Seed from unripe fruits

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-12-31, 06:06:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I have a lycopersicum plant that died, with a fruit only 3 weeks old. I'm wondering if the chance of the seeds being germinatable will increase if I wait for more time, and if so, how long to wait.

I did have another fruit from peruvianum that dropped before being ripe, and I extracted the seeds. They were green. Worried that they might not survive drying, I tried germinating the seed straight away. Some did germinate, which is great since they were a very important cross, being 25% domestic. But the seedlings were very week and it was quite a risk. This lycoperesicum might be even more immature perhaps. So I want to give it the best chance I can. Does anyone have experience or knowledge about this, ideas how long to wait, or maybe to put it under lights to maximise photosynthesis, or a time limit of how long to wait due to some kind of risk?

Thanks!

Roland

I once stored a fallen unripe fruit for months until it turned red. All seeds from this fallen fruit that eventually ripened without being on the plant had good germination capacity.
So it should be possible to store the fruit until it is ripe.

Another possibility:
In vitro culture of immature seeds for rapid generation advancement in tomato
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

Thanks Roland! Your experience is inspiring, I will try keeping it at least for a week or two more then, perhaps longer even. Not sure if I should put it underlights or not - I would think the photosynthesis would make it mature quicker though it would also have a drying effect that could be negative. Maybe I should put it under the light nearest the humidifier.

The paper you mentioned is interesting, but a bit over my head, like:
QuoteSolid medium (M11) comprising MS full strength
basal media (Murashige and Skoog 1962) ? 2%
sucrose ? BAP 0.1 mg ? IAA 0.5 mg ? GA3
0.5 mg l-1 was most effective for germination
(counted at two weeks) and plant regeneration for
10 day-old immature seeds (Table 1).

I'm not sure if the sterile conditions and preparing such a medium which I have to say I do not understand, is within my current capability. Did you ever try it? Would be cool if there was a video showing in a simple way how to do it and create the medium etc. Could really cut down the generation time!Maybe from 3 months to 2!

Adrian

#3
Hi justin gardener,
You should tried a wintering for avoid the diseases risk the air humidity and the light are not adapted for tryed a fast grow at home.
Difficult to wintering tomatos.At home the most dangerous risk is that air was too dry and hot for the available luminosity.Your plant can caught strangers diseases.

I have wintering one plant on andine cornue for tryed a cross one year and i have put the planter in a room humid and fresh.Avoided a room heated by electric convector the air will be too hot and dry.A room between 12 and 17°C and above 40% of humidity seem good.Court periods under 10°C are not a problem.
For the light i have put my plant toward a windows exposated south-east and he has started to grow toward mid-february (around 9h30 of light/ day).Up to mid february i have completed the deficient lightening with a light 4000k 1050 lumens  3h before the sun-wake up and 3h after the sunset.I have used a outlet timer connected at the light its not expensive and easy to use.
When the vegetation is restarted i have off the light i have noted  that 9h30 of sunshine/day is more efficient that 15h/day under the light.

Justin Jardinier

#4
I started using a humidifier and keep the humidity around 66% now, because my predator mites (to keep the spider mite and thrips populations under control) and the aphid predators, kept dying when it was too dry. It's lucky you have sunlight, my plants are almost totally reliant on LED light (and some of them with some supplemental non-LED UV light, 75% UV-b 25% UV-a for some wild crosses to reduce intumescent injury). There are some very high efficiency LED lights out there now. I recommend this company for those in Europe:
https://cre.science/en/?v=79cba1185463

Or this company for Europe and the US for lights that are not quite as good but you don't have to build them yourself, and they seem to be among the best on the market in terms of price:efficiency ratio:
https://migrolight.com/collections/aray

They also have an excellent UV light:
https://migrolight.com/collections/uv-grow-lights

If anyone is wanting UV lights I recommend staying away from LEDs for that, they are very inefficient and may not last long, and some offer only UV-a where actually UV-b is the one that seems important for wild species like habrichaites. LEDs are great for everything aside from UV.

Adrian

#5
The most important is to balanced light, humidity and t° and keep the poting soil draining with frequents vaporisations during that rhe plant is in vegetative sleeping.When you see that the grow restarted you can increase the watered and add a light fertiliser shot i have used NPK 4-3-2,5.At the most bad a cutting of the health party is possible.

