Super Fast Tomatoes

Started by Diane Whitehead, 2023-12-29, 03:30:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Diane Whitehead

This morning I accidentally found myself on a program called something like "Balcony Gardens".

A person nailed some clear plastic bottles upside down on a wall and put some soil in them.  Then banana was cut into slices and a couple of tomato seeds were scraped out of a cherry tomato and put on the banana slices. The pot was put in a plastic bag.  Five days later the plants were large enough to transplant into the bottles.  Ten days later, the plants had flowers, and chopped up banana peels were added to the bottles.  25 days later there were clusters of ripe tomatoes.

I decided to try the banana trick, so I sowed 7 kinds of microdwarf seeds in soil and 7 also on bananas.  They are in my warm living room (16 C, about 60 F) during the day and lower at night.

I will be amazed if any have germinated in five days.  Hmm - maybe I should also try it with some seeds from a fresh tomato, since that is what was done in the video.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Kadence Luneman

There is a ton of bizarre ridiculous impossible videos going around Facebook and YouTube, probably the internet in general.
There is a video where they boil a red cabbage, strain it, and boil a cotton shirt in it. Then pull out a commercial deep purple shirt.
The short version is that isn't quite how natural dyes work and they definitely don't give the shades shown.
The garden videos are generally more ridiculous. Often the seed, plant, and fruit shown are all different things even.

Banana and peels do make good fertilizer. But unless someone's hiding magic bananas somewhere... lol

Diane Whitehead

Well, they were definitely tomatoes, but the timing is crazy.  Fun, though.

Odd that they weren't trying to sell anything - seeds, fertilizer, potting soil - and I'm sure that banana farmers are not behind it.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Justin Jardinier

Did it have many views? These days if it's on something like YouTube anyway, it's views that are being sold basically - you are the product. More views = more revenue.  If it works then great, but it does sound like their typical kind of scam.

Steph S

We have a new micro breeder posting on TJ who says he is getting flower buds on average three weeks from seed, earliest around 20 days from seed, and an earliest 'seed to breaker' of 55 days for a micro. 
This timeline alone is a little hard for me to imagine, but I admit that even my living room temperature is well below the conditions used to get that record.
Non micro tomatoes, the earliest buds I see here are maybe 5-6 weeks at best.  I've never used 'buds' as a data point, since open flower is more definitive. But my seedlings are getting the cold treatment, too, so for sure there are conditions that would make for faster growth.  IDK how much of maturity is genetically controlled vs environment.
Your video claim of open flowers at 15 days from seed would definitely break all records that I know of.
Ripe clusters of fruit ten days later?
IDK if it's possible but seems doubtful for sure. 
Typical cherry I have on record takes about 30 days from open flower to ripe.  But I admit my data on flower to fruit cycles is only the first of season, and I have not formally recorded data for the interval in the hottest time of year. 

In the flower to fruit interval, the shortest interval I've recorded, from open flower to pea sized set, is 9 days.  15 days would be typical in spring conditions here and the interval can be 20 days or longer for some, in cool spring.  Definitely a variable affected by temperature, but discussion with other growers (Texas) indicated they also observed this rather long wait from flower to set.
Also in crosses made midsummer conditions, I think the wait of a week or more is also typical to see visible fruit growth ("pea sized set").

If there was something in the banana treatment or other conditions, or in the plant genetics, that got the flowers to pollinate and set immediately, it would take a chunk of time off the tomato ripe time.  (According to what I read, the intervals from seed to open flower. o.f. to pea sized set, and set to ripe fruit are under separate genetic control, but strongly affected by environmental conditions as well).
Thinking about a small cherry - if half of the nominal 30 days is needed to complete pollination and begin growing, you could definitely get the jump on mature fruit.

Just wondering what these intervals look like for micros, since it's obvious they are on a faster track.  I would really be interested in finding any plants where genetically, the interval from open flower to set is reduced by genetics.
One other observation from seasoned tomato growers, is that fruit that ripen quickly are not good tasters. Slow ripening seems to be linked to flavor development.  I don't have data to support that but I mention it as a possible down side to crazy fast tomatoes???

