Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

A Horn

On tomato junction they believe that the micro dwarfs have an additional dwarfing gene that is not rugose.

William Schlegel

#121
I have several varieties in my collection that are genetically small but the source isn't the rugose dwarf gene. One promising such strain is Lee Goodwin's Dwarf Hirsutum Cross. It's a small potato leaf plant with red normal flavored tomatoes. I think some number of other short season tomatoes also have small size with out the full syndrome of traits found in the rugose dwarfs. Though my perception may be a bit skewed by my shallow top soil which also keeps tomato plants small.

The dwarf rugose gene is probably the result of a mutation. It's also possible that not every strain is the same. So there could be several mutations with the same effect. Crossing mutations like that may have unintended consequences. For instance an F1 of two such rugose dwarfs could end up being normal size if the two mutations are in different places the complete normal protein could be expressed properly. I think someone mentioned they avoided crossing dwarfs from different source lineages for the dwarf tomato project to try to avoid complications. Though crossing between the small plants and the dwarfs could lead to new strains of micro dwarf.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#122
Quote from: reed on 2024-03-26, 09:28:53 AMI really like the idea of dwarf, but rugose doesn't seem to get along with the microscopic things that live in my garden and the microscopic things win.

This thought that the rugose crinkling is a deleterious trait in your garden Reed. It is a testable hypothesis. You've observed rugose dwarfs failing. You already have F1 seed in hand for a dwarf crossed to Utah Heart one of the few varieties that has succeeded in your garden. If you can get F2 seed and grow it out you would have a mix of rugose dwarf and non dwarf seedling types with a known genetic background that should segregate into individuals that do well in your garden and those that don't. If you grow enough seedlings the results could be statistically valid.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

Utah Heart x Dwarf MMR is one that I already have picked out to grow. Actually, I'm going to plant most of the F1s you sent. Being F1s I only have to grow a couple of plants to see how they do and to get lots of F2 seed. I'm also planting a crowded tub full of the F2, MMM x PH5 Pimp.

I also have Bush Early Girl; I don't know if it is rugose or if "bush" is the same as "dwarf", I suspect it is. It's also determinate and Galahad F1 is too. In my experience determinates are a bit dwarfish themselves, at least in comparison to most of mine. Hoosier Rose, I suspect could reach 15 feet or more if you built a trellis that big. I also suspect that determinate isn't really a one or the other type of trait, but I haven't grown them enough to know for sure, so that might be wishful thinking. It might take more than just one year but I intend to find out.

reed

I'm getting closer to knowing for sure what I'm going to grow. Aside from the various F1s that I'll find a spot for somewhere, I have six of my normal trellises ready to go. I plant four per trellis and normally three of them are Utah Heart because they are the ones we make juice and sauce from. I think I'll cut that down to just eight and plant two each of SuperSauce and Plum regal. That leaves three trellises for the regular leaf beefsteaks, Mr. Stripey, Cherokee Purple, Pineapple and Wyllard Wynn. I wasn't going to plant Pineapple and Cherokee Purple but was overruled on that. I can't really tell much difference between Pineapple and Mr. Stripey except that Pineapple has a little bit less red color. Wyllard Wynn is very much like Mr. Stripey too, except maybe slightly smaller fruits and a few more of them. It has potential to replace Mr. Stripey if it performs as well as it did last year. I've grown all of those for a long time except for Wyllard Winn.

I'm pretty much convinced that these large, sweet tomatoes are generally adapted to my garden, even if the seeds were not saved from it for years like with my old favorites. I think it might be though that any new seeds are better if they come from the general region of the Smoky Mountains but not too far south. 

I have two more trellises to set up for the potato leaf varieties, Hoosier Rose, Hillbilly, Brandywine OTV and Yellow Brandywine. They will be the mothers of most of my attempted crosses. Fathers will be all of those above plus the new ones I bought, especially Galahad F1, Hot Streak F1 and Purple Calabash. I'm hopeful that Purple Calabash has an intense non-sweet flavor to mix into juice and sauce. My only complaint and it isn't a strong one about Utah Heart is that is a bit sweeter than I really like for how we use it. Even though I won't have the easy tell like when crossed to a PL, I might try to cross it to Utah Heart and to Cherokee purple.

I set up a cold frame in the garden a couple weeks ago and already have lots of Utha Heart, Cherokee Purple, Hoosier Rose and Pimp mix all sprouted. They are close to big enough to tell if there are any RL crosses in the PL Hoosier Rose. Most of those will be to pot up and sell, I'll be staring all the others this weekend. I also have about thirty of the much larger HR that I started inside. I went ahead and planted that one that survived the freeze in the ground, just out of curiosity as to how it will do. I'm not going to cover it, even if another freeze threatens.