The last time that the plants was attacked by aphids i was expanded black soap without burned the leafs.If yours plants are again small you should monitored the fly of the seedling.

William Schlegel

#6
Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-31, 06:13:52 AMI once stored a fallen unripe fruit for months until it turned red. All seeds from this fallen fruit that eventually ripened without being on the plant had good germination capacity.
So it should be possible to store the fruit until it is ripe.

Another possibility:
In vitro culture of immature seeds for rapid generation advancement in tomato

I think the green fruit might mature the seeds more including by fixing more sugars by photosynthesis.

I have done some in vitro propagation and one embryo rescue on wheat mostly between 2009 and 2012. I was hoping to do some with tomato years ago around 2018 or 2019 to get peruvianum crosses from embryo rescue but realized I didn't have the ability to schedule it at the time with work and school. There was also a fairly good size investment in equipment which I still have (maybe a bit over $1000 in 2009 dollars). So have just started a separate thread on it. Though I also think Justin has already managed to work around much of the need for it just with simple techniques like immediately planting green seeds.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

I too have harvested unripe fruit and kept in a paper bag until it ripened - more than a month iirc, at fairly cool home temperatures around 60 F.  The fruit started to shrivel before it turned ripe color, but the few seeds inside were mature.
I do think that a green fruit could possibly photosynthesize under light and might be able to mature better, but I would hesitate to put it anywhere near a humidifier.  A clean dry place is a better bet.  Humidifier will multiply the risk of spoiling instead of ripening. 
One reason for using a paper bag is that it reduces the rate of drying out. Another reason, to protect from spores in the air that might colonize and start to rot. Humidifier would encourage any spores to germinate too.   Another reason for bagging is that any ethylene produced by the fruit will be retained around it and help it to ripen.  Even putting it in a bag with another sound but not fully ripe fruit would add ethylene and help the ripening process as long as you remove the other fruit when it does get ripe and before it starts to spoil.
Maybe you could put it in an open bag "collar" under light for a week or two then close it up?
I hope you have good luck with it.  Patience is advised for those green fruit.  I've seen many get to ripe color after waiting in the bag long enough.  Too shriveled to eat but for ripe seeds, the ripe color is what you want to see for seeds to have their best chance.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-12-31, 05:48:47 PMI do think that a green fruit could possibly photosynthesize under light and might be able to mature better, but I would hesitate to put it anywhere near a humidifier.  A clean dry place is a better bet.  Humidifier will multiply the risk of spoiling instead of ripening.

I suppose there might be a balance between the humidity level not being too low that the water loss is too great from being under light, and not being too high to too much encourage pathogens. Also, I wonder, if using a paper bag, choosing a thin white one might be better than one that would block out more light, so as the not overly reduce photosynthesis.

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-12-31, 05:48:47 PMAnother reason for bagging is that any ethylene produced by the fruit will be retained around it and help it to ripen.  Even putting it in a bag with another sound but not fully ripe fruit would add ethylene and help the ripening process as long as you remove the other fruit when it does get ripe and before it starts to spoil.

Do we know if ethylene has any effect on actually maturing the seeds, rather than merely ripening the flesh?

Also, does anyone know about the inverse - seed health in over-ripe fruits? I had thought that the riper the fruit, the more the seed would be developed, becoming ever better. But someone told me actually the seeds are best just when the fruits start turning red (or orange etc.), and that they go downhill from there, and might not germinate at all if the fruit is left to become over-ripe. Which is the case?

William Schlegel

Seeds have always so far proven viable for me in tomatoes picked at first blush but then I always let them fully ripen before extraction and fermentation.

Seeds would only be not germinating later if a secondary dormancy of some kind kicked in ot maybe if they didnt have endosperm or develop properly because of an interspecies cross.

You have the unusual case though of getting successful interspecies hybrids with difficult to cross species. This could lead to seeds that wont germinate because they lack endosperm or are somehow nonviable when fully mature.

You are also working on occassion with the difficult to germinate Galapagos island species. These species have dormancy mechanisms. This could lead to seeds that don't germinate if not treated as per the TGRC protocols for them.