Think about the number of crops you can produce in 30 days.  Radish.  Baby greens.
It's not that easy to find even basic crops that are big enough to harvest at 25 days.
All the fruit crops are challenging because they typically take 3 times as long to produce the edible.
So you have a long wait time grooming and caring for the plants before you get product.
Anyone who can shorten tomato cycle to 25 days would be worth a fortune in multiplied crop returns alone.

Justin Jardinier

#5
Like Kadence said, scam videos are really common. Plus the fact that they included banana screams of scam, there are many such scam videos using bananas! (I'm not saying it definitely is, just giving my impression). But on your point Steph about how fast - this cycle I've been going from seed to seed in 3 months, for producing F2 seeds or making crosses. (Not micros, just normal interspecial crosses). The key for me is keeping the root space very small; good lighting; and hydroponics. I don't monitor temperature but it's indoors so it's warm enough. I use Kratky because it's very simple and silent, though more complicated forms of hydro might be faster or better.

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-12-30, 06:26:16 AMon average three weeks from seed

What does 'from seed' mean? Does it mean from the time the seed is first made wet, or, from the time the seed germinates? I have been looking for a term to describe the former. And that is the one I mean above in terms of 3 months, from first wetting the seed, to harvesting the seed from the fully ripe fruit of the next generation.
 

Steph S

@Justin when I say "days from seed" I mean days from germination.
I think germination itself is a whole other thing to study, but very hard to do so, as it is not only the conditions that vary germination time, but also the age of the seed and other seed parameters (how they were processed, final moisture content, how stored, etc etc) just a lot of extra variables.
So wrt tomato earliness, I leave out the germination part and count from the day they sprout.

I found a recent study (2020) which looked at 191 accessions and measured days to flower, days to ripe, flower to ripe, etc the important intervals which are under separate genetic control.  If anyone has access to the article through an institution, it would be cool to look and see what are the absolute minimum days for those different parameters.  The intro/snippets suggest that Pimps have untapped earliness perhaps? cw tomatoes. Meanwhile, since earliness has a huge economic significance, I think it fair to expect that they tapped the earliest accessions they could get for this study.
 
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0304423820300224

William Schlegel

#7
In table 2-6 of the book Genetics, Genomic, and Breeding of tomatoes which I was just reading in again, it lists Farthest North, Fargo, Fireball, and Campbell 28 as the varieties representing the earliness achievement in tomato breeding. It lists Yaeger 1933 as the reference for the first two.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Boe came after Yaeger and developed some "Ultra Early" varieties.  They include Ida Gold, which I've seen on your cross lists William.  and Latah, which Tim did his backcross experiment with.
Boe gives maturity in 'heat units' or degree days, which he said is a better measure of earliness, so go figure, temperature always a big variable.  The ultra earlies take 1,000 to 1250 heat units/degree days at 50F to 90F.  IDK the math for degree day but the implication is that you can shorten it up with the high end of temperature range.
https://library.ndsu.edu/ir/bitstream/handle/10365/6317/farm_47_01_06.pdf?sequence=1

It's so annoying to see figures for "DTM" everywhere which are completely arbitrary 'days from transplant'. 

William Schlegel

#9
I have seed for Northern Delight and Nodak Early both ultra early and Boe's last tomato releases in 1990 and seed for Latah and Bonner also his work and on his Ultra Early list. Purchased from Sand Hill Preservation Center for growing out in 2024.

I haven't been able to find extensive pedigrees for Northern Delight and Nodak Early like were published for some of Art Boe's earlier varieties. There is a pdf about them, but it doesn't include a pedigree. Though from the description Nodak Early sounds like another dwarf like Payette and Sand Point and logically is probably from similar breeding to Sand Point and Kootenai. Interestingly Farthest North is an ancestor of Sand Point and Kootenai.

