Tomato Brown Rugose Fruit Virus (ToBRFV) Resistance or Tolerance Breeding Thread

Started by reed, 2020-02-10, 06:15:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Atilgan, that is very cool! Joseph worked hard to create populations like those as part of his promiscuous tomato project. So it is very neat that they had some utility for this problem of the brown rugose fruit virus.

I hope the commercial tobrfv tomatoes are another good source of genetics and that the corporations involved are not legally protecting them from use for breeding.

When this problem first came to my attention a few years ago (Thanks to Reed) I looked around for genetics and all I was able to get to use was an accession of current tomato called LA1375 that is known for having some tolerance. I've crossed it into my tomatoes in anticipation that the virus may get here sometime. I've shared some of that seed with the Experimental Farm Network. I have a great deal of tomato genetics from Joseph's promiscuous project so it is good to hear that there may be some resistance or tolerance in those genetics as well.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2022-01-11, 06:10:38 AMhttps://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s41348-021-00535-x.pdf

New article about (ToBRFV) The Brown Rugose Fruit Virus listing some resistance that has been found from 636 wild species accessions found about 31 resistant accessions or about 5 per 100 accessions.

I also notice that many galapagense got 60% disease severity there, including LA1410. LA1400 impressively got 20%. Cheesmaniae LA1409 was 40%.

I'd be curious if these kind of percentages of 40~60 are enough to be of significant value in an outbreak.

Then, did any of you notice this article? Same authors - Evaluation of responses to tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) and selection of resistant lines in Solanum habrochaites and Solanum peruvianum germplasm - 2022
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10327-022-01055-8

QuoteReactions of plants in 173 wild tomato accessions belonging to Solanum habrochaites and S. peruvianum were studied by inoculation with a tobamovirus, tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV). Around 10–50% of plants in nine accessions of S. habrochaites and one of S. peruvianum were demonstrated to be highly resistant. Resistant plants showed no symptoms at 22–24 °C, and no virus could be detected in their inoculated and newly developed leaves using bioassays and RT-qPCR. ToBRFV-resistant plants were also resistant to tobacco mosaic virus and tomato mosaic virus.

QuoteSymptomatological observations revealed that following three inoculations with ToBRFV, a number of plants in nine accessions of S. habrochaites (LA1738, LA1739, LA2171, LA2541, LA 2812, PI 308,182, PI 379,012, PI 379,014 and PI 390,659) and one of S. peruvianum (PI 308,181) remained symptomless both locally and systemically after 40 dpi (Table S1). The presence of asymptomatic and symptomatic individuals at different frequencies (2–10 resistant plant out of 15 inoculated) clearly showed that these accessions segregated for the type of reactions to the virus (Fig. 2). No symptoms were also detected in the cuttings that originated from rooted shoots of the symptomless plants after inoculation with TMV and ToMV after 40 dpi (data not shown).

So any of that material might be of interest.

Then addressing the above comment:
Quote from: atilgan on 2023-12-24, 03:35:45 PMThese were wilding panamorous (WP) and Q-series panamorous (QP) ...
Wow that's cool they showed some resistance, and a funny coincidence this thread came to life today just as i was reading up on this disease!

atilgan


Roland

I don't know how long tobrfv stays in the soil, but other mosaic viruses can survive for more than 10 years.

Perhaps you can try and cross many of the resistant tomato ancestors and after a few years use the most resistant as rootstock. Hopefully the virus will not be transported from the soil to the susceptible varieties.
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: atilgan on 2023-12-25, 02:02:08 AMHere is a  picture of wild panamorous one is effected and one is healthy
http://www.agaclar.net/forum/1623274-post1489.htm

Solanum pimpinellifolium accession LA1611 in the above studies got 0~20% disease severity. It's available at Nordgen genebank listed as NGB 22603, here's their page on it:

https://www.nordic-baltic-genebanks.org/gringlobal/accessiondetail?id=42807

For breeders in Europe this could be useful perhaps - or does anyone know a more resistant one available in Europe? I couldn't find any but it's not easy to search. Anyway, Atilgan perhaps crossing some large tomatoes with this (maybe in a place where you can at least grow to cross, free from the virus until you get F2), could be useful for your community?

It would also be really interesting to know how plants like that pimp or others from the studies, compare to those Wildings and Q series, in gardens known to have this disease. Then we would have some kind of way of measuring their resistance relative to those with known resistance.

Roland are you working with this disease resistance also? It sounds like it could be good to add, if possible, this to resistance to our projects. Would be sad to see hard work of late blight projects go to waste if our regions get overwhelmed with this one too!

