Early lettuce

Started by Cathy A, 2024-04-30, 06:17:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

I started some lettuce indoors under lights this spring because conditions outdoors delayed getting seeds planted directly outdoors.

I planted black-seeded simpson, pirat, winter density,and crispino. I've grown all of these before and they generally do well here.

But I was quite surprised at the indoor results. The black-seeded simpson grew astonishingly fast compared with the other three and were more than ready to be set outside when the other three had barely started.

Has anyone bred lettuce specifically for fast start, getting in a "hunger season" crop as early in spring as possible?

It seems like a highly desirable trait.

Ferdzy

I don't start lettuce indoors, it gets direct seeded or quite often just comes up where we failed to collect all the seed.

May King (aka May Queen) is generally the earliest to appear by several weeks.

Cathy A

I've generally direct-seeded lettuce in the past, but this year a lot of wet weather prevented me from doing that as early as I would like. So I started it inside and transplanted it out when the weather improved.

Gardeners such as Niki Jabbour have written that they routinely start lettuce indoors under lights and transplant it out to keep the garden productive.

Steph S

I grow lettuce indoors under lights in the fall-winter-early spring.
For sure there are differences in growth rate, with 60 DTM lettuces being slower generally than the earlier rated ones.  Deeply red lettuce is often a slow grower, noticeably slower than others.  Red Romaine for example.  In a red lettuce for cut and come, Rouge d'Hiver was well paired with Speckled Trout type for faster lettuce growth.

Overall though freshness of seed seems to be the biggest factor in lettuce emergence and speed of growth.
So in order to identify the genetic basis for that useful trait, you need fresh seed of all varieties being trialed.
I wish buying a new commercial packet was a good guarantee of freshness but it's not the case.
Overall purchased seed has not done as well nor even been as reliable when several years old, as the home harvested seed.   Seeds that seem fine in the year of purchase have also crapped out and produced nothing the year after, meaning they were close to their expiry year.
So this is what happened to my 'select fast favorites' process - the results got confounded by seed age and seed failures.
Cocarde is a bronze oak leaf that was very fast in recent trials, but the seed was exceptionally fresh and good (from Annapolis).   I can vouch for May Queen being fast too - at least in the first year it wowed me but the seed was kaput afterwards, i only got one plant which is still lurking in the greenhouse in the hopes of getting seed. 

Also overall, lettuce is never as fast as the fast brassica greens, so they do tend to fill the bill of 'hunger crop' the best, with lettuce coming along a little later.
I'm finding arugula and my favorite romaine Sherwood (similar to Winter Density but a spoon shaped leaf) are really well matched for a mixed sowing as both come on pretty slowly compared to the brassicas.  But possibly that Sherwood seed is getting old too. 

Adrian

Warning lettuce germination can be very long.Niether too cold niether too hot for a good germination.

Cathy A

Steph, that's important information. Most of the seed I planted was several years old, and that could certainly have affected both germination rate and speed.

I suppose the best way to do a trial would be to grow all the test varieties the year before the actual trial, save seed from each one yourself, and then do the actual trial using your own saved seed of known age.