Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

#105
I noticed this over on the thread about septoria tolerance.

Quote from: Nicolas on 2024-03-18, 11:47:54 PMIn this document green zebra is marked with some septoria tolerance
https://plantpathology.ca.uky.edu/files/ppfs-vg-25.pdf

That's an interesting paper, UK is just a few miles down the river from me too, so maybe their stuff applies a bit more to me than some. Image #2 on the first page of the leaf with the brown spots looks very familiar to me. Most of my tomatoes usually have some of that by mid-season or so. My pimp plants pretty much always have it, sometimes from day one. Even the cotyledon leaves have it but then it goes away as they grow. It doesn't really hurt anything as far as fruit production goes on any of my tomatoes, lower leaves are just a bit ragged looking by end of season.

Image # 7 on page two is also familiar although I've seen something just like it on fruits while they say "Infections on fruit are exceedingly rare". Someone gave me some oxheart tomatoes one time that were supposed to be a local heirloom and they had it bad. A single little spot ruined the flavor of the whole fruit. I called it moon crater disease and local history or not, I just stopped growing that variety. 

Mr. Stripy, Utah Heart, Hoosier Rose, Cherokee Purple, Willard Wynn and all of the pimps get that some, or something like it, but they just shrug it off and make lots of good tomatoes anyway. It's sort of useful in a way because it quickly eliminates new varieties that I try but that don't belong here.

I think it and maybe some early blight is what took out William's "The One". A tomato from Joseph that I called Captain Crunch also had it really bad. Plants were completely defoliated by it and maybe other diseases too, but still made a lot of really good tomatoes. It was weird to see an apparently dead plant hanging full of nice tomatoes that were unaffected and finished ripening just fine. Captain Crunch wasn't stable though and it's offspring were not as good. I sent Captain Crunch seeds to several people but never heard if subsequent generations turned out or not. Although the vine died soon after, the tomatoes in this photo had a really good fruity flavor and the green ones finished ripening. 

William Schlegel

Looking at that article. I have some bad looking leaves on my little early grow out to try to get some F2 fruit before spring. I was thinking Septoria and now I am wondering if it might actually be Early Blight. Also seed borne whatever it is. Thinking about treating all my seed before planting this year as I've agreed to increase some important seed for a mentor.

I've always had older leaves that look bad with yellowing and brown spots out in my tomato gardens. I've never properly diagnosed it. My mental model has been something like: old tomato leaves are yellow and spotty. It really just hasn't mattered. I don't pick the old leaves off or anything. It could even be that I have Septoria and Early Blight or something else similar. I did find a spot on a fruit a couple years ago that could have been Early Blight. Disease presence and disease severity are two different things. In my gardens I can get away with a lot of things others in different climates might not be able to. Like planting really close and overhead watering- though I tend not to water at all during the best tomato months of July and August. Then frost kills everything and the diseases just don't matter- because the climate is arid and short season.

That said I think a tomato with some tolerance to whatever I do have would come out looking good. Though in the article, it says that Iron Lady F1 has a bit of tolerance or resistance to both. I've grown Iron Lady F1 and F2 and it was ok if boring.

In the article it says that Green Zebra has some Septoria Tolerance and Indigo Rose has some Early Blight Tolerance. Folks have combined those two in forms like Muddy Waters but I don't think that is the only striped blue tomato- and its just possible that quite a few of the striped blue tomatoes have ancestry from those two or their close relatives. Wouldn't be surprised if some of them have both.

I think I sometimes notice a variety to be a really healthy-looking variety. I think I need to pay closer attention to that and try to make crosses when that happens. It could just be that I do have a few diseases and also the potential genetic solutions to them at hand.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

"I've always had older leaves that look bad with yellowing and brown spots out in my tomato gardens. I've never properly diagnosed it. My mental model has been something like: old tomato leaves are yellow and spotty. It really just hasn't mattered. I don't pick the old leaves off or anything. It could even be that I have Septoria and Early Blight or something else similar."

All of this applies equally to my own garden and my own mental model.

reed

That's the way I treat everything. As long as we have all of the tomatoes we want, I don't see why it matters.

I like my tomatoes very much just the way they are but that doesn't mean there's no room for improvement. A little more diversity, especially in color and flavor range would be fun. Slightly smaller but more fruits would be great. A few days shorter season, I'm all for that. Another type of sauce tomato would be great because I just have the one right now. A bit more disease tolerance shouldn't be a bad thing. Diseases aren't really a serious issue right now, but I guess they keep evolving too so maybe I should take them a bit more seriously.

