Breeding Brassica oleracea for winter greens

Started by reed, 2019-08-26, 09:25:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

They are delicious and what strikes me is all parts are delicious, even the thick stems. O'wow, I just thought of something else. I love the immature seed pods of turnip, radish and kale, I bet these will be even better. Maybe I should stop eating so many in the bud stage so I have more to eat as pods. 

reed

#31
Turns out the seed pods on these plants are not nearly as good as those on turnip or radish, that's a bit of a disappointment. Flavor is OK but it's like chewing on bailing twine. Still, overall this has turned out a huge success.

I imagine I could harvest a pound or more of seed but probably won't mess with reaching for the maximum on that. From the looks of it the first ones will be ready in a couple of weeks but they will keep on coming for a long time so once I have a good amount form each plant I'll go ahead and tear them out so I can use the space for something else.

The pods aren't so good but the flower heads and stems have been a real treat for weeks and had I known how abundant they were we could have eaten a lot more of them and still got lots of seed.

I'll save lots to plant again in late summer but gonna also go ahead and plant some immediately too just to see how they do. I've decided these plants are actually annuals in that it only takes a year to grow them for both food and seed. It's just that the year runs from the neighborhood of June to June. It may even be possible to completely naturalize them like the radishes, turnips and dill.

I did notice differences in flavor with the biggest plant and also the one that seemed most hardy being slightly less delicious than the others, I think it is a savoy cabbage of some type. The purple ones which I believe are mostly cabbage are the most tasty but less productive. Some that I believe are Brussels sprouts were most abundant in making the tasty stems. In the end though they are all great and I now have a nice mix up of crossed seed, all from plants that survived temperatures of - 5 F without snow cover. It can get much colder than that here but it's a start. 

Even though I will be pulling them out before maximum seed production I expect to have more than enough in case anyone else is interested in some.   

Steph S

Reed, I thought you might enjoy this recent article about brassica genetics, and the history of feral brassicas they found.  By feral meaning, escaped from cultivation and became wild again.  ;D
https://academic.oup.com/mbe/advance-article/doi/10.1093/molbev/msab183/6304875

My feral unknown overwintered brassica had the main flower stalk munched by moose but is now flowering a load of side shoots.  Somewhat turnipy tasting buds and leaves, but the best part is that the cabbage butterflies which have been making the rounds for a month have so far not laid any caterpillars on it.

reed

Thanks for the link, interesting read. I have several things that have basically gone feral and I love it. Mustard, turnips, dill, radishes all come to mind.

When I started this project it was partly because I had failed several ties to even get seeds from this species and partly because I waned to try to grow them when it's too cold for the worms. I never expected them to do so well planted this way and I really never expected them to adapt to it so well that they may become feral as well.

I've been collecting seeds now for several days and looks like that will continue for a while. They aren't like turnips or mustard where you can just cut a big stem full all at once and thrash out the seeds. Instead they are maturing from the bottom up mostly. Some pods are shattering on their own while others are still green. I'm sure many still green pods are full of perfectly good seed but I like when possible to let seeds mature and dry as completely as possible. Also there is a little bug of some kind that has infested probably 10% of the pods. Any pod with a tiny hole in it is full of mostly bad seed or just remnants of seeds. Although it is a pain, I started a practice of using scissors to harvest just the best and cleanest pods individually.

Apparently if left on it's own in my climate the natural time to plant this species is around early July because that is when they do it themselves. More that enough seed has been lost on the ground to test how they do when self-sown, I'm going to wait till probably mid to late August to start some for transplant.

I what to add in some more kinds this year. Maybe some of that Purple Peacock broccoli I've read about and some more types of Brussels sprouts and savoy type cabbages if I can find them. I think once I go through another year or two of mixing it all up good, all I will have to do is select for plants that shrug off the cold of winter and then make lots of the yummy stalks and stems in late winter, early spring while it's still too cold for the worms. Although I also am seeing that the worms are not all that interested in the old tough leaves on these plants.

Also of interest, I have harvested more than enough seed from a couple of plants already and went ahead and cut them down. The stumps are growing more new shoots and surprisingly although it is plenty hot here now the little shoots are just as good as back in the spring. Now I'm wondering if these same plants could be cut down and left in place. If they live through the hottest part of summer they might start production all over again this fall. I'm planting fast maturity cowpeas in the patch but think I'll leave the brassica stumps in place just to see what happens.



Diane Whitehead

As long as you have enough space to leave them, some brassicas are perennial.

