Suggestions of a "wow factor" tomato variety ?

Started by Nicolas, 2023-05-17, 11:32:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nicolas

Hi,

I'm looking for a tomato with the most potential for bringing special features in a breeding project.

What variety would you recommend that packs the most unusual features ?

I'm thinking traits like variegation, stripes or speckles, wooly, dwarf, multiflora, etc.
Bonus points if it has big fruits to be able to breed big fruits without too much trouble.

Thanks !

William Schlegel

#1
I made a cross with Brad's Atomic Grape last year which has anthocyanin, stripes, and tricolor flesh and I am excited to see the F2 next year. I generally agree that making well considered crosses with tomatoes with a lot of interesting traits is a good approach but it almost would turn into a need to back cross to the fancy parent if you want everything it has.

Other wow factors might include multiple disease resistance for example.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Are you looking for interesting "artistic" wow factors, or "practical" productive wow factors?

You will get a different list of varieties for the two cases.

Sungold has a lot of good traits that suggest it is good breeding material, such as taste, beta orange, high fruit productivity per plant, and earliness. I am growing quit a few Sungold F2 plants this with the intent of using them for crosses.

Uluru Ochre is a dwarf that seems to be very early. I am cautiously optimistic about this variety, both as-is and as breeding material.

Joseph's charts suggest that Jagodka is extremely productive in the early season and Nevsky is more productive in late season. I have found both Earl's Jagodka (a different strain from Joseph's) and Nevsky reliably produce large, healthy-looking plants from seed.

William reported that he found Krainy Sever to be the best of the Soviet dwarves. My single plant is very healthy; I hope it will do well here.

Big Hill has been used as a parent in several breeding projects.

If you are looking for more artistic traits, I'm the wrong person to ask. :-)

Nicolas


Cathy A

Have a look at the Baker Creek site, https://rareseeds.com. They have a lot of crazy-looking varieties.

William Schlegel

There are a subset of tomato breeders who seem inclined towards trying to make the fanciest possible tomatoes. I feel like their work is best found at the sites of extensive tomato collectors and seed sellers. Brad Gates is probably the most mainstream of them. I want that too but with good flavor and short season. I discovered Tom Wagners Muddy Waters last year. It has superior flavor, stripes, and anthocyanin. At least the strain I found. I feel like there might be varieties out there with more fantastic combinations though. Like Seattle Blue Woolly Mammoth  https://tatermater.proboards.com/thread/912/seattle-blue-woolly-mammoth
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

It sounds to me like 'wow' factor tomato is the one you want to breed yourself.
I recall that a lot of the traits you mentioned were being explored by Dan and collaborators - breeding projects that started at Tville and are now hosted at Tomato Talk. 
So you might actually find an existing line or variety that combined multiple traits you mentioned, at the Micro Tomato Diversity project, here:
https://www.tomato-talk.com/

Nicolas

Thanks for the reply

I'm not really interested in strange features myself, but it could be fun to propose some F2 between a good tasting and a fun looking tomatoes

Riley V

'Stick' is a really cool looking variety. Then there is variegation also. Multifloras, i don't know the names of any varieties carrying the Single Flower Truss gene (SFT) but that's pretty vool too i think. S. lycopersicoides has sweet smelling flowers and some accessions have white anthers. Some tomatoes are prone to growing woody stems too! I don't know the inheritance of that though

Nicolas

Have you examples of cultivars with woody stems ? Joseph talked about one showing up in his promiscuous project too

Riley V

I don't know any, sorry. My parent's had a volunteer F2 red cherry with a woody stem. I know S. chilense and S. lycopersicoides are supposed to have woody stems too

Riley V

I'm growing S. chilense right now for both an ornamental line myself and to eventually cross into my food lines. But from what I've seen online is alot of people don't know the difference between woody stems and aerial advantageous roots either from too much water or compact soil. So it's difficult looking for variety names. That and i don't know if any seed companies would want to advertise that or not. If its even a reliable trait from generation to generation.