I'm going to explore several possibilities this year but not focus on worry about any one particular thing. I'm afraid that might lead to bad consequences regarding all of the other particular things.

reed

Found an interesting yesterday. I had transplanted the larger seedlings of my Hoosier Rose into little grow bags to sell later and just set the tray with the later and smaller sprouts outside. Temperature when I took the picture below was about 38 F, at sunrise it was 25 F.
 
Frost-Tom.JPG

Looks like the larger they are, the more rapidly deadly the freeze was. All went ahead and died as the sun hit and thawed them out except for that one in the center, it still looks fine. I've had volunteers of this variety survive frost before but though it just might be luck of the draw, like maybe they were protected by some dry leaves of something, but these were all equally unprotected. I don't know how significant it is as far cold tolerance because from what I've seen, even if frost doesn't kill them, they still don't really grow until it warms up.
 

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-03-19, 07:13:43 AMI've always had older leaves that look bad with yellowing and brown spots out in my tomato gardens.

Almost all of mine had this last year, especially the BH self incompatible line. Don't know what it was, but Lee Goodwin's 'Wilderness' really stood out as having such healthy green and abundant leaves. So that might be one to try for those who haven't. Really delicious cherry tomatoes. Has habrchaites heritage, might even be 50%?




reed

@William Schlegel, I've been wondering about dwarf tomatoes and indeterminate tomatoes and how those things are inherited. One of the crosses you sent me is Utah Heat x Dwarf MMR. Your note says F2 will be 1/4 dwarf. Does that mean that dwarfism is a single recessive trait similar to PL?

Also, one of the new hybrids I bought says it is seedless. What causes that? Is it something a novice tomato breeder may not want to mess with?

A Horn

Quote from: reed on 2024-03-25, 07:30:59 AMAlso, one of the new hybrids I bought says it is seedless. What causes that? Is it something a novice tomato breeder may not want to mess with?

The easiest way to get seedlessness that I know is to combine parthenocarpy with male sterility

Kadence Luneman

Quote from: reed on 2024-03-25, 07:30:59 AM@William Schlegel, I've been wondering about dwarf tomatoes and indeterminate tomatoes and how those things are inherited. One of the crosses you sent me is Utah Heat x Dwarf MMR. Your note says F2 will be 1/4 dwarf. Does that mean that dwarfism is a single recessive trait similar to PL?


Yep! Dwarf is a simple recessive just like potato leaf.

Indet- dominant
Det- recessive

Non dwarf- dominant
Dwarf- recessive

William Schlegel

I have only heard of parthenocarpy in tomato but if it has male sterility I wouldn't want that.

Yep potato leaf, determinate, and rugose-dwarf are recessive simple traits.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-03-25, 04:30:11 PMI have only heard of parthenocarpy in tomato but if it has male sterility I wouldn't want that.
Me too! Also presumably it could only exist as a hybrid, since it could neither act as a female nor male for seed production to continue the line.

reed

The alleged seedless variety is a hybrid from Burpee called Super Sauce.  I was going to drop it based on your responses, but I found some you tube videos, and it looks to me like it does have seeds, just very few of them. I think I'll grow a couple plants just to see for myself and maybe eventually try to mix it up with Utah Hooser Heart. I might also try that with Plum Regal but mostly with it I'm going to experiment with selection for tomatoes that are easy to sun dry.

About the rugose-dwarf, do those things always go together? I really like the idea of dwarf, but rugose doesn't seem to get along with the microscopic things that live in my garden and the microscopic things win.

Kadence Luneman

Quote from: reed on 2024-03-26, 09:28:53 AMAbout the rugose-dwarf, do those things always go together? I really like the idea of dwarf, but rugose doesn't seem to get along with the microscopic things that live in my garden and the microscopic things win.

Rugose dwarf is what seems most commonly used. I know there's been talk here about other dwarf types/genes. A quick internet search didn't give me anything about dwarf that's not rugose.

I'm growing 5 dwarfs that are rugose dwarf and 2 micro dwarfs. Our climates are pretty similar. Guess I'll see if I have trouble with them.

Cathy A

It would be very interesting to cross a rugose dwarf with a non-rugose and grow out a sizable number of the resulting plants.

Are the traits caused by the same gene, so all resulting descendants are either rugose dwarf or non-rugose non-dwarf?

Are the traits caused by separate genes that are normally found close together on the same chromosome, thus linked? Then you could find a few descendants from a sufficiently large growout that are dwarf non-rugose.

Or are the genes unrelated, but the ancestors of the dwarf varieties just happened to have the rugose gene, and it was carried to the later generations of dwarf plants without selecting for or against it?

I don't know, but perhaps someone here does?

Kadence Luneman

Cathy, as I understand it the gene is rugose dwarf. It's a package deal, no separating the dwarf from the rugose.
I haven't seen enough about other dwarf types/genes to say about those.