William Schlegel

I made a cross between my two 2022 pimp crosses in 2023. It should segregate for visible characters like fruit size and color just as if it was either of the parent crosses but it has potential for both brown rugose fruit virus tolerance and late blight resistance. I also crossed my LA1375 cross to my cross with Purple Zebra F1.

LA1375 is the accession with some tolerance I was able to request from USDA-ARS-GRIN. I think I've now managed fifteen crosses with it.

LA1375 Crosses:

MMM x LA1375
Dwarf Gloria's Treat x LA1375 & PH5 pimp pollen mix
(MMM x Purple Zebra F1) x (MMM x LA1375)
 (MMM x PH5 LB pimp) x (MMM x LA1375)
 Fisher's Earliest Paste x (MMM x LA1375)
 Ida Gold x (MMM x LA1375)
 (MMM x Sweet Cherriette) x (MMM x LA1375)
 Dwarf Eagle Smiley x (MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375)
Wilford x (MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375)
Bison x (MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375)
MMS x (MMM x LA1375)
MMM x (MMM x LA1375)
(MMM x LA1375) x (MMM x galapagense X)
Payette x (MMM x LA1375)
Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375)
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Also for those in Europe, habrochaites accession PI 308182 segregated for total resistance, and for breeders can be found here:
https://cgngenis.wur.nl/accessiondetails/CGN23951

Steph S

This is great work, guys.  Very exciting Atilgan, that you've been able to identify some resistant plants to work with in the situation of an endemic virus. Please make lots of crosses with delicious tomatoes!

Justin Jardinier

I had 2 more thoughts on this topic.
1) Wild vs commercial
If some of those new commercial varieties are genuinely as resistant against ToBRFV as the most resistant wild accessions, i.e. having none of the virus in them at all when exposed to it, then wouldn't it be better to cross with them, rather than the wild ones? I.e. isn't it easier to breed out the undesirable traits from commercial tomatoes such as poor taste, than it is the undesirable traits from wild species like tiny size and in some cases disgusting taste?

On that point, does anyone know a way of obtaining any totally resistant commercial varieties, whether it be through purchasing seeds or actual fruits and self-harvesting their seeds?

Quote from: atilgan on 2023-12-24, 03:35:45 PMThis year I only tried WP and QP and a commertial variety that claimed some resistance. That commercial variety showed little resistance and died.
Which commercial variety did you try? And are there any which claim total resistance that are available in your area, like they seem to be in Israel?

2) Regarding total vs partial resistance
If we breed varieties or populations with only partial resistance, then if we do get the virus, does that not mean that from that point onwards, unless we are growing indoors and can sterilise the entire grow area including the building and soil, we are then basically unable to sell or share any tomatoes or seed? Because, so long as our tomatoes are not 100% resistant, having none of the virus, we may be sharing infected material. In which case, aside from the case of personal eating or in a case where the entire region might be infected and the virus becoming endemic (or in preparation for that time), so long as the spread of the virus is to be avoided, is it not rather pointless to have mere partial resistance?

William Schlegel

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-28, 07:26:51 AMI had 2 more thoughts on this topic.
1) Wild vs commercial
If some of those new commercial varieties are genuinely as resistant against ToBRFV as the most resistant wild accessions, i.e. having none of the virus in them at all when exposed to it, then wouldn't it be better to cross with them, rather than the wild ones? I.e. isn't it easier to breed out the undesirable traits from commercial tomatoes such as poor taste, than it is the undesirable traits from wild species like tiny size and in some cases disgusting taste?

On that point, does anyone know a way of obtaining any totally resistant commercial varieties, whether it be through purchasing seeds or actual fruits and self-harvesting their seeds?

2) Regarding total vs partial resistance
If we breed varieties or populations with only partial resistance, then if we do get the virus, does that not mean that from that point onwards, unless we are growing indoors and can sterilise the entire grow area including the building and soil, we are then basically unable to sell or share any tomatoes or seed? Because, so long as our tomatoes are not 100% resistant, having none of the virus, we may be sharing infected material. In which case, aside from the case of personal eating or in a case where the entire region might be infected and the virus becoming endemic (or in preparation for that time), so long as the spread of the virus is to be avoided, is it not rather pointless to have mere partial resistance?



To me, using commercial varieties as a source of resistance is a legal question only. Is it legal to breed with this variety? I suspect that it is still true that much of the time it is still fine. Though there are legal questions there where you could be potentially violating an MTA or something. Carol Deppe when she proposed her breeding scheme for late blight was very concerned about the bad taste of Iron Lady F1 and proposed an elaborate methodology to breed that out. For ToBRFV the situation would be potentially the same with whatever resistant varieties found. However, this should be much easier than working with wild species.

