My EFN seed order shipped today.

Started by Woody Gardener, 2021-01-18, 06:06:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Diane Whitehead


I buy seeds every year from Wild Garden Seeds.  Frank Morton has interesting mixes, especially of lettuce.  Every year he sells seeds from hybrids he has recently made, from which he will select and name some.

I buy his "Morton Secret Mix" every year.  https://www.wildgardenseed.com/

Here is his description for the 2021 Secret Mix:

The diversity of shapes, colors, and textures in this mix is pretty overwhelming, and as original as it gets. I like to think this mix gives growers a broader view of what lettuce can be, and some appreciation of all the choices a plant breeder gets to make. Enjoy.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

Quote from: Diane Whitehead on 2021-01-23, 04:55:50 PM
I buy seeds every year from Wild Garden Seeds.  Frank Morton has interesting mixes, especially of lettuce.  Every year he sells seeds from hybrids he has recently made, from which he will select and name some.

I buy his "Morton Secret Mix" every year.  https://www.wildgardenseed.com/

Here is his description for the 2021 Secret Mix:

The diversity of shapes, colors, and textures in this mix is pretty overwhelming, and as original as it gets. I like to think this mix gives growers a broader view of what lettuce can be, and some appreciation of all the choices a plant breeder gets to make. Enjoy.

I think that's where my Siberian kale originated. Only one red russian looking sort survived and became a lomg term volunteer. I bought a new packet from the local seed coop last year and it produced abundant seed so I'm back in the many leaf types world.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: reed on 2021-01-23, 02:58:52 PM
Not that terms really matter but I'm not that big on landrace. To me it implies connection to a particular locale. Following the Alan Kaupler definition it is even tied to localized wild populations. My selected but wild asters collected from all around my area definitely meet the Kaupler criteria but my cowpeas and peanuts do not.

I would love to see an have even thought of starting a seed business or cooperative providing mixes and grexes, rather than varieties or landraces.

My cowpeas that I mentioned, for example were grown for the first time last year from seeds I got in trades. Some were named varieties grown in Pennsylvania and California and some a "landrace" developed over the last twenty years in Minnesota. They all did well but I want still more diversity so I ordered 17 new named varieties from various companies this year. I also ordered six new peanuts to go with last years, 15 grain amaranth and 12 sweet sorghum.

Now, before they start adapting into my own local grex, or landrace there should be material that could be sold or traded to people outside my area. After several years though my landrace will be mine, and most useful just to those in my area. Even this year I will have more seeds than I need and could trade some to someone who has done the same thing with some other crop.

I don't know if EFN or anyone else has focused or regional cooperation in "landrace" development but that is what I would love to see happen.

{ADD} Count me out on maintaining anything, no matter the romanticized story that goes with it nor how much I admire and respect the one(s) that developed it. My friend from Minnesota nor anyone else can get back his cowpeas from me. Joseph nor anyone else can get his Harmony Grain Corn from me. You will have to be a Star Trek fan to get this reference but my garden is the Borg and they have been assimilated.   


A fine idea in its own way, but depending on what people WANT out of a given crop, a grex may not be what they are looking for.  Grexes and mixtures tend to be more up the alley of the homesteader, the person who is primarily interested in maximizing the amount of food energy he or she can get out of his or her land.  Even if such a person cares about having the ultimate product in terms of personal best taste, this MAY be secondary in importance if it is a matter of total food calories.  This is not to say they DON'T care about that, but if it comes down to a matter of taste versus productivity, different people may have different priorities. 

Mixtures also tend to be best for the person who is growing an appreciable amount of a given crop to have the numbers to select.  If you are a suburban gardener who only has room for three or four tomato plants or a half dozen cornstalks, getting something along the lines of "here are 100 seeds taken out of a pool of several acres of random plants I grew out. There could be pretty much ANYTHING in there." may not be appealing. You are probably going to go for a named variety where you KNOW what you are getting.

That's sort of the reason why I, for example would never seriously try a wheat grex. With room to only grow maybe 2-3 dozen plants at a time, I wouldn't have the space to do any real selection and it I tried to keep even a large portion of the diversity in, I'd end up planting only one grain of each type.

