My EFN seed order shipped today.

Started by Woody Gardener, 2021-01-18, 06:06:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nicolas

I got a notification from EFN on top of the paypal one, too

Diane Whitehead

I have now received a notification of shipping.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Garrett Schantz

I just got an email saying that my order is out for delivery. A day early which is nice

Jeremy Weiss


Woody Gardener

My order arrived at the local post office today and will be delivered tomorrow.

I made the 'mistake' of going back to read the descriptions of my new treasures and ended up buying another $60 worth of seeds. Included were perennial kale, perennial ground cherry, a new plantain variety, a small early melon, 2 new okras, and phacelia, a pollinator magnet.

I am so grateful to all who work at EFN and all the contributors.
I'm not interested in preserving heirlooms.
The best seed bank is the living seed bank which is growing every year in people's gardens.
Joseph Lofthouse

AndrewB

Quote from: Woody Gardener on 2021-01-22, 12:48:40 PM
I am so grateful to all who work at EFN and all the contributors.

I am too. I think the EFN will only continue to grow and i can see it not only as a valuable service to find rare seeds, but a valuable service for finding pre-bred varieties or varieties that are not yet to the point that they could even be pledged as open source. Some, like the wild yellow black raspberry are collected wild material, and thus no breeding has even been attempted. I think it is a wonderful service that compliments OSSI.

I hope OSSI learns from EFN and opens up a seed shop for those varieties that are pledged but not available anywhere. I hope OSSI forms some sort of seed bank even if it is decentralized and spread out among several board members. Sadly i have little hope this will actually happen, but OSSI is still young.

Joseph Lofthouse

Anyone can grow out OSSI varieties, add them to a seed bank, and/or distribute them.

For those worried about the varieties being lost or falling out of favor, adopt some varieties and start curating them. A number of my varieties are lost to me, but the community picked them up and are doing great work stewarding them. I'm getting to the point where it's too much effort to steward 100 varieties. I shared freely into the community. If my varieties were valuable to someone they will stick around. If not, then they will be lost. I'm not interested in preserving heirlooms. The best seed bank is the living seed bank which is growing every year in people's gardens.

Garrett Schantz

I do quite prefer the landraces over "heirlooms". Most heirlooms are grown with isolation distances nowadays. From what I have been reading the whole isolation thing wasn't all that popular until seed companies came around. Explains why heirlooms are considered weaker and need more attention. I might consider adopting some varieties after the upcoming growing season. I haven't curated / sent out seed to others before but I do plan to.
I am grateful to everyone making all of the diverse crosses/species and everything available. Hopefully I will have a bit of diversity to add as well eventually.

nathanp

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-01-22, 06:32:55 PM
Most heirlooms are grown with isolation distances nowadays. From what I have been reading the whole isolation thing wasn't all that popular until seed companies came around. Explains why heirlooms are considered weaker and need more attention.

This is really another topic altogether, but highly inbred, static varieties will inevitably lose the evolutionary footrace with pests and diseases which are continually evolving and reshuffling genes.  As I understand it, this is basic evolutionary science.  Landrace breeding almost always offers a way to get around this by reshuffling genes from a more diverse population.  Uniformity of inbred varieties, particularly mostly grown in monocultures, unfortunately, is what commercial growers want, and what most seed companies want, and there is also the myth of heirloom varieties being superior, to contend with.  Landrace breeding populations are probably always going to be not-quite-uniform enough, at best.  But grexes and similar mixed populations or landraces offer wide genepools to reselect individual varieties out of, assuming they exist. There is a lot of value in landrace populations and grexes for these reasons alone.  And for continually needing people modifying them to introduce new genetics into the picture. 

Heirloom varieties, by definition, are static varieties selected generations ago, with resistance levels that at best, were able to combat the disease and pest pressures of those times.  At worst, they are not capable of being grown without heavy care to ward off current pressure. 

Frankly, I'm both too lazy and too busy to spend the time babying plants, and if they can't handle my growing conditions, I do not continue to grow them or save seed from them. 

But back to the EFN - what they offer, especially with the landrace and grex seed populations, is the opportunity to shortcut some steps in the process of each grower developing their own breeding populations.  Someone else has done work to create those mixes, and those who follow in their footsteps to continue to work with them, benefit.  Which is pretty much what plant breeding has always been, historically. 

