Breeding 2 Generations of Tomatoes a Year?

Started by ThomatoGarden, 2022-02-12, 05:00:04 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

ThomatoGarden

Hello,

last year i made an experiement planting tomatoes in april.
Cause the weather was bad in 2021, it failed big.
Many plants froze to dead.

But i made an observation, Tomatoes dont care about low Temperatures > 0°C!

They grow more shortly, but thats not bad at all.
They grow more strenghtly, but thats not bad at all.
Every 3 leafes they grew flowers.

So, cause Temperature doesnt matter in the first place, would it be possible to grow a second generation
of tomatoes in winter with low effort?

Whats the lowest Temp Flowers get polinated?
How is the growth of Tomatoe fruits related to Temp?

Would it be possible to get seeds in Time?

The goal would be:
Summer: Grow Tomatoes in Summer, Select
Winter: Cross Selected.
Summer: Grow Tomatoes in Summer, Select
Winter: Cross Selected.
....

Does this make any sense?

Steph S

You didn't mention where you are situated, so I don't know what kind of winter you normally have.
If you live in a climate where winter temperatures rarely go below freezing, then yes you can probably grow a generation in the winter.
I would hesitate to call it "low effort" because you will have to watch for extremes that the plants can't handle and protect them if you want them to survive.
To answer the question about flowering and fruiting time, yes it will happen much more slowly in cold weather.  There is a lot of genetic variation for cold tolerance, there are many tomatoes that crap out completely in the cold, but there are some that adapt.
At least that is what I have observed when growing tomatoes in an unheated greenhouse when the daytime high doesn't reach 60 F.
The time from flower opening to a pea sized tomato set can go to 24 days from about 12 in cool but not frigid weather, on a cold tolerant variety.
For a cold intolerant variety I've seen 52 days from flower to set.
Some others especially large fruited lines may set small fruit but will never grow it until nighttime lows reach 60 F.
So I think regardless of the genetics you will see slower progress in cooler temperatures.

The other important question to consider is, what are you selecting for, and can you do that in both seasons.
For example, if selecting for heat tolerance, you would not be able to identify your best plants in winter.
You will probably also find that fruit quality is very different in a cold growing season vs a hot one. 
Some tomatoes do very well and are tasty in cooler temperatures, but don't excel in high heat.   Others lose their quality in colder temps.   
So the question is, can you select the important traits you wanted, or will you not make the desired progress, because you're selecting in opposite directions due to the different conditions in one generation and the next.

Roland

I grow some plant in winter inside at 15*C. My problem is to get pollen at these low temperatures. The Cherry tomatoes give sometimes pollen. But most flowers do not give pollen. The big beef tomatoes do not give pollen.
Still i made some backcrosses with my cherry tomatoes this winter im harvesting seeds at this moment to seed them in march/april 2022.

If u do not grow for production in winter but just for seeds. Mostly 1 tomato from a pant is enough. So u can keep the plants small and give them small P11 pots.

Also if u mace a cross but are not interesting in the F1 fruit but want to get soon as possible the F2 generation u can make the cross in summer. Grow the F1 in winter en seed the F2 seeds the next summer.
Netherlands

William Schlegel

#3
I just did so for an F1 but it barely worked and I would not do it for an F2. Pollen was hard to come by. Growth and ripening was much longer so it took longer than it should have. One of my parents was only in the F4 and I wanted blue fruit skin. Only one plant of four had the trait and I would probably not have noticed if ot did not because I wouldn't have expected the trait to be so strongly expressed. I think I planted the F1 seeds at the end of July and harvested the F2 in January. I pollinated the F1 fruit in May and harvested it in July. It gets cold in the basement where my grow lights are.

The winter fruit tasted terrible because of ripening in the cold. I knew that but it would have been useless for flavor selection for the normal growing season.

I actually think that four generations in a year might be just possible for very short season tomatoes. However heat and light would need to be optimal. Not my cold basement.