My stuff both IS and IS NOT a landrace. It IS in the sense that, for most crops I plant everything next to each other and let pollination occur freely, and selection is limited to being done on the original planted seed (usually on appearance). It ISN'T in that, when possible I try to keep the seed of each plant discrete from that of the others at harvest time)

There is also the fact that a lot of the crops are primarily selfers (like most of the legumes). Is it really much of a grex if 99% of the time you are getting back exactly what you put in, or is it just a bunch of discrete varieties you are growing together to select out which ones you like best and hoping for the odd cross? And where the only real selection pressure is did the animals eat the seed (which is a pretty random one, and, if it DOES have any effect on selection would actually probably select AGAINST desirable traits, since if the animals don't like it, you probably won't either.)

I suppose the closest I have to a grex is the cowpeas since I end up putting in a random assortment of whatever I found  that year in my hunting. It's usually heavily skewed towards one variety or another (originally it was mostly Owl's eye now it's mostly Vietnamese Greenheart* ) but the other stuff is still there.


*My names, don't bother trying to look them up.   

AndrewB

#33
Quote from: reed on 2021-01-23, 02:58:52 PM
I don't know if EFN or anyone else has focused or regional cooperation in "landrace" development but that is what I would love to see happen.

I think it is starting to catch on.

That is the main method i use when trying to locate seed to add to my own garden / breeding projects. Top priority is given to those who live geographically closest to me, or in a similar (though distant) climate. When i share seed i give priority to those in my own area or region first. When i am looking for breeding collaborators i look to those in my region first. I have my watermelon x citron hybrid project listed on EFN right now and in the intro I specifically ask for those in my region or climate to join me. I am still open to other collaborators, but i want the main group to be the closest to me or my growing conditions.

I am pretty sure regional adaptability is starting to catch on in the greater gardening / seed community though. I definitely am seeing that more and more being mentioned on various seed sites, blogs, etc. I am also seeing the idea that organically grown crops should be planted from varieties bred or grown in organic conditions so that they will not be dependent on fertilizers catch on more and more. People are starting to understand that seeds are not all the same despite being the same species.

https://awaytogarden.com/shopping-for-resilient-seed-with-laura-parker-of-high-desert-seed/

@william (mostly), as a side note i found an old packet of seed for Joseph's squash. I'll need to go back and check what type or variety or name or what. But i probably need someone else to grow it out for me. If anyone is interested in growing out a LARGE packet of Joseph Lofthouse squash seed, please let me know.

Maybe i should start posting what rare / unique seed i have available that is getting old so that others with the inclination and the space can grow it out before it gets too old.

William Schlegel

Andrew, I have stock seed for most if not all of Joseph's squash so would need to know the species or interspecies hybrid but there is a fair chance I've already got seed.

Last year I made a point to grow a seed crop of his buttercup and his crookneck. In 2019 I grew mospermia. Haven't decided for sure what to grow out in 2020. Depends in part on what's needed, squash seed is fairly long lived.

Three things of Josephs I don't have stock seed for are garlic, sunchokes, and okra.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

#35
Regional cooperation in landrace development has been my life's work for the past 12 growing seasons.

I have attended about 40 seed swaps in the Rocky Mountains, in 10 states, spending about 12 weeks, while traveling about 20,000 miles. I have distributed tens of thousands of packets of seeds at those swaps, and received thousands of packets of seeds from my collaborators which were assimilated into my landraces. As my seeds are assimilated into theirs.

I consider hundreds of people to be part of my close collaboration network. We swap seeds periodically whenever a landrace changes significantly. I love their stuff, because it is regionally adapted, and thrives for me. And people are doing a lot of really wonderful work with landraces, and selecting more uniform varieties out of the landraces. I'm in awe of the collaboration network.

I don't often write about my local landrace breeding network. I hold it precious. Many of the varieties that I grow are heavily influenced by my local community. The chef's that decide if it's worth saving seeds from a squash. The people at farmer's market that bring me fruits that they grew in their garden, or seeds, or trees. The Ogden Seed exchange is the biggest and most respected seed swap in Utah. It is "local only".  If you didn't grow the seed in your own garden, then it is not welcomed at the swap. Some of the local farmer's save their own seeds. That has been a rich source of locally-adapted germplasm for me. Our farmer's market is "producers only", meaning that anything that shows up there was at least capable of making seeds within 50 miles of my place. I've gathered a lot of germplasm from the farmer's market. A nearby garden store, sells bulk seed from varieties that are known to do well in our area. That seed is welcomed into my landraces. There are a number of small local seed companies in my area that grow all of their own seed. We exchange seeds periodically.