One thought is definitely to keep doing what you've been doing! You seem to already be enjoying a great deal of success in the face of obstacles!

I made a cross between Blue Ambrosia and Lofthouse strain of peruvianum about 5? years ago now. The cross took, and I would have had to perform embryo rescue on a certain date. I was very excited to try. Obligations came up. So I let the very few seeds fully mature. Then I planted them. No germination. I thought I would need more plants and more crosses to get a few successful embryo rescues. Your current protocol seems to be bypassing that peruvianum barrier. So maybe don't change a thing!

Once you've stabilized the cross a bit maybe even in the F2 strains should segregate out that are stable and will germinate normally. Though they may, or may not, have the traits you want.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-01, 08:20:44 AMSeeds have always so far proven viable for me in tomatoes picked at first blush but then I always let them fully ripen before extraction and fermentation.

Have you ever tried with over-ripe fruits? My work load is so extreme that I have many overdue jobs, which results in some fruits over-ripening on the plant, and some ripe fruits being neglected for weeks before processing. I do hope it's not an issue but if it is, I'll try to increase that priority.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-01, 08:20:44 AMYou have the unusual case though of getting successful interspecies hybrids with difficult to cross species. This could lead to seeds that wont germinate because they lack endosperm or are somehow nonviable when fully mature.

Yes I've certainly had some non-viable seeds. And in some cases where peculiar crosses give seeds that look bad, or such as where large somewhat irregular shaped seeds dramatically shrink when dried, when I recognise such seeds, and have only few, for example 1~6 seeds per crossed fruit (usually accompanied by numerous endospermless coatless seeds), I've tried germinating them right away. In some case many germinate, in some cases few, or none. I'm hoping to get to plants that produce good seeds so that I can relax more and save the seeds for growing outdoors. It's rather curious that in the hardest crosses, the F1 seeds were quite healthy, but more issues (the seed issues described above) are coming when crossing those to other species or hybrids, though the sibling crosses are giving good seeds.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-01, 08:20:44 AMYou are also working on occassion with the difficult to germinate Galapagos island species. These species have dormancy mechanisms. This could lead to seeds that don't germinate if not treated as per the TGRC protocols for them.

I have so far found that the F1 crosses with these species to lycopersicum seem to have no dormancy issues. (Nor short day issues). But the difficulties in pollinating them with arc cross pollen is the same as with lycopersicum as described above. Also with some of these difficult crossed seeds with lyc gal or che, I have been washing the fresh seeds I intend to germinate, in dilute bleach briefly, to reduce mould issues which I have been encountering in some seeds that take long to germinate.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-01, 08:20:44 AMOne thought is definitely to keep doing what you've been doing! You seem to already be enjoying a great deal of success in the face of obstacles!

Thanks! I feel like most of the hard crossing work is done now. I mean, still lots to do, I have to take care of these peruvianum crosses now and try to cross them into other candidates, to make a suitable seed population to be planted outside. But it feels like the most difficult part is somewhat over. I might still try to get the chilense female line in case that would be useful, and I hope I can make the peruvianum and arcanum female lines useful, I don't know how hard they will be to cross to. 25% arc might be harder to cross to them than 50% arc was to pure arcanum and peruvianum, but I get all I can do is try (for increasing the edible percentage). No luck so far trying 25% arc even to 50% arc but that was several plants of the same cross, and I have more 25% crosses growing so will keep trying. They should be more straightforward as males, even fully edible ones, though that will make the SI project longer SI and I do want to try to get the female lines. I'll be doing both anyway.

I've tried getting the pennellii female line too, but so far all but 1 attempt to pollinate pennellii with 50% pennellii have failed. Not sure if that 1 exception is really succeeding or not, but I will see in a few weeks I guess. And I have no idea is the female lines will be of any special benefit anyway, but it seemed worth trying to make them just in case.

Are there perhaps any peruvianum or arcanum crosses in the gene banks there in the US that you might be able to acquire seeds for, and then use them as a bridge for your aims?