   

William Schlegel

MMM x PH5 pimp is liable to be tested and thinned out by disease better in other folks gardens than mine including yours.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I'll probably put them in one of my big tubs, which are also ready to go. How many total plants do I need to get the full range of possibilities from these F2 seeds? Can I fit enough of them in a single 25-gallon tub, or should I use two.

Also, could you remind me what MMM is?

And I'm wondering if I should try to backcross some of the other F1s. For example, those crossed to Utah Heart. Cross them back to UH now or grow them out and backcross later with the F2 or the F3? I'm kind of leaning toward waiting a season or two. Just leave them 1/2 and 1/2 for a bit and do some selection then. Who knows, along the way maybe some will turn into something nice on their own.

William Schlegel

#127
Single 25 gallon tub would probably do for about 25 plants. Thats about all I would give it. I think about a quarter of them should be homozygous for that PH5. Well, hmm, maybe less than that if it is two genes? Would that halve it? I'm not going to get the calculations out and check but I still think 25 plants has a decent shot at finding a good one with the PH5. You could grow a lot more and have a shot at the biggest possible fruit and different leaves and maybe a splash of blue on the fruit, but I think back crossing the healthiest after a few generations is the better move than growing so many. Fruit could range from current size to saladette size.

MMM = Mission Mountain Sunrise x Big Hill OSSI registered as HX-9 by Joseph. Mission Mountain Sunrise is likely Joseph's unknown nicknamed "Brad" x Blue Gold bred by Brad Gates. So everything crossed from MMM is at least three crossings deep from my garden and everything is descended back from Joseph and Brad's work and of OSSI descent.

For back crossing I think it depends on what you want from each parent from the possibilities in the cross. Also, how big of a population size you want to have to grow to get a specific thing back. Back crossing will help you recover traits of your favorite parent in a cross. So if you really like Utah Heart but just want to change it a little (especially if you aren't super particular about what changes), back crossing early and often may be a good technique. It can be kind of nice to let a cross ride for a couple generations between either back crosses or outcrosses. It allows you to select a few things you like from the F2's and then cross with those. So it really depends on your goals.

Utah Heart x (MMM x Sweet Cherriette)
- Potentials here include bicolor yellow/red marbled fruit, red fruit, blue skin, potato leaf, earliness. 4 crosses in my garden.


Utah Heart x (MMR Dwarf)
- If you are interested in the Rugose Dwarf gene it might make sense to wait two generations before backcrossing this one so you can pick out the dwarfs to cross with. Aztek had good flavored yellow flesh and pointed fruit tips, Bicolor from MMM, possible blue skin, Red from Utah Heart. 4 crosses in my garden.

Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375)
This one is some small potential for resistance to that brown rugose fruit virus from the current tomato plus everything else current tomatoes might have. Bicolor maybe blue from MMM. Different leaf types. 4 crosses in my garden. Of the four crosses, this one fits my ideals best it has fancy + local + wild and because it has tomatoes from both your and my garden it has the local for both of us though that has to be allowed to segregate in our respective gardens to adapt.

Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ)
Bicolor possible from both sides, possible stripes, possible blue. 4 crosses in my garden.

These have all also been crossed pretty rapidly in the last few years so some of the possibilities may already be diluting out. Wouldn't hurt to let them segregate to the F2. The F1 won't tell you much even about the real potential of the cross- it might not even make it in your garden where some portion of the F2 is almost certain to because of the parentage that came from your garden.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#128
Well, it's settled then. Getting my garden ready this spring I realize that I need to trim this whole thing down a bit so as not to interfere to much with producing the tomatoes and other crops we like. I think I'll plant all the F1s crossed to my own but Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375) is the one I'll mostly focus on. It and a tub of the F2 Pimp cross.

I grew XH-9 and Big Hill some years back and they didn't really do all that well on tolerance or flavor. My season is much longer than in the high desert, humidity is much higher, and I don't irrigate. There was one tomato that I got from Joseph that I called Utah Red Bottom. It apparently had quite a bit of beefsteak in it because it was similar in size, it grew nicely and had flavor on par with some of mine, but it had a big hard green core.

I think most of the crossing I try this year will be between my own PL and RL types. They are all good and I think whatever comes from them will also be good. And also, with some of the new ones I bought. Yellow Brandywine I think is probably safe to take a chance on and Brandywine OTV probably is too, and they are a bit shorter maturity than mine.

Galahad F1 and Hot Streak F1 have the disease package, shorter maturity time and smaller fruit size, all things I would like to bring in, I'm very curious how they will do. Actually, by description they are just about perfect as they are, except of course they are F1s, and it's an "if" that they will grow here despite the claims and an even bigger "if" that they really do taste good.