I also have Fargo Yellow Pear to try in 2024 also from Sand Hill. It is a cross between Bison and Yellow Pear.

Kind of getting back to the original post in this thread: for fast seed germination starting with fresh seed right from a fruit would be fastest but would be further aided by quickly removing the gel sac perhaps mechanically or chemically to be faster than fermentation as that gel sac is supposed to inhibit germination. Important if you are trying to get in multiple generations in a year to practice some speed breeding.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-12-30, 10:23:35 AMBoe gives maturity in 'heat units' or degree days, which he said is a better measure of earliness, so go figure, temperature always a big variable.

I wonder if there have been tests to see if there are differences in different temperatures - hard to explain what I mean without some algebra. Suppose at 25°C, plant A takes 120 days from germination to ripe fruit, and plant B takes 100 days. If it's only temperature, then we might expect at 15°C something like, plant A: 120 x Y, plant B: 100 x Y. So plant B would still be faster than plant A by the same proportion.

But I am wondering if there might be other factors, like, perhaps plant A could be better suited to colder temperatures such that it's actually faster in the colder conditions, than plant B?

I wonder this because I hear that some tomatoes that are considered 'early' in the US seem to have been reported to not be early in Europe. I don't know if this might be to do with temperature (perhaps the night time temperatures are to blame?) or perhaps amount of sunshine. But it suggests to me that perhaps earliness is non-linear. Or like, perhaps even if the temperature variable is consistent, perhaps the amount of sunshine changes things, for example perhaps at temperature conditions where plant A takes 120 days, and plant B takes 100 days, under the same temperature conditions but different sunshine conditions perhaps plant A could be faster than plant B?

Just to give another example, there are some Russian pepper varieties which are said to be able to withstand cold conditions and considered among the earliest peppers, which do not do well in cloudy parts of Europe, others being more 'early' than those. And it has been proposed that this is due to the lower light conditions.

William Schlegel

I think there is some truth to that. I have early tomatoes from  several sources and it makes sense given the close relations between the tomatoes bred professionally in Idaho, North Dakota, and Alberta that the group of related tomatoes would have similar genes for earliness.

One exception in my garden is Coyote which is from a Mexican origin via Craig LeHoullier. Quite early, quite small. I still haven't managed a cross with it.

Tomatoes from the pacific Northwest like Siletz bred at Oregon State may handle cool and cloudy conditions better.

Year to year variation in climate here gives me hot dry years and sometimes cool wet years. I suspect Siletz would perform better in a cool wet and Coyote in a hot dry though the only year I grew Siletz was a hot dry in 2017 and it performed really well. I rejected it for breeding because I wasn't sure about the parthenocarpic trait which incidentally is good for cool and hot conditions.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Justin, you're right that amount, duration, quality of light has everything to do with it, not just temperature.  The new micro breeder at TJ says the plants flowering at 17-20 days are getting 2X a day of light daily.  The growing temperature is 74-80 degrees F in the plant enclosure.
So these would be a lot closer to optimal for speed breeding than my own, for sure.

@Diane, you might find 60F day is "cool" not warm, for a fast tomato.  My usual setup is similar...

Roland

I place my seeds on the 100W transformer of my LED lamp. The transformer is about 40C and then the seeds germinate due to the soil heat within 5 days.

For indoor cultivation and early ripening, most publications show that the average 24-hour temperature is particularly important. A difference between day and night temperatures results in larger flower clusters where a low night temperature is important.
A higher daily temperature or smaller difference between day and night temperatures results in vegetative growth with fewer fruits or even no fruits, but also ripening earlier.
However, the publications sometimes contradict each other. (Probably because in most publications either the temperature or the light hours/light intensity are monitored, but both can have a major influence on the results.
So they should examine both in relation to each other.)


The light hours are less important for early flowering. There is even a publication in which they indicate that flowers form faster with 10 hours of light than with 13 and 16 hours of light. The data showed that this was a difference of approximately 2 days out of the total 100 days.

https://repository.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2109&context=gradschool_disstheses
This publication also shows that adding food and nutrients does not have much influence on earliness.


