Question about dwarf tomato crosses

Started by Mike Deyo, 2025-01-26, 03:03:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mike Deyo

I apologize if this has been answered before. When you cross a dwarf variety with a normal indeterminate, will the F-1 plant be dwarf, or normal full size? I thought I had read that it would be full size, that full size is dominant. But I'm seeing something different in a couple plants I am growing under lights.

I made some crosses this past summer between some normal and dwarf tomatoes. The normal size plant was my own variety, stabilized from a cross I made 20+ years ago between Crimson Trellis and Pink Ping Pong. Both were vigorous vining varieties, and the resultant selection I have made shares that trait. I grow it every year as my favorite eating tomato. (I haven't named it) It has medium size red to pink slicing type tomatoes with good flavor and vigor. This past summer I used it as a female parent in crosses with Hazy's Dream and Sleeping Lady, both dwarf varieties. In December I started some of the possible F-1 seed, with the thought that if I could get mature fruits by spring, I could extract the seed, and start F-2 plants then and be a year ahead in the process.

So I have two plants in pots under led lights indoors. One is (my variety) X Hazy's Dream, the other (my variety) X Sleeping Lady. In the picture I have placed a pencil (7.5 inches long) on the soil
surface, and you can see that the first flowers are developing on the plant at about that level. The picture shows just the Hazy's Dream crossed plant, but it is the same with the Sleeping Lady crossed plant. The second photo shows the same plant from farther away so you can see the plant form. The pot is 12 inches in diameter. The stem length between leaves is around 1 to 1.5 inches. They look exactly like the dwarf tomatoes I grew in the garden last summer. I have the lights on about 16 hours a day, and it is somewhat cool in the basement where they are. Soil temperature is around 65F. The plants are developing quickly and vigorously, and are well fertilized. It is 38 days from planting. Maybe it is something about the environmental conditions or light spectrum?

William Schlegel

#1
So the dwarf was the father in both cases? I ask because sometimes people don't write the crosses female x male.

That being the case those look rugose. We definitely expect that to be recessive and not show up in the F1.

However, with genetics there could be exceptions. It seems like the rugose dwarf trait is not monophyletic. So it could be that some forms aren't subject to the same rule. Conversely you used your creation on both. It could be that your stable Crimson trellis x ping pong could be the source of the variation from our expectations. For instance if it simply doesn't have the opposing allele that is usual that might allow rugose dwarfism to express in the F1.

To get a better idea, more test crosses would be necessary. Test crosses with the two dwarfs you used and other mothers. Also test crosses with your variety and other dwarf and normal plants.

However in practice, as long as the cross was certain, segregation in the F2 should proceed normally even if the F1 is a dwarf.

An F1 dwarf might be a bit fun in its own right.

Some of my own lines like my Mission Mountain Sunrise (Brad x Blue Gold)] seem to have genes that keep them small but aren't rugose dwarfing. This makes sense given my love of short season tomatoes that were bred for such traits- probably the case with Braf. It's possible that you have somehow run into something like that with your stabilized Crimson trellis x ping pong.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Mike Deyo

Yes, the dwarf was the father in both cases. My Crimson X Trellis is regular leaf, and Hazy's Dream is potato leaf, so that turned out as expected.

I was expecting to get an full size plant for the F-1, and confirm it was a cross by seeing ~ 1/4 dwarf seedlings in the F-2. It looks like I might have confirmed the cross in the F-1. But might there be dwarf seedlings in this F-2 that don't breed true for dwarf, just like the F-1 plant had one dwarf gene and one regular gene, but expressed dwarf? I don't know the gene symbol for dwarf, but if D was full size and d was dwarf, normally you would expect 1/4 DD full size, 1/2 Dd full size, and 1/4 dd dwarf plants in the F-2. If another gene is involved that allows the Dd plants to express as dwarf, that would change the proportions, and also wouldn't guarantee a dwarf plant in the F-2 would have all dwarf progeny. Right?

William Schlegel

Correct. If this is an exception it potentially means non dwarf could keep segregating out. Should still be generally stable by F7 though as something like 95% of variation is gone by then.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

KaguyaCloud

#4
Hmm, can you take a picture of the stem around that flower truss in another angle(with the stem in view)? It almost looks like the growth was stunted for some reason at the growing tip. How close is the top of the plant to the grow light and what grow lights do you use? I find that the growing tip of the mainstem stunts considerably when it touches or is really close to the grow light. 

For my Micro-dwarf x Indeterminate, I find that the F1 can be quite small and compact in the initial growth cycles, then grow extremely tall as the season progresses. Early leaves of my F1 with Dd do show some wrinkling in the leaves, so non-rugose isn't fully dominant.

Here's a picture of my Micro-dwarf(Jochalos) x regular indeterminate(Rosella) cross at around 24 days:
https://i.imgur.com/a8pmWBA.jpeg

Do you have pictures of the two varieties you crossed? I might experiment to see if the stunted size is environmental by growing a sucker outdoors as a test.