Anyway, in a couple of days I'll decide for sure what I'm growing by putting seeds in dirt. Then it will be cut in stone, and I can quit waffling back and forth about it.  :-\  If later on I can use descendants of Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375) to add in some fancy colors that would be really cool. 

reed

Well, I'm not usually one to fall for marketing and about the last thing I need this year is another tomato, but I saw a YouTube ad for this SART ROLOISE tomato.

A big drawback is that it's a very long season tomato, which I'm trying to move away from. I like that it seems to set fruit on more blossoms than my big, long season tomatoes do. I ordinarily might rule it out too because of low chance it will actually grow here, but it had several good reviews including from North Carolina, Virginia, Pennsylvania and Tennessee. All of those places are in the geographic area that I target for acquiring seed or short of that, to at least know it has been grown there. Baker Creek has free shipping too, so I think I'll spend a few bucks and add one more tomato to my mix.


reed

#130
I saw on William's Montana Tomato Project that he had planted a lot of his tomatoes yesterday. I got most of mine planted yesterday too, except for what I call the Pimps. I plant in old commercial nursery pots around twenty seeds each. I planted nine of them, each with two varieties, nowhere near the numbers you folks plant but seemed like a lot to me.  I set them in the cold frame, I expect they will be up pretty soon, depending on the availability of sunshine to warm them up. I'm adding in a new practice this year, that is to actually write down the day I plant the seeds so I can see how long it actually takes each kind to make fruit.

Shorter season maturity is becoming more of a goal so I am hopeful Galahad and Hot Streak which are both two weeks earlier than most of mine will up the possibility for that in future along with the disease resistance. Two other new ones, Yellow Brandywine and Brandywine OTV are also a week or more earlier.  Flavor is a big priority to us and I'm pretty confident we will like both YB and BOTV, just have to wait and see on the others. Then of course Early Girl and Bush Early Girl are almost a month earlier than mine, but I don't have much hope they will taste very good.

From Williams seeds I planted those crossed to Mr. Stripy and Hoosier Rose. I think Hoosier Rose is the one that has some Purple Zebra in it, so that will be fun to see if I can pick up some more color in future generations. Purple Calabrese and even Cherokee Purple have some darker color so maybe eventually I can mix that all up too. I'm wondering about the flavor of Purple Calabrese, I hope it has an intense non-sweet flavor. I love my sweet tomatoes, but I like non-sweet ones too.

Then I planted Plum Regal and Supersauce, just to see what they do. Supersauce is short season, if I recall just 70 days or so. That seems odd for such a supposedly big tomato. It's also the one that's supposedly seedless. If they turn out ok, then I'll try crossing them to Utah Heart.
 
Anyway, seeds are in the soil and lots of others already sprouted in the other cold frame. About a hundred or more Hoosier Rose are almost big enough to tell if I have any natural crosses. My first purposeful attempt at tomato breeding is underway.

reed

All of the second guessing and mind changing is over now, thank goodness. All of my tomatoes including some late to the plan direct seeded pimp crosses are in the ground. I still have plenty of back up plants in case something happens to any and something did happen to a Hoosier plant croaked the other day, all of a sudden and for no obvious reason. I guess something must have chewed it roots.

I only ended up with two of the crosses with mine that Willam did for me. Those being Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375) and Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ). I have three plants each of those. I guess being F1s I really only need one each, but I like to hedge my bets a little.

I messed up and didn't plant enough of Child of Utah Heart. It is the off type that showed up in the Utah Heart patch and I realized that it might not have been F1 so should have planted more, as it is I only have three plants. I guess if it is F1 then they will all be the same and no harm done. If they turn out different, I'll have to plant more of the old seeds next year to get the full range of possibilities.

For all the raving about my own old standbys Hoosier Rose and Mr. Stripy, I think I'm most excited about the new one I tried last year, called Willard Winn. It is just as good as my Mr. Stripy, but it makes more, slightly smaller fruits per cluster. And the new one Brandywine OTV, going on just it's description it may rival or equal Hoosier Rose, and its potato leaf so a good choice for crossing as the mother. And Yellow Brandywine, a supposed I Indiana heirloom that's ten or so days earlier than Hoosier Rose or Mr. Stripy. And Galahad F1, of course for the disease resistance. If it really tastes good as well, I'll be using a lot of its pollen in my crosses.

I don't know yet that any of these new varieties will really do well here, let alone compare in flavor to mine so I'm certainly not abandoning mine. I'm them as well, plus have tons of backup seed. It would be nice though to produce an abundance of fresh seed this year and to know it is all good so I can get rid of the big box of individually packaged seeds accumulated over the years.