Also, I seem to remember Joseph saying embryo rescue can be very easy, I forget how he described it but something like just cutting the seed open and putting the embryo on a sterile medium, had he said perlite with a nutrient solution or something? Did he ever actually do it, or anyone else in a simple way not requiring special equipment? The technique may be redundant for me but I am still curious. I did see a video for how to make one of those fans that blows sterile non-turbulent air for quite a cheap price, it was a very good instructional video. I expect that might be part of what might be usually prescribed for the procedure but if the claim that it can be done so very simply and without such measures is true, even if the success rate lower but still viable, that would be good news.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-01, 08:20:44 AMOnce you've stabilized the cross a bit maybe even in the F2 strains should segregate out that are stable and will germinate normally. Though they may, or may not, have the traits you want.

Yes, that's what I'm trying to do really. It seems like a good idea that whilst I have a stable environment well suited to crossing, I should keep going, trying to make use of every flower (though my time demands do make me miss some), until the seeds are good. And this means building up seed stock too - some of these further crosses and even sibling crosses have rather few seeds, maybe around 18 is a high number for most of this in the arcanum cross sibling crosses, many have fewer, and as said in other crosses with them can be much lower. Plus with not knowing how many will germinate once dry, I am working hard to try to ensure enough seed increase that selection later might bring some good results. It feels like such a luxury opening up some of the more ordinary interspecial crosses and finding 100 F2 seeds in one fruit! The last fruit I harvested was 50% arcanum crossed to Uluru Ochre and the lovely big fruit gave me one single seed! Very possible that will not germinate even. (At least I got to eat a delicious tomato for Christmas). So I have to keep trying, keep crossing.


Steph S

WRT your question about overripe fruit, I think the issue is exposure to spoliage or disease organisms which might contaminate the seeds.
It's a general rule that you don't save seeds from rotting fruit, for that reason.
Instead the rule is to save seed from sound, healthy, ripe fruit at peak of maturity.  Makes sense to me.

Justin Jardinier

Sounds good as a general rule. Nobody here has tried? I would of course try to follow it as a general rule, but in some cases I have not been able to, so, just curious about the chances of viability.

William Schlegel

I think seeds from an utterly rotten tomato would be perfectly viable and good to save. In point of fact, a few years ago, when I couldn't find my packet of Payette, I just walked over to the field I grew it in, found a tomato mummy, picked some seeds out of it, and planted them to good effect.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#14
Oh wow that's great news William, thanks!
Also I have an interesting thing to report. So, for many of the crosses I do, there is a proportion of tiny tiny seeds with no seed coats, and I have assumed maybe no endosperm. The size varies a bit, as does the proportion. I think fairly often with some crosses it's 2 thirds those, 2 thirds seeds with embryos and seed coats. Sometimes the ratio of good seeds is smaller. I have tried germinating those tiny ones, never with any success.

Then a few days ago this happened:
seed thing popped out.jpg

I harvested a fruit from Uluru Ochre which I had pollinated with 50% arcanum, which was fully ripe, 49 days after pollination. This usually gives very few seeds and takes several attempts to get even one cross, whereas most of my crosses succeed with a single attempt. In this case, there were only 2 seeds. And I was cleaning them very gently, since the seeds from crossing with this pollen to any of the 3 edible species results in oversized soft misshapen seeds, as I mentioned above. As I was cleaning them, this spiral which you see above on my thumbnail popped out of 1 of the 2. I was disappointed. The other seed is seen whole, on the cross label.

Here's the casing from which it popped out, next to my finger, after it had popped out. Above it you can also see a typical example of the tiny seeds with no seed coats (and no endosperm?) which I was referring to:
empty case seed thing popped out of.jpg

The green colour is not unusual. Many of these seeds, despite waiting until the fruits are totally ripe, come out green, though many also come out yellow. Also the germination rate for these seeds is generally low.

So, I was thinking, the chances of this weird little spiral germinating are likely very very low. But, I may as well try. So I put the good seed, which you can see in the bottom right of the top photo, in the centre of some rockwool, and the tiny spiral to the side of it. I am shockingly low on resources otherwise I would have given them each their own space.
planting the spiral.jpg

3 days and 10 hours later, you can see the whole seed still there in the centre, but look carefully below and slightly to the left of that:
spiral result 1.jpg


Here you can see it more clearly - it is growing!
spiral result 2.jpg

I do not know if it will continue surviving or not, but either way, this seems a valuable experiment. In fact it even makes me curious as to whether dissecting these fat strange seeds might be a preferable method.