I tend to have more desired tomato projects than I have time so I will probably keep doing this. Ideally though it should be the F1 between two stable parents. Otherwise for me I would not be able to grow enough plants over the winter.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

ThomatoGarden

@Steph S
Hello, The Zone is here 7a/7b with high humidity.
  it can freeze from November to May. Thats why many of my plants got damaged
  last Year :-(
  With 'Low effort' i meant growing plants at 5-15°C with only little support
  by light maybe.

  Selecting only in Summer Season.
  Winter, backcrossing, crossing for larger fruit etc.

William Schlegel

#5
I know at least one person who has a much better winter growing situation than me. Has a greenhouse that is heated all through the winter. Also, you could do a grow room with heat and powerful lights.

For now, I plan to just stick to a few plants in the winter. They are using my seed starting lights in the basement.

Joseph Lofthouse grew a few winter plants for years for his promiscuous project then in the later stages someone in California did a few winter grow outs for him.

Some tomato breeders do winter grow outs in Hawaii.

The dwarf tomato project was able to send seeds back and forth between the Northern and Southern hemispheres for the first few years before laws tightened or authorities asked them to stop. This is still legal for companies and researchers with enough resources to do required testing and with enough scale to do large seed lots for testing etc.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

I have grown tomatoes many winters in my bedroom window. It's a small window, and they don't get enough light, even though I put an electric light on them. They don't get much heat, cause my bedroom isn't heated. But they make some fruits with viable seeds, therefore I'm able to advance breeding projects over winter.

One year, I put tomatoes into an unheated greenhouse in mid-winter. They were under a cloche. Surrounded by bottles of water. Under a floating row cover. They produced fruits early enough that I was able to plant seeds from them that same spring, and harvest a second generation. Then, I grew the grandchildren overwinter in my bedroom window. That was 3 generations in one year. That was only possible, because they were a super early variety. They are also descended from the variety that was the winner of my frost tolerance trials. 

Outdoor temperatures in winter here might be -30 C

Nicolas

I think that europeans get much less sun in winter (and in general) than in the US

ThomatoGarden


Good to hear that you all had success growing tomatoes in winter with low to moderate effort.

It may be difficult to get pollen and fruit, maybe a short temporary heating would help.

But its worth a try.

In Dezember we have 8-9 hours daylight. Dont know if thats enough.

( 3 of 3 Paul Robson Tomatos survived two frosts without any damage !? where most others were damaged.
  temp was -3°C  )



Arjan vD

I used to work in a commercial greenhouse where they grew organic tomatoes and they were usually planted end of december or first week of january.  Because they were organic no supplemental lightning was used.
They often started flowering in january and first fruit ripened in april.
So I think the most important thing to grow in winter is enough heat.

Steph S

I've heard ten hours of daylight given as the daylength needed for most vegetables to grow, and I would've agreed until this winter, where we've had very little snow so there's heat capture in the daytime and there's been noticeable growth on the chard x sugar beet plants overwintering there, even in november days which are much shorter than ten hours here.   So I suspect warmth is the most important limiting factor.
I haven't personally made any crosses in a winter indoor tomato, so I didn't realize until William pointed out, relative humidity can be an issue.
But it makes perfect sense to me, if you are not actually selecting but simply bulking seed from multiple plants for a large summer growout where the selection is done on all the offspring, you have advanced a generation without actually missing anything.  Nice.
Our light levels are generally so low in winter, tomatoes get extremely vegetative and it's a huge mess to have indoors, so I gave up on it.  We really like having fresh greens all winter and they tolerate being indoors so much better, it's what I do with the light setup for off season.
I think the bottom line is, everyone has unique conditions not only your climate but the specifics of your indoor growing space, so if selection is not going to be an issue for that generation, it's worth a try.   Everyone has tried it at one point or another, and some do better than others.  Just don't use your last precious seed of something, and the experience of trying won't cost you much.  :)