous (QP) and I believe one other. First year I tried 3 plants of WP. One died but not because of tobrfv.  The other two were extremly profilic and had no disease. Every other tomato including galahad and big beef died of the disease. The fruits of this tomatoes were small and the taste was bland. This year I only tried WP and QP and a commertial variety that claimed some resistance. That commercial variety showed little resistance and died. Some of WP's this time got the disease.  Some only had it on the leafs while some on the fruits and I ended up culling them. Remaining WP's had again small off tasting tomatoes (to my taste) and I let the neighboors have them. Many of the QP's eventualy got the disease but two black ones and a pink one were not effected at all. They had sunburn so I had to provide some shade. While the fruits were perfect looking taste was just average. I collected seeds and I will try to cross them with now commercially available tobrfv resistant high brix cherry varieties to improve their taste.