I would like ultimately for my Mid-Ohio Valley tomatoes to never really be a stable variety. Instead to be a continually changing variety true only in excellent flavor, tolerant to local conditions and always carrying the recessive potato leaf trait so whenever a potato leaf plant shows up, I can try to cross it to an equally superior regular leaf. 

Well, there is one more I haven't even started yet. It came from the grocery store; the label says it was greenhouse grown in Canada from Japanese seeds. I have some fermenting now. I can't really describe the flavor except the first impression when I bite it is a little lackluster. After that though it grows and changes, with different nuances as it hits the different areas of the tongue and lingers a little after I swallow it. It's like an expensive French Wine that just keeps on giving for a few minutes after you sip it, it's sort of addicting, you can't eat just one. I'm sure it is probably an F1 with only God and some Japanese plant witches knowing where it came from, but I'm going to plant it.

 


reed

#132
Most of my tomatoes are starting to develop blooms. Some of the pimp mix have small fruits already, they are some that I started early, under plastic in the ground and just left in place.  There is probably fifty or more of them in a space about two feet by four feet. I sure hope these first ones turn out to be some our favorites, in which case I'll just pull out a lot of the others.

Both of the F1s that William did with my Mr. Stripy and Hooser Rose x his wild crosses have clusters of small buds, still too early to tell what the flowers will look like but there is a lot of them per branch.

I'm encouraged by the size of the first buds on the Brandywine OTV. It's normal for early flowers on these beefsteaks to be big and often double but this one looks to be normal. Too bad nothing else is far enough along to try a cross when it opens, well noting but the pimps, so I guess I could try that, just for fun.

Color comes out wrong on my screen, the sort of brown looking areas are actually kind of purple. I'm guessing because it has been so cool and cloudy in recent days. It was 54 this morning and we are predicted for a couple mornings in high forties in coming days. Or maybe it's just normal for this variety. I have them growing right next to normal leaf Willard Wynn and am going to try lots of crosses between the two. 

reed

I have more flowers on Brandywine OTV and now some on Cherokee Purple, Hoosier Rose and soon on Willard Wynn. More fruit is forming in the pimp mix patch. That pimp mix is result of an accidental cross that happened several years ago. Whatever the father was it had to be a large beefsteak type because or maybe Utah Heart because they were the only other tomatoes I had.

I don't know how segregation really works over the years, especially with little to no purposeful selection but I guess years later they are still 1/2 pimp and 1/2 large fruited domestic. I wonder what will happen if I cross them back to a potato leaf beefsteak like Brandywine OTV. I haven't identified one yet but when one of the tiny, yellow and super sweet ones reveals itself, I'm going to give it a try. 

The Galahad F1 and Hotstreak F1 are supposed to be only about 70 days to maturity but neither one has bloomed yet.

reed

#134
I'm enjoying snacking on the pimp crossed tomatoes now while working in the garden, not a whole lot of them yet and none have made it into the house. Only those that were started early under plastic and left in place have ripe fruit so far. Those transplanted from that bed have green fruits and will soon also be ripening. They are much larger plants due to having more space and plenty of mulch.

Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375) and Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ) both have small green fruits, but at about the size of golf balls, are already larger than I had expected. I hope they keep getting bigger before ripening. Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ) fruits are heavily lobed, much more so than Mr. Stripey itself.

I picked out some new varieties partly because they are supposed to be shorter season, Galahad and Hot Streak F1s are right about 70 DTM. Yellow Brandywine and Brandywine OTV are close to that too, but my old Cherokee Purple has much larger green fruit than any of them.  I've never paid good attention to that before but looks like CP is the earliest of them all, even earlier than Early Girl F1 based on size of fruit at this stage. Early Girl may pull it out in the end though, as its fruits are much smaller when ripe.

Almost forgot, I'm not seeing as much openness in the flowers as I'm used to. Maybe its weather related, I don't know.  The winner on open flowers is Child of Utha Heart which showed up as an off type. I screwed up with it as it may be F2 instead of F1 and I only have two plants. O' well, hopefully it will be good, and I can move on from here next season. Actually, it about has to be good as I don't have any bad tomatoes to have crossed with the UH in the first place.

I'm impressed with Dwarf Early Girl F1 as far as strong, robust plants and very dark green leaves but its fruits are only about the size on marbles now.

My pimp patch has some spotting and yellowing of lower leaves but that's normal for them and doesn't seem impact growth or fruiting. No other disease issues at all so far. Supersauce F1 has larger than expected fruit for the time of season but has some hint of blossom end rot. Not all fruits have it, so I keep it around just to see if it really is seedless.

I haven't tired crossing yet, plan to start that this weekend. I probably won't mess with trying to collect pollen but instead just remove the male parent flower and dab the anthers directly on the female flower. Removing the anthers from the mother flower at the appropriate time without killing it is the biggest challenge.