Small Seed Size in Larger Tomatoes

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2024-01-04, 10:06:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2024-01-04, 09:22:07 AMI have one quite large tomato that has similarly small seeds.

How do you find that when it comes to planting the seeds? Presumably it takes significantly longer to become a fair sized seedling right? Do you find inconvenience with that?

Also how do you find the eating experience? Do you notice the difference while eating it, in the seeds being so much smaller? (I have thought that at least for cherry tomatoes it might make a significant difference though perhaps not in larger tomatoes where the flesh:seed ratio is greater).

I ask because I have been wondering about breeding a line with deliberately small seeds.

reed

When I plant it the same time, same conditions as the others it sprouts a week or so later and takes another week or so to catch up. Once it does, I can't tell much of a difference in growth. It is my primary sauce and juice tomato. It also makes very few seeds, compared to most. I'm a bit worried about its weird seeds which is why I want to do some crosses with it this year. I can't tell much difference because of the oddly small seeds in eating it fresh.

Justin Jardinier

Ok cool, thanks. So sounds like such seeds would mean maybe preferably starting 2 weeks or so earlier regular ones right? I can understand how that might not be ideal for some growers. And yeah makes sense it might not make much difference in a tomato with anyway so few seeds. Although I guess it's an added advantage for a paste tomato where minimising seeds is an aim already.

Quote from: reed on 2024-01-04, 11:44:07 AMI'm a bit worried about its weird seeds which is why I want to do some crosses with it this year.

What worries you? Is it just that you'd rather not have to start them earlier (or have them behind the others), or is there something else that worries you?

William Schlegel

Reed which of your tomatoes has the small seeds again so I don't have to go look through our other threads? I'm sure you've mentioned it before somewhere.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

It's the one I call Utah Heart. I'm not sure the seeds are as small as pimp, but they definitely are not normal looking tomato seeds. I got it from Joseph close to ten years ago, before he had done a lot of crossing and it never segregated, so I'm pretty sure is it just an inbred line. It probably is still out there somewhere by some other name.

The little seeds, the delayed germination and the small number of seeds just seems a bit abnormal to me. Despite the fact that I generally grow as many plants of it as the others put together and lots of them just get left to rot after the canning jars are full, I've never had a volunteer from it. The seeds sprout near 100% just like my other tomatoes so I guess it isn't really that big of an issue but in a way, it's the most important tomato in my garden, so I wish its seeds were not quite so wimpy and few.

William Schlegel

Quote from: reed on 2024-01-05, 02:42:43 AMIt's the one I call Utah Heart. I'm not sure the seeds are as small as pimp, but they definitely are not normal looking tomato seeds. I got it from Joseph close to ten years ago, before he had done a lot of crossing and it never segregated, so I'm pretty sure is it just an inbred line. It probably is still out there somewhere by some other name.

The little seeds, the delayed germination and the small number of seeds just seems a bit abnormal to me. Despite the fact that I generally grow as many plants of it as the others put together and lots of them just get left to rot after the canning jars are full, I've never had a volunteer from it. The seeds sprout near 100% just like my other tomatoes so I guess it isn't really that big of an issue but in a way, it's the most important tomato in my garden, so I wish its seeds were not quite so wimpy and few.

I think you should back cross it. Like take that cross I made with Utah Heart and cross it immediately back to Utah Heart. You want some more variation, but not too much. Sounds like a good use for back crossing.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

That sounds like a good idea. I'm also going to try to cross it to that big commercial tomato called Supersauce and Plum Pegal too. Just get a general mix up of sauce type tomatoes and then see what they all turn into the following season.