Potato Onion Report 2026

Started by A. Pel, 2026-09-30, 10:10:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

A. Pel

I have had quite a good year with my Potato Onion Resurrection project and have now posted the annual report. Lots of pictures and other details.

https://plantal.net/PotatoOnion2026Report.html

The Long Keeping Apple Project
http://www.longkeepingapples.com

Tim DH

Hi A.Pel,
           Thanks for posting this report. Sorry it has taken me quite a while to get round to properly reading it.
   Some day I'd like to move away from onion sets, partly because I suspect that they are an occasional source of White Rot, and partly to be more self reliant. (Due to other constraints that direction of travel is likely to remain aspirational for a couple of years yet.)
   What are your thoughts on productivity? Is a 5 clump line twice as productive as a 3 clump line? What is your view of the ideal clump number?
   Regarding White Rot has your friend tried the Garlic Juice method? In my rotation I water each bed with a liquidised garlic bulb in the year before onion sets are planted. The theory behind garlic juice is that it tricks the white rot spores into germinating when there is no host present. In badly infested ground I'd try doing that in the two years before onions, to get a double clean.

Luke83

A very interesting project, i think i want to plant onions now :)

A. Pel

Quote from: Tim DH on 2026-10-23, 01:10:15 AMSome day I'd like to move away from onion sets, partly because I suspect that they are an occasional source of White Rot, and partly to be more self reliant.

I certainly think that. I am quite paranoid about onion diseases and avoid importing bulbs.

Growing from seed works well for me. Last year I conducted an experiment in the autumn (about now actually) and just scattered onion seed on a newly cleared bed of an unheated greenhouse and loosely smoothed it over to bury the seed. I save the seed from my onions so I have lots for an experiment like that. It certainly worked out well. The onions germinated and slowly grew during the warm days of the winter. The frosty cold days did not bother them. By the time spring arrived I had a veritable forest of well rooted onion starts in the bed - all about the size and thickness of a pencil. I let them run until I needed the bed for something else and then transplanted them out.

Quote from: Tim DH on 2026-10-23, 01:10:15 AMWhat are your thoughts on productivity? Is a 5 clump line twice as productive as a 3 clump line? What is your view of the ideal clump number?

My view is that the productivity is about the same. The roots of the original bulb can only draw so much in the way of nutrients and water from the surrounding soil so the maximum productivity plateaus at a certain level. Having said that, there are a lot of double two clumps that seem to reach the same size as my best five clump and stall there. So genetics does have an effect.

Quote from: Tim DH on 2026-10-23, 01:10:15 AMRegarding White Rot has your friend tried the Garlic Juice method?

I have suggested that but, strangely, he seems uninterested. Breeding some Onion White Rot resistant onions seems like a generally useful thing so that is where I will direct my interests.
The Long Keeping Apple Project
http://www.longkeepingapples.com