Julie, at Giving Ground Seeds, collaborated with me in my fields. She carries more varieties of my seed than anyone other than Experimental Farm Network. All of it that she grew on her nearby farm. Many of the "cultivars" that she grew in my field, ended up incorporated into my landraces. I really respect Julie's work and varieties for our bio-region.

Some of my landrace varieties are carried by Snake River Seed Cooperative. Because of the weird nature of the Idaho see laws, I grow beans for them, cause they can't distribute locally-produced beans without extensive bureaucratic hurdles. If other of my varieties are showing up in their catalog, they are being grown by people other than me. Wayne Marshall of Buhl, Idaho is doing great work with my popcorn. Snake River Seed Cooperative is a bio-region specific seed company. More focused on cultivars than an landraces, but they do carry a few landrace varieties. The cooperative is pretty focused on maintaining cultivars, and some growers are doing things like hand pollination of squash, or growing over plastic. To me, some of the varieties seem weak, because of the inbreeding necessary to maintain heirlooms.

The Rocky Mountain Seed Alliance is a tremendous resource of collaboration for me. Growing and saving seeds has to be the foundation of any landrace breeding project. RMSA trains gardeners in how to save seeds, and breed varieties. They teach teachers how to talk about seed saving and plant breeding. They facilitate seed swaps, and regional get-togethers. They fund the cooperative growing, trailing, and exchange of grains with the Heritage Grain Trails.  I'd love to see organizations like RMSA serving each bio-region.

I also participate in more national networking opportunities such as Open Source Seed Initiative, NOFA-NY, Organic Seed Alliance, and cooperation with landrace growers anywhere, because of the variability inherent in landraces.

Before writing this post, I didn't understand how much effort I have put into developing my landraces!!! Ha! About 100 landrace varieties, from 80-ish species. And dozens to hundreds of ancestors for each variety.  Yup. That's about equivalent to someone's life's work!!!!




Joseph Lofthouse

Quote from: William S. on 2021-01-24, 11:59:48 AMThree things of Josephs I don't have stock seed for are garlic, sunchokes, and okra.

My garlic is gone. There are probably still weeds in my field, if I wanted to resurrect it. But why would I? Avram at Garlicana is doing really wonderful work.

Remind me in the spring, and I'll dig some sunroots.

My okra is close to being lost. I still have seed, but shared extensively, then had two cold growing seasons in a row...

reed

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2021-01-24, 02:21:50 PM
...I don't often write about my local landrace breeding network. I hold it precious. Many of the varieties that I grow are heavily influenced by my local community. The chef's that decide if it's worth saving seeds from a squash. The people at farmer's market that bring me fruits that they grew in their garden, or seeds, or trees. The Ogden Seed exchange is the biggest and most respected seed swap in Utah. It is "local only".  If you didn't grow the seed in your own garden, then it is not welcomed at the swap. Some of the local farmer's save their own seeds. That has been a rich source of locally-adapted germplasm for me. Our farmer's market is "producers only", meaning that anything that shows up there was at least capable of making seeds within 50 miles of my place. I've gathered a lot of germplasm from the farmer's market. A nearby garden store, sells bulk seed from varieties that are known to do well in our area. That seed is welcomed into my landraces. There are a number of small local seed companies in my area that grow all of their own seed. We exchange seeds periodically...

That is what I don't see in my area. I read lot about it in your area, the mountains and in the PNW and to lesser degree in Maine and New York. In my neighborhood however I haven't found much. With knowledge of your work and others in those places I have been secretly embarrassed by most of the "local" seed swaps I've attended. I am about the only one that shows up with actual local grown seeds and since I am not hooked on "variety purity" only a few people have been interested in my seeds. I've found little to nothing there I wanted.

