Future of OSSI Tomatoes?

Started by William Schlegel, 2023-04-17, 06:14:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

What is the future of OSSI Tomatoes?

Dwarf Tomato Project 2.0?

More Anthocyanin skinned varieties?

More disease resistance?

Just more varieties over time?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

I'm interested in what others think. I'm just getting started so I won't have anything to think about pledging for a couple years.


Some traits I'm working with for tomatoes...
Short season
High production
Dwarf
Beefsteak
Cherry
Promiscuous

I don't know what direction I'm going with anything yet. I plan to make notes on earliest flowers, earliest fruits, production, open anther cones, exserted stigmas,...
Then I can start making hand crosses and work from there.

I'm growing some dwarf varieties from the dwarf tomato project and will definitely post about them. If others are interested in doing a 2.0 thread here I'd definitely participate.

Cathy A

#2
My suggestion would be acquiring the widest possible range of traits (not just varieties) over time.

For example, having half a dozen beefsteak varieties with similar taste and DTM is not nearly as useful as half a dozen varieties with wildly different flavors, color, DTM, cold/heat tolerance, and so forth.

Looking at a typical list of OP tomato seeds for sale at the usual providers, what immediately strikes me is how much they look alike, and from the ones I've grown, how similar most of them taste.

So traits I'd like to see highly available among OSSI varieties:

- Taste; more of those fruity variations discussed in the wild-crossed and promiscuous threads
- Exserted stigmas; a wider range of tomatoes offering this useful trait
- Tolerance of cool weather; whether that means short season, ability to fruit with nights below 55F, frost tolerance, etc., etc.
- Heavy fruit set per plant
- Dwarf plants
- Wide range of disease tolerance
- Number of seeds produced per fruit; high is good for breeding and fresh eating, but low may be better for sauce

What other traits would be useful to gardeners,  but aren't much discussed or found outside of the breeding community?

AndrewB

#3
I really like Cathy's list above. Thanks Cathy!

QuoteWhat other traits would be useful to gardeners, but aren't much discussed or found outside of the breeding community?

hmm... great question... we may need to come back to this one.

I will start with my thoughts. I'm thinking these are the easiest steps to take first as some of them are already being worked on by various people here:

1.Continue breeding and selecting the Dwarf Tomato Project varieties as they have already been pledged and a considerable number of them too!

I am personally going to try and cross Uluru Ochre and Big Hill together as they both seem analogous in many ways, and both are supposedly around 65 DTM with decent sized tomatoes. Big Hill is not a dwarf, but is a determinate variety bred by Joseph L. and was the start of the promiscuous tomato project.

The traits that might want to be selected for in the F2 and beyond might be:
['Uluru Ochre' x 'Big Hill' = 'Ochre Hill'?]
A1. Dwarf stature
A2. Determinate growth
A3. Bicolour Fruits w/ green shoulders?
A4. Big Hill's exerted stigmas
A5. Big Hill's upright growth habit? (Does it have this, William?)
A6. 65 or less DTM
A7. Medium or Large fruits
A8. Large showy flowers (with lots of pollen?)
A9. Anything I forgot

Anyway, We can and should take the best of the Dwarf Tomato Project varieties and make them better. I also have a micro dwarf or semi-micro dwarf cherry tomato that I'd like to try crossing in. Perhaps micro dwarf tomatoes can also have large sized tomatoes too?? Worth experimenting with. Perhaps the "Dwarf Tomato Project 2.0" will also include micro dwarf tomatoes and those will be the next wave to be OSSI pledged.

I think all three projects involving (2) promiscuous tomatoes, (3) wild-tomato genetics/flavors, and breeding in (4) disease resistant lines will all continue and be folded into OSSI at some point.

There is someone on youtube trialing heirloom tomatoes they crossed to disease resistant lines and are growing out the F2s and F3s (maybe F4s) by now. She is also trialing dwarf tomatoes. AND they mention OSSI! I can't for the life of me figure out who this is, but these are the kind of projects that would be great to get OSSI pledged and officially recognized!

https://youtu.be/QlLjXoXgPtk

https://youtu.be/iryUiWdTfGI

https://youtu.be/QVgjGjO7iHE

back with more thoughts later...

William Schlegel

I don't think Big Hill is very upright in its growth habit. Though neither does it vine on the ground. I would call it bushy.

One thing I like about dwarfs is that some of them can hold their fruit off the ground without staking or caging. Though one of the things I learned last year is it is by no means universal. Weeding is important so they don't get etiolated and then fall down when weeded. Smaller fruit is important.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

#5
QuoteWhat other traits would be useful to gardeners, but aren't much discussed or found outside of the breeding community?

