Grains and ploidy?

Started by Kadence Luneman, 2024-01-21, 08:06:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kadence Luneman

Here is what my grains consist of...

Fall planting-

Evolution wheat (145)
Turkey red wheat (500) [hexaploid]
Hard red winter wheat (213)

Grain rye (50#, merit) (est 2250)
Grain rye (2oz, baker creek)
Grand prairie Composit rye (100)
Sepp Holzer rye (80)

Spring planting-

Hulless oats (188)

Evolution barley (226)
Rmsa 6 row barley (477)

Glenn hard red spring wheat (188) best scab tolerance
Black eagle spring wheat (65) 6 row
Rmsa wheat (570)
Kamut wheat (383) [tetraploid]

What I'm not sure about is the ploidy of them, other than the couple that are noted. I was planning on lumping them together and just saving seed. If I do that will I end up with each population being a mix of ploidy? Should I lump them instead based on ploidy?

winter wheat
spring wheat
winter rye
spring barley

Steph S

I tried grouping mine by ploidy but didn't see any spontaneous crossing.
Joseph mentioned that crosses occur more readily in dry environments, which it usually isn't here, so that may be a factor.
I also had hulled and hulless mixed one year, which I later decided would be a mistake - to avoid getting hull traits in your free threshing grains.  So that is another way to group them, for threshing purposes.

Your hard red winter, Glenn and Black Eagle would be hexaploid bread wheats.

I think Rmsa iirc is a mix that contains some tetraploids as well as hexaploids.
As I understand it, there's no serious barrier to crossing amongst the tetraploid and hexaploid wheats, but the F1's are unstable and some maybe not self-fertile so they might need TLC to produce next generations, which will end up being either tetraploid or hexaploid and stable ploidy.

Your rye is likely diploid, and won't cross readily with wheats in the field.  They will cross with each other though, really readily apparently!   
Saw this:
"If you are a seed grower of rye, then your seed field must be two miles away from other rye crops. Why? Because pollen from open rye flowers can travel for miles.

When you grow wheat, barley or oats for seed, the fields can be just feet apart and there is no cross pollination. Simply put, these cereal flowers do not open. They pollinate with closed flowers, and only afterwards do they extrude or push out the now useless pollen anthers, since the job of pollination has been done.
"
https://www.grainews.ca/crops/cereals/a-closer-look-at-ergot/

The take on wheat is not entirely true, for sure.  Crossing rates are low but it does occur.  I saw one study where they compared spontaneous crossing for different cultivars and there was variation in the range iirc roughly 5-10%.   

It does sound like you'll get lots of crossing with 4 kinds of rye though.

William Schlegel

If your climate is right for the crossing of wheat they do occasionally cross across those ploidy levels.

If you go back far enough the wheat fields sometimes had all the small grains and perhaps even some peas or some such mixed in.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

Slightly related question.

Assuming I have this right, all that needs to happen for an einkorn wheat to turn into an emmer wheat is to double it's ploidy (from 2n to 4n).

Does the same thing ever happen to Triticum uratu? And what's it called then?

Kadence Luneman

Thanks all. Sounds like keeping them just in spring/fall planted grouping will be fine then and they'll work it out.

Our weather is so varied year to year any more. We have a fair yearly average precipitation. But sometimes it comes evenly through the year, or only in spring and fall, or only in spring,... I'll just see what they do. I may not even be able to spot out crosses anyway.

Good to know the rye has a higher crossing rate.

Steph S

@Jeremy I haven't read anything about spontaneous doubling of the wild wheat relatives, but I have read about wild wheats spontaneously crossing into people's wheat fields in Europe and where the wild relatives are native. 
I know that during mixed species crosses you can end up with odd numbers but the ploidy eventually settles into a 2,4 or 6.  So regarding the doubling of ploidy, you would end up with some genes of both parents but the final ploidy could be double the original, afaik.  That might be more common than doubling of the ploidy without a cross, as a spontaneous mutation.  At least, that's what I think based on the bit I've read.

Jeremy Weiss

If I recall correctly from my classes at college, einkorn has this odd habit of sometimes doubling itself naturally, and that is where emmer comes from. That's why you can find wild emmers in the center of diversity of wheat. I may even have seen that happen personally; back when I grew out The Kusa Seed Society's Ambassador Wheat combo (the one that Salt Spring seeds seems to have gotten and now offer each of individually) I remember that, in the einkorn pot, there were a few heads that looked far more similar to (but not totally identical to) the emmer pot next to them. I remembered to keep the seed packets discrete, so either they got sloppy, or those would have to be spontaneous. 

Steph S

Emmer isn't a result of spontaneous doubling.  The two genomes A and B came from two different wild ancestors.
THe complexity of wheat breeding is because the extra ploidy genomes are homeologous but not identical, coming from different wild relative origins.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10399237/

"The bread wheat genome is substantially larger than barley and has a complex evolutionary history....
This hexaploid species contains three subgenomes (A, B, and D) obtained through two hybridization events. In the first round of hybridization, two diploid wild ancestors created wild emmer wheat (T. turgidum L. ssp. dicoccoides) (BBAA) (Haas et al., 2019). The second hybridization event occurred at least 8,800 years ago and involved a cross between free-threshing tetraploid wheat and the donor of the D genome, Aegilops tauschii Coss. (DD) (Salamini et al., 2002; Zhao et al., 2023). Furthermore, the D subgenome possibly resulted from an ancient hybridization event followed by gene loss (Marcussen et al., 2014). Following these duplication events, highly similar genes coexist among the B, A, and D subgenomes. "

The A genome in Einkorn is from T. uratu, as in other wheats, but it appears to have evolved independently, and is not the direct progenitor of the higher ploidy wheats, if I read correctly in skimming this over breakfast:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06389-7
Einkorn genomics sheds light on history of the oldest domesticated wheat

"Wild einkorn accessions belonging to race β, the proposed progenitor of domesticated einkorn, had two copies for this segment, indicating that the tandem duplication predated domestication (Extended Data Fig. 1e). The tandem duplication was specific to einkorn and was not found in bread wheat."