As far as obtaining one: This might be as simple as buying a seed packet for many growers in heavily infested regions. These tomatoes as near as I can tell, were at least initially, being marketed exclusively where they are needed most. Mexico, Israel, and Turkey amongst others. So I am not sure if in USA or Britain we can yet purchase a seed packet. However, it could be that a grocery store tomato from say Mexico would be both a potential source of infection and a potential source of resistance or tolerance. Though I would be fairly uncomfortable breeding with that unknown of germplasm because it could have legal implications. Or not! I would need some good advice on that point. However, if someone a little more knowledgeable could pave the way it would be very interesting to have something equivalent to Purple Zebra F1 or Galahad F1, that is legal to breed with, with a resistance gene or genes for this disease.

I bred mere tolerance into mine because it was the only accession I could get from the publication of tolerant and resistant accessions that was first shared. Someone shared that some growers had a clever work around- they basically bred a weak strain of the virus and infected their plants with it to out compete the more virulent strains. Their government did not accept that work around- but it worked. Having tolerant tomatoes would be much the same. You would still have, and potentially be spreading the virus once you got infected. One potential positive would be that you could still work on your breeding projects. You might also be able to disinfest your seeds and return to an uninfected status. In a practical sense, if the virus becomes globally widespread enough it won't matter anymore, and everyone will need tolerance and or resistance. We would lose non-resistant heirlooms.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

atilgan

Several big seed producers have now tobrfv resistant varieties. Some of them claim high resistance while others only partial resistance. Most of them are cherry type. Fito for example tested his cherry varieties and 4 of them have intermediate resistance. Two of these cherries had taste awards from customers. They are available in europe but not in small quantities. Rijkz Waan now has  several cherry varieties with high resistance but again only for professional producers. USA site also list several varieties
https://www.rijkzwaanusa.com/vegetable-seeds/tomato/amelioso-rz-f1-72-ck0619-prdSL12162-ctgCrops.tomato
Harmoniz have several with very high brix up to 9.
https://www.harmonizseed.com/product/dormaplum-2/
Hazera and other major companies have them as well. As I said I tested one commertial variety last year and it failed miserably but I did not purchase the seeds from a trusted source.


atilgan

By the way I was  getting fito resistant variety solemino from amazon spain but then I realized that it is just another tomato with the same name. Here is the link for Fito

https://www.hortidaily.com/article/9506744/tobrfv-resistant-cherry-pear-and-bouquet-tomato-varieties/

Steph S

Patent pending on the high resistance qtl and markers, for seeds offered here:
https://nrgene.com/traits/tobrfv-high-resistance-source/

I wonder if the patent would interfere with OSSI pledge.   If not, well you could buy the seeds and even the backcross with marker assist which they offer, given a budget for that.
Someone should talk to them and see whether the patent would bar the offspring from being OSSI pledged and freely used for further breeding.

Nicolas

The patent : https://patents.google.com/patent/US20230345900A1/

They've also filed one in Europe. Good luck to get it approved here (though we have a few outrageous ones already accepted) ...

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-12-29, 11:48:53 PMThe patent : https://patents.google.com/patent/US20230345900A1/

Wow that also states:
QuoteThe symptoms of the new virus included mild foliar symptoms at the end of the season, but strong brown rugose symptoms on the fruits. A later publication showed that the virus was also present in Israel in 2014, and it was established that the virus can also infect pepper (Capsicum annuum) plants (see "A new Israeli Tobamovirus isolate infects tomato plants harboring Tm-22 resistance genes." Luria et al; PLoS ONE 2017).

I wonder how serious that issue is, do we need to be worrying about peppers too? If so I'd be really interested if C. chinense and C. baccatum are more resistant or not.

I found this from 2020:
file:///Users/justin/Downloads/syn_syngenta_qa_-_tobrfv_-_external.pdf
QuoteIt infects tomato and pepper. Unlike other Tobamoviruses it breaks the widely deployed Tm2-2 gene in tomato providing resistance to TMV and ToMV. In public information the pepper L-genes providing Tobamovirus resistance are sometimes suggested to be effective against ToBRFV. This is however not yet supported with scientific evidence and may make pepper materials even be a hidden source of infections if pepper is not taken into account sufficiently.

QuoteThe impact of ToBRFV on pepper crops so far seems to be low.

