Breeding corn for masa quality

Started by Dale Wilson, 2021-09-04, 04:24:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Dale Wilson

A consortium of gardening friends started a community breeding program this spring at Prairie Crossing Farm, Grayslake, IL, to find or make varieties that are good for nixtamal tortillas. Grew Mandan Bride, Bloody Butcher, Hickory King, Hopi Blue, Looney, Texas Gourdseed, Open Oak, and Bill Davison's White Composite.  Also grew classic inbreds: LH82, OH43E, LH74, P207, PHHB9, LH51, B97, CML103.  Crossed pollen composites from the OP corn onto inbred ears, and the other way too.  Also made OP-OP crosses, and many F1 hybrids.  Objectives include earliness, improved agronomics, and achieving the right balance of flintiness and soft starch for good tortilla texture.  We are producing far more populations than we can possibly follow up with ourselves, and would love to collaborate.  When we get this stuff dried and shelled, I will post a list of the crosses and quantities available.
Dale

spacecase0

I am very interested in your results.

what alkali are you going to use ?
I only ask because it seems to change the outcome of the masa so much

Dale Wilson

We have made a small start using cal (calcium hydroxide) at 1% the weight of the corn.  Then we cook for roughly half an hour, and let steep, probably 24 hours, maybe more.  We started steeping for 12-18 hours but it seemed inadequate.  The nixtamalization parameters probably need to be adjusted for different batches and varieties of corn.  Don't yet know how to manage that for testing different varieties.

Dale Wilson

The corn project at Prairie Crossing Farm had a good year.  Texas Gourdseed and Looney were impressive, but awfully late.  Hopi Blue did surprisingly well, but it was dry year. Open Oak was superb, early and well-adapted, but kind of flinty for tortillas.  We made 121 crosses, most with multiple ears, especially the OP pollen composites crossed onto inbreds.  Attached is a txt file showing crosses made and seeds available.  You should be able to take this into Excel for easier handling. There are way, way more populations than we can possibly work on ourselves.  If any of you want seed, don't be shy. Let me know and we will send.

Joseph Lofthouse

Seems to me, like traditional boiling times are closer to 90 minutes, with soak times from dusk to dawn.

I've noticed that dark pericarps are more resistant to alkali than light colored pericarps. If that makes a difference to your processes and selection.

You get what you select for, even if the selection is inadvertent. Corns that respond well to 1% Cal, 1/2 hour boiling, followed by 24 hour soaking might be different than corns cooked by more traditional methods.  What's the goal of the project? Masa corn for peasants? Or for a factory? You might select differently if one is favored over the other.

Dale Wilson

Hi Joseph,
Mainly trying to breed for the Latino community in North Central states.  Currently working with tortillerias in Madison, WI.  My impression is that they normally adjust nixtamalization for the type of corn and batch characteristics.  This presents a real problem for testing.  For now we are trying to characterize the parents, and then prioritize the crosses based on parent flavor and texture.  Eventually we may fix parameters within-family and maybe begin small-sample nixtamal testing in 2023.

BTW, attached is a table as PDF showing background info on the parents.

Joseph Lofthouse

When I was breeding popcorn. I was test popping kernels from each cob. It was a slow and deliberate process, but it really helped to select for amazing flavors, and great popping ability. Eventually, I learned to identify useful traits by visual inspection, which greatly minimized the amount of testing. You might try something similar with your project, nixtamalizing and making a tortilla from a sample of each visually approved cob of corn, and replanting those that you love. I am working with a restaurant that cooks beans in test tubes, to evaluate for cooking qualities and flavor.

Other than the Blue from Hopi, do any of the corns you started with have a history of being used for nixtamalized tortillas? My general plant breeding strategy these days is to select parents that have already been selected for the traits that I want in the offspring. I limit wide-crosses to combining two desirable traits into the same offspring. What corns are the tortillerias currently using? Can those corns be incorporated into the project?

Some of the Hopi corns have been industrialized. For example Taos Blue might meet project goals better than Blue from Hopi.

When I was keeping records of my plant breeding, I loved sibling-group planting. I would save seeds from each mother plant separately, and then plant 7 to 11 seeds from each mother together in a short row. Then skip about 3 row-feet, and plant the next sibling group.  It was often easy, by looking at an entire sibling group, to decide that it should be culled, or that it was exceptional. Then selection/culling was done on entire sibling groups. (I harvested as a sibling group for evaluation of popping ability and flavor.) I estimate that corn is about 50% self-pollinating at my place, and when it crosses, it's most often with it's closest neighbor, therefore, sibling-group selection in corn (at my place) is essentially inbreeding, but with less manual crossing and record-keeping.


Tim DH

Hi Dale,
   Thanks for including the background info. That makes the previous doc much more digestible!

Tim DH


Dale Wilson

Joseph,
The tortilla corn project came up like a watersprout last winter in a book discussion group (on Carole's book, "Resilient Gardener).  We found bits and pieces on the web about quality of Hopi Blue, Hickory King, and Bloody Butcher for tortillas, but not much about other heirlooms.  Jeff Chapman, another corn team instigator, made test-batches of a few different varieties, and we basically followed Jeff's recommendations.  The Mexican varieties sold by Masienda as elite tortilla corns are dents, but with a lot of soft starch. We want to emulate that morphology.
 
Regarding selection, our strategy for 2022 is to mass-select full-sib for earliness in a few high priority crosses.  Maybe the generation after that, we will self selected plants, and in 2024 grow those ear-to-row.
Dale

spacecase0

if it matters,
when I looked into this topic 20 years ago,
most people I talked with thought that a white flour corn was ideal for masa,
flint corns were better for polenta...
this was talking to plant breeder/cooks and people from mexico.
I think that test batches are going to find you your answer.
I tested corn bread with every kind of corn I could find,
but never masa.
the masa I made from white flour corn was quite good, but it was not that fantastic compared to yellow dent corn.
I do kind of wonder why shoe peg corn went from very popular to a forgotten memory, but not sure if it is related to this at all

Dale Wilson

spacecase0,
I think tortillerias around here tend to use dent corn.  The varieties that Masienda describes as good for "table tortillas" like Chalqueno Blanco are dent corns that contain abundant soft starch. "...chalqueño produces a pitch-perfect table tortilla; it's tender, pillowy—ethereal, really. While it can produce a fine recipe tortilla (i.e., for enchiladas, enfrijoladas, etc.) and can even be coaxed into totopos or tostadas, its highest and best use is for the kind of tortilla that puffs (i.e., a table tortilla)." We are tentatively aiming for that style of tortilla corn.
Attached are images of cut kernels. The Chalqueno image was pulled from the Masienda website.  The other images are from kernels we cut here.  Notice that the ratio of soft-to-flinty starch in ordinary B73 looks a lot like that of Chalqueno.  There are other Stiff-Stalk lines that exhibit this same kind of soft-starchiness, but are earlier, and better agronomically than B73.  I wonder how they taste.  WRT flavor, I'm excited about Texas Gourdseed.  We haven't had a chance to make tortillas with it, but it is delicious as hominy and corn bread.  Though so soft at the tip that it doesn't literally dent in (just shrivels at the tip), it does have a sheath of flinty endosperm, and is a type of Southern Dent.
Dale

Dale Wilson

Dear fellow corn breeders,
Sorry I'm so slow communicating. The frenzied pollination season is over. We have five generations under our belt now (counting 2025). Several promising families are (almost) stable OP varieties. Larry and I are going to make a website for the "Tortilla Corn Project."  Do any of you have suggestions about what to include on the website to make it useful to the hobby corn breeding community?
Dale