Alan Kapuler and his family's line of poly-truss tomatoes would be a useful trait to keep going in some lines and even cross with some dwarfs. I think this trait actually originated from wild tomatoes such as S. habrochiates.

Red Centiflor
Orange Centiflor
Yellow Centiflor
Chocolate Plentiflor
Early Willamette
Fullmoon Kiss
Geranium Kiss
Gold Plentiflor
Handy Lady
Lemon Lady
Plentiflor Paste
Purplex Paste
Sacred Heart
Sunrise Plentiflor
Summer Kiss

http://www.peaceseedslive.com/uploads/9/4/8/5/94858306/tomatoes_that_occasionally_outbreed.pdf

Cathy A

The YouTubers Andrew mentions say on their YouTube site that they are "professional horticulturalists and permaculture practitioners" and based in West Yorkshire. Does that fit anyone that the members here know?

Cathy A

I typically grow my tomatoes in tomato cages, and while it works, the tall indeterminates end up having stems break off when they grow beyond the cage, despite my efforts to thread them through cage gaps for more support.

I don't mind using cages, but am not going to the trouble of creating a tall staking system. The ground below the good soil in the beds is too hard (clay) to easily drive stakes deeply, and there is bedrock not far underneath.

Self-supporting stems, or at least stems that only require a simple one-piece tomato cage for support, are an important trait for me.

This is one of the few issues I have with Sungold. I lose a lot of stems to breaking from insufficient support. Of course, there is some tension here between the high fruit production per plant that I want too see, and the ability of the plant to carry the fruit with minimal support.

Steph S

I agree with Kathy that a wide range of traits, and unusual combinations of traits, is a useful goal for OSSI tomatoes.

Tomato is an interesting case because there are thousands of OP/heirloom varieties in circulation, so a substantial representation of traits which are public domain.   I am not up to date on tomato patenting issues, but to my knowledge the only utility patented traits are genetically modified.  I wouldn't expect a utility patent to be possible on any trait that's represented in the public domain, because it does require a demonstration that the trait is 'novel'.  However when I consider Frank Morton's work with lettuce (which is incredible!), his comments about patenting of lettuce traits would suggest that the same could happen with tomatoes, since lettuce is another crop with a large body of public domain varieties.  So novel traits, and novel combinations of traits, might be most important to prioritize for protection with OSSI.

The exserted stigma is an important trait for landrace tomato projects, because it enhances the opportunity for novel traits to emerge, especially where wild relatives are part of the project.
So for those of you who can and do work with landrace approaches and/or wild relatives in general, the important thing would be to watch for the emergence of novel traits, and pledge the material that has useful traits whether stigmas are exserted or not.

The other context for emergence of novel traits is stress related.  Using crosses that are as wide as possible, making crosses in plants under stress, increases the chance of 'hopeful monsters' ie phenos that exceed the parameters of both parents for important traits like tolerance of weather extremes.

From a strictly food security perspective, it makes sense to select for the ability to readily self pollinate under variable conditions (temperature, humidity) without the intervention of pollinators or mechanical device.  This is a highly variable trait in tomatoes, with a big impact on yield. Considering that climate stress can also have unexpected impacts on pollinator populations, it may be an important trait even in climates more friendly to tomatoes than my own.  Consistently setting a full truss is not the only component of yield but it is the sign that I'm looking for, of reliable self pollination.  There are also tomatoes that produce fruit in spite of low or no pollination rates in adverse conditions, which is another food security plus.  In larger, beefsteak type tomatoes, catfacing is the sign of incomplete self pollination, so selecting away from that is helpful.  If a good shaped fruit turns out to have few or no seeds because of incomplete pollination, I don't worry about it.

William Schlegel

#9
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41438-020-0291-7

I just found this article and am reading it. It seems like they wanted to develop some research germplasm from wild and traditional domestic tomatoes in the center of tomato diversity in Ecuador and Peru and made crosses to do so. "In order to help to exploit the variability detected in our collection and facilitate its use to the research community, F1 and F2 generations were constructed for the 163 accessions by crossing each accession with one accession representative of each species (SP, SLC, and SLL). The accessions, BGV007109 of SP, LA2278 of SLC and Money Maker of SLL were selected as parents." - above article quote

We could do the same thing in a way for OSSI. Cross existing OSSI tomatoes, with genetically diverse wild and domestic tomatoes (likely from South America). The resulting cross pools would be of OSSI descent and would lead to new and very genetically diverse breeding grexes and from those a suite of new varieties could be bred. Leveraging the power of OSSI's existing morphological diversity we've inherited mainly from the Dwarf Tomato Project.