And this sounds rather important information:
QuoteHealth treatments
All tomato and pepper seed lots receive a sanitation treatment active against Tobamoviruses within the seed extraction process. On tomatoes, Sodium Hypochlorite and Trisodium Phosphate treatments are applied, effective against bacteria and viruses. On peppers, Trisodium Phosphate treatments are applied.

It's starting to sound like C. chinense and C. baccatum might be alright. Here's another article:
https://archive.ahdb.org.uk/knowledge-library/the-symptoms-of-tomato-brown-rugose-fruit-virus-tobrfv
QuoteTomato is a major host of ToBRFV, but inoculation trials have demonstrated that sweet pepper (Capsicum annuum) as well as the experimental host plants Nicotiana species, Solanum nigrum, Chenopodium quinoa, Petunia hybrida and Chenopodium murale can act as minor hosts showing slight symptoms.

And:
QuoteSymptoms in sweet pepper
ToBRFV in sweet pepper is less common, but you should remain vigilant for any unusual symptoms in your crop. To view images of symptoms in sweet pepper crops (and further images in tomato crops), visit EPPO's ToBRFV gallery.

That gallery has many photos from around the world, including some infected peppers, found here:
https://gd.eppo.int/taxon/TOBRFV/photos

Here's one of the pepper photos, from Palestine:


For anyone interested, here's the 2022 paper Pepper Plants Harboring L Resistance Alleles Showed Tolerance toward Manifestations of Tomato Brown Rugose Fruit Virus Disease:
https://www.mdpi.com/2223-7747/11/18/2378

Now back to that patent Nicolas shared:
QuoteIt is another object of the present invention to disclose the tomato plant as described above, wherein said ToBRFV-resistant wild tomato plant is selected from a group consisting of LA0107 (S. corneliomulleri), LA0361, LA1918, LA2650 (S. habrochaites), LA1938, LA1969, LA2748, LA2755 and LA2931 (S. chilense).

I decided to check these accessions in the paper Screening of Solanum (sections. Lycopersicon and Juglandifolia) germplasm to ToBRFV - Ahmad Jewehan - 2021. Here's the disease severity given for those I could find:
corneliomulleri LA0107: 80% - that surprised me that they used that, even though it gave such poor results in that trial. There were 4 corneliomulleri accessions that had only 40%, and several with 60%.

habrochaites LA2650: 40% - again surprising. There were 2 segragating 0~20%.

chilense LA1938: 40%
chilense LA1969: 60%
chilense LA2748: 60%
chilense LA2755: 80%
chilense LA2931: 60%
These again, surprising since there were 3 with 20% and one segragating 0~20%.

That leaves habrochaites LA0361, LA1918, the former of which was used in the paper Evaluation of responses to tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) and selection of resistant lines in Solanum habrochaites and Solanum peruvianum germplasm - Ahmad Jewehanet al - 2022. Note this is by the same authors as the paper above but tests different accessions.
LA0361: 40% - that paper has 2 with 20% and 9 segragating 0~40%, plus the 2 segragating 0~20% in the previous paper.

So I'm really curious why they used all these accessions that have significantly less resistance than numerous others from the same species.

The only other reference I could find to LA1918 was in a paper Tomato Brown Rugose Fruit Virus Pandemic in Annual Review of Phytopathology (perhaps an interesting read for many folk here), by the same 2 lead authors of the above 2 papers, published June 2023:
https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev-phyto-021622-120703

Incidentally that paper gives this map:
Screenshot 2023-12-30 at 12.54.21.png

Note that map is incomplete. As the article states:
QuoteToBRFV has been detected on tomato seeds imported from Japan into the Netherlands (44) from Taiwan into Greece (45), from Thailand into the United Kingdom (38), from Peru into the Netherlands (37, 44, 57), from India into the Czech Republic (45), from Lithuania into the United Kingdom (57), from Australia into Spain (45), and from Ethiopia into the Netherlands (44). It has also been detected on pepper seeds imported from Taiwan into the Czech Republic (45), from Thailand into Spain (44), and from Japan into Spain (46) as well as on tomato and pepper seeds imported from India into Italy (38, 44) and from Slovakia into the Czech Republic (46). This suggests that ToBRFV is most likely present in these countries (Japan, Taiwan, Thailand, Peru, India, Lithuania, Ethiopia, Slovakia, and Australia) even if the virus has not been officially reported yet.

Anyway back to the patent and that one accession, LA1918 - that paper only made mention of it in reference to that patent! Also, I now see that patent was filed  on 2021-09-22, so they were clearly working on all of that before these more recent studies were published, which would seem to explain why they may not have been aware that there are many accessions with far greater resistance than the ones they used. This implies that we might be able to get better resistance than them perhaps, by using better wild sources.