Richard Watson

What is EFN, when I do a web search I see Environmental Funders Network, Element Fleet Management, European Federation of Nurses, Employee First Network......
Changeable climate manly during winter & spring - 500mm average yearly rainfall. 23 years of soil improvements plus sub soil top soil reversal means my garden beds are about half metre deep. Below that is 100's of metres of alluvial shingle

Diane Whitehead

Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Richard Watson

Thanks Diane, that is so interesting.
Changeable climate manly during winter & spring - 500mm average yearly rainfall. 23 years of soil improvements plus sub soil top soil reversal means my garden beds are about half metre deep. Below that is 100's of metres of alluvial shingle

William Schlegel

 Got my green fleshed moschata seeds ok.
RE: EFN as a source of seed for both amateur plant breeding and evolutionary plant breeding: yes! especially with them distributing the most complete selection of Joseph's material. This is an important service for our community of plant breeders.  I contributed a grow out of "exserted orange" tomato to EFN for the current catalogue and have a very good collection though not perfect of Joseph's material for stock seed. I also have some of my own material in development but haven't really pushed anything to say finished product level. I plan to keep muddling my way through the OSSI process on those.

Notably Snake River Seed is also carrying alot of Joseph's strains. I grew a few seeds for them in 2020 of Payette tomato and Hooker's sweet blue corn.

I would be very happy to continue to maintain such material and offer them through EFN and Snake River and collaborate with others to do the same.

If we do so I think we can as a community maintain this sort of a collaborative often OSSI pledged network of amateur breeder seed for evolutionary plant breeding which should make ourselves and our communities resilient.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#28
Quote from: nathanp on 2021-01-23, 06:37:58 AM
But back to the EFN - what they offer, especially with the landrace and grex seed populations, is the opportunity to shortcut some steps in the process of each grower developing their own breeding populations.  Someone else has done work to create those mixes, and those who follow in their footsteps to continue to work with them, benefit.  Which is pretty much what plant breeding has always been, historically.

Not that terms really matter but I'm not that big on landrace. To me it implies connection to a particular locale. Following the Alan Kaupler definition it is even tied to localized wild populations. My selected but wild asters collected from all around my area definitely meet the Kaupler criteria but my cowpeas and peanuts do not.

I would love to see an have even thought of starting a seed business or cooperative providing mixes and grexes, rather than varieties or landraces.

My cowpeas that I mentioned, for example were grown for the first time last year from seeds I got in trades. Some were named varieties grown in Pennsylvania and California and some a "landrace" developed over the last twenty years in Minnesota. They all did well but I want still more diversity so I ordered 17 new named varieties from various companies this year. I also ordered six new peanuts to go with last years, 15 grain amaranth and 12 sweet sorghum.

Now, before they start adapting into my own local grex, or landrace there should be material that could be sold or traded to people outside my area. After several years though my landrace will be mine, and most useful just to those in my area. Even this year I will have more seeds than I need and could trade some to someone who has done the same thing with some other crop.

I don't know if EFN or anyone else has focused or regional cooperation in "landrace" development but that is what I would love to see happen.

{ADD} Count me out on maintaining anything, no matter the romanticized story that goes with it nor how much I admire and respect the one(s) that developed it. My friend from Minnesota nor anyone else can get back his cowpeas from me. Joseph nor anyone else can get his Harmony Grain Corn from me. You will have to be a Star Trek fan to get this reference but my garden is the Borg and they have been assimilated.   

William Schlegel

#29
Reed that's why I am really liking the "Evolutionary Plant Breeding" term. I think we perhaps have that with EFN right now a place where we can develop then sell our grex material.

I hear you on maintaining things. I'm most interested in Maintaining Joseph's work and I live further north in the same bioregion. I use his Moschata for breeding I'm not sure if I can grow moschata realistically without its genetics, but outfits like Kristen Rome's resilient seeds maintain that taxon so I don't need to. Maybe you should become the grex man of Indiana. I doubt for instance that I could maintain Carol's bigger better butternut. It would probably not survive unless I crossed it with my or Joseph's moschata. Which is precisely what I wanted to do with Rancho Marquez (failed or mostly failed I think) have done I think with Autumn's choice. And intend to do with this green fleshed Guatemalan moschata from EFN. Alot of the value of these grex style populations is that they do enable further experimentation and the potential inclusion of traits from unadapted varieties via crossing with an adapted grex. It can also all be done very casually with limited time.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days