Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

https://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/ribeosdes-wild-tomato

As far as accessions from HR seeds the description on this ribseosdes would seem to indicate an accession from the source.

However and this is just interesting to me. From that description we could look at any currant tomato with more than 12 flowers / fruits in an inflorescence and infer that they belong to the ribseosdes variety. https://www.rareseeds.com/spoon-tomato and the Baker creek listing shows spoon with a 16 fruit inflorescence.

So on the one hand we may want as many clearly different accessions as possible of currant tomato with South American accessions preferred because of greater diversity at the genetic level. On the other hand on the visible level we have all the diversity in currant tomatoes with heirlooms commonly available. Only documentation can tell us the difference.

I think while in some ways far less exciting than working with something like Solanum habrochaites, making crosses with lots of different currant tomato accessions has a lot of potential for wild tomato breeding. 

I did two such crosses last year with two accessions I requested from ARS-GRIN.

It is just pretty straight forward. They contain genetic diversity but more at the individual accession level than at the within accession level like habrochaites- which is why more accessions would be needed. However, you make the cross and it is basically the same as if it was a domestic x domestic cross in terms of complexity. Just select your favorites with whatever traits you are interested in over seven generations or so. Or don't and leave it as a diverse grex.

So less potential from any one cross, but also less difficulty.

That doesn't mean I'll stop breeding with Solanum habrochaites any time soon. It is just an interesting contrast. I think Solanum habrochaites is kind of a wild tomato only a botanist could love and I happen to be a botanist. I will say that any of the rest of you working with it have that same trait- the ability to love a plant that doesn't immediately provide benefit but rather has the potential to do so down the road. Solanum pimpinillifolium though is easy and immediately accessible and palatable. Not that you might not get the occasional spitter even with currant tomatoes or even with domestic x domestic crosses.

Another benefit of currant tomato breeding is that being simpler you could probably work with more strains for approximately the same amount of effort.

Garrett to respond to a comment you made earlier I don't know if a hybrid swarm of pimpinillifolium x pimpinillifolium or x habrochaites would necessarily take over but it would certainly add some potential that a population of an inbred strain of pimpinillifolium may not have. The feral or wild tomatoes I have seen have often occupied habitats that kind of make sense like a few escaped tomato plants I found in a often dry riverbed in Southern California or a few currant tomatoes on the edge of a agricultural field at a UC ag facility in Orange County California or a currant tomato plant I saw when I visited the island of Kauai kind of on some bare sandy soil on the edge of a stream not far from the beach I think. So if a wild tomato got into a good habitat like a often dry riverbed it would probably spread and do fine, if it was part of a hybrid swarm with something diverse it might do better but time scale might matter. I've often wondered if a weedy enough tomato could survive in the wild- but even then the proper habitat might be really important. I don't think I could just spread the seeds on my hill and expect anything to happen. So if everglades is already well established for the guy at HR seeds maybe he has some of the correct habitat or has created it by creating that field edge habitat. If some deeper diversity genes get into his population that might help it but it isn't a certainty.

When Joseph first sent me some seed for ¾ domestic ¼ wild habrochaites and penellii tomatoes I grew 13 plants, saved all the seed, and direct seeded it. The direct seeded plants did well and there were a lot of them but I ended up not saving any seed. Joseph sent me the next generation from more elite plants and it seemed so much better that I saved that seed only as it was the same cross. Those plants that I didn't save seed from also ended up not volunteering. Some of the project volunteered great from 2021 seed in 2022 basically on the other side of the same garden area so I don't know for sure why but more wilder genetics may not lead to a more fit population. At least not immediately.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

My main thought with that, is that HRseeds guy, "John" as he usually calls himself - he has Everglades and probably hybrids with it that he allows to grow and volunteer all across his yard. They pop up along his trellises and everywhere in his yard. And they have for years.

I think he lives on a swampy land in zone 6.


He's started growing these wild types in the past two or three years.

When I've grown his Everglades tomatoes, they seem to be somewhat prone to outcrossing.


If habrochaites or something crosses with one of his patches that self seeds, and makes a baby habro X Everglades, that plant is probably going to produce a beast.

The beast is more likely to create baby hybrids due to the plant being a monster with a ton of flowers.


So, let's say the following year, a bunch of things that are more or less monsters, appear from that one plant / plants.

Some of these may outcross to a higher extent due to habrochaites or something.

Plus, he still has random varieties that grow in his greenhouse and whatnot. Including the wild types which bees prefer in my experience.


It would be interesting, if wild genes slowly trickled into his Everglades population as other currants possibly do. That population is basically naturalized on his property to my understanding.


So, new genes plus a population with epigenetics that work well for that area.



The pimp tomatoes seem to make the singular monster hybrids like that, but there's also the fact that typically one plant survives there from a lone few seeds that a bird left there.

And, those just get absorbed into the population very quickly.


In HRseeds case, he grows a large amount of tomatoes, what happens if some wild types start to naturalize and spread around, cross with the Everglades on a yearly basis.


I assume he'd cull nasty tasting plants himself.



Just a fun thing to ponder.


Also feels like a fun experiment to try by getting some currant tomatoes to naturalize, and doing the same with habrochaites or things.