One exception, but still sounds like it falls short of your experience is the swap in Berea KY, but the fella that hosted it has retired and the swap moved to Tennessee. Berea was already a three hour one way drive for me so I have missed it the last two years.

One of my favorite seed companies is Southern Exposure Seed Exchange, headquartered in Virginia. I believe it is employee owned and has a network of growers rather than selling industrial produced seed. I have met them in the past at the Berea swap. I believe their growers range from Georgia to Ohio and Indiana, west to the Mississippi. That whole area is close enough in what I would consider my region and ripe for collaboration. It is actually more like mine, I think than is northern or even central Indiana.

I've been thinking of trying to hook up with SESE in some manner, especially since I'm discovering that crops traditionally thought of as southern grow extremely well here. In the end though I am most interested in growing food for my self and my people so if it doesn't work out and my stuff ends up going the way of the dinosaurs, o well.  .



William Schlegel

https://givinggroundseeds.com/collections/vegetable-seeds/products/okra-landrace

Looking through giving grounds offerings after Joseph mentioned them and they have an Okra landrace.

Would not be surprised if they either started with but added to the Lofthouse version and or recreated it using the articles about it for guidance. Very cool either way as it's a great story. Though to me an unfamiliar vegetable.

I have a packet from Mike Jennings I've been meaning to grow out sometime of his okra grex from a few years back.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Giving Grounds website has a lot, more if you look at their own landraces and breeding work which have diverged from Josephs or been recreated. They have a promising looking parsnip segregating cross between Turga and Hollow Crown and a okra landrace.

I think but am not certain that they also grow alot of the lofthouse landraces for snake river seed. They also grow the Lofthouse moschata which frees me up in my pursuit of banding, spots, and green flesh. I think a diversity of Lofthouse inspired varieties is great. We don't necessarily need to preserve everything exactly. However for just eating I would prefer a 12th generation Lofthouse moschata over a 3rd generation moschata of my own. Flavor matters and it takes some time to fix in a population. 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Woody Gardener

"I have a packet from Mike Jennings I've been meaning to grow out sometime of his okra grex from a few years back."

*chuckle* I have 3 packets of Mike Jennings okra and 2 packets of Joseph's okra. I had planned to grow out a huge okra patch with both and start selecting. Alas, other more important seeds took their place in my small garden. Maybe next year.

A note: I love the thread drift from my original post.
I'm not interested in preserving heirlooms.
The best seed bank is the living seed bank which is growing every year in people's gardens.
Joseph Lofthouse

William Schlegel

Quote from: Woody Gardener on 2021-01-24, 07:17:22 PM
"I have a packet from Mike Jennings I've been meaning to grow out sometime of his okra grex from a few years back."

*chuckle* I have 3 packets of Mike Jennings okra and 2 packets of Joseph's okra. I had planned to grow out a huge okra patch with both and start selecting. Alas, other more important seeds took their place in my small garden. Maybe next year.

A note: I love the thread drift from my original post.
I like the thread drift as well.

I have been wondering if Mikes mix would reproduce the ability to grow short season. In theory there is a good chance. I'm glad Julie at Giving Ground has one going that would probably work for me though the fact that she has that makes it seem less urgent to me.

One thing I think I have seed for and could grow out is Joseph's OSSI registered red tomato DXX-M Clade: Actually maybe not I thought I had sorted out such a packet but the one I have sorted out is LXM-F3 a different breeding line. Anyway I may or may not have DXX-M but if so would it be worth reviving? It might not be worth a tomato isolation garden to me as I've decided I agree with Joseph's own writings that yellows are better. I would rather advance a yellow or bicolor line than growout a red. I established six 150 foot tomato isolation gardens last year, seven with the house garden. I think I could fill them up with the promiscuous project alone, however there are a couple domestics I would like to advance as well.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

#42
I'm planning on planting "saladette / cherry / currant" tomatoes around some promiscuous saladette types - probably hand pollinating some flowers on purpose to ensure I get crosses from most plants. Mostly for striping and other "fun" traits. Tomatoes like Green Ripper, Zlatava, Green Gage, White Currant, J&L currant types among others.