Someone on the Experimental Farm Network offered seeds of a perennial kale grex which I am growing.

And overwintering cauliflowers are perennial for me.  These are the ones that are sown in July and produce cauliflowers in early spring.  Purple Cape is one.  Aalsmeer is another.  There used to be a whole range of cultivars that could be harvested throughout the spring, but most seem to have disappeared.  If anyone knows of a source, I'd like some.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Steph S

Diane, here is a thread about my friend Vladimir's trials of overwintering cauliflower in the Czech republic:
https://www.tomatojunction.com/viewtopic.php?f=111&p=48912#p48912
Aalsmeer is one of them and compared to some others.

Steph S

Regarding the saving of brassica seeds, I've been told that they must mature and dry on the plant, or will be no good.  I have saved and used lots of brassica seed,  and I think it's true you can tell the immature seed from pods that were green when you cut the plant. So best plan is to take the pods that are dry and brown.  I put mine in a big paper bag stalks and all and let them hang somewhere to dry completely.  They need to be really dry to get the seeds out efficiently.
All you need to simplify processing is a colander with round holes.  I put that over a big bowl and strip the pods off the dry plants into the colander.  The bowl then contains mostly clean seed and a few pod bits to pick out.
Just mentioning that because my first experience with brassica seed was a huge mess.  ;D  And the labor made me wonder why anyone would bother.  But if you plan ahead and have a setup it's not much work at all.

I had the same problem with radish seeds, something got in and et them before I had a chance.  >:(  I think it was earwigs here.  The radish attracts more pests than anything for me.

reed

Quote from: Steph S on 2021-06-26, 02:19:25 PM
Regarding the saving of brassica seeds, I've been told that they must mature and dry on the plant, or will be no good. 

Humm, I hope that isn't true and don't believe it is. The main reason I hope not is that the pods are shattering if left to dry 100% on their own, if they are not good till then I will not be able to collect them.

I don't believe it is true because I'm seeing that as long as the pod is starting to yellow it can be easily shattered with a little pressure and the seeds are already dark colored, while not completely hardened up. The sees in fully green pods are green, I doubt the are good. I have also seen a few sprouted in the pods even in the greener ones.

There are so many and I only need a couple hundred or so from each plant so starting tomorrow I am going to harvest individual pods from now on and screen them for those little bugs, discarding the whole pod if I see one of those little holes. That will make the winnowing and cleaning much easier. Only nice fully mature looking seeds will be saved from the start. A little more trouble up front but better in the long run I think.


Joseph Lofthouse

My experience with seeds, is that they are viable long before they are mature, and very long before they are dry. With my short-season, I often collect and plant seeds that were harvested before maturity.

For example, corn embryos are viable at about 17 days after pollination, fresh eating stage is at about 25 days. Dry down is about 50 days.

Tomato embryos are viable at about 35 days after pollination. Seeds are generally collected at 50 to 60 days.

I expect brassicas to follow this same general pattern.


reed

#39
Yea, I'm pretty sure the seeds are good even if the pod is not 100% dry. Thought maybe it was time to post a few photos.

First is what the pods look like now on the plants.

Next is the seed I've collected from the first two plants to mature seed. They were also the most cold tolerant and most productive and robust overall. Unfortunately I would only give them about 7.5 out of 10 on the flavor scale while most others at least 9 with a couple in the 10 range. I don't want them to completely overwhelm the landrace so that is all the seed I'm keeping from them.

Last is some pods not quite 100% dry and what the seeds inside look like. Those two at the top have those little holes indicating a bug. Even though there are some good seeds in most of them I'm discarding those pods completely. Also any pod partly dry, as in at just one end or fully dry but doesn't easily shatter is discarded, there is lots of rotted seeds, prematurely sprouted or other issues with them.

Now that it has dawned on me I don't need millions of seeds I can skip the hassle of all that winnowing and cleaning and just collect a few hundred primo seeds from each plant from the start.

{ADD} Even though I have abandoned the idea of collecting every single one of these seeds I still expect to have more than enough to share if anyone is interested.

Steph S

Yeah that is definitely your best approach for the amount of seed needed, just take what is primo from each.  :)
If I get some good seed from my feral overwinter I'll swap you for a few of your grex in the fall.

I have mustard planted for condiment seeds this year, but they're not close to flowering yet so shouldn't overlap.


reed

#41
Yep, and much easier overall. Some of the plants are distinctive enough that it is easy to collect what I need form one and then go ahead and cut it down, those two earliest ones were like that. Weird about them is even though they matured first is they were not the first to flower. There is one anomalous plant that has long skinny pods with just one row of seeds inside.