It would mostly be an experiment.

William Schlegel

I think there are some odd species barriers there that would make that just a little harder than you expect.

In my experience habrochaites F1s can be weak to start then grow up to be really big. In a competitive situation like a direct seeded row I don't think they make it. In theory I should have had some in some of my past growouts.

However that early seedling growth ability can be restored a couple generations down the line.

It has to occasionally happen in the wild in South America.

In my garden though it has taken a a lot of really deliberate effort with my effort to cross LA2329 Solanum habrochaites with domestics and Joseph's promiscuous project.

Arcanum in my garden hasn't produced hybrids yet. If the HR seeds guy is correct in his wild parentage his pink Arcanum might be easier to cross with Arcanum.

I think it is a good experiment I just think the first few generations might usually need some help.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

I had it happen with habrochaites and some "pimp" tomatoes.

I noticed that it happened more frequently with healthy F1s using the wild currant from peru accession.

But yeah, it'll take some work.

Garrett Schantz

I didn't update much on crossing habrochaites and that accession together.

I didn't have the space indoors to start enough of the offspring indoors, so I ended up with like two or three seedlings each generation.


I'm going to just restart that one. It crossed with some other tomatoes, lost exsertion.

They were things like Hartman's Yellow Gooseberry Tomato and Husky Cherry that ended up crossing too early in the experiments lifespan.

Now, I can dedicate a whole area to this sort of project. And I don't have to be as selective when saving seedlings.


I'm not exactly why the "Wild Currant From Peru" seemed to accept pollen more easily from habrochaites and give fertile / healthy F1's frequently.

That with its alight exsertion sorta had me seeing it as a helpful little accession.


I'll probably limit what currants I toss in or grow around the experiment / crossing group for now.

William Schlegel

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-01-12, 09:41:09 PMhttps://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/arcanum-pink-cherry-tomato-hr

Fun!

I reexamined the photographs and text.

1. Seed looks very well formed.
2. Stripe is there but also a little more blue skin.
3. Fruit size is 1 oz that is too big for arcanum x pimpinillifolium.
4. Says height of 1.5 to 6 feet but only discovered in 2022.

So now I have questions.

Growing the F2 would give alot more info about the parents. Or if it is an F1.

Intriguing though.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

"However and this is just interesting to me. From that description we could look at any currant tomato with more than 12 flowers / fruits in an inflorescence and infer that they belong to the ribseosdes variety."

William that is interesting. I have the pimp seed from you, Cache valley currant (Joseph via EFN), and spoon tomato (via baker creek). It will be interesting to compare them with each other.
Is he saying over 12 per inflorescence is a trait from ribseosdes specifically? So like Barry's crazy cherry may have pimp/ribseosdes influence?

Tim DH

Hi Garrett,
    Interesting discussion. ... Your profile still says you are in Zone6 which may confuse some readers!

Tim DH

William Schlegel

I am assuming the description of ribseosdes is from a publication such as a key.

If you look at the tgrc key they don't have varieties. So it must be some other source description.

https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/key.aspx
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#339
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fy3ay5_ZXPc

I just found this video. It explains how commercial tomato breeders have largely reversed the low genetic diversity in tomatoes over the last fifty years by bringing in wild genes.

From something called UPOV which I think is briefly explained in the video perhaps as some sort of international variety protection with a breeding exception.

That would mean we could legally breed with any commercial tomato as long as our nation was a signatory. 

https://www.upov.int/edocs/pubdocs/en/upov_pub_423.pdf

USA is a signatory but still there are all these rules and I wonder if we can actually do as the video suggests in all instances? I'm sure GMO transgenes are covered as a longer term patent. However there may be a whole lot of other exceptions.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-01-15, 02:02:27 AMHi Garrett,
    Interesting discussion. ... Your profile still says you are in Zone6 which may confuse some readers!

Tim DH


Thanks, I forgot to change that!


William Schlegel

I bleached seeds using TGRC protocols and planted Solanum galapagense, Solanum cheesemaniae, Solanum habrochaites, and some 50% F1 hybrids with the latter today.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

I planted some of HRseeds Chilense Type 2, a couple of days ago - two sprouts are up.

Also have some of HR's peruvianum and the J.F. Macbr's tomato, other peruvianums and wilds coming up.

As for tomatoes, exserted orange and exserted tiger - a few other varieties are popping up.


I'm likely to use those two varieties as parents in some crosses.

Chance

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-01-14, 10:09:18 PMI reexamined the photographs and text.

1. Seed looks very well formed.
2. Stripe is there but also a little more blue skin.
3. Fruit size is 1 oz that is too big for arcanum x pimpinillifolium.
4. Says height of 1.5 to 6 feet but only discovered in 2022.

So now I have questions.

Growing the F2 would give alot more info about the parents. Or if it is an F1.

Intriguing though.



I got a pack of these, along with some of his galapagense x pimpi.  Gonna plant them next to the Q Series this year. 

I agree with its not a pimpi hybrid with the fruit size, that was my first thought.  The foliage kind of has that delicate habit of some arcanum photos, but I haven't spent time looking at wild tomato morphology. 

Nicolas

It looks like more of an habrochaites hybrid to me ?