Chive x Green Onion (scallion) interspecific hybrids

Started by AndrewB, 2021-01-23, 08:58:28 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

AndrewB

Interesting hybrid between green onions (scallions) and chives. Anyone want to try recreating it?

Apparently the hybrid has more beta carotene, has more edible parts, and tastes better than either parent species.

https://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=JP2010004048

Cropping types, utilizing characteristics of the beta-carotene-rich interspecific hybrids between Allium fistulosum L. and Allium schoenoprasum L.  [2010]
Sueyoshi, T., Fukuoka-ken. Agricultural Research Center, Chikushino (Japan); Umehara, M.; Shimomura, K.; Koga, T.;

https://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=JP2007005406

Production and characterization of interspecific hybrids between Allium fistulosum L. and Allium schoenoprasum L.  [2007]

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-005-9029-8

Interspecific hybrids between Allium fistulosum and Allium schoenoprasum reveal carotene-rich phenotype
Mikihisa Umehara, Takayuki Sueyoshi, Katsumi Shimomura, Masatoshi Iwai, Masayoshi Shigyo, Keita Hirashima & Takao Nakahara
Euphytica volume 148, Article number: 295 (2006)




Garrett Schantz

I'm growing Ishikura onions(Allium fistulosum) and Chives(Allium schoenoprasum) this year, both in the same spot. I can't really do much for the ovary culture though.

Diane Whitehead

I have grown a patch of chives and a local wild onion (A.cernuum) for about 40 years and have noticed no hybrids.  Could be because I add the flowers to salads.  This year I will leave a few to seed.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Adrian

How do you did for flowered the oignon and the chive at same Time?

Diane Whitehead

Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

AndrewB

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-01-23, 10:32:30 AM
I can't really do much for the ovary culture though.

true. I'm not sure if the need for ovary culture is because there is some sort of barrier to natural crosses or if that was just to get known hybrids in a university setting. But from the papers abstracts it seems that it does work better with the chive as the pollen parent rather than the other way around. I have not taken a look at onion or chive flowers in a long time, but perhaps there is an easy way to cut off the pollen anthers early on the scallion parent, which could then be dusted with chive flower pollen?

Quotethe hybrids were much fewer in the combination using A. schoenoprasum as a seed plant

I have tried writing one of the authors from Japan to ask for some germplasm samples. I'll let you know if i get a response.

Steph S

I have chives growing and also two types of perennial green onion - Hardy Evergreen flowers early while the other one usually doesn't flower until July.  Anyway I've grown out seeds from all three and haven't seen any natural crosses with chives.


AndrewB

It seems that the original scallion types i purchased may not be of the Allium fistulosum species but the Allium cepa species. It seems that most green onions / scallions / bunching onions are of Allium cepa, but some others (usually japanese or "welsh" types are Allium fistulosum.

Now I need to do more research to see if chives will cross with Allium cepa (which i think was being discussed in the other thread) or whether Allium cepa can cross with Allium fistulosum. Will make for some interesting reading.

Steph S

Andrew, I have a pack of Hardy Evergreen seeds that I collected from a couple of blooms which were simultaneous to my big shallot patch in 2019.  The Hardy Evergreen is A fistulosum.  Also I have a pack of seeds I received this year in a swap, labeled "Welsh onion".   I don't need either of these, so if you want them send a PM.

AndrewB

Apparently there have been rare hybrids between A. fistulosum and A. cepa.

QuoteSome years ago, an interspecific cross between A. fistulosum and A. cepa was made by the USDA and an amphidiploid variety (a tetraploid having a complete set of chromosomes ofA. cepa and A. fistulosum) was produced and called "Beltsville Bunching". It is still used a little today, but the seed is expensive and hard to produce.

One can identify the species by looking carefully at the bottom of the green leaves near where they turn white. If the leaf cross section is "D" shaped (or has a flat side), it is A. cepa. If "O" or round, it is A. fistulosum.

'Beltsville Bunching' and it's refined offspring variety 'Jones' BBO'. It seems both of these are pretty much commercially extinct. Though at least Beltsville Bunching is said to be at USDA GRIN. Though the tetraploidy is a bit disappointing, though not surprising. I tend to avoid tetraploid plants whenever possible, though if they were still available it might be interesting to evaluate them.

@Steph S, thanks for the offer. I actually ordered some "red beard" Allium fistulosum before knowing that scallions can be of these two species. Not sure what my plans are at this point. I may end up only planting the A. cepa varieties. If that is the case, then i probably will not try my hand at breeding any onions at this time. I have ordered a few red A. cepa. varieties of green onions that i plan to plant together. I guess i'll make a small little grex.

triffid

Zone 9a - brown calcareous earth, high natural fertility base-rich loam - coastal maritime climate

AndrewB


Garrett Schantz

#12
Territorialseeds seems to carry Guardsman in the U.S.
Johnnyseeds also carries it, but they are only doing commercial farmer sales right now.

A tree onion variety called "Finnish air onion" appearently produces flowers and sets a bit of viable seed.
Might be worth growing near Guardsman to see if anything fun happens.

Walt

In 1978 I was just out of grad school where my work had all been with barley.  I joined  the Peace Corps By the time I had the hybrids growingwas sent to Niger.  There I was told I'd be working with onions, okra, Peppers. and tomatoes. 
I found thrips were a problem on the onions and read that A. fistulosum was resistant to thrips.  So I got some A. fistulosum and made the cross.  By the time I had  the hybrids growing I had realized that thripswere only a problem where too much irrigation was flooding a small part of the field.  So genetic resistance wasn't needed. So the F1 hybrids were pulled out and tossed yo the side of the field.  There irrigation hit them 2 or 3 times a week, so they didn't die.  They flowered at same time as the field of A. cepa.  And they set some seeds. not a lot.  The litterature says the F! A, cepa x A, fistulosum is sterile unless doubled.  That is not quite true.  The diploid has low but not zero fertility.

Jeremy Weiss

I've been trying to play around with Hooker's Chives (Allium hookeri) but it doesn't seem to like it here (or, at least doesn't like having to start from seed, which is the only way I can get it at the moment).

Would love to do something with Allium chinesis (Rakkyo) as well, but it seems to have the same problem here that garlic does (because the winter never really gets cold enough to kill the aboveground part off, the plants keep trying to actually grow during the winter, so any extra food they stored in the summer gets used up over then, and the plants start the spring with LESS energy than they had in the fall. Rakkyo also has a nasty habit of trying to send out flowers before leaves in  the spring, putting even more strain on the bulb.

I keep trying to work with the Trans-Caucasian wild onion species (on the grounds they will be USED to a long cold period) but they don't like to germinate for me.