I could I guess note characteristics and store seed from each plant separately but that sounds like a lot of trouble. I do think I will keep them in categories. Those first two in one, then the bulk of plants that all are very similar being green, very productive and quite tasty. Then and this one is important is the purple plants. They were not nearly as robust or productive as most but their edible stalks and flower clusters taken individually were the largest and most delicious. I want them to be at least 1/4 of the total planted this year. Last is a few other oddballs which I'm pretty sure are cabbages. They seemed to try to make heads when they first woke up this spring and bloomed later but plenty of flowering was still going on on all the others that most of their comparative few seeds are probably crosses.

This initial mix included half dozen or more cabbages, mostly savoy types because I read they were most cold tolerant. Another half dozen or so types of Brussels sprouts, some collards and kohlrabi. I think most of what survived was cabbages and Brussels sprouts but I didn't try to keep track. Most of me seed was left over and kind of old so I just planted it last summer in a bed and transplanted the best looking plants around early September or so. I guess I really should keep better track of such things.

I think this technique of summer/fall planting might work in about any climate. Places where it gets cold and stays that way might be better than in some ways than here, where in winter it might be 65F one day and 15F the next. In places where it barely gets cold at all I guess they would just keep growing, only thing if it doesn't get cold enough they might not bloom the next spring.

Quote from: Diane Whitehead on 2021-06-26, 11:34:05 AM
As long as you have enough space to leave them, some brassicas are perennial.

Someone on the Experimental Farm Network offered seeds of a perennial kale grex which I am growing.

And overwintering cauliflowers are perennial for me.  These are the ones that are sown in July and produce cauliflowers in early spring.  Purple Cape is one.  Aalsmeer is another.  There used to be a whole range of cultivars that could be harvested throughout the spring, but most seem to have disappeared.  If anyone knows of a source, I'd like some.

I wonder if they could actually be perennial since they have already been though flowering but I am going to leave the stumps and grow the cowpeas in the same place. If they survive then later on I'll pull the cowpea vines and use them as mulch. That would be really sweet if the same plants made another harvest this fall even if they didn't make it through another winter.

On the perennial cauliflowers, if they make heads the next spring after being planted in July, when do they flower and make seeds?

Diane Whitehead

I eat the cauliflower heads each year so I don't get any seeds.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Steph S

I like this project Reed, you've really reminded me to give this another go.   My mom had some unknown brassica overwinter and it's been keeping her going while I haven't had a vehicle to go visit and put some new greens in.  We had a really nice one that overwintered at her place and at mine (different microclimate).  I still have seeds but they're old. Last time I tried to grow and refresh the seed, they got devoured by pests.

Up til today I haven't planted any brassicas.  Just watching the cabbage butterflies out dancing in the garden, not even to mention the slugs, although they've been busy with other things and didn't touch my volunteer Red Russian Kale nor the unknown overwinter.   But today I started some, and especially some to try and overwinter.  I have seeds of Red Spear purple sprouting broccoli from a swap.  Haven't grown this one before.  But if other brassicas overwinter here, why not these?  It's all about planting them late, right?  Which is just what I ended up doing.  ;D as if I had planned.

Now I just hope it all gets in the ground, as I may burn out on the amount of gardening at some point.  Have to do other work.

reed

Quote from: Steph S on 2021-06-28, 09:55:45 AM
It's all about planting them late, right?  Which is just what I ended up doing.  ;D as if I had planned.
I think so at least here in my climate but not too late. They need time to grow into a nice little plant rather than just a seedling before winter set in. I wish I knew exactly what that optimal planting time was. Maybe between those that are scattered on their own and will probably sprout and those I saved which I can plant at different times I can figure it out. Last year the butterflies chomped on them quite a bit before it cold enough to freeze them out. The worms, I discovered can survive a pretty hard freeze hunkered down in the leaves. Below is a picture of a plant taken on a cold morning this January, frozen basically at the point when the worms finally croaked the previous October.

Quote from: Steph S on 2021-06-28, 09:55:45 AM
Now I just hope it all gets in the ground, as I may burn out on the amount of gardening at some point.  Have to do other work.
I know what you mean. With gardening I'm finding I have prioritize. I can't take on my own version of every interesting project I read about. I think I'm lazy, if something doesn't show good results in the first year or two, like potatoes for example, I ditch it for the easier ones, like sweet potatoes, cowpeas and now brassicas.