Also trying some different shaped / striped tomatoes near the Q-series Panamorous Tomato. Again probably some hand pollination as well. Bowling Pin, Reisetomate, Alladins's Lamp, Vintage Wine, Oscar Pearson Hard Fruit, Saraev-M22, White Beauty(One of my favorite tasting), Cherokee Purple etc.

The Promiscuous lines right now seem to be mostly large beefsteak types or saladette types. I am hoping to add in some (sweet) sauce tomatoes. Also some nice looking fruit alongside the already impressive flowers. I do prefer white - yellow types of tomatoes, orange is fine as well - seems that many others here agree so that is nice.

I also want to see how different stripings types from wilds will work with domestic stripings. Will they both show up, create a entirely new pattern etc. Some habrochaites for example seem to have a green coloration towards the top, the rest of the fruit eventually ripening to white or yellow.

Many of these will be split into their own groups due to different fruit sizes/shapes, probably intermixing them every few years. Suppose they would be varieties in a way.

Thread shift is nice, assuming the whole EFN shipping thing is about done for most people anyway

Steph S

The seed offered at EFN is inspirational to say the least.  Such a great selection of interesting things.  Landrace breeds and grexes are a really handy shortcut for someone looking to one stop shop and adapt a crop to your region.
I will say though that I don't mind maintaining or at least saving seed of whatever OP's I grow in a given year.  If I grow it, I will save some seed either to grow again or swap or give away, which helps to keep them in circulation.  OP's are the big reservoir of diversity and I appreciate the networks that continue to grow and save and exchange those seeds.   
I didn't buy a single seed for about a decade, but instead used my saved seed as a currency to trade for other seed I needed.  I've just been blown away by the wonderfully useful things that have come to me from all around the world.
Well I was lucky last year to actually have a seed budget, and this year too.  It's a treat to scroll through the many online shops, see the pics, imagine it in your own field, and read what other growers are saying about this or that. :) 
Like most others here, I'm really focused on developing regionally adapted crops that are tasty, interesting and diverse.  My farmer friends and network are the inspiration for that (and the worst weather, of course ::)).   I think there's a place for stable varieties especially the selfing crops, but the new breeds are adapting to today's conditions and need to happen to update those 'heirloom' crops to the time and place.   That is not to say anything against landraces or landrace breeding.  Any crop diversification work that can be delegated to bees, I'm for it. ;)

reed

Quote from: Steph S on 2021-01-25, 08:18:27 PM

Like most others here, I'm really focused on developing regionally adapted crops that are tasty, interesting and diverse.  My farmer friends and network are the inspiration for that (and the worst weather, of course ::)).   I think there's a place for stable varieties especially the selfing crops, but the new breeds are adapting to today's conditions and need to happen to update those 'heirloom' crops to the time and place.   That is not to say anything against landraces or landrace breeding.  Any crop diversification work that can be delegated to bees, I'm for it. ;)

I think when it comes down to it I don't really care if things cross or not, jut that I have good food crop that will actually grow and produce. If that comes about from a cross or if it is an inbred heirloom doesn't really matter. As weather and bugs and disease got worse and weirder of last few decades I first started trialing things based on catalogue descriptions, what a waste of time that was.

Then I figured if I just saved my own seeds that they should adapt a little but when I started reading about it with the isolation distances and all that junk I got discouraged. Then a great epiphany, why the heck do I care if two beans cross or not, whatever comes from it is still a bean. So that unproductive trialing went out the window, instead I just planted what ever I could collect. If things cross I'm ok with it, if something remains true to type but does well for me I'm ok with that too. I don't really know or care how much crossing is going on in my garden. I usually even bother to know for sure if they will cross. I'm planting multiple species of amaranth this year, I don't know if they will cross, I don't care. I'll just save seed from what ever produces good. 

Researching on such matters is what led me first to the writings of Joseph Lofthouse and then to the forums.  That was almost ten years ago and my gardening is not just more successful but more enjoyable. I did get caught up for awhile in the breeding thing, thinking if someone was growing garlic from seeds I needed to do that too but I'm over that now.

So mostly I don't think I am even a plant breeder. I just plant as much diversity as I can of a species and see what happens. Except of course for my sweet potatoes and corn, I'm definitely breeding them.