The above article is a logical follow up to the Blanca et al 2015 article we've recently been discussing in another thread:
https://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-015-1444-1

Blanca et al 2015 state that "The SP category was the most genetically diverse group (He = 0.21), followed by SLC (He = 0.17) and SLL (He = 0.12) (Table 2)." where SP stands for current tomatoes and SLC stands for traditional domestic tomatoes in Peru and Ecuador. and SLL stands for domestic tomatoes from everywhere else. Since this measure of diversity is so much higher for current tomatoes and traditional domestic tomatoes both from South America- a logical way to improve OSSI tomatoes might be to do something like systematically match each of the 178 OSSI tomatoes which already represent tremendous morphological diversity each with a South American origin tomato accession and cross them.

Goal could be to achieve something like (He = 0.21) for OSSI tomatoes. The same level of genetic robustness found in wild current tomatoes.

I do notice also a very few morphological traits that seem to be still absent in the current OSSI tomatoes. Like the pear shape of yellow pear, deep ribs like in tomatoes from Oaxaca, or the odd clustered shape in Reisetomate.

Note: We also had a quote awhile back that a single accession of one of the obligate outcrossing tomato species can contain more genetic diversity than all cultivated tomatoes. Since cultivated tomatoes according to Blanca et al 2015 sit at (He = 0.12) and used to sit at (He = 0.09) that might not be as much as SP has spread out over all Peruvian and Ecuadorian accessions, but the obligate outcrossing tomatoes are certainly a more concentrated source than the species the above articles are focused on. Which means that a goal such as (He = 0.21) could be achieved with far fewer accessions total if say Solanum habrochaites was included. Though in my experience the red tomato clade is easy to work with and the outcrossing clade relatively more difficult. I've opted to work with both, but I think relatively few of us will. Though I do think that those of us who are working with the obligate outcrossing species will continue to create material that is easier for a larger group of breeders to exploit.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#10
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2022-02-09, 10:26:29 AMOn the similar European project https://www.opensourceseeds.org/en/Find%20varieties there are two Sunviva and Vivagrande amongst three total tomatoes where the U.S. site has 147 tomatoes but none that I know to have resistance (though this could be hiding in the details or could be revealed with trials).

A couple of years ago there were only a few varieties of tomato over at the European Open Source (OSS) vegetable project. Now there are quite a few more (Nineteen) and they capture some really interesting morphological variations. It also seems like they often mention resistances which is rare for the OSSI tomatoes.

https://www.opensourceseeds.org/en/Find%20varieties?page=1

https://www.opensourceseeds.org/en/seed/tomate-%E2%80%9Eelements-obsidian%E2%80%9C

https://www.opensourceseeds.org/en/seed/tomato-%E2%80%9Em%C3%A4rchenfeuer%E2%80%9C

https://www.opensourceseeds.org/en/seed/bonbon-de-gembloux-cthgx

If trends hold, it will be quite a while before very many of these are available in the US but for European board members this is probably a very good collection of breeding stock now.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#11
Just a bit of a comparison of the few OSSI varieties with some modern or currant tomato genetics and the OSS varieties that mention resistance.

OSSI           
Blush Yellow    antho       
Blush Plum    antho       
Dwarf Eagle Smiley    Currant       
Dwarf Johnson's Cherry    Currant       
Dwarf Mocha's Cherry    antho       
Dwarf Mignonne    antho       
Gondwana Lava    antho       
Gondwana lightning    antho       
Gondwana Moon    antho       
Gondwana Rose    antho       
Gondwana Thunder    antho       
Home Stoop    Currant via Stupice       
Honeydrop    Sunsugar Dehybridization       
Pink Princess    Sunsugar Dehybridization       
Anona's Sunset    Sunsugar Dehybridization       
Perfect Rogue    Early Girl Dehybridization       
Super Snacks    Juliet F1 x Blush       
Estate    Currant via Stupice       
Santium Sunrise    ?       
Magic Bullet antho ?
OSS           
Sunviva    Late Blight Resistant
Vivagrande Late Blight Resistant
Elements-Beach fungal resistance
Marchenfeuer    Resistance   
Marchenwald    Antho + Blight Resistant
Marchenengel    Antho + Late Blight Resistant
Marchenglanz Antho + Blight tolerant
Marchengold    Resistance       
Elements-Glut    Resistance   
Elements-Tornado    Resistance     
Bonbon de Gembloux-CTHGx    Resistance       

I may have missed a few that should be added? I would guesstimate that crossing with this group of open-source tomatoes might be more productive in terms of resilience and resistance. OSS seems to be breeding for resistance much more seriously than OSSI- much as our forum members from Europe are.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days