I am still looking for the optimal conditions to ripen my beef tomatoes as early as possible, a few fruits for seed extraction are sufficient in the winter period.

I am thinking of a seedling period with a big difference between day and night temperatures and once the fruits have set, bring the night temperature to the day temperature to make them ripen faster. But I have not yet been able to find which temperatures are best for which light hours and which light intensity?

Some publications:
https://edepot.wur.nl/290701
https://edepot.wur.nl/200986
https://edepot.wur.nl/288925
https://www.agronomysociety.org.nz/files/1979_13._Effect_of_temperature_on_flowering.pdf
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

#14
Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-30, 02:51:15 PMA difference between day and night temperatures results in larger flower clusters where a low night temperature is important.
A higher daily temperature or smaller difference between day and night temperatures results in vegetative growth with fewer fruits or even no fruits, but also ripening earlier
.

Interesting!

Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-30, 02:51:15 PMThe light hours are less important for early flowering. There is even a publication in which they indicate that flowers form faster with 10 hours of light than with 13 and 16 hours of light. The data showed that this was a difference of approximately 2 days out of the total 100 days.

Was that with equal daily photon quantity? If so, that would be a fair judge of day length as a single variable (especially if they tested it at various photon levels). What I meant by 'amount of sunshine' though, was not day length, but basically hours of cloudless sky. So I'm really talking about total photons per day. I think maybe you also mentioned some tomatoes that were supposed to be early in the US but were not for you? That's what I mean.

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-12-30, 02:48:35 PMJustin, you're right that amount, duration, quality of light has everything to do with it, not just temperature.

Have you experienced (or know about) tomatoes where one is earlier than the other under good light conditions, but reversed in poor light conditions? If so that would confirm my suspicions.

Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-30, 02:51:15 PMI am still looking for the optimal conditions to ripen my beef tomatoes as early as possible, a few fruits for seed extraction are sufficient in the winter period.

Did I share with you the papers on speed breeding? I did with someone but I forget now with whom. There should be info in there also about light intensity. Light spectrum also probably plays a role - it certainly does in some plants but I was unable to find specific info on tomatoes for that - I just try to keep the blue:red ratio sufficiently large to keep the plants sufficiently small. And although as you say some research showed increased nutrients to not speed things up, from what I have read, hydroponics do speed things up. Like I mentioned, I can go from seed to seed in 3 months now. Keeping the root space small is also important.

And I mentioned this elsewhere but I'll say it here too - I read a paper which says S. chmielewskii is 'late', but has some kind of trait that apparently in crossing, can result in early plants. I don't have anything to report on that yet but hopefully will next year. And chmielewskii is very easy to cross with, so that might be worth people exploring. Also the F1 smell amazing! I really hope that it's possible to get some edible descendents with the plant still smelling this great.

Also, whilst most of my plants I have been keeping in small containers (beer cans) for their entire life, and whilst this is fine for getting two bunches of flowers at least, for some several more (and for peruvianum, many!), using Kratky method of hydroponics I have found root rot occurs quite easily. This may be why I have had lower leaves so often drop. It's still be fine for making F2 seeds and numerous crosses, but now I am starting to switch to a new system, where I plan to grow them in cans until they make their first flower buds, and then transfer them into a larger container where the roots can have more space, hoping that this will be better for their roots but they will continue to produce flowers. I have made the spacing still very tight, I'm trying 9cm spacing (about 3.6 inch) in 2 rows, 11 plants per container. The container is 21 litres (5.5 US gallons). The nutrients are not filled to the top since they need space for air roots. I don't know how successful this will be, the spacing is quite tight, but I will see how it goes.

In my main grow room I give them about 10 hours of dark at the moment, and in my other grow room the timing is a bit random but around 9 or 10 hours. The light quality is not the same and I'm not sure which has been working better but they are both working quite well.