 

Mike Deyo

The light is a Mars Hydro SP-150 led grow light, 135 watts. The plants are about 16 inches away, as you can see in the first photo. In the second photo you can see the flower truss, I put a penny on a lower leaf so you can see the size. It's true the stem is smaller diameter near the top, but it does seem like it is growing vigorously, not being stunted. The light intensity is enough for good growth, but I'm sure it is much less than full sunlight. The led lights are amazing, much cooler for the plants than flourescent or metal hydride. The manual for the light recommends 12-18 inches for flowering stage. I could probably raise the lights a few inches.

Mike Deyo

Also, where the first flower truss is, there was a strong sucker on the left that I pruned off. The plant's growth was probably split between the two. The stem with the flower truss will now be getting all the growing energy, and should quickly catch up.

Mike Deyo

I don't have photos of the two dwarf varieties I used in the crosses, but they do at Victory Seeds:

https://victoryseeds.com/products/dwarf-hazys-dream-tomato
https://victoryseeds.com/products/sleeping-lady-tomato

That's where I got the seed.

I included a picture of my stabilized Pink Ping Pong X Crimson Trellis from this past summer, on Aug 1. Not the best picture, but it grew easily 6 feet tall.

KaguyaCloud

#8
According to the ppfd map(https://www.saucegrowing.be/cdn/shop/products/mars-hydro-SP150.jpg?v=1699386102&width=1000) and hours you keep on, you have a very ideal amount of lights for the plants. Given the average values(ppfd value of 900) with 16 hours from 16 inches away, you are giving each plant a DLI(daily light integral) of 51! That's actually better than the recommended amount of 25-30. So you actually have better lighting than what the outdoors could provide.

Given ample fertilization, I think those plants will do very well indoors, but that might explain why they are growing so short. At higher light intensities(ppfd value of over 500) with a higher ratio of blue spectra in your lights, plants tend to grow shorter internodes due to photomorphogenesis. So I'm not too surprised that they're that small despite how large the leaves are. If you want to do another experiment, you could try rooting a sucker in a plastic cup and grow it by the windowsill or very far from your grow lights to see if it'll stretch out.

KaguyaCloud

You you have:

Dwarf potato leaf plant(dd, rr) as the father.
Normal regular leaf plant(DD, RR) as the mother.

F1 generation should be a regular leaf non-dwarf plant(Dd, Rr). I probably would've recommended using the dwarf potato leaf as the mother as it would show if the cross is true, but the slightly wrinkled leaves of the F1 might indicate being heterozygous for the dwarf gene.

Mike Deyo

I did crosses both ways, and for whatever reason I had no success with the dwarf plants as the female and the normal as the male. We had some really hot weather. I didn't catch the first flowers on the dwarf plants, that would have been the time to make a cross with them as female.

I have used this light to start tomatoes the past several years, and my memory is that the genetic normal height plants don't grow this short under this light.

In an earlier post William Schlegel wondered if there is a genetic factor in my stabilized Pink Ping Pong X Crimson Trellis that allows a Dd plant to express and grow as a dwarf. Or a different dwarf gene brought to the mix.

When I started these seedlings in December, I also grew a plant of my PPP X CT for comparison. When they had a couple of true leaves (past the cotyledons), I couldn't see a dramatic difference between them, and I discarded it. I wish now I had kept and potted up the PPP X CT plant, to at least see if it grew taller under the grow lights. That would have answered the question of whether the lights are making them short, or the genes.

KaguyaCloud

#11
They probably would still grow taller than your F1. While light does influence height, it only does to a certain extent as genetic factors still contribute to overall size.

Here's the indeterminate parent Rosella at 13 days planted after opened cotyledons:
https://i.imgur.com/chh2Nti.jpeg

Here's the F1 cross with micro Jochalos at 13 days:
https://i.imgur.com/x3vVfnz.jpeg

Here's the F2 generation at 14 days with the dwarf gene d selected(along with other potential dwarfing genes):
https://i.imgur.com/o9U6e3g.jpeg

Completely different sizes with the same light coverage from the top of the plant.

Mike Deyo

I moved my two plants to a 10F degree warmer place upstairs, 70F at night rather than 60F. Fruits are developing, and also I see that the new growth has longer nodes, closer to indeterminate growth habit. The first fruits developed about 9 inches up from the ground, when the plant was growing more like a dwarf. I left the first two flower tresses, and am cutting off the rest. Plant light and hours of day and night are the same as before.

The photo is of (PPPXCT) X Dwarf Sleeping Lady. The bottom of the yardstick is touching ground level in the pot. The other plant (PPPCT) X Dwarf Hazy's Dream looks very similar.

KaguyaCloud

#13
Very interesting. I see that the fruits on the plant have the non-uniform ripening gene(aka dark green tops). Does your regular non-dwarf plant have that trait in the fruits? Sleeping Lady does have that gene based off the images from Victory seeds and dark green tops are a dominant trait. If your Ping Pong x Crimson Trellis regular plant doesn't have that trait, your cross is successful.

Mike Deyo

Yes, my Pink Ping Pong X Crimson Trellis stabilized cross, does not have green tops when ripe. My memory is that that gene came from Crimson Trellis, which had fully red fruits when ripe. I selected for that trait during the stabilization of PPPXCT. Good to have confirmation of a cross!

Checking photos on Victory Seeds web site, I see Hazy's Dream also appears to have the non-uniform ripening gene. And I see that the developing fruit on my PPPXCT X Hazy's Dream plant has a dark green top, so it also must be a hybrid.