ThomatoGarden

Siberian Tiger(Panther) and Wapsipinicon Peach are two Tomatoes  which could be
a crossing Partner in a good looking, fancy, tasty Tomato.

- Siberian Tiger(Panther) red-violet Tomato, every Year Winner in taste Contest here. Plant needs
   some attention , only let 2-3 grow per truss.

- Wapsipinicon Peach light yellow hairy peach like fruit, exotic good taste, a bit resistant. Production
   is very inconsistent and not high, smaller fruit, bigger fruit, ripening ....

Still this two and Primabella are the only ones i grew every year.

Crossing this with some fancy looking Tomatoes would be interesting


William Schlegel

#13
I looked up Siberian Panther and superficially it looks like the original Oregon State University violet tomatoes. That skin color is pretty easy to transfer to new varieties and starting with one with good flavor is always a good idea. I especially like the flavor of Tom Wagner's Muddy Waters a green when ripe with good stripes. Though I think similar flavor segregated out of my 2023 cross with Brad Gate's Brads Atomic Grape. The similar named Amurski Tigr sometimes translated to Siberian Tiger is a pretty ordinary early red with stripes- but I don't think the stripes are as clear as some of the other striped genetics out there. It seems like it would be pretty straightforward to do a double cross with your top three and something fancy looking. I've also been crossing with Purple Zebra F1 which seems like a good source of stripes and resistances and the popular dark muddy red flesh color. I'd suggest maybe doing something like Wapsipinicon Peach x Primabella and then something like Siberian Panther x Purple Zebra F1. Then cross the F1s together. Let that segregate a few years and then maybe cross the best results with something like Brad's Atomic Grape.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#14
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-05-18, 05:42:05 PMI made a cross with Brad's Atomic Grape last year which has anthocyanin, stripes, and tricolor flesh and I am excited to see the F2 next year. I generally agree that making well considered crosses with tomatoes with a lot of interesting traits is a good approach but it almost would turn into a need to back cross to the fancy parent if you want everything it has.

Other wow factors might include multiple disease resistance for example.
Now that I have seen the F2 of my cross with Brad's Atomic Grape I can confirm it was a very good choice. I crossed it with a blue bicolor. Lots of stripes, green flesh, yellow flesh and at least one red flesh. Round fruits, long sausage shaped fruits, and at least one very large red striped fruit. I think I will make some subsequent crosses with my favorite selection(s) from the cross but I could also see just going back to Brad's Atomic Grape.

Wondering what other cross parents might provide as much useful visible variation after a cross- one thought is to research the crosses the Dwarf Tomato Project made and reuse some of the parents that resulted in larger numbers of varieties. Or use the resultant varieties that the project created that are most like the high yielding parents.

It looks like from Victory Seeds page of families https://victoryseeds.com/collections/dwarf-tomato-project
That Beauty, Grumpy, Plentiful, Sneezy, and Snowy were particularly productive crosses in terms of new varieties. Also, they produced new varieties similar to at least one of the parents in all cases that could be used in new similar crosses. Surprisingly the crosses themselves don't seem that exotic. I think they could be summed up as: Striped bicolor x purple fleshed, Red x Black, Red x purple, yellow x green, white x red. I'm not sure if there is really any difference between tomatoes described as black and those described as purple. This strikes me as encouraging as I included Purple Zebra F1 (purple), Dwarf Mocha's Cherry (purple & antho), Amethyst Cream (white and antho), the before mentioned Brad's Atomic Grape, my standard blue bicolors, and quite a few yellows and reds in my crosses of the last few years.

https://www.tomatofifou.com/en/dwarf-tomato-project-variety-repertory/
From this Tomatiofifou article above it looks like we can add the Witty family to that highly productive list which is essentially a red x green cross between Budai Torpe and Cherokee Green.

Another thought is the very odd, shaped traveler's tomato or reistomate. It has already yielded a couple of new similar varieties, but it could be crossed with a lot more. Similarly, deeply ribbed tomatoes have been perhaps underutilized especially for OSSI tomatoes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days